The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

HP EliteBook vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Lenovo ThinkPad.

HP EliteBookLenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion972732
Positive verdicts67% of 8475% of 2366
Positive/negative since 202416/15686/273
Happy after 3+ years13281
Longest happy owner13 yrs25 yrs
Praised forreliability and repairabilityreliability and performance
Criticized fordisplay and performancebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

HP EliteBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Or not. I've been using Linux since 2006, initially for fun and giggles, and then by choice, and nowadays it's without a doubt the superior alternative. My successive employers forcing me through Windows gave me the "privilege" of daily-driving Windows at work and seeing up-close everything that Microsoft has produced since XP. That show-stopping 15min drivers installation because you plugged-in some headset or mouse? That's Windows-only. That screen positioning that can't be remembered consistently between work and office? Ditto. That nefarious hours-long unskippable OS-upgrade? Same. That feeling of losing your mind because you configured something in a specific way and now it's gone? Oh yeah, that's Windows overriding your user-preferences behind your back, just because. Your playlist blasting in the open space? Apparently that's a Windows feature of your bluetooth headphones switching off (even when they were not playing because your playlist was paused). That wifi that you have to re-enter the credentials once a month or so? Yeah, Windows suspend/resume once again crapped and that somehow caused network amnesia. And that's just the hardware-ish stuff. The permanent nagging, upselling, silly distractions, adverts and overall lack of polish and stability is nothing new in software-land. I cannot remember when I last had a network, bluetooth, audio or driver issue with Linux on my ThinkPad. I legitimately cannot. But I can assure you I that had 3 of those in the last couple…
HP EliteBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
> is of zero consequence to me It is inconsequential, until it isn't. In front of me I've got a 2017 lenovo thinkpad running the latest Fedora+KDE, as well as a 2025 HP elitebook running "last corporate-friendly-stable version of W11". I can pop open the lenovo, key in my session password and hit enter, and I'm instantly productive, with shortcuts like meta+E giving me a working file explorer within milliseconds. On the Windows' side, there are several seconds of delay between typing my password and the on-screen feedback. Once finally unlocked, I've got a laggy environment where OS-essentials like the start menu and file explorers take whole seconds to render and respond. It's a shame, if you ask me, that a dozen-or-so CPU and "general hardware" generations between those two devices got to waste due to poor software engineering and practices. And I'm not even talking about quality/reliability which is another sore point for Windowses of late.
HP EliteBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Works fine for me, on Fruit Factory hardware even. Close the thing, it goes to sleep. Open it, it wakes up. Leave it closed for a very very long time and it hibernates. Open it again and it comes back to life. Your experience may vary depending on what hardware you run it on but for me it works fine on the mentioned machines, on a HP Spectre 360, another HP Elitebook and on a really ancient Toshiba Satellite. I've had problems with sleep on a Thinkpad P50 with a discrete NVidia Quattro GPU, it goes to sleep but won't wake up so I have that machine set to hibernate as soon as the lid is closed. This takes a bit longer (but not that long, SSD is fast) but it would have been more pleasant to use if normal sleep worked as intended.
HP EliteBook: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Not sure about this Apple displays. But I have driven dual 4K displays off of my HP Elitebook 850 g7. I have actually gone back to 2K displays and I find those better for programming. I am currently running 3 2K displays (all of them massive 32 inch) via a single cable to my docking station. I also have a thinkpad t420s this can do the same. Both of them running Ubuntu 22.04
HP EliteBook: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Same flaw all the Thinkpads have had for centuries now. Garbage speakers are the norm for laptops. The first time I heard one of the newer MacBooks speakers while I had a Thinkpad was eye opening. Work gives me an elite book and while it’s much better than most, it’s still bad. The whole case resonates and adds noise and it runs some shitty software that uses 30% cpu to make it sound decent. Disabling that software brings it back to average laptop levels.
