The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Keyboards

Kinesis Advantage vs MoErgo Glove80

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Kinesis AdvantageMoErgo Glove80
Owners with an opinion30047
Positive verdicts90% of 25877% of 39
Positive/negative since 202468/523/7
Happy after 3+ years570
Longest happy owner31 yrs2 yrs
Praised forergonomics and comfortergonomics and comfort
Criticized forease of use and reliabilityease of use and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Kinesis Advantage: NeutralMoErgo Glove80: Likes it
100% agree. I have almost never travelled with my Advantage2 or 360 when I still had them. But the Glove80 is so light that it’s easy to carry with me. The Advantage helped me a lot, but the Glove80 is the only keyboard I’ve truly loved using. The key well is insanely well-designed and even though the tenting is a bit of work to set up, it is really tailored to my preferred angle. MoErgo is also expanding the Choc keyboard space with really nice silent switches (Cherry/Plum Blossom) and keycaps.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMoErgo Glove80: Recommends it
Another vote for the Glove 80: I used the Kinesis Advantage 2 for 10 years (after a few initial signs of finger pain developing), then tried the new 360; and recently got the glove 80 so I could easily travel with it and fell in love with the keyboard. It definitely doesn't feel as solid as the Kinesis or ergodox (which I used intermittently as well) but is the most comfortable keyboard I've used, the LEDs are actually useful (for showing battery life and bluetooth connections), and there are enough keys (including function keys); I don't like having to reason about layers at all, I want to be able to smoothly transition to my laptop's keyboard in a pinch).
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itMoErgo Glove80: Neutral
I used kinesis advantage for 15 years, switched to a glove80 for the past 2, but recently went back to kinesis with an advantage2. The glove80 is very nice, but my hands are big enough that the kinesis thumb cluster works better for me and the cherry mx brown switches are much more satisfying than the low profile chocs. So ymmv, but for those with larger hands, it may make sense to try a kinesis.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMoErgo Glove80: Doesn’t like it
Runner up is the glove 80, but the only thing is I don't like how flimsy it feels in my hands compared to how solid the kinesis feels. Glove80 has a better key well and thumb cluster for most people though. I have made a detailed comparison here: https://danieldk.eu/MoErgo-Glove80-Review Also agree with the sibling commenters. In order, get: - Help from an expert/exercise/do very regular breaks. - A properly adjustable chair. - A height-adjustable desk (get an electronic one, it's the only one you will ever tune properly, other desks are too much effort). - Only then an ergo keyboard. An ergo keyboard is worthless if you do not get the basics right (diagnose the issues, letting the blood flow, having a good posture). I am in some ergo keyboard Discords and it happens far too often that people by an ergo keyboard, but do not even have a setup where they can have a good posture.
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itMoErgo Glove80: Neutral
I started having RSI issues 2 years ago, what a way to welcome me to my 30s. It was excruciatingly painful just getting through a workday even with plenty of breaks. I didn't care for building my own keyboard I literally just wanted something to help me not be in pain no matter how weird it looked. I've ended up on a Kinesis advantage 360 pro after spending thousands of dollars on keyboards because I needed something that allowed me to type for more than 5 minutes at a time without pain. The things I think are key for people with persistent issues: - programmable keys - tenting - concavity (rules out most keyboards) - thumb clusters - ortholinear I know some go without the concavity but I just cannot go back. Its so much more comfortable on my hands. Programmable keys are probably the most important though, primarily so you can pick which stretches and awkward movements to completely remove and no longer have to do. For example I've entirely removed the need to ever stretch my pinkies and ring fingers on both hands. It destroys my hands having to do so on a normal keyboard and so many normal shortcuts require excessive pinky finger movement. I honestly think anybody who plans on using a keyboard for the rest of their life should invest in a high quality keyboard even if it's expensive. I would not be able to continue working today without having done so. Runner up is the glove 80, but the only thing is I don't like how flimsy it feels in my hands compared to how solid the kin…
Kinesis Advantage: Doesn’t like itMoErgo Glove80: Likes it
Different designs for different preferences. HHKB is quite classic, it’s been around since the 90s and is just refining and refining the original design. I can’t go back to staggered or flat keyboards since switching to Kinesis Advantage 10 years ago. These days I’m rocking a Glove80 since the Advantage360 Bluetooth version is so buggy. Still I wish there were options in my preferred form factor that are as nicely built as the HHKB. So I like to appreciate the aesthetics and craft even if I’d never use it personally.
