The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

HP Dev One vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad.

HP Dev OneLenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion112732
Positive verdicts71% of 775% of 2366
Positive/negative since 20241/1686/273
Happy after 3+ years0281
Longest happy owner–25 yrs
Praised forease of use and repairabilityreliability and performance
Criticized fordisplay and reliabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

HP Dev One: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
I see very disparate use cases for these laptops, so the competition is not really that fair. - Fastest CPU + GPU + battery life, x64 not needed, money no object: M1 MBP. - Reliable, serviceable, upgradeable, fashion-despising: T14 / T480 / T490. - Serviceable, upgradable, but sort of new kids on the block, and less fashion-oblivious: Star Labs Starfighter, Framework, System 76 Oryx Pro. - Sleek-looking at the expense of everything soldered and glued down: Thinkpad X1, MBP 2019. - Open-source loving, more things under user's control: System 76 Oryx Pro, Star Labs Starfighter, partly Framework. Star Labs Starfighter looks incredible BTW, thanks to bringing it to my attention. I sorely miss a trackpoint though. No idea about others. I'd like to like HP Dev One, but I don't trust HP to make reliable things any more :( I wonder why no model from the Dell Latitude line made it here; I thought some of them have good Linux support.
HP Dev One: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
The problem with many of HP's laptops that have pointing sticks, including the HP Dev One, is that they lack a middle mouse button for scrolling and middle-clicking. All Lenovo TrackPoints have that middle mouse button, which lets you scroll with the TrackPoint when it's held down. HP Dev One keyboard (no middle mouse button): https://media.graphassets.com/TdgqLuYTbeGM2oI8PWsV ThinkPad Carbon X1 keyboard (with middle mouse button): https://www.lenovo.com/medias/lenovo-laptop-thinkpad-x1-carb... A keyboard with a pointing stick and no middle mouse button is a waste. Hopefully, any pointing stick keyboard for the Framework Laptop will include this button.
HP Dev One: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Nothing against the Framework (it'll likely be my next laptop) but there are plenty of other good Linux options as well now (in general, I don't think Thinkpads have been very good for a while since their battery and keyboards have gotten so much worse and they've switched to partially or fully soldered RAM on most models). There's the HP Dev One if you need a trackpoint, System76 and Star Labs with coreboot, Tuxedo or Slimbook for some really compellingly specced options (the Pulse 15 Gen2 and Slimbook Executive 14 both hit a lot of high-points for iGPU-only computing IMO).
HP Dev One: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
The keyboard is missing an Insert key. But they're advertising an "FHD" screen as though that's a selling feature? That's only 1920x1080 - my Sony Vaio Z laptop from 2010 has the same resolution. People doing any kind of user-facing frontend dev-work pretty-much need a screen capable of 2x/200%/192dpi (i.e. 4K) at least. ...that's a deal-killer for me, as is the lack of a true middle-button on the touchpad. I'll be sticking with my ThinkPad X1.
HP Dev One: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Same here, the keyboard is the most important tool I'm using as a developer. Prioritizing flatiness over the quality and comfort of it is a huge dealbreaker. I'd gladly put more money for more power if I need, but having a decent keyboard is my main requirement. Which is a shame because otherwise it seems quite good (except for the design which is yet another soulless copy of Apple). I guess that I'll just stick to Thinkpads until this crazy trend dies.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad to the HP Dev OneHP Dev One: Recommends it
I used to use ThinkPads exclusively, but Lenovo's priorities for ThinkPads no longer match mine. I've since moved on to HP Dev One. It's well-rounded for me, was easily upgraded to 64GB of ram, and came with Pop! OS out of the box. I've also used System76 machines in the past with success, but I'm rather attached to having a pointing stick. My dayjob provides a Dell XPS 13 (factory-loaded with Ubuntu) which is an acceptable machine, but I don't travel with it much. I always use GNU/Linux. Of late I've been sticking to LTS Ubuntu or Pop! OS releases. I'm a strange case though, because my desktop is LXDE, and all I ever really do is run a browser or two with a pile of terminals, so I'm not running heavy desktop apps like Slack, Discord, or LibreOffice.
HP Dev One: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
The pointer stick is a really great thing to have assuming it works well. That said, my muscle memory would be decimated by the lack of a middle button. On Thinkpads, holding this makes the pointer stick scroll, making it a lot more useful than if it only middle clicked.