The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Keyboards

Kinesis Advantage vs Microsoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard

Hacker News owners lean toward the Kinesis Advantage.

Kinesis AdvantageMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard
Owners with an opinion300119
Positive verdicts90% of 25886% of 104
Positive/negative since 202468/521/7
Happy after 3+ years5717
Longest happy owner31 yrs23 yrs
Praised forergonomics and comfortergonomics and comfort
Criticized forease of use and reliabilitydurability and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Kinesis Advantage: NeutralMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Doesn’t like it
I’ve been using split boards since the original Microsoft Natural Keyboard, the one with the awful number pad. Then a Kinesis Advantage, then the 360. The DIY boards like a Lily58, Corne and a similar custom are mostly for travel. Switching to split or ortholinear takes time. Doing both together is a significant and slightly annoying adjustment and takes a few weeks to feel normal. The payoff is when you lean into it. Home row mods so the home keys become ctrl shift alt meta when held, plus a thumb layer for navigation so you get vim-style movement everywhere, and a symbols layer for the stuff not on the top row. Two thumb keys per side works well. Layer on both sides, enter on one thumb, space on the other. About 6x4 per side is the sweet spot for me. A function row on things like the Advantage 2 or Glove80 can be handy. If you want to try it in steps, the Kinesis mWave is a decent bridge. Split but not ortholinear, full keyset so you don’t have to relearn everything at once, mechanical, runs ZMK, and in US pricing it’s very cheap for what it is, roughly $120.
Kinesis Advantage: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Likes it
The issue with kinesis and all those nice small symmetrical keyboards is that not every alphabet is as short as English. Russian, for example, has 33 letters. So if you’re someone like that, you really want that ordinary macbook-like number of keys = larger non-symmetrical right half. — As for the ortholinear keyboards, I spent a few months with the latest kinesis but sold it eventually: not that comfortable. Just clench your fist and you will see that not all your fingers are moving in direct lines. I don’t buy the ortho logic at all. I would argue that left half of the ordinary keyboard is even more ergonomic in this sense. — Tdlr; split, traditional layout https://uhk.io/ is my best purchase: use it for almost 5(?) years. Modded it for swappable switches, lubed, what have you. Don’t waste money for uhk riser, not worth it. Small plastic built-in legs are more than enough. — Previously was a big fan of microsoft split ergonomics (2nd gen and sculpt later)
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Doesn’t like it
I picked up the (back, del) (enter space) thumbs layout from Kinesis, that feature alone has saved me years of strain, id wager. The shape took a bit of time to get used to but I was back at my average wpm speeds in a couple of weeks. Not as much of a learning curve as Ergodox with its layers but the curve and ortholinear layout take a bit of adapting to, though that's true of the Ergodox too. I kind of wish split keyboards were standard, instead of the default mode being all squeezed into the same 38cm wide form factor. The MS Natural keyboard was a step in that direction, split keyboard with a JUMBO space bar, but I wouldn't nominate it for the new standard.. While the kinesis doesn't have layers like Ergodox, it does have macros and you can remap keys via the hardware of the keyboard itself. I've been using an Ergodox for a few years now and got used to the layers but found the switches needed replacing a lot sooner (maybe I should have gone with a different set) and found the firmware update process for remapping to be annoying and tedious (even though they've gotten it down to about as few steps as is practical). Ergodox is more powerful in the abstract, though.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Doesn’t like it
less keys = more cognitive overhead. Having to remember what layer i put fucking pipe on is not better than just hitting the damn key. In ~2000 I started suffering from tendonitis and my coding job became very painful, I tried kind of the 'easy onramp' ergo options at the time, namely the ms 'natural'. It did not help. Eventually someone pointed me at the kinesis advantage (then essential) and I bought one. After some struggle coming to terms with thumb keys and wells and ortholinerness I switched to it for all tasks except for gaming and my symptoms basically disapeared. About 10 years back I was in a job that was potentially going to cause me to travel a lot, at that point I had already modded my kinesis advange keyboards with custom controllers and wanted to try and build something that travelled better, was smaller, while still not fucking up my wrists. I built a lot of keyboards trying to shrink my luggage. I went ortho and built a split preonic, uncomfortable, then I went down the road that leads to corne/iris/etc (thumb keys, vertically aligned but not horizontally aligned). More comfortable but the thing i always ran into when removing keys. Overhead, you have to remember what layer and key you put xyz rarely used symbol on (and when you are a software engineer that's a lot of the symbols).. at the end of the road I built a very low profile board based on the dactyl with the same number of keys as the kinesis advantage minus the f-key chicklets. Reducing the number…
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Doesn’t like it
My perception is that cherry browns require less force than the MS natural 4000. I say this after comparing the two side by side. There is another advantage to the cherry browns (or mechanical keyboards in general)... they last a LOT longer. I've had my main work Kinesis for 4 years. The key strokes feel the same today as the day I got it. I would burn through an MS natural 4000 at a rate of 1/year; the spacebar & alt/ctrl keys would become too sticky after.
