The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

HTC Vive vs Meta Quest

Hacker News owners lean toward the Meta Quest.

HTC ViveMeta Quest
Owners with an opinion104806
Positive verdicts53% of 6853% of 672
Positive/negative since 20249/7169/143
Happy after 3+ years12
Longest happy owner6 yrs5 yrs
Praised forperformance and comfortperformance and ease of use
Criticized fordisplay and ease of usecomfort and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

HTC Vive: NeutralMeta Quest: Likes it
I had the HTC Vive quite a few years ago, using it a lot and constantly buying new games and experiences to try it out. It was a little annoying paying full whack for little 5-10min tech demos but was still encapsulated by it. Eventually got the wireless extension to avoid having to detangle the rope of a cable you were tethered to, but the base stations in the corner of the room were still annoying me cause you constantly had to re-calibrate it everytime someone nudged or moved them. Left it for quite a few years and after seeing the reviews about the Quest 3, I bought that and was amazed by how simple it was to pickup and use and the fact that you didn't need a monster computer running it. You literally pick it up and get going. The Meta app store is filled with lots of VR Titles which aren't just tech demos and you can STILL hook it up to your computer and play a host of Steam games. The Quest 3 was like €500 and basically a full platform. The Vision Pro got announced with a few improvements like higher resolution but it was an insane €3500... ok I was curious how much better it would be, since I was quite impressed by my Quest 3. My friend had bought one, one of those people who loves to wear expensive watches and be seen in public having a lot of money. As with a lot of Apple products it's sometimes about being seen to have the latest thing and the Vision Pro was great for sitting in public, catching attention and showing people that you can afford a €3500 device. He bri…
HTC Vive: NeutralMeta Quest: Likes it
I've had the HTC Vive, bought a million games, done virtual desktop and then last year bought the Quest 3. The fact you can pick it up and get going without tethering to a computer or setting up base stations and see through it is amazing for €500. Had a friend show me the Vision Pro and couldn't believe the cost and how similar it was to the Quest 3. I asked him if you can install Steam etc and he's like nah... ok so you paid €4500 to look at a dinosaur tech demo and do a virtual desktop. It just doesn't make sense why anyone would buy one over the Quest other than to show people in public they can afford a 5k device and have people looking at them
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Likes it
I think there are creature comfort areas Apple can work on, definitely, but I was very surprised at how Apple-like the experience of the Quest was, from unboxing to the UI. Especially coming from a Vive/Steam combo which is a bit of a technical Rube Goldberg machine and expects a certain amount of technical skills on top of owning a gaming PC, which is its own barrier to entry, both financially and technical skill-wise. The bigger issue is that the Meta is just a gaming device while the Vision Pro is being marketed as a productivity device. I think this is where Apple can have success. They could, predictably, be the Apple // to Meta's Colecovision.
HTC Vive: NeutralMeta Quest: Recommends it
I was an early adopter of VR. Original Quest, followed by Htc Vive followed by Valve Index, followed by Quest 3. Spent almost as much hours gaming and using VR as I do my regular computer. I recently tried the Vision Pro at my friends house. Graphics are definitely a lot better. Hand tracking is better than Quest 3. Weight is definitely bulkier on out of all the headsets, but thats something that you get used to - when I first started gaming in VR, my neck was super sore, but after a while, you actually end up strengthening your neck and upper back, which ironically resulted in less headaches for me during the day. That being said, Vision pro is nothing revolutionary. You either have to be a massive Apple stan or never experienced VR to begin with to find it amazing. Its a better iteration of the current VR headsets for sure, but just like the rest, its missing the point. The biggest problem in itself is that everyone is trying to mix VR and AR into one, which is the wrong way to go. VR is way better with external tracking, because you can do things like full body tracking. In VR chat, Ive participated in a few events where people were teaching dance or martial arts, with trackers on hip, knees and legs, and it worked out quite well. Behind the back tracking is also useful for games. Of course the issue with VR is that the entry cost (including the space to play VR) is very high, so the community is VERY tiny. AR on the other hand needs to be a very lightweight, low profile…
HTC Vive: NeutralMeta Quest: Likes it
Ha, I was downvoted and told "why do we need controllers, the iphone and macbook dont come with controllers" yesterday when I said this is stupid without controllers. I have a vive, q2 and q3. Look at him trying to type on that keyboard. I have hand gestures on my q3. They're nice for a few certain things, but thankfully I can forget they exist for 99% of what I do, that isn't flinging windows/screens left and right and expanding them in front of me. Or turning wifi on and off, etc.. And.. you can't do multiple screens and it has less resolution than my real life monitor when connecting to a mbp.. hm. I thought that was a super cool feature when I thought you could just add monitors wherever. I hadn't even thought of it before they showed it in the demo.
