The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Keyboards

Kinesis Advantage vs ZSA ErgoDox

Hacker News owners lean toward the Kinesis Advantage.

Kinesis AdvantageZSA ErgoDox
Owners with an opinion300221
Positive verdicts90% of 25876% of 188
Positive/negative since 202468/535/21
Happy after 3+ years5718
Longest happy owner31 yrs10 yrs
Praised forergonomics and comfortergonomics and comfort
Criticized forease of use and reliabilityease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Kinesis Advantage: NeutralZSA ErgoDox: Likes it
Intensive keyboard used caused me two problems: soft tissue overload in my palms and elbow pain. After trying Microsoft Natural 4000, Kinesis Advantage 2, I finally settled on ErgoDox EZ with Kailh Silver switches. These switches don't require much force to activate, and I retrained myself to type lightly. This made the palm issue go away. For my elbows, physical therapy and foam rolling made the pain go away. I keep it away by ensuring proper posture when sitting: bending my elbows without turning my forearms inside (like the person pictured on the right in the article) and tilting the keyboard to minimize wrist rotation. I believe this helps minimize tension in the ulnar nerve. If you want to feel that tension then try a few reps of ulnar nerve flossing! I optimized my typing further with a custom keyboard layout (see https://configure.zsa.io/ergodox-ez/layouts/60Q7r/pjzqDd/0 ): 1. Colemak as middle ground between QWERTY and Dvorak. 2. Command, Shift, Alt, and Control keys on both sides of the keyboard. I'm Polish and a standard keyboard layout forces you to use the right alt + letter to type diacritical characters (for example ą is Right Alt + a). This prevents you from typing with proper technique, but having two equivalent Alts solved the problem. 3. Hyper (Command + Shift + Alt + Control) and Meh (Shift + Alt + Control) on both sides of the keyboard. I use Hyper for system-level shortcuts (e.g. Hyper + A is Sublime Text; Hyper + Q is Sublime Merge; Hyper + Z is Ghostty…
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Neutral
Looks like a cool kind of keyboard. I tried the ergodox, but eventually resold it (came from a typematrix). But I like most my Kinesis Advantage 360. Strangely, I find myself using dictation more and more while working. With a headset on, people don’t notice much since it looks and sound like being in a virtual meeting. Coding is still best with a keyboard.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Neutral
I picked up the (back, del) (enter space) thumbs layout from Kinesis, that feature alone has saved me years of strain, id wager. The shape took a bit of time to get used to but I was back at my average wpm speeds in a couple of weeks. Not as much of a learning curve as Ergodox with its layers but the curve and ortholinear layout take a bit of adapting to, though that's true of the Ergodox too. I kind of wish split keyboards were standard, instead of the default mode being all squeezed into the same 38cm wide form factor. The MS Natural keyboard was a step in that direction, split keyboard with a JUMBO space bar, but I wouldn't nominate it for the new standard.. While the kinesis doesn't have layers like Ergodox, it does have macros and you can remap keys via the hardware of the keyboard itself. I've been using an Ergodox for a few years now and got used to the layers but found the switches needed replacing a lot sooner (maybe I should have gone with a different set) and found the firmware update process for remapping to be annoying and tedious (even though they've gotten it down to about as few steps as is practical). Ergodox is more powerful in the abstract, though.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like it
Anecdotal, but ergodox flared up my RSI terribly. I think it might be the shear size of it and overstretching my pinkies with the shift keys pulling double duty with parenthesis. I’m now a happy user of the kinesis advantage (though the configuration software pales in comparison to the ergodox) and feel so much better.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Neutral
On the other hand, I've tried many keyboards, including the ErgoDox and Kinesis Advantage, with the latter being the most comfortable for me. While the Moonlander boasts impressive customizability, I found its untypical angle of the thumb cluster to be a drawback for my personal typing experience. Given its premium price point and the extended delivery time from Taiwan (mine took almost a month to come to the UK), I'd strongly recommend trying it out before making a purchase to ensure it meets your ergonomic needs and avoids potential disappointment.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Recommends it
I use the ErgoDox EZ, I love it and I've been RSI free with good, productive workflow. My first non-standard keyboard was the Kinesis Advantage. When I first got it (to mitigate RSI), I went through a similar phase as you. My solution was to stop everything else, get Mavis Bacon (any typing tutor really) and develop muscle memory. 1 week later, my productivity levels were manageable and I used the keyboard for regular work stuff. I continued Mavis Bacon for 2 more weeks. At the end of the 3rd week, I felt more productive than before. It's been 8 years now and I haven't turned back. The switching to regular keyboards part might be a real issue if you are, like me, a creature of habit. I avoid it as much as possible.
Kinesis Advantage: NeutralZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like it
I really want a basically traditional keyboard, except with a thinner space key that permits two more modifier keys under each thumb. The anatomy of the hand is meant for the thumb to work in opposition with the other four fingers. Sadly the ErgoDox doesn't fit my hands so it's uncomfortable to use the thumb clusters. The Kinesis does if I place it very low, but I'd like to retain the rest of my muscle memory for key location.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Recommends it
I’m also very happy with my Ergodox EZ, and a trackball mouse. The configuration of the keyboard is highly flexible and super easy, and no software on the pc is needed (only to flash the updated config). I’ve also used a Kinesis Advantage in the past, which was amazing. But that was my boss’s, so I had to leave it. Apart from that I’m using the Dvorak layout, which gives me a much better typing experience than querty; way less fingerstreching.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like it
