The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Networking

Google Wifi vs Ubiquiti UniFi

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Ubiquiti UniFi.

Google WifiUbiquiti UniFi
Owners with an opinion23583
Positive verdicts50% of 1865% of 498
Positive/negative since 20242/3182/93
Happy after 3+ years119
Longest happy owner3 yrs20 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and ease of usesoftware and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Wifi: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
TP Link's support is the worst, too. I bought an Omada, thinking I was getting a quality product. It died in the first 2 weeks. Support accused me of not using a surge protector (it was plugged into a UPS) and grudgingly sent me a replacement. Even at home, I can't risk having to replace my router every 2 weeks, so I just stuffed it in a box. I did use it again later, but wasn't happy with it, and ended up with a Ubiquiti Unifi UCG-Ultra. It's better than the TP-Link Deco and Omada, Eero Pro, Google Wifi, and Asus routers I've had, though I'll admit some of the Asus were pretty decent.
Google Wifi: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
Google's own mesh WiFi products (under Google and Nest brands) are shit. It took 8 months for the support morons to discover there were too many APs, with one taking all of the others down without any user-visible feedback. While I use Ubiquiti non-mesh now that only gets 600 Mbps max even with WiFi 6e NICs, hardwired works and provides dedicated, point-to-point bandwidth.
Google Wifi: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
I feel really burned by Ubiquiti. I had ~5 cameras with their PoE switch and originally the NVR, which was flaky, and later the CloudKey G2. I was considering replacing my Google wifi 4-node setup with Ubiquiti. I regularly had problems with cameras not coming back up after a power outage or firmware updates. Then at one point a switch update caused a the Google wifi nodes to start being shut off because of loop detection and there was no way to turn it off. Then a year later most of the cameras bricked during one of their firmware updates. The Google setup has been pretty nice, though sometimes it gets into a weird state where wireless performance goes into the toilet. I'm currently playing with a Ruckus R620 from ebay, which seems to be some really solid Enterprise gear that you can get for around $250 on ebay, used.
Google Wifi: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
I agree that segmenting VLANs and stuff aren’t accessible to average people, but there are accessible alternatives. I recently upgraded to Google WiFi pucks after babysitting a ubiquiti installation for almost half a decade, and you can “disable internet” on devices without disabling LAN. You’d have to trust the device to be friendly on the LAN but it’s good balance for consumers. After Eufys whole security meltdown I updated a bunch of IOT junk to lose internet access. I saw a lot of tech site’s recommend this, and it’s definitely “easy enough for the parents to do”.
Google Wifi: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
I had started down the path of going all Ubiquity ~5 years ago. I started with cameras and their camera controller. It was super flaky, when everything was working, it was great, first class app experience. But any time the cameras rebooted (power outage, firmware upgrade), I would literally spend days with some cameras offline, until multiple reboots of impacted or all cameras would eventually fix it. Then, a few years in a firmware upgrade to the switch (their 250W PoE switch) caused it to start isolating my Google WiFi APs because it would do some loop detection. An hour on the phone with their support (which in that instance was really good) resulted in a a prognosis of "This particular loop detection can't be turned off." So I had to drop a dumb switch in front of the Ubiquiti for the Google APs. I was considering replacing them with Ubiquiti, but needed to run some more wire throughout the house to get what I needed. Then I ran into a firmware upgrade that bricked 3 of my 4 cameras. After going back and forth with their support and getting nowhere, I just gave up. I had replaced the controller with the CloudKey G2 at one point because the old one was no longer supported, and it seemed to help with but not totally resolve the days of rebooting cameras situation. Honestly, having the cameras bricked was a relief, because of all the consternation that the firmware updates had been causing. I just couldn't bring myself to buy new Ubiquiti cameras. I ended up pullin…
Google Wifi: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
google wifi also has the same option, using fq_codel, almost as equally hidden. IMHO having it on by default would improve both products out of the box experience. UBNT now does it by default, at least. Happy to have seen both cake and fq_codel stablize in mikrotik in the past month: https://forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php?t=179307
Google Wifi: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
My employer switched from Ubiquiti to Aruba. Much, much better. Far easier to manage. The Ubiquiti APs had very little range and below-threshold subscriber loads would cause them to become unstable and require a reboot. No good when 500 employees and guests are attempting to get work done. We issue primarily laptops with only certain people getting docks for Ethernet. Quite a few people have purchased the Anker USB-C dongle docks from Amazon and use their IP phone's secondary Ethernet port for a connection if they want a solid Ethernet connection. At home I'm happy with Google WiFi mesh all around my house.
Google Wifi: NeutralUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
I bought a UDM about two years ago, and it was a real mess for about 6 months. It was hanging every few weeks which required a hard reboot- which was shocking, because this was my first attempt at upgrading my network to more expensive and capable stuff, and for the previous 20 years, had never had an issue with my network equipment hanging or rebooting. They were going to RMA my UDM, but then they had me install a special release as a last try, and it worked, and everything has worked well since then. That said though, do I really need these features? The biggest draw was having a proper AP to put on my ceiling instead of my old google wifi pucks. The upgrade from wifi 5 to 6e was not noticeable in any way. I spent 3x the money and really have nothing tangible to show for it aside from a cool UI to log into, which was never necessary prior because everything Just Worked. Also- this may be my fault for not reading the fine print, but the IDS stuff on the UDM only works at 600mbps, and I have a gigabit connection. People in Unifi forums will tell me I am the idiot for assuming that, but it has gigabit ports, its 2023... I just ass/u/me/d that everything would work without issue at line speed and wouldn't have to read the spec sheet like a lawyer. Anyway, its fine in the end. I would never buy anything cutting edge from them again, I want anything to bake for at least 6 months after release, which is usually how long it takes for their "shipping" stuff to become actually avai…