The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Chairs

Herman Miller Aeron vs Herman Miller Mirra

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Herman Miller Mirra.

Herman Miller AeronHerman Miller Mirra
Owners with an opinion28435
Positive verdicts81% of 22990% of 31
Positive/negative since 202430/83/0
Happy after 3+ years595
Longest happy owner26 yrs17 yrs
Praised forcomfort and ergonomicsergonomics and comfort
Criticized forvaluevalue
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Mirra: Likes it
I know several people with HM Aerons and I always see them leaning all the way back, using it like a reclining chair. It makes me hesitate about these chairs. Personally I have a HM Mirra and I feel it is a superior chair. To my previous point, Mirra's design seems to encourage more straight-up sitting style rather than gratuitous reclining. Another advantage are the adjustable arm rests, which can rotate inwards (good for laptops) or outwards (good for desks) depending on your situation. Makes me wonder if the Aeron might be a little over-hyped.
Herman Miller Aeron: Recommends itHerman Miller Mirra: Neutral
Aerons are designed to have individuals dial them in. My 18 year old or so Aeron finally gave up near the start of the pandemic and I really wasn't sure what to do. There were newer HM models, including the Cosm which was billed as basically a self-adjusting Aeron. However, I couldn't try anything. But it was just for me. So I just ordered another Aeron with the new back support system and I couldn't be happier. Right call. Mirra 2's are OK--we have them at least one of our company offices--but they're not Aerons. (And I prefer the web style to something like an Leap or Embody.)
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralHerman Miller Mirra: Recommends it
Omg, you've gone too long without a good chair my friend. I did not like the Aeron at my last job more than my Herman Miller Mirra 2. A good keyboard and properly adjustable monitor arm are key as well. I like the Mirra 2 more because it it suspends my boney ass in a way that I can easily just forget that I'm sitting for hours. As another person mentioned, this is awful for general health, but if you'd be doing it anyway, this is one option. I also like it because it's more adjustable, and looks way better. It's the nicest thing I own, and after 7 years, (12 year warranty), it's pristine. I've also tried the Sayl, and HM has a few othwrs that look and feel great. I'm sure the Aeron can be good, but I don't find it to be. I do not have a headrest either, and I'm a good few inches over 6 feet.
Herman Miller Aeron: Recommends itHerman Miller Mirra: Likes it
I have had Herman Miller v1 of Mirra and it was awesome for well over a decade. (I still use it in one of my offices, it's probably 17 years old and still in decent condition, but the latest model is built a lot cheaper, don't get it) I moved to a new office and they gave me a "very expensive" Steelcase leather chair, and it gave me back pain. I then invested in a Herman Miller Aeron (newest model as of 2021) and it's the greatest chair I have ever had. But keep in mind, I intentionally use it for doing work. Work chairs suck to watch movies and relax in. If you have good posture and you want your chair to help you with your posture they are pure gold. I have spent over 22 years in a chair, and I have spent 22+ hours a day in my Mirra and 10+ in my Aeron (I am older and wiser now, ha!) and I wouldn't go back to anything less ever again. NOTE: Do NOT get the Herman Miller Cosm, it is a conference chair NOT a task chair. Go to a show room if you can and try them out, it was worth the time to drive there and do this for me.
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralHerman Miller Mirra: Likes it
Current favorite: humanscale freedom with headrest (1 year) Runner-up: Herman Miller Mirra (2 years) - I find the Mirra than the Aeron and more comfortable for my body (2 years on the Aeron) - I've used various Steelcase models and liked them but not as much as the Mirra or Humanscale (~7 years on various Steelcase) - My issues tend to be caused by over exercising and I think the relaxed options with Humanscale are good for this.
