The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Keyboards

Kinesis Advantage vs Kinesis Freestyle

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Kinesis AdvantageKinesis Freestyle
Owners with an opinion30089
Positive verdicts90% of 25890% of 78
Positive/negative since 202468/516/6
Happy after 3+ years574
Longest happy owner31 yrs10 yrs
Praised forergonomics and comfortergonomics and comfort
Criticized forease of use and reliabilityease of use and portability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Kinesis Advantage: Likes itKinesis Freestyle: Neutral
I went from “regular” keyboard to kinesis freestyle 2 to kinesis advantage 360. The switch to the freestyle 2 was basically seamless. Switching to the advantage 360 was brutal, but I can tell you that i have not only fully recovered my typing speed but have even improved on my historical ability. I used monkeytype.com for a couple years before the jump to the advantage 360 and still to this day, and you can see the deep trough my speed went through while i figured out the ortholinear layout and thumb clusters, and the new all time high records i’ve recently set.
Kinesis Advantage: NeutralKinesis Freestyle: Likes it
I haven't used that many different keyboards, but each one has kind of added a feature to my must-have list. My first mechanical was a tenkeyless Max Keyboard Nighthawk. It sold me on the TKL size, and backlighting. It also has a USB hub, which is very convenient for mouse dongles and headsets. For several years I used a Kinesis Advantage at work. I never loved it, but it sold me on having my preferred layout (Dvorak) in hardware, rather than configuring it in the O/S. I also liked having a backspace under my left thumb. Not long after I got a Kinesis Gaming Freestyle Edge RGB at home. Even better than the Advantage, I could program an arbitrary layout (and lighting) in hardware. And because it's split, I can program the left spacebar for backspace. When I got tired of the Advantage, I bought a System76 Launch, a compact TKL with a split spacebar. This sold me on hot-swap switches. I generally like light tactile switches like the Cherry MX Brown in the first three keyboards, but it's fun to put clickies on some of the keys, and very light linears on the pinkie modifiers. I guess the point is that as your list of must-have features grows, the set of candidate keyboards shrinks. There aren't many programmable RGB keyboards with hot-swap switches, a split spacebar, and a USB hub. What are your must-haves?
Kinesis Advantage: Doesn’t like itKinesis Freestyle: Likes it
I just want a freaking vertical keyboard. I don't understand why this is so freaking hard to find. Kinesis had the Free Style 2 keyboard[1] that you had to go out of the way to buy a vertical stand with, and it has been my go to keyboard FOR YEARS now because I just can't find any alternatives. I used to use the Kinesis Advantage keyboards, but they mess with my carpal tunnel. As cool as they are the plastic placement for the wrist rests still mess with you. It's awful if you have carpal tunnel. And yes, everyone is saying they help, but they're still sources of aggravation because you are wresting your wrists on the plastic and compressing them. And yes, you can get some pads, but that really doesn't change the system. I just want some g- d- vertical keyboards. And no one makes them with good layouts. I got this crazy battlestation vertical keyboard from Safe Type [2] and I freaking HATED it because their layout puts a bunch of keys in the middle and there's an insane F-row keyset that requires me to move my hands all over the place. It's ridiculous! How hard is it to get a vertical keyboard with a good keyboard layout?! I'm so scared my free style 2 is going to fail and I'm going to have to go back to a world with terrible keyboards. I even e-mailed Kinesis asking if they were going to go the same route of vertical keyboards and they refuse to. I'm dying here. At this point I would love if someone made keyboard gloves that let me put them on and wear them to type so I don't…
Kinesis Advantage: Doesn’t like itKinesis Freestyle: Neutral
Please explain if you have one of these what drew you to this? Wrist pain posed me to research other keyboards than the Apple Magic Keyboard and Microsoft sculpt. Within a brief amount of time I tried a Kinesis Freestyle Edge RGB, Kyria, and Ferris Sweep. I found the Kyria and Sweep pretty awkward (for different reasons) and caused other pains. Then I got a Kinesis Advantage2 and that really changed things for me, my hand/wrist health improved a lot. I did replace the controller with a KinT to get QMK though. I am also using a Model 100, since it also allows me to experiment with different switches. But the Advantage2 is my main work keyboard. I also have an Advantage360, but I don't use it much, because I don't like the switches. Review: https://danieldk.eu/review-kinesis-advantage-360-pro/
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itKinesis Freestyle: Doesn’t like it
Not sure if you are still reading this, but on the odd chance that you are: if travel is a problem, your typing technique is probably wrong. The travel to the operating point on Cherry Browns is 2mm, however, the total travel is 4mm. A lot of people press mechanical keys much too far. You have to learn nog to press the keys not too far behind the actuation point. This is the easiest on a tactile switch like Browns, where the force curve changes after the activation point. Another thing that works well is a keyboard with a piezo speaker like the Advantage 2. You could also ask your ergo guy what he thinks about the Kinesis Advantage 2 or 360. For me, the Advantage has been much better for reducing complaints, since it offers far more ergonomic features, like key wells (make it easier to reach keys and put the fingers in a more comfortable position), thumb keys (reduce load on pinkies), etc. Another option is to build a keyboard with low-profile Choc keys. The heavier Choc keys are very scratchy, but those between 20-35gf are pretty good. Be warned though that no group studies are done on these custom designs, so they may be terrible for ergonomics and destroy your thumbs (or not). Ideally it also wouldnt cost a car payment like this thing: https://dygma.com/products/dygma-raise?variant=4356523982871... The standard switches for the Raise will have the same travel as a Freestyle pro. Also some facets of the Defy are terrible for ergonomics, e.g. they have positive tilt. ---…
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itKinesis Freestyle: Neutral
I have two Freestyle Edges as well, but they are mostly collecting dust now. Once your are used to the column stagger, key wells, and thumb keys of the Advantage, there is not really a way back. I dread typing on a row stagger single/split spacebar keyboard now. (That said, the Freestyle Pro/Edge is an awesome board for a more traditional layout, especially with the tenting kit.)
