The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

E-readers and e-ink

Kobo vs Xteink X4

Hacker News owners lean toward the Xteink X4.

KoboXteink X4
Owners with an opinion54745
Positive verdicts80% of 45998% of 41
Positive/negative since 2024256/7040/1
Happy after 3+ years250
Longest happy owner16 yrs0.5 yrs
Praised forease of use and displayportability and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitydisplay and durability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Kobo: NeutralXteink X4: Likes it
You have to wonder why someone did not think of this form factor sooner. I have the original X4 and have been enjoying it a lot. My Kobo mostly lies unused because I do most of my reading in bed and the X4, even with a clip-on light, is so much easier on the wrists. Dual core Arm CPUs, Android etc used by mainstream readers are a serious waste of resources. A microcontroller paired with the SD card is more than enough. And CrossPoint is a gem! The list of pros is long and the device recommends itself. But there is one con that you must watch out for: The screen is delicate . I love cases but hate screen protectors, and tend to use my devices with care. So it has worked out fairly well for me the past few months. But you might have a different experience.
Kobo: NeutralXteink X4: Likes it
I prefer the e-ink display. I first stared reading ebooks on my Palm Vx. I went on to a Nook, Nook Color, some no names, Kobo. Five years ago, I became disabled and no longer had a free hand to carry an ereader and did not want to carry a bag just to carry an ereader/book. I started reading on my phone. Last April, after seeing a comment on the X4, here on HN, I decided to get one. I prefer the display and I can advance a page by pressing the button, rather than swiping the screen. It's always with me, in het same pocket as my phone/
Kobo: Doesn’t like itXteink X4: Likes it
> > The Kobos don't limit what you can do with them either, you can sideload alternative e-reader software like KOReader that improves on the built-in reader functionality. > This is patently false, the latest Kobo Libra Color is using secure boot which completely locks out custom development Your "patently false" is not true. There are nuances here that you are glossing over or ignoring. Yes, the Kobo Libra Color uses secure boot. But, you can still get root and install KOReader on it. What is "custom development" if you mean "boot my own operating system" because, then yes. But the 90+% of the Kobo hacking community has never meant that. For most folks in the community "custom development" means being able to install/side-load applications like Plato and KOReader alongside the existing Kobo/Nickel software. Yea, I agree it sucks that the new Kobo uses secureboot, but it was never an open development platform. I feel for the quill-os folks, that sucks. I'm glad they found a home with the PN as they won't get a rugpull. But the Kobo is still a system where you can trivially get root on it without having to jailbreak or otherwise exploit a vulnerability. And +1 for the xteink x4 (though if you're rabidly against manufactures locking down their devices, you should look at the recent xteink developments where they are only releasing unlocked devices to the western market.)
Kobo: Likes itXteink X4: Recommends it
Different person, but I bought a set for me and my wife on a whim because they’re so cheap, and found I adore the little thing. I have a public transit commute to and from work. Since getting it, I’ve spent my commutes reading books I’ve meant to get around to. I have a Kobo I keep at home. I love it, but don’t want to risk breaking it while carrying it around in my backpack, and it’s too big to comfortably hold on a crowded BART (let alone to dig around in my bag to get it out and put it away). The X4 is always in my pants pocket during the commute and small enough to break out wherever I am. Also, it’s small enough to not feel fragile, and cheap enough that it wouldn’t be devastating if I broke it anyway.
Kobo: Likes itXteink X4: Likes it
I have the Kobo Libra Color and the contrast on the X4 is much much better. The whole sticking-it-to-the-back-of-your-phone i find a bit useless, but mine came with two metal rings so that I can stick it to other places. I have one ring on the dashboard of my car so the X4 can hang there until i need to use it. Good for trips with many stops.
Kobo: Likes itXteink X4: Likes it
Got the X4. Put CrossPoint on it. Works like a charm. The http server accessible over wifi makes transferring books extremely simple. (Shame on the Kindle for locking everything down.) This is proof-of-concept that a microcontroller is more than enough for something like an e-reader. I have a Kindle and a Kobo. They are sturdy devices. But the X4 is the one that is a genuine e-reader. Would not get it as my one and only e-reader though as you tend to miss the size and backlight of the larger ones. What would I want from future iterations? - backlight even if it compromises on battery a bit - a bit more DPI Everything else is good enough.
Kobo: Likes itXteink X4: Likes it
I'm with you on every bit. I love my Kobo Libra 2 and it lives on my nightstand table. It's an excellent reader. The X4 with CrossPoint is an alright reader, but I've been chewing through books on my morning commute because it fits in my jacket pocket and I can have it out on the train without bumping into other people. It's not the best reader I own, but it's the best reader I have on me at any given moment when I'm not laying in bed.