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Mirra: Likes it
I'm a self admitted chair-o-holic. I have personally owned an Aaron, Embody, Steelcase Leather Leap. In a nutshell, I found the Aeron the most uncomfortable chair of just about every office chair I've had the pleasure of sitting in personally and at work. It was the right size and it was fully loaded with every top option. I gladly and quickly sold it. The Steelcase (Leather) Leap is probably my favorite. The Embody is a close though. The Leap I have is leather, so it's very easy to keep clean. The best part about the leap though is not only is the build quality top notch and feels like a tank (and weighs it), is how configurable it is. The sweetest part though is that instead of rocking back like probably most chairs, it actually reclines keeping your rear end in the same place. It's excessively comfortable. All my friends ended up getting a Leap after trying mine. I got the embody out of curiosity, again I topped it out with every option to make sure it was the best model. It's far superior to the Aeron for me and close to the Leap in terms of comfort, but I do think the Leap wins, especially for longer days or when you just have one-of-those-days. At work, I had a Mirra, it was pretty nice also, which looking at it, surprised me. Much better than the Aeron in my opinion for just pure comfort. I've had a number of there chairs, from the $50 Staples specials to other big brands. The Leap and Embody are still by far my two favorites. I kept the Embody and Leap because I could
Herman Miller Aeron: Recommends itHerman Miller Mirra: Neutral
The high end office chair companies will usually offer a try before buy deal. The Aeron chairs by Herman Miller are popular in some re-insurance companies. I have used the Mirra 2 chair, but prefer the Aeron. The Aeron, unless purchased used, probably won't fit in your budget, but breaking the budget on such an important item as this will probably be of value.
Herman Miller Aeron: Likes itHerman Miller Mirra: Doesn’t like it
Steelcase Leap v2. Refurbished models can regularly be found on Craigslist for about $250-300. It's an incredibly comfortable chair, arguably much more comfortable than the more well-known Aeron, which I used for a long time. I also used a Humanscale Freedom. Compared to both, settling into a Leap is like sinking into a luxuriously soft car seat. It has levers for everything, and it's just really pleasantly soft. I've also tried the newest Herman Miller chairs (Mira etc.) and they are nowhere as good. The Wirecutter [1] has recommended the Leap repeatedly. Their current choice is the Steelcase Gesture, which is very similar to the Leap. If you can afford a new Gesture, a great choice, but if you want to save money and can find a refurb Leap, go for that instead. Note: Avoid leather as a material. It's not anywhere near as breathable. [1] https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-office-chair/
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Mirra: Neutral
This is what I have. I had a Mirra, Aeron, and Steelcase Leap. The Mirra was fine, nothing special. The Aaron was horrible. Yes, I had it fit for the right size. The Steelcase Leap and Embody are both top tier. You can almost argue the Leap is superior since you can get it in leather, making it easy to keep clean and free of stains and you can get it with a headrest. They also make a Leap Lounge and it's sublime. I wouldn't mind the Herman Miller lounger though. Either way, you can't go wrong. You have to find out what fits you best. Many rave and swear by the Aeron, but for me it was terrible and uncomfortable. The Embody and Steelcase Leap are sublime to me though.
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralHerman Miller Mirra: Recommends it
First, don't sit for 13-15 hours per day. You will regret it later and it is detrimental to your health. Either pomodoro every 30 minutes and walk around for 5-10 mins or do a combination of standing desk / sitting. Second, I can't sign off on the Aeron it's a good chair - but it's far from great. Personally, and through experience of owning all of these chairs, I would go for the Herman Miller MIRRA 2 chair -or- the Steelcase Gesture chair. They are impossible to beat from an ergonomics standpoint not to mention the countless hours of studied and research that went into these products. The lumbar on these (all) chairs is negligible, cushioning technology is sound, the extendable lower thigh support is pretty sweet, butterfly suspension adjust to your posture and has a solid suspension / cushioning effect, build quality is A+ We have Mirra 2 and Gesture at our office, originally we started with the Gesture and they are fantastic and more "luxurious" but the Mirra 2 is the current star. They are expensive ($1.2k each) when fully equipped. But they are worth it. The Aeron chairs we used to have back in the day were given to people to take home and I have two of them in my garage. Don't get me wrong - they're good chairs - but the Mirra and the Gesture are simply better and not by a little. Don't sit for 13 hours per day. Otherwise you'll be in physical therapy for 13 hours per month. Signed, someone who used to sit for 13 hours per day.
