The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

HP Reverb vs Meta Quest

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

HP ReverbMeta Quest
Owners with an opinion24806
Positive verdicts61% of 1853% of 672
Positive/negative since 20245/3169/143
Happy after 3+ years12
Longest happy owner5 yrs5 yrs
Praised fordisplay and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitycomfort and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

HP Reverb: Likes itMeta Quest: Doesn’t like it
At least with the Quest, the video quality over cable was only slightly better than wireless. The heat and weight of the extra hardware also becomes noticeable when sitting for a while. For example, there's no way I could do an 8 hour work day inside a Quest - but I imagine a cool lightweight bigscreen beyond would be fine. I used to love shooting games in my G2, I got the Quest and, despite having a similar resolution, I could hardly make out distant targets whether wired or not. It entirely killed VR for me and I haven't used it in over 6 months.
HP Reverb: Likes itMeta Quest: Neutral
I know everyone is singing the praises of the Steam Frame's wireless capabilities but honestly, I just want my wired VR experience back. I had a Rift 2, Reverb G2, then Quest 2 and eventually Quest 3. Despite the Quest 3 having a resolution similar to the G2, it looked more like the Rift 2 than the awe inspiring G2. Wireless gaming never looked as sharp and streaming over USB was also a very poor experience, with input latency and artifacting. Wireless headsets also _suck_ for simulators and productivity - where a battery only adds weights and a wire is not noticable. Personally, I would love to see a wired headset that resembles the bigscreen beyond but with inside out tracking and a universal face gasket. For wireless experiences, I'd love to be able to plug my phone in, put it in my back pocket and use it that way. That sort of "head mounted display"-first approach would make it practical to use the device for productivity / screen replacement while gaming would be dependant on your phone or computer.
HP Reverb: NeutralMeta Quest: Doesn’t like it
Q2 owner, decided not to upgrade to the Q3 because I want a mid range headset with a DisplayPort connection. As much as I appreciate wireless PCVR - I am excited for its future but it doesn't do it for me at this stage. People say that the latency and fidelity are indistinguishable from wired PCVR - that has not been my experience. I have a high end WiFi 6 router where the Q2 is the only device connected in line of sight of the router via 5ghz and my PC is connected via gigabit ethernet. I have also tweaked all the settings, purchased Virtual Desktop and done my best. It's _fine_ but certainly not delivering anywhere close to what the headset hardware can offer in terms of fidelity. The worst part is that, though better than wireless, even PCVR over the link cable is kinda rubbish. Previously to the Q2 I had an HP Reverb G2 and the visual quality was mind blowing - however the controller tracking and software was a disaster. Prior to that I had a Rift 2 and prior to that Lenovo Explorer. The Quest 2 feels about as good as the Rift 2 - though I think I preferred the Rift 2 because it had little-to-no setup and felt more responsive in games like BeatSaber. The reviews for the Q3 sing its praises but I have been here before. I have tried the Pico 4 and I know the Q3 is around that level of quality - however the lack of uncompressed, responsive PCVR keeps me away. If Meta released a Rift 3 - which was just a lighter/thinner Q3 without the battery/SoC - I'd be all over it. I'd lov…
HP Reverb: Likes itMeta Quest: Doesn’t like it
As someone who spends a good amount of time on iracing, what annoys me most about VR not taking off more is the lack of improvements in VR headsets. We just get more high-end stuff like the Varjo Aero, Bigscreen Beyond or Pimax Crystal, but since the release of the HP Reverb G2 there haven't been any sensibly priced options anymore. And things like the Quest or Pico are just pretty rubbish for PCVR (compression, dealing with flimsy USB C connectors, Oculus software etc.).
HP Reverb: NeutralMeta Quest: Likes it
The hardware looks pretty good. I bought a HP reverb G2 because it had the highest resolution. While not bad, i learned that resolution isn't everything as the picture is pretty blurry anywhere except dead ahead due to the Fresnel lenses, so the new pancake lenses sound promising. I also don't get motion sickness and might be interested in working in VR if the readability is good. My only other hold up is that even at 36 years old and using computers since I was 5, I still don't type properly and do occasionally look down at the keyboard lol. Would be great if the forward facing cameras will allow this.
HP Reverb: Likes itMeta Quest: Doesn’t like it
I find the HP Reverb G2 to be incredibly comfortable and can wear it for hours. I do have an air conditioning unit in my VR room which keeps me cool while moving during that time. The Quest 2 is the lest comfortable thing I've ever put on my face and due to its popularity, seems to skew perspectives around how comfortable VR can be.
HP Reverb: Recommends itMeta Quest: Doesn’t like it
I would not recommend Quest 2 for flight sim: Terrible image quality and noticeable latency. I cannot recommend this headset anymore after having tried the G2. The only thing the Quest 2 has going for it is the price. A nice 2nd hand G2 reverb is the best choice IMO for overall value atm.
HP Reverb: NeutralMeta Quest: Likes it
That's a hard question, as they are all a little flawed in some way. Something like: Varjo Aero - probably the nicest overall, but quite expensive. HP Reverb G2 - nice for sit-down VR like simulators etc. Not great for general VR so much. Meta Quest 2 - good entry level for general VR as it can be stand-alone (no wires!) or PC linked and is probably the best value overall. Valve Index - probably the nicest stand-up VR overall package due to its tracking tech, but getting long in the tooth now and needs a revision.
HP Reverb: NeutralMeta Quest: Likes it
I haven't tried this device, but I've tried HP's G2 (which is noticeable absent from Simula's comparison matrix). From personal experience, it's terrible for games that require controller tracking aside from driving and flying sims, but... it has a 2160 resolution per eye (text is very clear with no screen door effect) and it's $599 MSRP; it also frequently goes on sale for $399. Paired with Virtual Desktop software, you can work in VR now in Windows & MacOS if portability and Linux support isn't a necessity; though I imagine it could work on a high powered laptop https://www.hp.com/us-en/vr/reverb-g2-vr-headset.html https://www.vrdesktop.net/ On a side note, I don't notice the screen door effect in either the Index or Quest 2 while playing games. Are you saying you notice it while playing games, or while reading text?
HP Reverb: Likes itMeta Quest: Likes it
If you want to work in VR, I recommend getting the highest resolution possible. I love my Quest 2 for everything other than reading text. It was nausea inducing. The Valve Index is better but the resolution still isn’t there With HP’s reverb G2, it’s definitely possible since it has a higher resolution at a good price point. You can get used headsets for less than $300. It’s not great for games that require moving around since tracking is horrible, but it’s really great for work and sim games