The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

HTC Vive vs Valve Index

Hacker News owners lean toward the Valve Index.

HTC ViveValve Index
Owners with an opinion104128
Positive verdicts53% of 6856% of 102
Positive/negative since 20249/724/13
Happy after 3+ years10
Longest happy owner6 yrs0.5 yrs
Praised forperformance and comfortperformance and comfort
Criticized fordisplay and ease of useease of use and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

HTC Vive: NeutralValve Index: Likes it
In your case, with an RX 590, do NOT buy an expensive x3D processor expecting any improvement. I upgraded from an RX580 (using an original HTC Vive) to an RX 5700xt (and a valve Index) and that's the position you are in. You cannot drive a high pixel density VR headset with a Mid tier GPU from 8 years ago. Get something that is at least as powerful as that RX 5700xt I had (I now have a 4070 super) and you will be satisfied. It drove my Index at 90hz.
HTC Vive: Likes itValve Index: Recommends it
If budget isn't an issue, get an Index. I personally prefer the Vive hands and lighthouses from 2016 and the Index headset from 2021, but if you're starting from scratch, you might as well just get the Index and go from there. A full Vive set would also be fine for starting, but's aging (7 years old now), and you may appreciate the fidelity the Index has.
HTC Vive: Likes itValve Index: Neutral
Regarding using a joystick to move around in VR, in my experience I wasn't very inconvenienced by it. I travelled immense distances in a variety of worlds and am glad to have not actually had to walk that far. I also found a preference for the original Vive's trackpads for movement over the Index's more conventional stick movement. The pad just felt more intuitive. Walking around with 1:1 between VR and real space is indeed pretty cool, but I wouldn't want to do it full time in all games.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
> Personally, I'm not at all: I can spend hours in VR and not mind at all. Others are sick in moments. For me, it depends on the game. I can play Beat Saber or PokerStars VR for hours and not care. Assetto Corsa or MS Flight Simulator? As soon as the car/plane starts moving, I get queasy. I can only handle a single lap around the Nurburgring before I have to take a 30 minute break to let my stomach recover. In MS Flight Simulator, I gotta stick to large aircraft that maneuver very slowly and have massive cockpits. I'm fairly sure my experience is pretty common, which is why I always feel people are doing a MASSIVE disservice to VR adoption when they let someone try VR for the first time and it's a racing game or a roller coaster simulator. > The "heavy headset" thing I don't really feel either - I have a Valve Index for chrissakes - but again other people will have a different experience. When I had an HTC Vive, it felt heavy on my face. When I updated to an Index, it was a world of difference. The strap design on the Index does a much better job of putting the weight of the headset on the top of your head, spread over the strap. I don't know about any of Meta's headsets.
HTC Vive: NeutralValve Index: Likes it
I went Cardboard (though used it very little, probably only 1 hour cumulative) -> HTC Vive -> Valve Index. I'll probably buy a Valve Index 2 if it ever happens. Portable VR is highly limited by battery power. VR requires high pixel counts and high framerates to be immersive, and pushing that many pixels uses a lot of power.
HTC Vive: NeutralValve Index: Doesn’t like it
The Quest 2 is the best bang for the buck by far. Unfortunately made by facebook, but designed by John Carmack while he was still working there, and if I'm not mistaken sold at a loss. For the money it's the clear choice. Another option if you don't mind over paying is the valve index. You'll get higher resolution and finger tracking. It's also said to be quite comfortable. At $1000 it's more like a sports car. By that I mean it breaks down all the time. When it's working it's great but if you use it a lot there are problems with the controllers. Lots of RMA stories. Many people turn to dissembling them and fixing things themselves. I've turned to that with my Vive. The soon to be released PSVR 2 on PS5 is also worth an honorable mention but leaves out some of the experimental VR stuff you can hack around at on PC VR. Edit: I should note as well with the Quest 2. There isn't even a tradeoff between PCVR and standalone mode. You can get the link cable and use it as a PCVR headset to play steam games etc.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
Correction: majority of people who didn’t spend their lives gaming get motion sickness pretty quickly anyways. This is coming from someone with an index running at 144 Hz on a 3090. I’ve actively been encouraging friends and family to try it and my experience is that motion sickness hits about 18/20 people within 30 minutes of play, depending on the game. However I’ve noticed that my friends who have played a lot of computer games (in particular fast paced FPS) tend to fare better, and also that the sickness goes away with practice. I used to get it too but now I can beatsaber for literal hours without discomfort. The headset does make a difference, (my friend’s Vive was particularly bad), but it’s not as great as you suggest. Time and practice are far more important.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
Many people got a very bad impression from Oculus DKs and the Vive. Vive basically was a half baked tech demo compared to the new hardware. Terrible lenses, very heavy and uncomfortable, possibly the worst controllers ever made. VR (Quest 2, Index) is actually good now, 5 years on from that - give it another shot.
Switched from the HTC Vive to the Valve IndexValve Index: Likes it