HTC Vive: Likes itMeta Quest: Doesn’t like it
Based on my extensive experience with a Quest 2, overall weight isn’t as much of a factor as balance of that weight is. The Quest 2 wasn’t that comfortable to use out of the box, but after adding a Vive Deluxe Audio Strap connected with 3D printed adapters (which distributes weight better) and a counterweight that’s attached the back of the strap it’s dramatically improved. Still not perfect, but I have no issues wearing it for an hour or longer playing Beat Saber.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Likes it
I still wish I could jailbreak them so I could purge their egregious telemetry. Collecting VR telemetry in particular, details that can be gleaned and inferred about your physical body and physical activity, really creeps me out. It's the only reason I haven't bought into VR again yet (I was on the train with the original HTC Vive for a couple years but that headset has aged). I've played the quest and I'm very impressed with it hardware and experience wise. I'm still waiting for a comparable option that has: - open source / jailbreak capability for full device control - stream higher spec games from PC - the ergonomics, ease of use, and portability of the quest headset - reasonably priced Once that headset arrives, I will probably get sucked back into VR
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Likes it
Yeah, the Quest's boundary setup process astounded me at how polished and user-friendly it is compared to the Vive and Index's room setup process. Anyone saying that the Quest's software is obviously terrible lives on a different planet than me. The Quest is so simple and works so well compared to other VR headsets+software I've used.
HTC Vive: Likes itMeta Quest: Doesn’t like it
As an owner of an HTC Vive and a Quest 2, I find the terrible specs of the Quest to be the biggest reason why it collects dust. The resolution is horrible, the cameras are horrible, and the apps it can run are crap. Exploring raytraced worlds on my 3090Ti in a high resolution Vive or Valve Index delivers a level of immersive experience that’s impossible to achieve on Quests hardware. The Quest 3 is still a bit of a potato but one day, quality and convenience will converge into a sweet spot that clicks for more people in a way that only enthusiasts get to experience nowadays. A portable Index would likely have the impact people tend to expect when they imagine futuristic VR.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Likes it
The only pro that I see with black box is that you get resistance training. I can’t think of any other VR offering that has this feature After that all I see are negatives: I should try it before I complain, but a big point about VR is being able to do stuff remotely with people. Having to physically go to a gym gives you lots of excuses not to go vs having VR in the living room. The travel time is also a time sink. As others have pointed out, hygiene is a thing. I’m not keen on wearing a headset that other sweaty people used. It’s one thing to use normal gym equipment, but this goes on my face. Not sure if UV light is enough. That particular headset is gross when it’s damp. Looking at the headset, it looked like an HTC Vive model which is really old. The Quest 2 has much better visual fidelity. I know this because I’ve owned and used both extensively. A quest 2 is also a very affordable as a standalone VR peloton. Another big problem that this shares with other gyms is the lack of variety compared to VR workouts at home. It looks like there is only one game. Even if there are variations, it’s still just one game. That will get boring within two months.
HTC Vive: Likes itMeta Quest: Doesn’t like it
As an early adopter of the Vive (didn't preorder but bought within the first few weeks) who also has a Quest 2, the "good-enough" part of your previous post is definitely open to interpretation. I will say I agree with using it wireless being the default recommendation, but there's a reason people still buy fiber optic USB-C cables. If you have a good WiFi setup, which a lot of people do not (and a lot of people who think they should have good WiFi because they spent a lot of money on it still don't because they don't understand what they bought), it's perfectly fine for most games that don't depend on tight timing, but you can still tell when playing Beat Saber or similar. I noticed it most as input jank on the controllers, both compared to the Vive and native Quest apps. IMO the right answer is a Quest-like standalone handset with a VirtualLink style input to allow uncompressed signals with predictable latency to flow between the two. Best of both worlds. Wired Quest now is effectively just using the USB port as a network interface rather than a display.
