The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

Intel Arc vs NVIDIA GeForce RTX

Hacker News owners slightly favor the NVIDIA GeForce RTX.

Intel ArcNVIDIA GeForce RTX
Owners with an opinion37617
Positive verdicts75% of 3276% of 416
Positive/negative since 202422/6214/71
Happy after 3+ years010
Longest happy owner2 yrs6 yrs
Praised forperformance and valueperformance and value
Criticized forreliability and softwarenoise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Intel Arc: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
Personally I think the price is way too high right now. It’s a power hungry gaming GPU. The efficient single card equivalent would be a 4500 Blackwell which launched at about $3500. Or you could get a 9700 32GB or an Arc B70 for well under $2k, today. You only buy a 5090 if you want absolute speed. 32GB is still not that much. I would rather get a Spark and have the RAM to experiment with larger LLMs, even if it was slow.
Intel Arc: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
The A770 actually has more transistors than the RTX 3070 Ti: RTX 3070 Ti: 17,400 million transistors A770: 21,700 million transistors https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/geforce-rtx-3070-ti.c3... https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/arc-a770.c3914 It has taken Nvidia decades to figure out how to use transistors as efficiently as it does. It was unlikely for Intel to come close with their first discrete GPU in decades. That said, it is possible that better drivers would increase A770 performance, although I suspect that reaching parity with the RTX 3070 Ti would be a fantasy. The RTX 3070 Ti has both more compute and more memory bandwidth. The only advantage the A770 has on its side is triple the L2 cache. To make matters worse for Intel, I am told that games tend to use vendor specific extensions to improve shader performance and those extensions are of course not going to be available to Intel GPUs running the same game. I am under the impression that this is one of the reasons why DXVK cannot outperform the Direct3D native stack on Nvidia GPUs. The situation is basically what Intel did to AMD with its compiler and the MKL in reverse. In specific, information in these extensions is here: https://gpuopen.com/amd-gpu-services-ags-library/ https://developer.nvidia.com/rtx/path-tracing/nvapi/get-star... Also, I vaguely recall that Doom Eternal used some AMD extension that was later incorporated into vulkan 1.1, but unless ID Software updated it, only AMD GPUs will be…
Intel Arc: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
Arc has already caught up to Nvidia. The latest Nvidia GPUs are a disaster (the 4060ti is being universally mocked for its very pathetic performance), they're intentionally royally screwing their customers. The A750 and A770 are tremendous GPUs and compete very well with anything Nvidia has in those brackets (and Intel is willing to hammer Nvidia on price, as witnessed by the latest price cuts on the A750). Drivers have rapidly improved in the past few quarters. It's likely given how Nvidia has chosen to aggressively mistreat its customers that Intel will surpass them on value proposition with Battlemage.
Intel Arc: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Contrary to what other posters are saying, I do think AMD is actually trying to compete; for example, they finally gave up on OpenCL and are trying to play catch-up to Nvidia via ROCm, effectively allowing you to run CUDA on AMD's server GPU offerings. And on the gaming side their top-of-the-line offering, the 7900 XTX, is ~$600 cheaper (aka 60%!) at MSRP than Nvidia's top-of-the-line RTX 4090 — and the prices you'd pay from e.g. resellers on eBay are even more skewed towards Nvidia. That being said, they're just way, way behind. Nvidia can charge what they do simply because AMD isn't great at making GPUs. In gaming AMD never caught up to Nvidia's raytracing perf, and AMD's attempt to clone DLSS is significantly less performant. Meanwhile in AI/ML the industry consolidated around CUDA because OpenCL was never that great, and — Nvidia owning the standard, and having built around it for over a decade, gives them a really big advantage. Plus, every GPU sold in the last decade+ by Nvidia supports CUDA, whereas only the new server GPUs from AMD support ROCm. Nvidia has executed incredibly well for decades: they pioneered shader programming, CUDA, raytracing, and DLSS. Arguably they even invented the GPU itself with the GeForce 256 in 1999 (as opposed to earlier "accelerator" cards). I struggle to think of anything AMD has done in the GPU space that matches even one of those accomplishments... Their only slight win is having OSS drivers for Linux, but honestly, that doesn't sell a…
Intel Arc: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