Prescription lenses works as long as no-one else wants to use it. I mostly used my headsets myself, but it was fun showing VR to other people. > As far as FOV, it sounds like based on one video review that the company is giving a low estimate for FOV so as to avoid over promising, and they suggest that users may find the FOV is higher. I'm not sure I'd trust that, I'd like to hear some other reviews first. The 90Hz thing is still an issue for me though, it turns out that higher refresh is important for immersion. I don't play "flat" games at higher than 60Hz, but 90 to 120 (HTC Vive to Valve Index) was a good change.
HTC Vive: Likes itValve Index: Likes it
There's an incredibly simple product case I think HN is missing: I bought a Vive and then an Index. This has higher resolution than the Index, lower mass (even with a battery!), and easier setup that can enable more spontaneous use. In addition, I now get the benefits of "standalone" headsets that I previously did not think were worth hundreds of dollars on their own. Am I paying $1000 for a minor improvement? Yes. It's a hobby. It costs money sometimes. I don't do this for nearly anything else, like phones that other people seem fine for paying $1000 every other year. I expect this device to last until another 6 years when I can justify spending another $1000 on another iterative improvement. Similarly, I may spend $1000 on a new setup for simracing soon. Spending $6k on a gaming PC, a VR headset, and wheels and pedals is an experience you otherwise cannot get. I would spend money on VR even if it only worked with one or two driving games and nothing else. For those of us in that niche, VR has been anything but a "Failure", that business people seem convinced it is because it couldn't be the next "Platform" to put an app store on. But, that's the market for VR. It's a niche toy for people with expendable income. It's not a mass market to rival the smartphone.
HTC Vive: Likes itValve Index: Likes it
I suspect the motion lag from “inside-out” tracking (compared to valve index or vive, which was tolerable) was enough to induce nausea, at least for me.
HTC Vive: Likes itValve Index: Likes it
I've had a HTC Vive, Quest 2, and the Valve Index. It's much higher fidelity than any of them by a very large margin. The virtual desktop feature is pretty similar experiences. The hand tracking controls are classic apple (it just works). The eye tracking can use some more work. I do feel that this could be the future. It's a huge step forward in certain areas, and I think the rest will be fixed. In a generation or two, this is going to be really compelling. I never felt that way about any of the other headsets I own.
HTC Vive: NeutralValve Index: Neutral
I was an early adopter of VR. Original Quest, followed by Htc Vive followed by Valve Index, followed by Quest 3. Spent almost as much hours gaming and using VR as I do my regular computer. I recently tried the Vision Pro at my friends house. Graphics are definitely a lot better. Hand tracking is better than Quest 3. Weight is definitely bulkier on out of all the headsets, but thats something that you get used to - when I first started gaming in VR, my neck was super sore, but after a while, you actually end up strengthening your neck and upper back, which ironically resulted in less headaches for me during the day. That being said, Vision pro is nothing revolutionary. You either have to be a massive Apple stan or never experienced VR to begin with to find it amazing. Its a better iteration of the current VR headsets for sure, but just like the rest, its missing the point. The biggest problem in itself is that everyone is trying to mix VR and AR into one, which is the wrong way to go. VR is way better with external tracking, because you can do things like full body tracking. In VR chat, Ive participated in a few events where people were teaching dance or martial arts, with trackers on hip, knees and legs, and it worked out quite well. Behind the back tracking is also useful for games. Of course the issue with VR is that the entry cost (including the space to play VR) is very high, so the community is VERY tiny. AR on the other hand needs to be a very lightweight, low profile…
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
Yeah, the Quest's boundary setup process astounded me at how polished and user-friendly it is compared to the Vive and Index's room setup process. Anyone saying that the Quest's software is obviously terrible lives on a different planet than me. The Quest is so simple and works so well compared to other VR headsets+software I've used.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
I hope it comes to fruition! It's too bad that the computational parts aren't outside of the headset so the headset could be MUCH lighter, then I'd definitely be willing to get one. I'm a real VR nerd myself and play often, I've had the original Oculus, CV1, Vive and now Index - the next one will have to be super-light because it's frustrating to not be able to use VR for more than an hour due to neck and face pains.
HTC Vive: Likes itValve Index: Likes it
As an owner of an HTC Vive and a Quest 2, I find the terrible specs of the Quest to be the biggest reason why it collects dust. The resolution is horrible, the cameras are horrible, and the apps it can run are crap. Exploring raytraced worlds on my 3090Ti in a high resolution Vive or Valve Index delivers a level of immersive experience that’s impossible to achieve on Quests hardware. The Quest 3 is still a bit of a potato but one day, quality and convenience will converge into a sweet spot that clicks for more people in a way that only enthusiasts get to experience nowadays. A portable Index would likely have the impact people tend to expect when they imagine futuristic VR.
HTC Vive: Likes itValve Index: Likes it
They work REALLY well. Ever since getting my HTC Vive in 2017, and recently upgrading to a Valve Index, I haven't played a non-vr FPS game. Check out PavlovVR (CS:GO ripoff): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OPMllOHfxCc Serious Sam VR: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-Qgx70_P8E