Herman Miller Aeron: Likes itHerman Miller Mirra: Recommends it
I've got an Aeron at home, and a Mirra ( http://www.hermanmiller.com/mirra/ ) at work. Both are made by Herman Miller. The Mirra is a bit cheaper and doesn't look as swish, but I find it about 50% more comfortable than the Aeron (to the point that I'm thinking about replacing the Aeron). And both are many, many times more comfortable than anything else I've used.
Switched from the Herman Miller Aeron to the Herman Miller MirraHerman Miller Mirra: Likes it
The Mirra2 for me instead of Aeron. But I am going to say to OP the more important thing is to take breaks and _move_ around. I remember from a past injury I was sedentary for a long time and then had an MRI on my lower back. I am fairly fit BMI wise but the doctor made a point to highlight to me fat deposits embedded in ny muscle tissue. As in my back muscles were so 'unused' that muscle tissue was being replaced with fat. So great that the recliner works for you but for your sake do move around.
Herman Miller Aeron: Likes itHerman Miller Mirra: Likes it
People will love you much more if you use a real microphone. I have a travel-sized one from RØDE; the difference it made, in how people perceive my voice, is massive - I sound like a professional speaker rather than a geek in the basement. This brought significant reputational advantages. I also have an UPS under the desk, keeping up the wifi hub in all circumstances; it has a couple of USB charging ports on the front, so I use those with most random things that need charging. For some things I recently started using elbow USB-C connectors, or ones that can bend either way, to tidy up some corners and reduce strain on connectors. The rest is about ergonomics - screen at the right level, good chair (Aeron, although tbh I miss my previous Mirrah) to avoid back pain, good split keyboard (Kinesis, although I wish i could afford an ergodox) to take away wrist pain (massive difference), that sort of thing.
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Mirra: Doesn’t like it
I'm 5'10" too and have an average build! I had terrible back pain from my Office Max chair so I tried the Aeron, Mirra, and Embody. I didn't like any of them. I was about to give up, but then I tried the Steelcase Leap v2 and it was perfect! I purchased it ~6 years ago and haven't looked back. I think someone with a stocky build might prefer the Aaron since it has more seating room, but for my build the Leap is perfect.
Herman Miller Aeron: Likes itHerman Miller Mirra: Likes it
ALWAYS try a chair in person first, whether Herman Miller or Steelcase. DO NOT order blind and try to "tough it out" to see if a chair is for you. The thing is, high end chairs differ radically in comfort. I thought the Embody was a great chair but the Aeron outdid it. I thought the Aeron was great but the Mira was better. For me, of course. If I ordered online I wouldn't have known this. At the most I'd have returned the Embody for an Aeron but not found the chair that suits me best - the Steelcase Gesture ;) To answer your question, I would recommend going to a furniture store and trying chairs from Herman Miller and Steelcase.
Herman Miller Aeron: Recommends itHerman Miller Mirra: Recommends it
Not OP but: IDE: Use IntelliJ Community Edition (or whatever Jetbrains IDE matches your project). Print out a keystrokes cheat sheet and tape it on your desk. Try to do stuff as a series of snippets, autocorrects, autocompletes and refactorings rather than pounding out the code (this is especially relevant in Java where it can save you like 90% keystrokes). Example: don't start a new method by writing the new method. Start it by calling it somewhere with arguments, then alt-enter (auto-correct) to create the method, with the types and arguments already filled in. Chair: get Herman Miller Aeron or Mirra (cheaper), second hand Standing desk: I use cardboard boxes on a regular desk. I take sitting breaks when I'm thinking but not actively typing. Pomodoros also work (stand 20, sit 5 or 10). Don't use your phone when you sit.