The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Keyboards

Kinesis Freestyle vs Microsoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Kinesis Freestyle.

Kinesis FreestyleMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard
Owners with an opinion89119
Positive verdicts90% of 7886% of 104
Positive/negative since 202416/621/7
Happy after 3+ years417
Longest happy owner10 yrs23 yrs
Praised forergonomics and comfortergonomics and comfort
Criticized forease of use and portabilitydurability and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Kinesis Freestyle: NeutralMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Likes it
Don’t rule them out. I was in the same boat, doing most text navigation on the keyboard and fully adapted to the quirky arrangement of home/end/pgup/pgdn of the Microsoft natural keyboard elite I’d been coding on for 23 years. But I do a lot of nomading, so I really wanted a small keyboard. And I’m a tall guy, so I was looking for a full split (I tried the Kinesis Freestyle2 for a while but didn’t love it). I bought a ZSA Voyager. The first day I went from ~120wpm to 20. I hated it and had buyer’s remorse. Second week, I was still switching to another keyboard in the afternoons because I was making so many typos and felt so tired . I swapped out most of the switches with higher force ones, and that helped a ton. It took about two months before the keyboard disappeared again and there was only me and the work. The biggest single win is that backspace is under my right thumb next to space bar, which felt life-changing once I got used to it (if I were still using a normal keyboard, I’d probably re-map right alt to backspace). And while word selection with ctrl+shift+arrow took a bit longer to get used to, now I appreciate not having to move my fingers at all to hit the arrow keys. Nine months later, you can pry the Voyager from my cold dead hands. It’s probably the last keyboard I’ll ever buy. I do wish it had two more keys (haven’t found good homes for Alt and ~) but overall I’m very happy with where I ended up.
Kinesis Freestyle: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Likes it
Kinesis freestyle is pretty cheap. I bought the mechanical one which is more expensive but don't use it. I'm too comfortable with microsoft ergonomic keyboard with light membrane keys https://www.microsoft.com/en/accessories/products/keyboards/... of which I have three. The only issue with the microsoft one is that it has to fit you since it is split but one piece. With a fully two piece split keyboard you can adjust it to your needs.
Kinesis Freestyle: Recommends itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Likes it
It's a kinesis freestyle 2. It doesn't have slick trendy features aside from being split, and I am not madly in love with it. Instead I would say as it's mostly invisible to me, which is exactly what I want out of a keyboard. So, I would recommend it. I also have a Microsoft 4000 at home for light/occasional usage and it's struck the point of being good enough for that purpose, and it was quite inexpensive. (If your wrists are straight on a regular keyboard and your shoulders are not scrunched you probably don't need a split board)
Kinesis Freestyle: Recommends itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Doesn’t like it
I've been a fan of the Kinesis Freestyle keyboards for years http://www.kinesis-ergo.com/freestyle2.htm . They're a little more expensive than most, but totally worth the price. I never could get used to the MS Ergo keyboards, same experience, the keys take too much effort. Bonus, all of my wrist pain as disappeared since switching to the Freestyle.
Switched from the Microsoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard to the Kinesis FreestyleKinesis Freestyle: Likes it
The [Kinesis Freestyle Edge]( https://gaming.kinesis-ergo.com/edge/ ) is what you want. It's a full keyboard, with extra keys you can map, and you can choose what switch you want. It's marketed for gamers, but it's good for everyone. My one complaint is I find the space bar too large. I started used the Freestyle after decades of MS Natural keyboards. It took a while to get used to the size of the space bar.
Switched from the Microsoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard to the Kinesis FreestyleKinesis Freestyle: Likes it
I came from using two Microsoft Natural keyboards at once, as my "split" keyboard. I eventually upgraded to a Kinesis FreeStyle 2. I've tried some ortholinear keyboards but hated hated hated every minute of it. I'm back on the FreeStyle 2 at work and a newer FreeStyle Edge at home.
Switched from the Microsoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard to the Kinesis FreestyleKinesis Freestyle: Likes it
I also upgraded to a split keyboard and I love it. I really liked the Microsoft Natural keyboard, but slamming my mouse into the number pad was driving me crazy, so I decided to get a split keyboard without one. I have the Kinesis Freestyle Pro. As a bonus the mechanical keys are nice to type on! My only complaint is it takes a moment to get it dialed in for placement if it's been moved.
Switched from the Microsoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard to the Kinesis FreestyleKinesis Freestyle: Recommends it
I've been using the Freestyle Edge for the past year or so. Before that, I had used the Microsoft Natural keyboard for many years because I never found a mechanical ergonomic keyboard I liked and found affordable. The Edge keyboard has been awesome. I highly recommend it to anyone who's looking to upgrade to mechanical, but in the style of the Microsoft Natural 4000 series.
Kinesis Freestyle: Likes itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Likes it
There are much cheaper Microsoft ergonomic keyboards, even if the 2 keyboard halves are not separate, so you cannot adjust the distance between them or the lateral tilting. I had been using for many years Microsoft ergonomic keyboards and it was still much more comfortable than with a classic keyboard. A few years ago I have switched to a really split keyboard (Kinesis Freestyle), which was an improvement over Microsoft, but not a so great improvement as Microsoft was over a standard keyboard. Unfortunately, Microsoft has first discontinued their cheapest ergonomic keyboards, which had almost the same price as standard keyboards. Then the remaining more expensive models have been sold to Incase in 2024, so they can now be found "Incase Designed by Microsoft" products, but at significantly higher prices than when they were made by Microsoft. Even so, they might be the cheapest ergonomic keyboards of decent quality. Microsoft still sells a "Microsoft Surface Ergonomic Keyboard". Old stock cheaper Microsoft ergonomic keyboards may still be found at certain shops. On eBay and the like a lot of old and very cheap Microsoft ergonomic keyboards can be found, but buying a "pre-owned" keyboard is risky, as you do not know how worn out it is. Moreover the wireless MS keyboards used proprietary USB dongles paired with the keyboard. If an old wireless keyboard is sold without the dongle, it cannot be used unless it also has a wired connection. For someone who types all day, there is a gr
Kinesis Freestyle: Likes itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Likes it
Not sure if there's a Sculpt clone out there, but I've been using a Natural Keyboard Elite for >20 years, and I'm pretty happy with the Kinesis Freestyle Pro I just picked up (brown switches because I don't want to make tons of noise in a coworking space). Key placement is close enough that there isn't much of a learning curve.