HTC Vive: Likes itMeta Quest: Doesn’t like it
> Apple is good at making consumers want something they didn't know they needed. No one needs VR, and no one ever will. So you think you don’t need VR and now it’s up to Apple to show you that you are wrong. The modern VR that was jump started by HTC Vive (which got demo at WWDC) is really impressive. Quest 2 is a success — 20 million units sold. Even with terrible UX and limited use cases.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Likes it
> They were using HTC Vive headsets, which retail for $1,000+. Slight nitpick: Those would be the HTC Vive Pro headsets. The "HTC Vive" came out in 2016 and is a pretty shitty device by today's standards. Also, it retailed for $600. > We had a 1 hour session with the goggles and I felt quite sea sick during and after gameplay. This varies from person to person, but most people only get sick when playing games where the real-world movement doesn't match game-world movement. For example, most people can play Beat Saber with no motion sickness problems, but will feel sick almost instantly if they play a racing game or a game that lets you walk by using a controller input. I've had VR since late 2016 and this still rings true. I can play PokerStars VR for 4+ hours and my only complaint will be the weight of the headset starting to feel overbearing. On the other hand, 2 minutes of Assetto Corsa and I feel like I'm gonna lose my lunch. > The arcade was expensive. I paid nearly $100 for 1 hour for 2 people in a MCOL area. One of the reasons for the high cost is the arcade required an employee to help us cycle through games and explain gameplay and controls. Shitty experiences in VR arcades are exacerbated by the fact that they're usually staffed by people that just needed a job, and not VR enthusiasts that care about sharing their excitement for the platform. > solve the sea sickness problem It's a difficult problem to solve because the core issue is the mismatch between mo…
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Likes it
I have that strap for my Quest 2. It's very good. Better than the 1st party battery-pack strap. This configuration is called a "halo" strap. I also have the Quest Pro now. It comes with a halo strap. Nothing touches your cheeks. Resolution is also very high, and the new pancake lenses are very clear. That's another problem with older headsets. The Fresnel lenses in previous systems cause "god rays" around any bright objects on dark backgrounds. Like, say, light text on a dark background for a dark-mode UI. Pancake lenses don't have that problem. They also have a much larger sweet spot, so you don't have to get the headset perfectly adjusted every time, and you can look around with just your eyes, not moving your head, more. I think the Vive Flow was the first commercially available headset to use the pancake lenses, but the Flow is otherwise not a great experience. The Quest Pro is really impressive.
HTC Vive: NeutralMeta Quest: Recommends it
The Quest 2 is the best bang for the buck by far. Unfortunately made by facebook, but designed by John Carmack while he was still working there, and if I'm not mistaken sold at a loss. For the money it's the clear choice. Another option if you don't mind over paying is the valve index. You'll get higher resolution and finger tracking. It's also said to be quite comfortable. At $1000 it's more like a sports car. By that I mean it breaks down all the time. When it's working it's great but if you use it a lot there are problems with the controllers. Lots of RMA stories. Many people turn to dissembling them and fixing things themselves. I've turned to that with my Vive. The soon to be released PSVR 2 on PS5 is also worth an honorable mention but leaves out some of the experimental VR stuff you can hack around at on PC VR. Edit: I should note as well with the Quest 2. There isn't even a tradeoff between PCVR and standalone mode. You can get the link cable and use it as a PCVR headset to play steam games etc.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Likes it
Many people got a very bad impression from Oculus DKs and the Vive. Vive basically was a half baked tech demo compared to the new hardware. Terrible lenses, very heavy and uncomfortable, possibly the worst controllers ever made. VR (Quest 2, Index) is actually good now, 5 years on from that - give it another shot.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Likes it
The so called "screendoor effect" is not there anymore with the Quest 2 high res HMD's. My HTC vive had it and it was annoying but a good game could rule it out, with video it was visible. But on the Quest2 you can't see it.
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Neutral
This blog post goes into one person that claims they've spent 1000s of hours working in vR https://blog.immersed.team/working-from-orbit-39bf95a6d385 And when it hit HN https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28678041 For me, the Vive is too heavy for this. I have not personally used a Quest 2 more than 5 mins (not willing to use an FB account) but it is arguably slightly more comfortable than a Vive headset (not saying it's comfortable enough, only that it's less uncomfortable than a Vive)
HTC Vive: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest: Neutral
I tried the exact setup of this 1000+ hours person, having been excited by the concept of a monitor-less office for years. My current setup is multiple 4k monitors in pixel-doubled resolution. It is relatively easy on the eyes and not too expensive ($300ish/monitor + VESA). I am working remotely and when I travel I have to work from my laptop and I would love to have a headset to replicate the multiple monitor experience on the go. I have been hoping for this since the HTC Vive. HTC Vive - simply too low resolution. Screen door effect visible. Also software such as Immersed was not available. Replicating this 1000+ hour setup went as follows: 1. Buy a Quest 2. Meta has its issues however I have an account so no real issues on the Meta side other than Meta itself. Resolution is clearly superior to HTC Vive, with no obvious screen door effect. As the original poster mentions - the strap that comes with the Quest is terrible, and you will have to spend at least $100 to get the Quest to the point where it can be used continuously for long periods without the device itself being a distraction. 2. Immersed - Major issues with this software. Thankfully they give you a "pro" trial so you can try this without paying. Main issue was painlessly delivering what I wanted: screen closed multiple 4k-equivalent virtual monitors. On mac (preferred), there were issues with HDMI spoofing that I probably could have fixed with dongles had I desired. On windows the situation was better,…