Kinesis Advantage: Doesn’t like itMoErgo Glove80: Likes it
The thumb cluster design was one of the reasons I went with the Glove80. Moonlander, ErgoDox, and even Advantage 360 thumb clusters seem harder to hit than the Glove80's, though I do wish there was some option to use 1.5u keys on the Glove80 thumb cluster.
Kinesis Advantage: Doesn’t like itMoErgo Glove80: Recommends it
My Kinesis Advantage collection is useless as the function keys die and they won't sell you spare parts any more. I got a MoErgo Glove80 ( https://www.moergo.com/ ) which is designed by friends of mine. It's great. Two independent halves so you could just put a track pad between them. Really low to the ground, the old Kinesii were always quite high off the desk. And THE FUNCTION KEYS ARE PROPER KEYS SO WON'T DIE AFTER 5-7 YEARS!!!!! Also it's a great keyboard. I recommend the white (clicky) keyswitches.
Kinesis Advantage: NeutralMoErgo Glove80: Likes it
A small group of us (Kiwi software geeks) have been working on this series of split contoured keyboards for the last 6 years. We all had RSI, and all were intimately familiar with Kinesis Advantage. Although Kinesis Advantage was the best ergonomic keyboard in the market 6 years ago, we were not entirely happy and we decided to make our “perfect” split contoured keyboard. The foundational ergonomic design of Glove80 was finalized about 5 years ago. It is the result of 500+ ergonomics A/B test experiments and prototypes. We had to come up with an innovative prototyping process to make this number of tests possible; which is documented at [1] https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/repetitive-strain-injury-rsi-... Although it’s superficially similar to the upcoming split Advantage360 (based on published renders, ergonomically appears to be based on Advantage/Advantage2), during the development of Glove80, we re-think, re-evaluate, and re-invent every part of the contoured keyboard. Some of these ergonomic changes are subtle but some are more obvious. Here are some examples: - The thumb cluster is an innovative curved 2-row 6 key design, with each row at a different height. All 6 thumb keys are easily accessible - The pinkie columns have been completely redesigned so that they work for people with short pinkies and long pinkies - The top row keys are new, but are easily accessible for the majority of users - The bottom row keys are made easier to reach and press - The outer index colum…
Switched from the Kinesis Advantage to the MoErgo Glove80MoErgo Glove80: Likes it
I have "XXL" size hands (some fingers push against tips of most XL gloves I try) and I find the Glove80 very comfortable fwiw https://www.moergo.com Switched from Kinesis Advantage after 15 years. Love the Pro Red config that's available out of box without expensive customization.
Kinesis Advantage: NeutralMoErgo Glove80: Neutral
You don't really have to use them all. Realistically on each side I use ~3-4 of the thumb keys consistently and I have the others bound to just things I rarely do. I also completely unbound the outermost row of keys on both sides. i.e. far left and far right. Since I found one of the biggest issues I had that aggravated my issues were stretching the pinky. I also have a Kinesis Advantage 360 pro but I think its better suited for people with bigger hands than me. I do prefer its tenting setup though since its much quicker/easier to use. The Glove80's is a bit more custom but I think I'd have preferred if there was like a good mix of the two.
