The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Keyboards

IBM Model F vs IBM / Unicomp Model M

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

IBM Model FIBM / Unicomp Model M
Owners with an opinion20201
Positive verdicts83% of 1877% of 176
Positive/negative since 20247/360/26
Happy after 3+ years126
Longest happy owner15 yrs38 yrs
Praised forsound and comfortcomfort and reliability
Criticized forreliability and noisenoise and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

IBM Model F: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Doesn’t like it
As a bit of a Model M fanatic, the Unicomp keyboards are nice but they are not as durable as a Model M, and certainly not as a Model F. I've had a number of Unicomps and they have all died eventually. My current keyboard is a Topre REALFORCE (exact model https://www.realforce.co.jp/en/products/104UB-S_XF11T0/ ) and it's been going strong. Kind of regret getting the one with very dim keycaps, I have to admit. The real deal would be the Model F 122 key - which I still have somewhere and still works with a strange adapter I found on eBay - the additional keys make weird letters.
IBM Model F: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Doesn’t like it
Nothing else has the Model F mechanism. The Model M has a similar but not as good mechanism. If your question is really "where can I buy a good ergonomic mechanical keyboard with high quality clicky keyswitches", the answers are myriad. Ergodox and variants are columnar and split. The Moonlander is columnar and split. X-Bows are columnar and angled but not split. All of these can be bought with blue and/or clear and/or green series switches.
IBM Model F: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes it
Exactly. I started out in my first job in an open-plan office where everyone had Model F and Model M keyboards because we were an IBM dealer and that's what IBM shipped. We made calls, talked to customers, talked to clients in the office and so on, no problem, because we were used to it. The biggest such environment I worked in circa 1993 had about 40 people in it. No problem. I carefully kept a bunch of those keyboards as people were throwing them out in the late 1990s and early 2000s and I have about 5-6 original IBM boards. I still use them. Yes in open plan offices, in the last decade. Including in crowded workplaces. I let people try my keyboards, encourage them to pick them up and feel them. I let my younger colleagues marvel that I type on a keyboard older than they are. Nobody minds. I've had like 2 complaints this century. It's not that bad. And it's also worth noting that I don't have RSI, I think because I use stiff mechanical boards with long travel and my fingers get a workout, even if the rest of me doesn't.
IBM Model F: Doesn’t like itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Doesn’t like it
Those beam springs had the second-best feel ever, after the Selectric. Then the Model F cost-reduced (and thickness-reduced) it, and the Model M further. > The downside is how tall and aggressively angled the keyboards are, which are very far from modern ergonomic standards. Like a typewriter. And like a typewriter, you were expected to have them on suitable furniture so the keytops were at the right height.
IBM Model F: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes it
Ive been collecting Model M and Model F keyboards from IBM off from Ebay over the last few years. I've got quite a collection now. Only the IBM manufactured keyboards, no Lexmark or third-party. I remember typing on a Model M as a kid. My fingers pushing the empty spaces between CTRL and ALT, where on newer keyboards, an OS meta now lives. I remember writing Basic. Then Turbo Pascal. Full of curiosity and wonder. The IBM authentic keyboards have a badge on the back with the year and month of manufacture. Most of these keyboards are older than my co-workers. Many still function correctly. They're a joy to use.
IBM Model F: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes it
> German Utility Patent 1,279,693 This one's pretty amazing to see, given how close it is in appearance to the Ergodox and other "glove keyboards" (rather, the other way around—they all resemble IBM's patent!). > British Utility Patent 1,363,777 (GB1363777A) While the buckling spring switches used in the Model M (or, for those with more rarified tastes, Model F) are rightly lauded, the beamspring is less well-known. The individual modules are absolutely massive as far as keyswitches go, but they feel wonderful to type on. They were designed to evoke the Selectric so as to be familiar to new users, and some models, such as the 3278, even included a solenoid that would click with each keypress. They also featured doubleshot keycaps and were absolute bricks that make the Model M seem a featherweight by comparison.
IBM Model F: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes it
As an Xer who grew up with all these old technologies and saw the transitions to modern stuff, I fully agree. It's odd how Millennials are so interested in obsolete and obviously inferior technologies like LPs and Polaroid photos. There's very, very few cases I can think of where an older technology really was better in a significant way. Mechanical keyboards like the IBM Model M (or better yet, the Model F, though the layouts on those keyboards sucked) were really great, but they were also expensive, and we do have all the Cherry-switch mech keyboards now, though personally I don't like them as much. However, one big negative trend I do see is with streaming services and the entire lack of ownership this carries. This isn't really a technology problem: there's nothing stopping you from buying real CDs and ripping them to FLAC and listening to those on your phone, for instance (that's what I do). I'd call this a mis-application of new technology, similar to how so much software is so ridiculously slow and laggy: it's entirely possible (and easier than ever before with modern tooling) to write software that performs well, but people are just too lazy to do it, and insist on building in too much BS like ads and tracking.