The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Chairs

Herman Miller Aeron vs Steelcase Gesture

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Herman Miller Aeron.

Herman Miller AeronSteelcase Gesture
Owners with an opinion28423
Positive verdicts81% of 22979% of 19
Positive/negative since 202430/80/0
Happy after 3+ years590
Longest happy owner26 yrs1.5 yrs
Praised forcomfort and ergonomicscomfort and build quality
Criticized forvaluevalue and ergonomics
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Herman Miller Aeron: Recommends itSteelcase Gesture: Likes it
For long hours of serious work it's important to prioritize seating that provides sufficient support and structure to remain comfortable after several hours over chairs that may feel super "comfy" in the first hour. In my experience, they rarely overlap. Another important trait is durability and repairability (including parts availability). My goto chair is the legendary Herman Miller Aeron. I've had my primary Aeron for >15 years and it still looks new, relatively inexpensive parts remain readily available on eBay and are easily user serviceable with a hex wrench. Aerons are built like tanks. They aren't cheap but no really high-quality, durable chair is cheap. The good news is that used Aerons are widely available. A relatively newer chair that I'm using at my vacation house office is the Steelcase Gesture and I'm really liking it. IMHO, its best feature is the infinite adjustability of armrest position which is by far the best I've ever seen. However, the long-term comfort of the chair itself apparently varies by individual. I love it but I've read that, unlike the near-universally beloved Aeron, the Gesture just doesn't click with some people so be sure to give it a test drive.
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itSteelcase Gesture: Recommends it
Based on looks and reviews I almost purchased a Herman Miller Sayl until I sat in it and noticed how cheap it looked and felt. It also wasn't comfortable and the lumbar support was a joke. I then tried a Herman Miller Aeron and Leap but didn't like them. I went with a Steelcase Gesture that I had at my last employer's office and I love it.
Herman Miller Aeron: Likes itSteelcase Gesture: Recommends it
ALWAYS try a chair in person first, whether Herman Miller or Steelcase. DO NOT order blind and try to "tough it out" to see if a chair is for you. The thing is, high end chairs differ radically in comfort. I thought the Embody was a great chair but the Aeron outdid it. I thought the Aeron was great but the Mira was better. For me, of course. If I ordered online I wouldn't have known this. At the most I'd have returned the Embody for an Aeron but not found the chair that suits me best - the Steelcase Gesture ;) To answer your question, I would recommend going to a furniture store and trying chairs from Herman Miller and Steelcase.
Herman Miller Aeron: Likes itSteelcase Gesture: Recommends it
I think the Four Kings of chairs are the Herman-Miller Aeron, the HM Embody, the Steelcase Leap, & the Steelcase Gesture (my preference). I've not tried the Embody myself, but I'd bet it's good. HM Mirra is a close runner up. I've got maybe 11,000 hours in the Leap, it's fantastic. My Gesture is new but I think I like it more; the arms truly are great. It's really hard to guess what you'll prefer; just keep your eye out for trying out as many as you can. Also note Aerons come in 3 sizes, so maybe you like the M better than the L, or vice versa.
Herman Miller Aeron: Likes itSteelcase Gesture: Doesn’t like it
I have owned / used extensively pretty much what I would say are all the chairs you would want to sit in if you want to maintain back and neck / mitigate back pain: 1. Steelcase leap: my first not-crap chair, bought from an office closing used for like $300, great chair. 2. Steelcase Gesture: decided I wanted to “upgrade” after bringing steelcase to office. Went with a sale online and actually didn’t like it much and returned it, but some people love it. This was also way worth it — the store I used had free returns, paid nothing to try the chair for a month. 3. Herman Miller Embody — went to this after the gesture and use this as at-home work chair. It’s awesome. I don’t know if I like it more than leap. Leap makes you sit up right, like it holds you in the position you want to sit in in order to not screw up your back. Embody is super supportive leaning back but feel like it’s less so sitting upright, but I also game in it, so as an all around at home chair i think it works. 4. Herman Miller Aeron — currently using at work, was super psyched I didn’t have to be the guy with their special chair at the new job. It’s — also a great chair! I think it’s similar to the leap, moreso than researching to death might make it seem. You sit upright in it, if you try to slouch the chair makes you feel it, so you sit back up right and then it supports you correctly again. If you want to get in on cheaper end, I’d check out craigslist / fb marketplace because you can get a barely-used le
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralSteelcase Gesture: Recommends it
First, don't sit for 13-15 hours per day. You will regret it later and it is detrimental to your health. Either pomodoro every 30 minutes and walk around for 5-10 mins or do a combination of standing desk / sitting. Second, I can't sign off on the Aeron it's a good chair - but it's far from great. Personally, and through experience of owning all of these chairs, I would go for the Herman Miller MIRRA 2 chair -or- the Steelcase Gesture chair. They are impossible to beat from an ergonomics standpoint not to mention the countless hours of studied and research that went into these products. The lumbar on these (all) chairs is negligible, cushioning technology is sound, the extendable lower thigh support is pretty sweet, butterfly suspension adjust to your posture and has a solid suspension / cushioning effect, build quality is A+ We have Mirra 2 and Gesture at our office, originally we started with the Gesture and they are fantastic and more "luxurious" but the Mirra 2 is the current star. They are expensive ($1.2k each) when fully equipped. But they are worth it. The Aeron chairs we used to have back in the day were given to people to take home and I have two of them in my garage. Don't get me wrong - they're good chairs - but the Mirra and the Gesture are simply better and not by a little. Don't sit for 13 hours per day. Otherwise you'll be in physical therapy for 13 hours per month. Signed, someone who used to sit for 13 hours per day.
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralSteelcase Gesture: Neutral
Over the years I've tried a leap, gesture, HON exposure, aeron, and embody... and after all of it still find I vastly prefer a $70 Ikea Millberget to all of them https://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/00331707/ - the cheap material starts to flake after about 2 yrs of use so I'll just buy one every two years I guess. I guess the lesson is that every body is different and you gotta find what works for you