The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Pixel vs OnePlus

Hacker News owners slightly favor the OnePlus.

Google PixelOnePlus
Owners with an opinion1968301
Positive verdicts56% of 160273% of 255
Positive/negative since 2024503/387104/32
Happy after 3+ years5425
Longest happy owner10 yrs11 yrs
Praised forreliability and performanceperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftware and batterysoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
Besides a mix of older Pixels and other phones, in the past few years I went OnePlus 8, Pixel 8 Pro, and currently OnePlus 13. I was completely underwhelmed by the 8 Pro. If felt like a marginal improvement over the OnePlus 8 for a premium price. The back cracked, water got in, and it stopped working. The OnePlus 13 feels like a significantly better phone in every way.
Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
I still have my OnePlus 9 Pro, sadly I smashed the screen on day 2. Despite the broken screen it still feels and looks like a more premium device than my Pixel 9 Pro XL in terms of hardware, but the software really went down hill after the switch to the OPPO software. Now I want rid of the pixel because they destroyed battery life with an update in march they've still not fixed.
Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
Where OnePlus excelled over Pixels (at least at one point in time; I've owned both and gone back to Pixel) was that the OnePlus' beefier hardware meant that the camera startup time and autofocus speed was much faster. The cameras were comparable, but pulling out your Pixel and having a noticeable delay between double-tapping your hardware button and actually being able to take a decent picture was painful. OnePlus solved this with their camera software and beefier specs. Somewhere along the way, the Pixel caught up, and the other quirks of the OnePlus diminished the relative benefit (I recall having some issues with their Android variant, and their charging system not actually following the USB-C spec in a way that was causing me issues). As someone who generally doesn't care about smartphone specs aside from "can it last all day?" and "can I take decent pictures without giving it much thought" the OnePlus line was briefly a great option, but hasn't done anything to make me want to try another one in a decade now. I can't speak much to other flagship phones; I'll never own an Apple product and my experiences with Samsung's software across other devices means I'll likely never consider them either.
Google Pixel: NeutralOnePlus: Likes it
I used the same OnePlus 3T that I bought used, until it was stolen. Would have probably considered a new OnePlus but all their models were too big and expensive at the time, so went Pixel 7 near the end of the cycle. Even though I've been a mac user for about 12 years, iPhones have never made it into the realm of consideration.
Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
OnePlus used to - until they didn't anymore. OnePlus 8 was excellent. Pixel 8 Pro has the worst mobile reception I've ever had in a phone.
Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
This feature is also a lifesaver when your phone screen breaks! A mishap on the bus led to this happening with my old OnePlus phone, and with a USB C to HDMI adapter I was able to navigate around and salvage anything I needed from that device. I actually assumed this was the standard, so when the same thing eventually happened to the Pixel 6 Pro I got after that, I was distraught to learn that Pixels didn't support video-out at all. I ended up managing to get TalkBack (Android's audio assistance tool for the visually impaired) turned on, use that plus screenshots I referenced online to get USB debugging enabled and authorize my computer, and then use scrcpy [0] to control my phone over an ADB connection. [0] https://github.com/Genymobile/scrcpy
Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
I just replace a OnePlus6T from 2018 with a brand new Pixel 8 and I regret it. The 6T had the latest LineageOS and the P8 has GrapheneOS. Both have the latest Android but there's nothing on the Pixel that's better than the OnePlus. 6 years and no noticeable differences in terms of battery, performance, screen, ergonomy, etc. I should have stuck with the old one but I was convinced things were still progressing. My bad.
Google Pixel: NeutralOnePlus: Likes it
I daily drive a OnePlus 11, but I really miss my Pixel 3's compact size. I still have my P3 but am not into using tech until it dies. For me I just accepted mega phones won. Yes, I know the Pixel 8 is smaller, but I tried it and screen size aside it's not as good as my OP11.
Google Pixel: Likes itOnePlus: Doesn’t like it
OnePlus is a big disappointment to me. I'd be a customer for life if they'd kept doing what made them so good: 1. Never settle: big specs, lots of features. SD cards and headphone jack on a flagship? yes please! 2. Factory images available so I can easily re-flash to stock 3. Great pricing 4. Not required proprietary charger to get max speed They could really turn it around, but they would need to return to their roots. Until then I'll just stick with the Pixel A series. It never excites me about phones, but it checks most of my boxes.
Google Pixel: Likes itOnePlus: Doesn’t like it
If any of those are android users, it may be down to the non-android standards friendly battery optimisation the manufacturer ship their devices with (e.g. Samsung, Huawei, OnePlus, Xiamoi, etc.) https://dontkillmyapp.com/ I've had more issues with missing notifications on my OnePlus than I ever had on my Pixel (I have list of reasons why I'll never buy Google hardware again, mostly coming down to their support). Most issues get fixed by me persuading OnePlus to stop applying their secret sauce to power control
Google Pixel: Likes itOnePlus: Doesn’t like it
I had a pixel 7 pro, that after a half a year developed a battery problem. I got my money back and could get another pixel but was afraid of battery problems again, and picked a one plus 10 pro. I regret it. Pixel has the best Android expirence on the market. I'm not buying iPhones probably ever. I tried iphone 14 pro max a little bit and it's not worth 400 EUR over the Pixel for me. I also had Samsungs, they are ok, but pixel is better.