Kinesis Advantage: NeutralMoErgo Glove80: Neutral
I know, right? I feel every keyboard warrior goes through stages where each stage imposes a "no return" point - mechanical, split, concaved. I've tried so many boards, yet these three factors invariable remain important. There are many things I dislike about my Advantage 360 - it's absolutely not suitable for travel, even taking it from the desk to the couch is a hassle; there are too many keys (the halves definitely never needed to be this big); firmware patching is wonky (I have the ZMK variant); etc. Yet, that is the only class of boards that allow me typing without getting wrist and neck pain for 14-16 hours. Over the years I owned like a dozen boards from KinesisErgo - I started with Advantage models, then Advantage II, then I bought Freestyle for my kid, then pre-ordered 360, etc. In-between I tried Glove80, Mistel, Ergodox, Vortex Pok3r, and some others. I am also sad that I have discovered the importance of the choosing the right switches way too late. I highly recommend getting to know your boards and the types of switches you can install on them, and then get a switch tester. Finding just the right type is absolutely worth it.
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itMoErgo Glove80: Recommends it
I find it strange that people who start caring about ergonomics settle for Ergodox, Moonlander and other halfway there solutions when Kinesis, Glove80, Maltron who have put in real ergonomic research exist..
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMoErgo Glove80: Likes it
I use two of these: https://www.amazon.ca/dp/B077JX7GBL?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_d... it lets me tent at nearly 90 deg which is great. And it is also good for reclining on my LC4, where I use two Perriand berger stools as armrests and a Levo laptop stand. For something sturdier I use Ulanzi super clamps with extensions. The Glove80 (which is fantastic, as a 15 year Kinesis Aadvantage user prior) also has a tripod mounting kit which I haven't tried yet.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMoErgo Glove80: Likes it
> And your willingness to turn a blind eye to pretty major annoyances makes it seem like you’re trying to justify the effort you’ve put into Colemak Nah, I know vim, meow, emacs keybindings but mostly use boon. I am also able to use my zoo of keyboards in the drawer without any problem, including Model100, KA2 and Glove80. Not everyone is limited by difficulty of learning a skill. There was absolutely no reason to keep qwery and staggered keyboard skills sharp, so I did let it go. Q.E.D.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMoErgo Glove80: Likes it
I've tried a lot of keyboards over the years – ergonomic ones, such KA2 and Glove80 (now) absolutely did solve my RSI issues. Pain may have many issues, such joints, posture problems (pinching nerves in shoulders/elbow) but getting a proper chair and ergonomic split keyboard is still my number 1 advice. Also more sport, if it is not too severe. Going to a doctor should also be high on the list, but unfortunately, I have yet to see one willing to do a proper diagnosis. My experience there is more than mixed, so you have to experiment yourself.
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itMoErgo Glove80: Recommends it
Went through the same process last year due primarily to trying to find a solution to my cubital tunnel syndrome. I dropped down to like legit 20wpm from ~120wpm. I'm back to around 100 or so but a lot more comfortable and with less pain. I recommend either the Kinesis Advantage 360 pro or the glove 80 to anybody who uses a keyboard a lot for a living. I tried both and frequently switch between them. Another thing I recommend to people with problems is to get literally the lightest keycaps you can, and while it may slow you down a bit try to bottom out less/type a bit lighter in general.
Kinesis Advantage: NeutralMoErgo Glove80: Neutral
I feel the trackpoint is less relevant today on laptops considering designs like MacBook Pro or these Aura laptops that have massive touchpads that are easily reachable without much hand movement. I can mouse with my thumb on a MacBook trackpad without much downward shift in hand position, and I find that a faster and more accurate pointing device compared to the trackpoint. The place I really want the trackpoint is on my Glove80 or Kinesis Advantage, with these ergo desktop split keyboards I really never want to move my hand to the mouse, yet there’s no easy way to get a trackpoint. For a while I lived with an Apple touchpad in between my glove80 splits but it doesn’t seem any quicker or more ergonomic than a good mouse, although it is a bit more compact. I would love to see a stand alone trackpoint stick “mouse” that could easily be adapted to a desktop ergo keyboard. The happy hacking keyboard has a variant with a trackpoint, but it’s hardly ergonomic and is missing various modifiers.