The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Chairs

Herman Miller Aeron vs Herman Miller Embody

Hacker News owners lean toward the Herman Miller Embody.

Herman Miller AeronHerman Miller Embody
Owners with an opinion28450
Positive verdicts81% of 22984% of 45
Positive/negative since 202430/85/0
Happy after 3+ years595
Longest happy owner26 yrs15 yrs
Praised forcomfort and ergonomicsergonomics and comfort
Criticized forvaluereliability and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Embody: Likes it
Also what I forgot to mention is that the back of the Leap is flexible like the even more expensive than that Aeron chair: the Embody. So basically you get a substantially better chair than both the Aeron and the Embody for a better price. I feel Herman Miller is coasting a bit on the Aeron being so iconic.
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Embody: Likes it
I have an Aeron from ~2006 which is still in good condition, virtually no drop in the pellicle mesh despite near daily use for 12 years. The foam under the seat near the front lip has died a little, and the arm rest pads needed replacement once. In 2018 I purchased an Aeron Remastered which for some reason I did not care for, it seemed to tilt differently in the seat and I felt the front lip more on my legs. So I sold it and purchased an Embody, which I've been very happy with so far. I think they are only for commercial buyers, but our office uses SitOnIt Torsa chairs ( https://www.sitonit.net/productcatalog/torsa_taskchair.html ) which I have found to be quite nice in quality and comfort.
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
I considered the Aeron but the hard edge of the seat just didn't work for me. Embody has a huge seat without any hard pieces and a back rest that narrows at elbow height. The first chair I've bought for myself and very expensive, but I love it and expect it to last a decade or more.
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
Not a lot of love for the Embody on this thread. It has been my only chair for the last 10 years and it is amazing. I’ll never use anything else. Aeron just isn’t good enough and I have spent several weeks trying to use the one I have. I know Aeron works for a lot of people, but I could not get it right. As a general compliment to Herman Miller, I had some issues with the arm pads and the arm adjustment at about 9.5 years in. Herman Miller sent someone to my house, redid all the fabric, replaced the pads and chair arm adjustment gear. No charge. They really do stand by their warranties. It’s still going strong. I can’t recommend it enough. I know these chairs are expensive, but if you are going to sit, get the best chair you can. A good one lasts over a decade. You could easily replace a crappy 200-300 chair every few years and have no where near the comfort of this chair.
Herman Miller Aeron: Likes itHerman Miller Embody: Doesn’t like it
I'm the opposite. Had the Embody for years, but it slowly started to deform (long torso with lots of reclining) and cause back pain. I've since switched to an Aeron C, and after a few months, I'm back to lifting like I used to.
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
It's worth going to a Herman Miller dealer to try the range of models. Some of them fit different body sizes, especially varying heights and widths much better. I didn't like the way the Aeron felt on my shoulder blades, it's very wide, so I got the Embody which is also quite popular, and much more narrow. The Embody is more expensive but worth it in my opinion. Also remember that both come with an incredible warranty. The only models I wouldn't spend much time looking at are their conference room chairs -- the ones not designed to be sat in comfortably for a full day. More info on Aeron vs Embody - https://www.btod.com/blog/herman-miller-aeron-vs-embody/
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Embody: Likes it
I'm a self admitted chair-o-holic. I have personally owned an Aaron, Embody, Steelcase Leather Leap. In a nutshell, I found the Aeron the most uncomfortable chair of just about every office chair I've had the pleasure of sitting in personally and at work. It was the right size and it was fully loaded with every top option. I gladly and quickly sold it. The Steelcase (Leather) Leap is probably my favorite. The Embody is a close though. The Leap I have is leather, so it's very easy to keep clean. The best part about the leap though is not only is the build quality top notch and feels like a tank (and weighs it), is how configurable it is. The sweetest part though is that instead of rocking back like probably most chairs, it actually reclines keeping your rear end in the same place. It's excessively comfortable. All my friends ended up getting a Leap after trying mine. I got the embody out of curiosity, again I topped it out with every option to make sure it was the best model. It's far superior to the Aeron for me and close to the Leap in terms of comfort, but I do think the Leap wins, especially for longer days or when you just have one-of-those-days. At work, I had a Mirra, it was pretty nice also, which looking at it, surprised me. Much better than the Aeron in my opinion for just pure comfort. I've had a number of there chairs, from the $50 Staples specials to other big brands. The Leap and Embody are still by far my two favorites. I kept the Embody and Leap because I could
Herman Miller Aeron: Likes itHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
I have owned / used extensively pretty much what I would say are all the chairs you would want to sit in if you want to maintain back and neck / mitigate back pain: 1. Steelcase leap: my first not-crap chair, bought from an office closing used for like $300, great chair. 2. Steelcase Gesture: decided I wanted to “upgrade” after bringing steelcase to office. Went with a sale online and actually didn’t like it much and returned it, but some people love it. This was also way worth it — the store I used had free returns, paid nothing to try the chair for a month. 3. Herman Miller Embody — went to this after the gesture and use this as at-home work chair. It’s awesome. I don’t know if I like it more than leap. Leap makes you sit up right, like it holds you in the position you want to sit in in order to not screw up your back. Embody is super supportive leaning back but feel like it’s less so sitting upright, but I also game in it, so as an all around at home chair i think it works. 4. Herman Miller Aeron — currently using at work, was super psyched I didn’t have to be the guy with their special chair at the new job. It’s — also a great chair! I think it’s similar to the leap, moreso than researching to death might make it seem. You sit upright in it, if you try to slouch the chair makes you feel it, so you sit back up right and then it supports you correctly again. If you want to get in on cheaper end, I’d check out craigslist / fb marketplace because you can get a barely-used le