Having read all comment (54 atm), none seems to share my concerns: heat. My current card, an RTX 3080 (stock everything), runs so hot that I hate using it in the summer. The noise of cooler is also unpleasant. From the physical appearance of the Intel Arc, it looks to be a much more power efficient card. I hope they keep evolving it and maybe their next, or next-next, generation will be in my shopping cart.
Intel Arc: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
i've run inference on Intel Arc and it works just fine so i am not sure what you're talking about. I certainly didn't need docker! I've never tried to do anything on AMD yet. I had the 16GB arc, and it was able to run inference at the speed i expected, but twice as many per batch as my 8GB card, which i think is about what you'd expect. once the model is on the card, there's no "disk" anymore, so having more vram to load the model and the tokenizer and whatever else on means there's no disk, and realistically when i am running loads on my 24GB 3090 the CPU is maybe 4% over idle usage. My bottleneck, as it stands, to running large models is vram , not anything else. If i needed to train (from scratch or whatever) i'd just rent time somewhere, even with a 128GB card locally, because obviously more tensors is better. and you're getting downvoted because there's literally lm studio and llama.cpp and sd-webui that run just fine for inference on our non-dc, non-nvlink, 1/15th the cost GPUs.
Intel Arc: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
I mean, you could have a bunch of other things in the GPU instead of those cores, but the reality is that ray tracing serves multiple target markets for GPUs very well, and actually meets a demand people have: better graphical quality. In contrast, while I'm jealous of my friend with a 16GB 4080, versus my paltry 10GB 3080, it does not realistically impact anything I do outside of occasional ML retraining tasks. Neither did my old 8GB card. Gaming workloads just generally don't need it, because people there are mostly bound by compute, not texture or RAM limits -- and solutions like super-resolution/upscaling instead improve performance and memory usage all at once. > and it costs about $250 for a basic NVidia card today that can do slightly better Eh, the 3050 is like 30% more efficient in every single benchmark versus a 1060, with 30% more VRAM, and costs like $280. I don't think 30% is "slightly better". The Arc A750 also is around the same price point and is nearly 80% better, but I admit Nvidia has the best software stack on the market at the moment so the 3050 is a more fair comparison.
Intel Arc: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
TDP of 450W Someone else made this point elsewhere but a 4090 can be CPU limited at 4K. It's 50% more performance with the same power draw as the 3090 Ti. Undervolting grants a 150W drop with a 5% drop in performance. The 40 series is looking spectacular so far. The RX 6xxx XT gen do better than the newer intel GPU and with a LOWER TDP!! close to half the TDP in fact! In rasterization. But the future of gaming is "DLSS" and ray-tracing. Both areas that AMD struggles so far. It's generally accepted, but muted in most reviews that both Intel and Nvidia are ahead in ray tracing and upscaling tech compared to AMD. It doesn't bode well for AMD's market has what appears to be a pretty competent opponent in that space now with Arc.
Intel Arc: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
I am so confused by all of these comments/articles, they're clearly created before actual benchmarks have come out (and also seem to have no real world experience with intel GPUs, etc). Intel Arc cards are dead in the water because they have extremely unusably unstable drivers. To the point of the word "broken" being applicable. This hasn't gotten better with the A750 (in fact, it's gotten worse it seems?). The 4090 is extremely expensive, but it is ludicrously stupidly comically powerful. It's 10x-20x more powerful than a 2080, nearly 100% more powerful than a previously more expensive MSRP 3090ti and this is BEFORE DLSS3, which is not a gimmick. Check out the GN review of the 4090, the metrics are ridiculous. F1 at 4k gets 230 FPS vs 135 for a 3090ti and 41 for the 2080. Total War at 1440p gets 235fps vs 135 for a 3090 ti and 47fps for a 2080. Yes, its extremely expensive, but it's Nvidia's HERO card. You're going to see downward movement with the 4080 models (one basically being a 4070 in disguise) next month. These cards are too powerful for anything out there today (they do cyberpunk at 4k at 80fps without DLSS and 135 fps with it) but this is a card you buy if you're looking at 3-5 year upgrade cycles. Comparing this card to Intel's Arc is crazy. It's like comparing a Ferrari to a Civic. They both serve a purpose, but their markets are completely different. That being said, I bet you the 4090 will outsell the intel arc 750 by a stupidly large margin. It has…