HP EliteBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I run two Thinkpad T420s and one T420 at home, for myself and family. The T420s in particular are as small as I need a laptop to be (T420, no 's', is a bit bulky and old school); and yet they are fully modular - you can swap out battery, or Ultrabay (DVD to HDD to extra battery) with a quick pull of lever; it takes one well-marked screw to access primary hard drive or RAM. They're reliable, sturdy, good looking in a timeless way; AND, they don't try to re-invent the keyboard. This is a massive, massive reason I stick with the *20 series of Thinkpads - all modern laptops feel the need to reinvent the layout, which means I can NEVER use my muscle memory to do Ctrl-Home, Ctrl-End, PgUp, PgDwn, which I use constantly. They get relegated to some tiny buttons in non-sensical random places that differ between manufacturers and models. I had to use HpElitebook and Dell something or the other for work, which were fine laptops in their own way, but try to emulate Apple in size and format, and the keyboards were maddeningly awful in their layout. Less of a Rant, more to the point - the T420s is perfectly usable today without any crazy "mods" - a $40 SSD which literally slots in is pretty much the only thing it needs. We do browsing, movies, light photo browsing/editing, email, MS Office, Schoolwork, etc all on them a full decade after their release :)
HP EliteBook: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I just bought a laptop for the first time in 10 years or so and I've spent quite some time and effort looking for it (bought 4 laptops, sent them all back and bought a 5th one). My priorities were - best keyboard possible - good layout you can get used to (ANSI vs ISO, dedicated pgup, pgdn, home end keys not too far from each other and arrow keys), good tactile feedback - case stability - good touchpad. I prefer physical buttons instead of or at least next to clickpads which is getting increasingly difficult to find - decent cpu perf, measure what's important for you (turns out for my use case AMD 5800U's 8 cores didn't make a difference compared to Tiger lake for my work) - upgradeable RAM or at least 32GB soldered - OK screen (350+ nits, reasonably color accurate, preferably matte) - battery life 6h+ on wifi - thermals and noise - does the fan make high pitched noise, how often does it kick in, is the case/keyboard warm - no nose webcam - USB-A AND USB-C ports (+placement: both on both sides), ideally also HDMI, headphone jack, thunderbolt - fingerprint reader/Hello, hardware TPM2.0 - 3 year warranty, on site service - after all this also portability I tried HP Zbook power, HP Firefly 14, HP Elitebook 840, Thinkpad X1 Carbon, Thinkpad P14s and Schenker Vision 14 and settled for the 840. The Carbon is also a nice machine, the P14s is massive while not bringing any major benefits, the Schenker had some built quality issues but otherwise looks great. I've found HP's keyboard j
HP EliteBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
Hm, just some data points: my private laptop is a Thinkpad T520. I replaced the battery four times now in some 10 years, I gave it a RAM boost a year ago... the marketing lettering is flaking off, and it has one small crack on a side where it made unplanned contact with a concrete floor - but the machine is working strong. They will have to pry that machine out of my cold dead hands should it not die before me. I run it under a debianesque Linux with i3wm. Work laptop is a 2017 HP Elitebook. This thing is utter garbage. I'm not talking about the funny idea to add a display port instead of HDMI for political reasons - but it keeps overheating, it's fan is loud as hell's airport approach, and every once in a while, it randomly bluescreens - and needs some funky key combination during BIOS to become workable again. Once Covid is over and we're back in the office, this thing will get replaced. Windows 10, and sluggish.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad to the HP EliteBookHP EliteBook: Doesn’t like it
I switched jobs to a small startup, and could choose the laptop model for the first time Bought the latest generation HP Elitebook G11 to try something else than Lenovo that had crappy trackpads due to the nibble It has been a disaster in terms of software/BIOS: * The mic cut off my voice when I was speaking all the time * The CPU clocked down to ~300 MHz and got stuck there * External display would not work if I disconnected, came back 30-60 min later, and reconnected. Had to hibernate inbetween * The display would suddenly dim and be impossible to change I think all these issues resolved itself with some firmware update released last week, and today I discovered there's an "HP Audio Control" app that by default is set to "conference mode" and "AI noise reduction" Now I only need to get the built-in 5G modem to work Would have gotten a Microsoft Surface model, but the selection is very slim in Norway
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad to the HP EliteBookHP EliteBook: Likes it
Just to add a data point, the HP ElitBooks have been my replacement for ThinkPads. I find the to be a good replacement. I've been running Redhat on an HP elitebook 840 g6, which Ive had for about a year now, and I've been very happy with it. The trackpad is mostly good, not great, but I'm more of a nub guy and that works perfectly.