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
I had Aerons for years, and finally got rid of my last one for an Embody. I definitely think the Embody is an upgrade from an Aeron. At least for me, the mesh was uncomfortable and I prefer the fabric of the Embody. I also really like the fact that it's taller and supports more of my back. We picked up 2 Embodys used for less than the price of one new one. The only negative was we had to drive from Austin to Houston and back (around a 6-hour round trip.) This was still worth it, because we saved almost $2K vs. buying new. One of the Embodys had a broken piece that doesn't affect functionality, so we got a true deal. The place that we went also had Steelcase Leap chairs, Aerons, and many more high-end chairs and furniture. We found it via craigslist originally. I would definitely suggest finding the places like this vs. buying online.
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
Depending on where you live, trying out an office chair for a while might be an option. I found a local office furniture store that sold Herman Miller (not a big box retailer, but one who sells to bigger companies), and was able to give them a credit card number and a drivers license and they let me borrow a few chairs to try out. I tried the Aeron for a week and then the Embody for a week. I ended up buying the Embody. I paid a little more than $500, I think it was more like $750. Totally worth it though, I expect to still be sitting in it in 20 years. A note on the Aerons that lots of people have recommended: they come in three different sizes, something most people don’t realize since corporate buyers usually just buy the medium size. If your frame is larger or smaller than average (speaking of height here, not weight) then one of the other sizes might fit you better. I can’t recommend the Embody enough though. I can sit in that chair for 10+ hours and not feel it. It’s an amazing chair.
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Embody: Likes it
I ended up with an Embody after owning an Aeron (fully loaded, correct size), and Steelcase Leap (Leather). The Aeron was terrible. Quite possible the most uncomfortable. It felt stiff, not nearly as configurable as the Leap, and unlike the Leap, rocked instead of actually recline. I could never find a comfortable position or sit still. I liked the Leap, actually ended up keeping it with my Embody and giving it to my dad. The Embody is a nice in-between. The Leap feels better built, more comfortable and I love how it reclines instead of rocking on a spring mechanism, almost like a lounger. Makes those longer days far more comfortable.
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
This is what I have. I had a Mirra, Aeron, and Steelcase Leap. The Mirra was fine, nothing special. The Aaron was horrible. Yes, I had it fit for the right size. The Steelcase Leap and Embody are both top tier. You can almost argue the Leap is superior since you can get it in leather, making it easy to keep clean and free of stains and you can get it with a headrest. They also make a Leap Lounge and it's sublime. I wouldn't mind the Herman Miller lounger though. Either way, you can't go wrong. You have to find out what fits you best. Many rave and swear by the Aeron, but for me it was terrible and uncomfortable. The Embody and Steelcase Leap are sublime to me though.
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
I used to use a Leap at my previous job, and have an Embody at home. I tried the Aeron at a store prior to purchasing, didn't see what the fuss was about. Overall I like the Leap and Embody a lot. From what I can remember about using it, the Leap v1 had a few more adjustment points than the Leap v2. Both v1 & v2 were comfortable, had all the adjustments I needed to get proper ergonomics. I ultimately picked the Embody for home because while the Steelcase was good, I didn't want to spend 8 hours in the work chair and come home to sit in the exact same chair. The Embody is definitely more of a flexible chair, you feel it move when you move in it. This has the side effect of feeling like you'll tip over if someone stands behind you and puts weight on your chair back (e.g. shoulder surfing and resting on your chair back). I don't like the arm adjustments as much as the Steelcase v1 Leap, there's no angling -- it just gets closer to you as you raise them up higher. Overall the Embody is very comfortable, and with working from home I use it 8-10 hours a day now. It holds up great.
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
herman miller embody. after using the aeron, steelcase leap, and humanscale freedom i finally tried the embody. fell in love instantly. employers paid for previous chairs (they were in the office), but i paid for the embody. best decision ever made. spinal disc herniation what?
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
Seconded. Having owned an Aeron and multiple other high-end chairs, I wholly believe that the Embody is the best option out there. Considering how many hours we spend on average in front of the computer, buying a chair that encourages a proper posture and relieves stress on joints is easily worth the money, imo.
Herman Miller Aeron: NeutralHerman Miller Embody: Recommends it
I was looking to buy an Aeron but it wasn't very comfortable for me. The medium one was too small and the large one too big. When I tried the Embody at the store, I fell in love. It's expensive as hell, but I'm glad I bought it. It's an outstanding chair, superior to the Aeron in every way in my opinion. I can sit on it all day with no pair or discomfort whatsoever.
Herman Miller Aeron: Doesn’t like itHerman Miller Embody: Doesn’t like it
I'm 5'10" too and have an average build! I had terrible back pain from my Office Max chair so I tried the Aeron, Mirra, and Embody. I didn't like any of them. I was about to give up, but then I tried the Steelcase Leap v2 and it was perfect! I purchased it ~6 years ago and haven't looked back. I think someone with a stocky build might prefer the Aaron since it has more seating room, but for my build the Leap is perfect.