Kinesis Advantage: Doesn’t like itKinesis Freestyle: Likes it
For me, the angle matters, but also the softness of the touch. For this reason I have loved the Kinesis Freestyle 2. I really tried hard for some weeks, and much customization, to like the Kinesis Advantage, which is programmable, but the keys were just too stiff for my hands' comfort. Maybe someday I'll have to try more of the other kinds, that people discuss. Time/$/priorities... Edit: I've tried multiple MS split keyboards but they were also a bit stiff. The nearest other I've liked was a Belkin that I found somehow at work, but I forget which model. (Ps: if someone seriously wants to try my Advantage enough to make it super-easy for me to mail it to them, it's just sitting here in the box...)
Switched from the Kinesis Freestyle to the Kinesis AdvantageKinesis Advantage: Likes it
A Kinesis Advantage2 (almost 500 dollar in the EU, but read on). I had a flare up of wrist pain again. Decided to invest in a good ergo keyboard. Started with a Kinesis Freestyle Edge RGB (pretty good), then Kyria, Ferris Sweep (meh), and then I did what I should have done in the first place: buy a Kinesis Advantage2. It immediately felt great and after some weeks my wrist pain was gone. Concave key wells are just fantastic! Since then, I also got an Advantage360 Pro (> 500 in the EU) and replaced the controller of the Advantage2 with a KinT [1], so that I can program it with QMK. I can now keep similar configurations between the 2 and the 360 Pro (which uses ZMK). [1] https://github.com/kinx-project/kint
Kinesis Advantage: NeutralKinesis Freestyle: Neutral
I know, right? I feel every keyboard warrior goes through stages where each stage imposes a "no return" point - mechanical, split, concaved. I've tried so many boards, yet these three factors invariable remain important. There are many things I dislike about my Advantage 360 - it's absolutely not suitable for travel, even taking it from the desk to the couch is a hassle; there are too many keys (the halves definitely never needed to be this big); firmware patching is wonky (I have the ZMK variant); etc. Yet, that is the only class of boards that allow me typing without getting wrist and neck pain for 14-16 hours. Over the years I owned like a dozen boards from KinesisErgo - I started with Advantage models, then Advantage II, then I bought Freestyle for my kid, then pre-ordered 360, etc. In-between I tried Glove80, Mistel, Ergodox, Vortex Pok3r, and some others. I am also sad that I have discovered the importance of the choosing the right switches way too late. I highly recommend getting to know your boards and the types of switches you can install on them, and then get a switch tester. Finding just the right type is absolutely worth it.
Kinesis Advantage: Likes itKinesis Freestyle: Likes it
Nice to see the Noppoo Choc Mini! I had the same keyboard, got me through 5 years of starcraft 2 and another 5 years of brood war remastered. Had to retire it when I stopped playing starcraft and now use a kinesis advantage360 pro when working/programming. If you haven't used a split keyboard, I highly recommend it! It feels way more natural typing and less stressful on your wrists. I still use a kinesis freestyle 2 on my desktop pc, good enough for most games too. It feels alien at first but you quickly adapt. It's also not hard to go back and forth between the different types of keyboards.
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itKinesis Freestyle: Recommends it
As someone who has made a bunch of keyboards (including hand wiring), I agree that the space is very hard to navigate. Especially since /r/ErgoMechKeyboards/ has gone full "the only ergonomic keyboard is a hand-soldered keyboard that only 50 other people use", while for most people a prebuilt ergo keyboard would be fine and a large improvement over a $15 black slab. What makes it worse is that most designs do no have any long-term group studies at all. E.g. Dactyl Manuform keyboards are quite popular, but many long-term users report thumb injuries from using Dactyl Manuforms. Who knows what injuries many of the custom designs can cause long-term? Most hobbyist keyboard designers are not trained medical professionals and basically don't have much of a clue what they are doing. I would recommend people to start with prebuilt keyboards that have been around for a while and are pretty well-understood and in some cases had input from or testing by experts. Some examples: - Fixed-split angled Microsoft keyboards (some models had extensive group studies, etc. Some models do break fairly quickly.) - Logitech ERGO K860 - Kinesis Freestyle Edge RGB. This is traditional keyboard but with split and optional tenting (both of which have been shown to be good in various studies, be sure to get the tenting kit). - Kinesis Advantage, goes all-in with ergonomic features and requires relearning typing a bit. Has been around in various forms for 30 years and is well-understood. Most people who u
Kinesis Advantage: Recommends itKinesis Freestyle: Recommends it
Get a Kinesis Freestyle Edge RGB with palm rests and the tenting kit. Which is pretty much like any ergonomic keyboard, but split and tented. Or get a Dygma Raise if you want QWERTY row staggered, but thumb keys. Or get a Moonlander or Keyboardio Model 100 if you want row stagger. Or get a Kinesis Advantage2 if you want almost all possible ergonomic features (I had wrist pains and switching to a KA2 solved that completely). You can get some of there brands (in particular Kinesis) at regular ergo shops, so many employers will just see them as another expense besides a good chair or desk. (My employer bought me a Kinesis Advantage2 for the office-office.)