Google Pixel: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
FWIW When I switched from Android->iPhone, I didn't think much of it. Some stuff was better, some stuff was worse. I didn't 'feel' that much better. Then when I switched back from iPhone->Android (Pixel 4) the change was a lot more jarring. I noticed a lot of polish and batteries issues and I missed my iPhone until I finally switched back. My theory is it's similar to lifestyle creep. You wont appreciate improvements as much as you'll notice regressions. > Every once in a while I boot up my old android phone (oneplus 6) and use it and it's snappier than I remember and feels way better in my hand than my iphone does. I wonder if you'd use it as a daily driver for a longer time if you'd have the same experience as me.
Google Pixel: NeutralOnePlus: Likes it
Danger Sidekick II Palm Treo 700 Motorola Droid Samsung Galaxy Nexus LG G2 Google Nexus 6P Google Pixel XL OnePlus 7Pro None of them had glaring problems I had to live with or work around. The battery life up until the LG G2 was a problem -- I usually needed to recharge mid-day if I was doing anything active. The G2 had the best form factor ever -- honestly, they should have kept the external dimensions the same and just improved the internals each year. 5.2" screen, 460 ppi. 138.5 x 70.9 x 8.9 mm. 143g. Eventually it developed a touchscreen fault that slowly spread. The Nexus 6P was a great phone, but big. It developed battery problems after about a year. Up until then, fine. The Pixel XL was a little disappointing because it didn't really feel like much of an advance, but it didn't have the battery problem. I'm still using the 7 Pro, which, for a bigphone, is not bad. It has the excellent motorized pop-up selfie cam, which I like because I hardly ever use it. When I do use it, it deploys quickly. Battery life is starting to degrade (2.5 years in) and I'm thinking about either a Pixel 7 or an Asus Zenphone 9 this fall. So, no. Not every phone has glaring problems.
Google Pixel: Likes itOnePlus: Doesn’t like it
Google is no crapware, Samsung is as much crapware as possible. Samsung has their own version of every built-in app. Text messages for example, they have a much shittier version of "Messages" (no RCS support at least a few months ago). Their apps get set back to default randomly. Photos/Gallery, email, web browser, you name it. They then have other junk installed. Their own app store, their own voice assistant, and other useless/niche apps. You are blocked from uninstalling any of it. It is the scourge of Android. "Android One" was an effort by Google to curb it, but I think only Motorola signed up (in addition to Google, obviously). OnePlus started on the premise of a clean/stock experience, but have started losing their way (rather rapidly). "Nothing" is a new manufacturer aiming for a stock experience. Asus seems to be doing stock. If you ever consider moving away from Pixel I strongly recommend prioritizing a stock experience over _anything_ else. Crapware is maddening, full of bugs, and likely full of vulnerabilities.
Google Pixel: Likes itOnePlus: Doesn’t like it
I tried a OnePlus once (OnePlus 7T in 2020). I thought at that time OnePlus was supposed to be free of bloatware, a pure Android experience. However it did some annoying thing with any app that it considers to be a game. Whenever opening a game it'd pop up some message how it "optimized" the game (whatever that meant), and it also had some unremovable game center app (forgot exact name). I didn't want those popup messages nor that game center thing, but there was no way to disable it, there was only some complicated way of disabling it individually for every specific game which it could also forget after updates. So if OnePlus was supposed to be bloatware free, nope, not at all, comes with annoying things that can't be disabled. Nexus and Pixel are the only bloatware-free Android phones I've seen.
Google Pixel: Likes itOnePlus: Doesn’t like it
The closest (proper) android equivalent to me is the Pixel 4a (at 144mm height). Unfortunately the 5a and (leaked specs) of the 6a are both gigantic and is unfortunate to me. It does a lot of things right: is a (relatively) smol phone, has proper software updates/support, has a headphone jack, allows for bootloader unlocking, support eSIM, has usb3, has a large development community for custom roms/after-market support, and has proper noise cancellation for calls (many other OEMs don't have proper noise cancellation leading to echos all the time) The other contenders are all either larger (but better hardware value), had worse software support, or had a combination of the previous. I will however give a nod to OnePlus for allowing QFIL flashing and having those files available for when devices are soft-bricked/stuck in EDL mode so you can always rescue them. However, their software leaves a lot to be desired in both long term software updates (older models are often not given timely updates), and in refinement (ex. my OnePlus 6T constantly echos on phone calls). A note if you're going to go Pixel line: if you ever decide to root, MAKE SURE you flash the correct model's files. I've seen several times online and had a friend flash the wrong model and end up perma-bricking their phones. Google does /not/ release the QFIL/firehose files for their phones (unlike OnePlus, Xiaomi) so if you make this mistake you WILL have to send it back for a motherboard replacement. If you don't h