The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Pixel vs Samsung Galaxy

Hacker News owners lean toward the Google Pixel.

Google PixelSamsung Galaxy
Owners with an opinion1968255
Positive verdicts56% of 160250% of 215
Positive/negative since 2024503/38734/35
Happy after 3+ years5411
Longest happy owner10 yrs15 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forsoftware and batterysoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy: Likes it
Pixel 9a and earlier were officially sold as Android Open Source Project reference devices. Google made a commitment to providing 7 years of updates from launch for 8th/9th gen Pixels. Google then arbitrarily declared they were no longer AOSP reference devices with the release of Android 16 and stopped providing those updates. Many people bought Pixels due to this and it wasn't fulfilled. GrapheneOS has been able to continue support with a massive amount of work including reverse engineering, but other operating systems haven't been as successful and mostly haven't even moved to Android 17 yet or supported 10th gen Pixels. There are currently around 400k to 600k active Pixels with GrapheneOS. There have been far more than that when including the past devices our users have purchased. Pixels are a small segment of the overall market and that's substantial. If you add in people on other operating systems such as LineageOS then there are even more people using Pixels with another OS. A significant portion of people who bought Pixels did so because they were AOSP reference devices. Samsung provides 7 years of support with monthly updates for their flagship devices. Unlike the Pixel OS, Samsung ships a lot of the security preview patches early. Motorola Signature (2026) has 7 years of support. The upcoming successor to it is the first non-Pixel meeting all of the update and hardware security feature requirements for GrapheneOS. Pixel 11 currently doesn't meet our security requirem…
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
As a Pixel / Galaxy / OnePlus user... My app and photo quality preference are OnePlus > Pixel > > > ... > Samsung. shrug Really it could be a toss up between OnePlus and Google depending on generation. My partner's Pixel 7 takes nearly as nice photos as my OnePlus 12. My Galaxy photos were... very watercolor paint. I could not stand them.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
I had one of those too - quite liked it. I think I got that one after I stopped using a nexus 4. I had a temp samsung galaxy s9 for about 6 months that I hated and then ended up getting a pixel XL and have only really had pixel phones since (pixel XL, pixel 3a XL, pixel 6a). I do miss the slidy keyboards on my old HTC phones - I think the first keyboard slider I got was an HTC Touch Pro still running windows mobile 6 because android wasn't a real thing then. That one required so much fiddling and rom stuff that LineageOS would have seemed like a beautiful dream.
Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy: Recommends it
Yeah, the reception issue is a serious problem, I went from years of the galaxy line to a pixel 6 and then to a pixel 8, and both pixels have terrible reception, though I suspect it's a software issue because for about 8 months into the pixel 6 I had never had a single reception issue, now I have them constantly, even with full bars I'll lose connectivity about a dozen times a day. I'll be going back to a Galaxy for my next phone.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
I just bought Google Pixel a couple of days ago. The reason is that my 6+ y.o. Samsung Galaxy phone hasn't been receiving updates for a long time and my banking app had finally stopped working. The main deciding factor for purchasing Pixel was GrapheneOS. The privacy and security it offers while allowing you to use pretty much use any Android app hassle free is a big selling point. My old phone was actually still working okay but it became unusable as day to day phone due to lack of updates from Samsung. Also, the idea of locking myself into the Samsung ecosystem never appealed to me. I never really used Samsung-specific apps beyond Camera and Gallery. We're at the point already when a mid-range phone has more than good enough hardware specs. Paying $1,000 for a phone or purchasing a new phone every year or two makes no sense to me.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Neutral
I had a pixel 7 pro, that after a half a year developed a battery problem. I got my money back and could get another pixel but was afraid of battery problems again, and picked a one plus 10 pro. I regret it. Pixel has the best Android expirence on the market. I'm not buying iPhones probably ever. I tried iphone 14 pro max a little bit and it's not worth 400 EUR over the Pixel for me. I also had Samsungs, they are ok, but pixel is better.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
All I know is my galaxy wants to download N gigabytes to update every month or two, do it again the same day after the first one, and revert every privacy setting to default (not private) in the process. I've resorted to DNS shenanigans to limit the abuse, only temporarily allowing some domains as necessary for wifi calling or whatever. My pixel 2 never had that sort of bullshit. I never had to figure out how to disable (because uninstalling isn't allowed and neither is root on a Samsung) Candy Crush, I never had to disable (every unwanted "update") location services and ads for my fucking builtin camera, and it had a general feeling of just working. The stock Samsung apps weren't amazing, but ignoring the phoning home with my location and screenshot and recent conversations they weren't shockingly terrible, nevertheless that wasn't my issue with the experience by a longshot.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
Pixel 7 Pro, but I wouldn't avoid it because their dialer sucks. It's still a really good phone when compared to the iPhone/Samsung Galaxy/etc., and it's the only Android phone series I'd consider in the future. When I had a Samsung Galaxy, I installed the full suite of Simple apps onto it because the included apps sucked so bad. Simple gets it mostly right from a UI/UX perspective, and I was happy to support the author by purchasing the apps in the Play store.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
I'm such a big fan of the Pixel experience that I've been letting myself rationalize my plan to stick with it by planning to preorder (tomorrow) the new Pixel Watch. I tell myself that surely _one_ of my Pixel devices would be able to make an emergency call at any given time... Recently I tried out both an iPhone and a Galaxy and failed to make the adjustment to either one within their respective return windows.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
None of the Samsung cameras really come close to Pixels. Owning both Pixel 6 and Galaxy S22+, the S22 has a massive problem with slow shutter, movement and dark scenes (this issue I've observed on S22 Ultra as well). So while Samsung might look better on paper, Pixel consistently takes better picture due to more responsive shutter and less blurry pictures.
Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy: Likes it
The specs are meh, nothing to motivate me to drop using a Galaxy phone...and I doubt it will convert any iPhone users Not clear what Google is going for here, the Pixel line offers very little Yeah, I guess you get new Android versions first, but who cares? The core OS upgrades now only seem to deliver notification and UI changes I don't care about or consider a net-negative. I'll get them eventually on my Galaxy phone, and they won't improve my life. Security and app updates aren't impacted.
Google Pixel: NeutralSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
The point of the Pixels is that raw hardware specs don't trump good software and features. I bought an OG Pixel at launch, really enjoyed it, and then bought a Pixel 3 XL which was... rough for a while. I preferred both and their unlocked bootloaders to TouchWiz on any Galaxy I've owned or Samsung abandoning feature updates on my model after a year or two. If you've never owned a Pixel, they're just generally good phones. Each one has a unique gimmick, and yeah, you're their QA team, but they're ultimately thoughtful, functional devices that show you ways to add value to the things you do.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
Secure BYOD is mostly unsolved wrt most common/popular Android phones. (Windows is also “a thing” but that didn’t stop Maersk or whoever from getting ransomwared, did it?) Most serious orgs prohibit BYOD unless you are on Pixel or iPhone where MDM can actually work securely. There is no meaningful way to secure corporate data on an employee-owned Galaxy, for example. It is the rare corp that can do BYOD securely. The best practice is issuing corporate iPhones to all staff with universal MDM and keeping all corp data physically separate from personal devices. This also saves your employees’ nudes in a subpoena/discovery situation during a civil action against the corp, which is all too common.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
Pixel series is my favorite. Even the second tier Pixels are better than the Samsung Galaxy I got last year. The builtin Samsung apps suck and can't be installed, true. But also the keyboard or screen size isn't a fit for me so it's constantly inserting periods/upper case words into my stream of words when I type quickly. And worst of all the USB-C port has gotten so bad only 2 of my 8 USB-C cables work with the phone anymore (though they still work with other USB-C devices I need to charge). Really looking forward to going back to the Pixel phones and not touching Samsung again.
Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy: Likes it
Good to know the S22 Ultra has a decent fingerprint reader. Note that S10 is totally different than S10e when it comes to the fingerprint reader, though. On the S10e, the power button is the fingerprint reader. The position is perfect. Contrast that with phones like Pixel 4 or Pixel 5, where Google think a sensor in an awkward location on the back of the phone is the right move.
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
> I absolutely despise most third party Android vendors. Years ago I got a Samsung Galaxy 8 which came preloaded with CNN and Facebook. After uninstalling those apps, I poked around with adb and found services still running for CNN and Facebook. Made me also despise non-Pixel devices. For a long while my daily driver was a Pixel 4 (probably my favorite phone hardware of all time) running GrapheneOS and then eventually CalyxOS. If I were to ever switch back to Android I would 100% go back to Pixel running CalyxOS. I absolutely loved that setup. Things that keep me on iOS: - On-demand VPN. I use Wireguard and it is unnoticeable when it automatically turns on when I leave home. I was able to use Tasker on Android to unreliably replicate this functionality. - Apple Shortcuts. Android could really benefit from a first-party automation toolset, Tasker is still pretty mediocre compared to Shortcuts from my somewhat recent tinkering. - Apple is a decent steward of data and I'm encouraged by the continuing privacy features they release (Private Relay is awesome). Despite this, I try to avoid the walled garden as much as possible. Homekit is one area where I've totally invested into but could switch that out with HA if I ever switched back to Android. Things I miss from Android: - Sideloading. F-Droid is the best -- I miss sideloading so much and hope that Apple is eventually forced into allowing users to actually sideload (not the temporary 7-day renewal you are forced to do). Because…
Google Pixel: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
I have bought flagship android devices from many brands. The most expensive Samsung Galaxy native Google Maps app would be more laggy than an iPhone SE in the web view gmaps (and the native app would be even smoother). The only exceptions I've had where performance was reasonable given the price are Sony's phones, the LG G1(?) and some of the pixels. But generally speaking everything on Android stutters _so much_ it's really painful. I have always had this silly theory that this is somehow a Java thing, because there have been very motivated people trying to get low latency stuff working on Android and are just unable to... but it's just unavoidable no matter how much money you spend.