The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Keyboards

IBM / Unicomp Model M vs PFU HHKB

Hacker News owners lean toward the PFU HHKB.

IBM / Unicomp Model MPFU HHKB
Owners with an opinion201109
Positive verdicts77% of 17688% of 99
Positive/negative since 202460/2619/3
Happy after 3+ years2616
Longest happy owner38 yrs20 yrs
Praised forcomfort and reliabilityergonomics and comfort
Criticized fornoise and build qualityease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

IBM / Unicomp Model M: NeutralPFU HHKB: Likes it
I really hated most keyboards but had realized that some keyboards were better than others: for example in the nineties I had an amazing keyboard on a Mac. Then I worked on IBM Model M a tiny bit (big mainframe terminals). So I started looking for both a shape and a switch that'd suit me. I obsessed over it. I even got a few collectible ones: a very rare split Cherry MX-5000 keyboard (comes stock with cherry brown switches but they could be swapped) and then the rare real "industrial" IBM Model M (in olive grey instead of beige color). Eventually I found out Topre switches on the japanese HHKB keyboars (Happy Hacking Keyboard) and as I've got family in Japan, I had three HHKB Pro JP shipped to me (when family would come to visit). I don't speak/type japanese but I dig that japanese version as a very narrow spacebar and hence more modifiers and modifiers that are easier to reach with the thumbs. Been a happy camper since more than 10 years now. So basically... Maybe I obsessed over it a bit but then I eventually "found" my keyboard and it's the HHKB Pro JP and found my switch: and my switch is Topre and nothing else.
IBM / Unicomp Model M: NeutralPFU HHKB: Likes it
> My perfect keyboard would be something like a 150% with standard full layout but then adding in a bunch of programmable macro keys, I want more than F12! I want F1 through F36. Not 36 but I've got one of these IBM Model M clickety clik keyboard with 24 function keys: https://www.reddit.com/r/thinkpad/comments/9i1aef/24_functio... But that said: I switched to a 60% HHKB more than a decade ago and I don't regret it. I prefer to use modifiers and less keys than more keys and longer hands / fingers travel. Maybe you'd like this Wey Tech MK06: https://deskthority.net/viewtopic.php?t=15102
IBM / Unicomp Model M: NeutralPFU HHKB: Likes it
It's a mix of three different cultural factors long extant in the programming community which came together to create today's keyboard culture: 1. Keyboard elitism Until as late as the early 2000s, there was a lot of elitism in programming circles about how using the mouse was something only "lusers" did. Keyboarding was supposedly faster than mousing (even though programmers do a lot more thinking than either keyboarding or mousing) and was the mark of an expert user. These communities would often shill certain keyboards, like the IBM Model M, or the Happy Hacking Keyboard (HHKB) because of their resilience and the feedback one felt from clacking the keys. 2. Customizing/Hacking Not much has to be said here. Hackers have been customizing their setups for as long as setups could be customized. The ability to program custom keyboard layouts and make custom keyboard firmware is as iconic hacking as it gets. 3. Setup as identity culture From the late 2000s, Unix Porn and a lot of other "setup porn" stuff became very popular. People would make cool setups that they really identified with and so setting up your keyboard to express your personal identity became a bit of a hacker rite of passage. While keyboard culture may have started with these ingredients, it's definitely its own thing these days. I'm not in it myself but I like watching it from the sidelines and it's really cool to see what people come up with. Cool layouts, custom firmware, colored keys, experimenting with diff…
IBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes itPFU HHKB: Recommends it
> i wantes to look for IBM Models M orginals. > I don't like the normal mechanical keeb market, because they're loud. So it sounds like you heard about the mythical model M and now want to own one for geek cred. Only problem is it seems like you never heard one in action. To give you an idea listen to an audio recording from a WW1 front-line. I own a 1986 Model M and bought a USB cable for it off eBay. It's FUCKING LOUD. The buckling springs not only emit a loud report but also a twang that vibrates through the steel backing plate. Very unique sound but not everyone within a kilometer will agree. Its also HUGE with a very deep profile. I love it but it took up too much room on my little desk. On a whim I bought a Happy Hacking 2 (HHK2) since I've always wanted one and wound up falling in love with the Topre switches. They are quiet while having a really soft and comfortable feel. The HHK's lack of keys was a bit annoying in some situations so I purchased an 80% Realforce RGB. Initially I did not want illuminated keys but you can turn them off or change the colors using the keys directly - no driver or software needed.
IBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes itPFU HHKB: Recommends it
Same as you basically. Tried so many of them back in the days... To me the switch is way more important than the physical layout: if the physical layout is good enough, it's good enough. Buckling springs: I stockpiled IBM Model M back when it wasn't a thing and used that for years. Alps. Cherry MXes. Then I tried a board with Topre switch and since then I'm happily camping with my HHKB Pro JP (japanese). I'd try these fancy ergonomic / self made keyboards but only the day they'll start making them with Topre switches. That's my "hack": seen that I couldn't get any custom keyboard with Topre switches, I picked the next best thing to me... A japanese Topre keyboard. Now the funny thing is: despite having some japanese family, I don't speak japanese at all (well, ok, I know the names of a few animals and know the hiraganas but that's it). I really only picked a japanese keyboard for the very narrow space bar (the point is not that the space bar is tiny but that a tiny space bar makes for modifiers left and right of the spacebar easy to reach with the thumbs as the thumbs have much less distance to travel). Another bonus of having more modifiers is that can have these additional modifiers acting as Super and Hyper. P.S: as a european for whatever reason it wasn't easy to get a Japanese HHKB Pro JP shipped to me, so I got my family in Japan to bring me two when they visited me.
IBM / Unicomp Model M: Doesn’t like itPFU HHKB: Doesn’t like it
HHKB sounds nothing like mine. Weird to type on it and hear a totally different sound. Model M sounds reasonably close, Unicomp Classic sounds very wrong.
IBM / Unicomp Model M: Recommends itPFU HHKB: Recommends it
This is a good article to familiarize yourself with the concepts, but would be great if they just listed a few keyboards that are top notch or popular for people to get started. Regardless, this is a lot of words to day that people should own either: 1. An IBM Model M keyboard, or 2. An HHKB Type S in charcoal with Topre switches and blank keycaps.
IBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes itPFU HHKB: Likes it
> There's a split between what people online post pics of on fancy desktop setups and what people prefer to use as their daily driver. I've been using the HHKB for over a year now as my "daily driver" and I absolutely love it: * I like the feeling of the keys, and also the compactness of the keyboard layout * I like that it connects to both my work & personal laptops over bluetooth, and I can switch between them with a single key chord * I like that I can carry the keyboard with me to the office, and that it was simple for me to take it with me on my recent trip to Australia, so I have my preferred keyboard feeling / layout wherever I go. Before that I was using a Unicomp Model M as my "daily driver", and while I liked it, I don't really miss the extra keys.