I used a Kinesis Advantage as my main keyboard for close to 10 years. A few years ago I got an Ergodox EZ, but just couldn't get into it. I've been using a NiZ Atom68 as my main keyboard for over a year now and am rather happy with it. I have plans to build and try a Kyria with some ultra-light linear keys soon as well. These days I think that there are so many good community designed keyboards that it behooves anyone who has the notion they'd like something better than a standard layout keyboard to do a bit of research and testing. For any keyboard layout it is fairly trivial to make a printout and stick it to your desk to get an impression of how it fits your hand size/shape and your preferred resting/neutral position. There's a good layout comparison tool which makes it trivial to narrow in on your preference as well [0]. Recently I've found Ben Vallack [1] to be an excellent resource on keyboard customization and his philosophy echoes my own, though he shows much more dedication to the craft and exploration of keyboarding than I could ever hope or wish to. He has an excellent series on designing and making your own keyboard [2], as well as well thought out explanations and explorations of creating and learning personalized keyboard layouts [3][4]. His more general explorations of usability in computing and beyond have been inspiring as well [5]. 0: https://github.com/jhelvy/splitKbCompare 1: https://www.youtube.com/c/BenVallack 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U…
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Recommends it
I bought an ErgodoxEZ a couple months ago in an effort to find the right ergo keyboard for me. Though I ended up choosing the Kinesis Advantage 2 instead, there are a lot of great things about this keyboard. - Really nice build quality. - Lights made me feel cool and helped me keep track of which layer that I was in. - Extremely customizable layout options with a user-friendly way to map keys and all that stuff. - Customer service was very friendly and helpful in helping me return the keyboard and get a refund. In the end I just found that the Kinesis Adv. 2 felt more comfortable for my hands. I would recommend the Ergodox to anyone who is looking to try out an ergo keyboard, especially if the layout config is high on your priority list.
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itZSA ErgoDox: Likes it
A couple thoughts. I've had an ErgoDox for almost 9 years. I wrote my thoughts after a year here [0]. I use the Norman layout which I'm generally pleased with but don't know if the finger travel buys you that much. More important to me had been leveraging both thumbs to hit commonly used keys and modifiers. In the last week, I was made aware of the miryoku layout and made a Norman version. (Prior to COVID-19, I traveled quite a bit and thought about getting a gergoplex for travel which would require a smaller layout like miryoku). It was like learning to use the ErgoDox all over (so I pulled out my extra ErgoDox with my normal layout). Time will tell if I commit to learning it. I like the ErgoDox but admit that it is an acquired taste and you should get a keyboard that works for you. That said, were I buying a keyboard today, I would get the Kinesis 360. 0 - https://hairysun.com/revisiting-the-ergodox.html
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like it
Same. I was about to say there are so many projects like this maybe in the next decade or two the split community will grow and have more nice custom keyboards. But who am I kidding, I'm all in on the kinesis advantage. A couple years ago I gave the Ergodox EZ a good solid try, but it just didn't jive with me, so I think I'm stuck (in a good place).
Kinesis Advantage: Doesn’t like itZSA ErgoDox: Recommends it
You really ought to consider a split keyboard. I'm also broad-shouldered, and the Advantage still caused inward rotation of my arms (i.e. activating my chest muscles to pull my hands inward). With split keyboards, you can place the two halves as far apart as you want, tent them (rotate them outward), etc. It's really an RSI game changer, especially if you have a sit/stand desk. I think Kinesis is coming out with a split board version of it soon, but the Moonlander and Ergodox EZ are also good options you can get now (I have these).
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itZSA ErgoDox: Neutral
I have been a Kinesis user for 8 years, starting with an Advantage USB, added a classic PS2(with a usb adapter) as a backup and then was a tester for the Advantage 2 which I ended up buying. A company I worked for gave me a choice for keyboards when I joined so I tried a Ergodox EZ with the RGB backlighting. General observations: 1. Overall I prefer the Advantage over the Ergodox. The big reason is the contoured design and the fact that the Ergodox tends to walk around unless you have a solid desk pad underneath it. Also, the Ergodox never felt as comfortable as the Advantage. Yes the Advantage is not as easy to travel with but still.... 2. I like the new design, but there are a few things that would have made the pro perfect. PBT backlit keycaps like they offer on the Ergodox-EZ and RGB backlighting...and maybe a set of f-keys (on the fence with the last one). One other thing... A mix of o-rings and QMX clips made a huge difference with the feel of the keyboard for me. I have been a cherry brown user from the beginning though and different people have different preferences with that. Kinesis is also really good about providing parts and service. I've had them send me replacement switches and have seen them offer up in-expensive replacement boards to repair and keep older models going. I'm going to buy one of these, but given that I already have 4 high quality mechanical keyboards and I have yet to have one die I am starting to feel guilty having all of these laying around. T
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like it
Not OP but the issue for me moving from a scooped keyboard (Kinesis) to a flat one (Ergodox) was reaching the top/bottom row comfortably. On a flat keyboard, hitting that top row (especially edge keys like the 5 and 6) required either moving my entire hand or doing some weird reaching motion. And I wear a 4XL glove so I don't even know how other people deal with the top row at all. Being able to not move your hands as much doesn't sound like a big thing but it helped a lot with my wrist issues because I can find a comfortable position when I get started and never leave it until I stand up. I'm currently on a scooped and fully split KB from bastardkb.com which is kind of the best of both worlds (scooped for reach, split for my shoulders, and custom firmware so I can use less keys overall). But if Kinesis offers that out-of-the-box it's a pretty easy choice for my next keyboard.