HP EliteBook: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
Nice for experimentation, but if you want a daily driver that lasts for years: Dell Latitude (now Dell Pro), HP EliteBook or Lenovo ThinkPad. Literally laptops built to last. Will last a decade with ease. Higher segments ofcourse better than lower segments, but in general very very good if you stay away from lowest tier
HP EliteBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I would recommend getting nice used/refurbished laptops from ebay. Take the time to do your own install of Windows, cause who knows what's on there. I recently got two; a refurbished HP EliteBook 645 G10 and a used Lenovo ThinkPad L14 Gen 2. Both around $300, with a recentish processor (Zen 3), 16 GB ram and a 256 GB SSD. Scratches and dings included at no additional fee. The Thinkpad has fewer USB ports, but the Elitebook has an annoying fan. If you need more than 16 GB ram, you probably need to consider if it's better to get one that already has that much, or if you should get one with replaceable RAM and swap... 16 GB is enough for my needs; one of the machines has 1 channel soldered, 1 DIMM; the other machine is 2 DIMMs. I was doing the same work on a $100 laptop with 4 GB ram; it wasn't fun, but I could do it --- but if my needs change I can upgrade. The "refurbished" machine had a proper out of the box experience and windows 11 professional; the used one had win 11 enterprise installed with a user named user --- I put a fresh copy of windows 11 pro on that (bios activation); after some judicious changes in group policy editor, and disabling the push content in the lock screen, it's not terrible. Not my listing, caveat emptor, but something like this might be a reasonable option since you are sort of indicating 16GB ram might not be enough ... https://www.ebay.com/itm/257198634361 $250, ThinkPad L14 Gen 1; 6-core zen2, 32GB ram, 512 GB SSD. The L14 is bigger and clunk…
HP EliteBook: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
Get a proper laptop where you can install sodimm memory and m2 ssds. A previous gen base model with decent screen Elitebook 8xx or Thinkpad T1x, 128gb ddr5 kit is 300€, 4tb ssd 200€ and you dont have to worry about upgrades. My 5yr old machine has 64gb/4tb, it was doable for a long time
HP EliteBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
My interest in Framework is the DIY repairability. Not interested in modular upgrades but hot swappable ports on the side and should something need replacing, can be done in a relatively shorter and more predictable timespan than with ThinkPads and EliteBooks these days. Have had terrible experience with those in the last few years.
HP EliteBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
There are also laptops that went the opposite direction from Apple, yet they keep on trucking. Old Thinkpads, Panasonic Toughbooks and HP Elitebooks are perfectly usable today, arguably moreso than older Macs. Toss Linux on it, and you'll have longer first-party support than any Macbook shipped in the last decade. If anything, the repairability and upgradability that prevented old Macs from being e-waste is gone now. It's hard to imagine Apple pushing the envelope on reusability or device longevity in their current era.
HP EliteBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
My first Thinkpad is a T490 from work randomly and if I would get to pick in the future I would pick Lenovo over HP or Dell. They are great business laptops. Still amazing chassis quality and keyboard. Great driver support from Lenovo. I also get over 8h battery solid out of mine still, on low power plan in Win10. But the business laptops of HP and Dell are also good, the HP Elitebooks and Dell Precisions/Latitudes. It's just that when people buy Windows laptops, they buy cheap ass 300$ Acers from Walmart or a really expensive and loud gaming laptop. These business laptops are built to last for company use, and it does show. If a company buys 1000 laptops from HP, Dell, or Lenovo, and they are shit they won't buy from them again, so the quality has to be high. Yes, new they are expensive, but a lot of enterprise companies do 3 or 5 year hardware refreshes so used you can get them cheap. And company employees in general take care of their laptops or just use them docked 90% of the time. My keyboard looks new after 3 years because I most often have mine docked or hooked to an external screen/mouse/kb.
HP EliteBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
In general, Intel-based business laptops (Dell Latitude, HP ProBook/EliteBook, Lenovo Thinkpad) work incredibly well with Linux. I have an EliteBook 830 G8 that has zero issues running Linux. Everything works, no "buts". I do primarily use Windows though, but that's a personal choice :).