The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Chairs

Herman Miller Embody vs Steelcase Leap

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Steelcase Leap.

Herman Miller EmbodySteelcase Leap
Owners with an opinion5094
Positive verdicts84% of 4595% of 85
Positive/negative since 20245/05/0
Happy after 3+ years517
Longest happy owner15 yrs20 yrs
Praised forergonomics and comfortcomfort and value
Criticized forreliability and ease of usereliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Herman Miller Embody: NeutralSteelcase Leap: Recommends it
Without knowing what you don't like about the Aeron, how large/small you are and how you sit, etc this is incredibly difficult. I really like the Steelcase Leap v2 and recently switched to a Herman Miller Embody. The embody is a neat chair, but I kind of wish I went for something else. I also use a standing desk and a topo mat.
Herman Miller Embody: Doesn’t like itSteelcase Leap: Recommends it
I'm 5'10" too and have an average build! I had terrible back pain from my Office Max chair so I tried the Aeron, Mirra, and Embody. I didn't like any of them. I was about to give up, but then I tried the Steelcase Leap v2 and it was perfect! I purchased it ~6 years ago and haven't looked back. I think someone with a stocky build might prefer the Aaron since it has more seating room, but for my build the Leap is perfect.
Herman Miller Embody: Likes itSteelcase Leap: Recommends it
I think the Four Kings of chairs are the Herman-Miller Aeron, the HM Embody, the Steelcase Leap, & the Steelcase Gesture (my preference). I've not tried the Embody myself, but I'd bet it's good. HM Mirra is a close runner up. I've got maybe 11,000 hours in the Leap, it's fantastic. My Gesture is new but I think I like it more; the arms truly are great. It's really hard to guess what you'll prefer; just keep your eye out for trying out as many as you can. Also note Aerons come in 3 sizes, so maybe you like the M better than the L, or vice versa.
Herman Miller Embody: Likes itSteelcase Leap: Recommends it
I'm a self admitted chair-o-holic. I have personally owned an Aaron, Embody, Steelcase Leather Leap. In a nutshell, I found the Aeron the most uncomfortable chair of just about every office chair I've had the pleasure of sitting in personally and at work. It was the right size and it was fully loaded with every top option. I gladly and quickly sold it. The Steelcase (Leather) Leap is probably my favorite. The Embody is a close though. The Leap I have is leather, so it's very easy to keep clean. The best part about the leap though is not only is the build quality top notch and feels like a tank (and weighs it), is how configurable it is. The sweetest part though is that instead of rocking back like probably most chairs, it actually reclines keeping your rear end in the same place. It's excessively comfortable. All my friends ended up getting a Leap after trying mine. I got the embody out of curiosity, again I topped it out with every option to make sure it was the best model. It's far superior to the Aeron for me and close to the Leap in terms of comfort, but I do think the Leap wins, especially for longer days or when you just have one-of-those-days. At work, I had a Mirra, it was pretty nice also, which looking at it, surprised me. Much better than the Aeron in my opinion for just pure comfort. I've had a number of there chairs, from the $50 Staples specials to other big brands. The Leap and Embody are still by far my two favorites. I kept the Embody and Leap because I could
Herman Miller Embody: Recommends itSteelcase Leap: Likes it
I have owned / used extensively pretty much what I would say are all the chairs you would want to sit in if you want to maintain back and neck / mitigate back pain: 1. Steelcase leap: my first not-crap chair, bought from an office closing used for like $300, great chair. 2. Steelcase Gesture: decided I wanted to “upgrade” after bringing steelcase to office. Went with a sale online and actually didn’t like it much and returned it, but some people love it. This was also way worth it — the store I used had free returns, paid nothing to try the chair for a month. 3. Herman Miller Embody — went to this after the gesture and use this as at-home work chair. It’s awesome. I don’t know if I like it more than leap. Leap makes you sit up right, like it holds you in the position you want to sit in in order to not screw up your back. Embody is super supportive leaning back but feel like it’s less so sitting upright, but I also game in it, so as an all around at home chair i think it works. 4. Herman Miller Aeron — currently using at work, was super psyched I didn’t have to be the guy with their special chair at the new job. It’s — also a great chair! I think it’s similar to the leap, moreso than researching to death might make it seem. You sit upright in it, if you try to slouch the chair makes you feel it, so you sit back up right and then it supports you correctly again. If you want to get in on cheaper end, I’d check out craigslist / fb marketplace because you can get a barely-used le
Herman Miller Embody: Recommends itSteelcase Leap: Likes it
I used to use a Leap at my previous job, and have an Embody at home. I tried the Aeron at a store prior to purchasing, didn't see what the fuss was about. Overall I like the Leap and Embody a lot. From what I can remember about using it, the Leap v1 had a few more adjustment points than the Leap v2. Both v1 & v2 were comfortable, had all the adjustments I needed to get proper ergonomics. I ultimately picked the Embody for home because while the Steelcase was good, I didn't want to spend 8 hours in the work chair and come home to sit in the exact same chair. The Embody is definitely more of a flexible chair, you feel it move when you move in it. This has the side effect of feeling like you'll tip over if someone stands behind you and puts weight on your chair back (e.g. shoulder surfing and resting on your chair back). I don't like the arm adjustments as much as the Steelcase v1 Leap, there's no angling -- it just gets closer to you as you raise them up higher. Overall the Embody is very comfortable, and with working from home I use it 8-10 hours a day now. It holds up great.