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Likes it
Wish there was more competition in ergonomic input devices. Was just searching for a new mouse and couldn't find a vertical mouse with acceptable reviews. Ended up forgoing the vert. mouse altogether and buying a Logitech MX Master to replace my Logitech G500 (which I've used for many years and is now discontinued) and I'm pretty happy with it so far. I'm even pleased with its gaming performance (probably not OK for highly competitive or pro gamers, but np for me). Mouse was visibly sluggish over Bluetooth but works great over Logitech RF. Although the MX Master is not billed as an ergonomic device, it fits my hand better than the G500 and I already feel some relief of the slight pain in my right wrist. I've used a Kinesis Advantage keyboard for about 3 years (and the MS Ergo 4000 for several years before that, in response to pain that developed before I even turned 20) and it's been a godsend. Would like to find a good ergo mouse before I'm forced to.
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Doesn’t like it
I use a Kinesis ( https://www.kinesis-ergo.com/shop/advantage-for-pc-mac/ ), which is a mechanical keyboard with an ergonomic layout. It saved my wrists while writing my master's thesis. I use an MS 4k for a while, but the Kinesis is lightyears ahead in terms of comfort. It takes about a week to learn to type on it, as the columnar layout is very different, and I had to learn to retype some characters (like x, c, and v). It's easy to switch back and forth between typical keyboards and the kinesis, so nothing's lost in the learning.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Neutral
I used to love my Microsoft Natural Ergo 4000 keyboard. I did find that the pressure (PSI to press a key) goes up quite a lot after owning one for a few months, which can cause finger pain if you are coding for long hours. After having MS Ergo keyboards for about 7 years, I finally switched to a Kinesis model ( http://www.kinesis-ergo.com/advantage_pro.htm ), and although more expensive, the pressure has stayed consistent for the 1+ years of owning it.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Doesn’t like it
Ergonomic keyboards ease strain when one is typing a lot, which can easily happen when one types for a living. They are a necessity for many who end up with wrist strain (I had my first serious episode at age 17, another one at age 22, and another one at age 24). They also can enable you to type faster. This isn't very important for coding, but it may be important in a variety of other contexts depending on what you do. I've been trying to push over 90 awpm myself. Here are the keyboards I've had and tried: MS Natural Elite, classic, affordable, does everything right. I feel the same way about this keyboard as I do the classic MS intellimouse, which was superceded by (IMO) inferior products. The spacebar felt a bit loose and broke on me a couple of times. MS 4000, never felt as smooth to me as the Natural Elite, but easier to obtain. I think they made the spacebar more stable, but not as easy to reach. I was in the habit of putting my natural elite in my lap and pounding away, the adjusted curvature of this model didn't allow this and otherwise annoyed me. Kinesis Advantage, major price tag and major pain to use if you have to use a mouse periodically. Also more difficult to adjust to. That said, gives you a slight advantage w/ typing speed (+10 or so words per minute) and allows you to easily touch type the numbers, something that very few people can do. Also, very very comfortable. Do you really need an ergonomic keyboard? Depends on what you do. I predominately use a lapto
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Neutral
I've been using the Kinesis Advantage for about 8 months, and I'd say ergonomic keyboards are definitely useful. The biggest factors in RSI tend to be taking frequent breaks and making sure you desk and chair are set at proper heights, but after doing those things I was still having frequent wrist pain and decided to look into more ergonomic devices. I started with the MS 4000 and the Kinesis Vertical Mouse ( http://www.kinesis-ergo.com/evoluent.htm ), but after a few weeks was still having pain and it was starting to get worse. Your mileage may vary, but I found the MS 4000 to be just about the same level of comfort as a standard keyboard. It didn't really offer anything more than having a bit of a split in it. The vertical mouse seemed to help on days when I was using the mouse a lot, but on days with lots of typing, I was still getting pain. I decided to bite the bullet and get the more expensive Kinesis Advantage. After getting used to it, my pain went away, so I'd say it was worth the extra cost. Maybe it's just the sunk cost of relearning to type on a weird shaped keyboard makes me want to feel like the time was worth it - but I suppose it doesn't matter as long as the pain is gone. Also, it's just really cool looking which is good for nerd cred in the office. :D