Herman Miller Embody: Recommends itSteelcase Leap: Likes it
At work I have a Leap. It's pretty good (lots of knobs to adjust), but at home I use the Herman Miller Embody. Personally I feel it's more comfortable than the Leap, but chairs are very subjective. You may like it because the seat "pan" isn't actually moving the seat. It extends the front of the seat further out. That way you don't feel like you're sitting off the back end of the seat. Have you had a chair fitted, or read the instructions on fitting? If you haven't I highly recommend it. The Steelcase vendor was in my work the other day explaining proper posture on the chairs. You're not supposed to sit up, but rather recline at a slight angle.
Herman Miller Embody: Recommends itSteelcase Leap: Neutral
I second the "sitting in it." When I bought my chair I got a chair I hadn't even considered previously. I went with an Embody. I was considering an Aeron and Humanscale but they just didn't jive with me. The Steelcase Leap is what I have at work, and after several weeks of sitting in it I already feel like it's not as comfortable as the Embody (and I had the chance of snagging the Leap at 40% off new). If you do buy a Herman Miller (any) they run a semi-annual sale of 15% off; one of those sales starts around Thanksgiving. You might be able to get the discount by haggling or otherwise waiting for the sale.
Herman Miller Embody: Likes itSteelcase Leap: Likes it
Everybody's body is different. You've got to go and try them out. I've got a Herman Miller Embody and Steelcase Leap: they are both great chairs, but neither is perfect. Embody has a completely fluid motion of the back, but it tilts the seat's front a bit too much up when leaning back (and it creaks a bit after couple of years). Steelcase Leap doesn't have the seat's front tilt problem, but the back doesn't move as nicely and setting up the tension is kinda hard to get right. It also has a more nicely padded seat, but it also gets much warmer. Though I got Steelcase Leap last year because of the niggles with Embody, I still prefer Embody for daily sitting (not that Leap is bad, I am not bothered when I sit in it either, I just prefer the back movement of Embody, and reduced sweating too). I also like to combine it with standing at least for video calls. Now, this is a perspective of a 6'5" (195cm), 97kg guy with a particular set of proportions and body weight distribution (and lumbar issues): nobody will have exactly the same experience with these chairs. Unfortunately, the best you can do is to get a chair and try sitting in it for a week: no sitting in the store and outside of your work environment will let you learn if it works for you or not (which is why I got the Leap outright). If you are not in the 5% of the undersized or oversized people, and your limbs and torso proportions are close to average, any of the well-known and well-reviewed ergonomic chairs should d
Herman Miller Embody: NeutralSteelcase Leap: Neutral
Over the years I've tried a leap, gesture, HON exposure, aeron, and embody... and after all of it still find I vastly prefer a $70 Ikea Millberget to all of them https://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/00331707/ - the cheap material starts to flake after about 2 yrs of use so I'll just buy one every two years I guess. I guess the lesson is that every body is different and you gotta find what works for you
Herman Miller Embody: Likes itSteelcase Leap: Likes it
I ended up with an Embody after owning an Aeron (fully loaded, correct size), and Steelcase Leap (Leather). The Aeron was terrible. Quite possible the most uncomfortable. It felt stiff, not nearly as configurable as the Leap, and unlike the Leap, rocked instead of actually recline. I could never find a comfortable position or sit still. I liked the Leap, actually ended up keeping it with my Embody and giving it to my dad. The Embody is a nice in-between. The Leap feels better built, more comfortable and I love how it reclines instead of rocking on a spring mechanism, almost like a lounger. Makes those longer days far more comfortable.
Herman Miller Embody: Recommends itSteelcase Leap: Recommends it
This is what I have. I had a Mirra, Aeron, and Steelcase Leap. The Mirra was fine, nothing special. The Aaron was horrible. Yes, I had it fit for the right size. The Steelcase Leap and Embody are both top tier. You can almost argue the Leap is superior since you can get it in leather, making it easy to keep clean and free of stains and you can get it with a headrest. They also make a Leap Lounge and it's sublime. I wouldn't mind the Herman Miller lounger though. Either way, you can't go wrong. You have to find out what fits you best. Many rave and swear by the Aeron, but for me it was terrible and uncomfortable. The Embody and Steelcase Leap are sublime to me though.
Herman Miller Embody: Likes itSteelcase Leap: Likes it
I have the Herman Miller Embody http://www.hermanmiller.com/products/seating/performance-wor... At my last job I used the Stealcase Leap (v1) http://www.steelcase.com/en/products/category/seating/task/l... . It was good but not so good that I wanted to come home from work and work in the same chair.
Herman Miller Embody: Likes itSteelcase Leap: Likes it
It depends on how much you're willing to pay for them, but the category is "stools", even though you would think of a bar stool rather than a really tall chair. They come in "ergonomic" as well--a few of the well known chair manufacturers also make their ergo chairs in stool version, like Steelcase's Leap http://store.steelcase.com/products/leap-stool/ I have the chair version of this at work, and I like the adjustable arm rests, but overall find my Herman Miller Embody more comfortable. Personal preference though. See if your employer has a preferred supplier for office furniture, the price you see on the sticker isn't the price you pay (around Christmas time, we get discounts of up to 40% for personal purchases)