Switched from the Microsoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard to the Kinesis AdvantageKinesis Advantage: Likes it
I switched from a Microsoft Ergonomic to a Kinesis a month or two ago, because I wanted my mouse closer to avoid shoulder fatigue. I was pretty fast right from the beginning, but it took me a couple days to relearn space, enter, backspace, equals, and tilda. By day three I was getting comfortable. I still make mistakes, especially around hyphen vs equals, but they are getting less and less. Now I'm trying to teach my brain to switch between Kinesis and the old way. The first few times I worked on a laptop I was furiously pounding on the spacebar trying to make the cursor back up, but even that has gotten easier lately. So I'd say the learning curve is really pretty easy! Maybe harder if you don't touch type. A year ago I also tried the Truly Ergonomic, and that was a much harder adjustment.
Kinesis Advantage: NeutralMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Neutral
Intensive keyboard used caused me two problems: soft tissue overload in my palms and elbow pain. After trying Microsoft Natural 4000, Kinesis Advantage 2, I finally settled on ErgoDox EZ with Kailh Silver switches. These switches don't require much force to activate, and I retrained myself to type lightly. This made the palm issue go away. For my elbows, physical therapy and foam rolling made the pain go away. I keep it away by ensuring proper posture when sitting: bending my elbows without turning my forearms inside (like the person pictured on the right in the article) and tilting the keyboard to minimize wrist rotation. I believe this helps minimize tension in the ulnar nerve. If you want to feel that tension then try a few reps of ulnar nerve flossing! I optimized my typing further with a custom keyboard layout (see https://configure.zsa.io/ergodox-ez/layouts/60Q7r/pjzqDd/0 ): 1. Colemak as middle ground between QWERTY and Dvorak. 2. Command, Shift, Alt, and Control keys on both sides of the keyboard. I'm Polish and a standard keyboard layout forces you to use the right alt + letter to type diacritical characters (for example ą is Right Alt + a). This prevents you from typing with proper technique, but having two equivalent Alts solved the problem. 3. Hyper (Command + Shift + Alt + Control) and Meh (Shift + Alt + Control) on both sides of the keyboard. I use Hyper for system-level shortcuts (e.g. Hyper + A is Sublime Text; Hyper + Q is Sublime Merge; Hyper + Z is Ghostty…
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Likes it
I used an MS Ergonomic for 10+ years at the office and a Kinesis Advantage for a similar amount of time at my home office. I'm now entirely home-based, and plan to use the Kinesis Advantage until it's no longer an option. I'm on my second Kinesis. Something about the function key connection (they're on separate boards internally) made them start failing intermittently after 3-4 years. After the third failure Kinesis had discontinued the replacement parts and I replaced the whole keyboard with a newer revision that has redesigned function keys which are going strong so far. Kinesis supports key remapping if that's a thing you need.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Likes it
I had a opposite experience with MS Natural: I used them with great success for 12 years - I would quickly develop wrist pain on regular keyboard. I only switched to Kinesis because I decided it doesn't make sense not to use the best tool available. Kinesis is great too - btw, if you are in the Seattle area, you can stop by their office and buy directly from them.
Kinesis Advantage: NeutralMicrosoft Natural Ergonomic Keyboard: Neutral
Yep, I'm about 110 wpm without adjustment last time I clocked on a regular keyboard, but I can't maintain this for long periods of time. I suspect that ergonomic keyboards allow you to maintain high speeds, not necessarily to reach them. I don't personally don't find myself slower on, for instance, my old natural elite. My only written reference is the material by "ergonomic experts" included with my Kinesis Advantage -- a bit on the unreliable side. Would love to know if you and Google can turn up anything else.