The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Pixel 6 vs Google Pixel 8

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Google Pixel 8.

Google Pixel 6Google Pixel 8
Owners with an opinion175122
Positive verdicts40% of 14446% of 101
Positive/negative since 202425/1644/50
Happy after 3+ years10
Longest happy owner3 yrs–
Praised forreliability and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and batteryreliability and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Pixel 6: Likes itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
> but my USB-C port is failing I'm having the same issue with my pixel 8 (along with the screen randomly turning green out of nowhere, so I have to "ground" the display to get it to work again) In general the 8 feels a lot more cheaply made than the 6 I agree that the android UX is better than apple (or at least, it makes more sense to me). But I'd consider moving to iphone for build quality alone
Google Pixel 6: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
FWIW I was on Pixel 3a until last month; bought Pixel 6 in the meantime, but it was too big and heavy to carry around, so I only used it as a "tablet", only at home. Just updated to Pixel 8 and it fits the hand very well (including Spigen Liquid Air cover), and doesn't feel too heavy. Have a few friends who got Pixel 8 last month on sale as well and they all confirm.
Google Pixel 6: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
I just want to put my vote in that I'm really glad they're making reasonable sized phones again. Pixel 6, 7 were oversized monstrosities. If pixel 10 is even smaller than the 8, that's fine by me
Google Pixel 6: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
Not bad, really. My Pixel 6 was being flaky a month ago (not playing sounds reliably), and I needed to fix it right then, so I bought a Pixel 8 from Best Buy for $549+tax and got $220+tax back (described as $70 valued price + $150 promotional) for trading in my Pixel 6. If you consider the $70 as the true value of my flaky Pixel 6, you could say I only paid $399 (plus tax) for the Pixel 8, and now Google's offering me $490 for it if I buy a Pixel 9. Even so I'm not sure the Pixel 8 -> Pixel 9 upgrade is worth $799 - $490 = $309 (plus tax) to me when the Pixel 8 is brand new and working well.
Google Pixel 6: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
I'm really picky. Creaks, screen issues (got the line down the middle of the screen on a 2XL, 3, and 6), speaker went out on 5, cell radio would randomly stop working on the 8, having to reboot multiple times per day. Most recently a 9 Pro XL, flexed more than my wife's, and the screen creaked when pressed (which my wife's didn't). The camera bump falling off didn't happen to me, but I've seen it on others. If I'm going to pay Apple prices, I expect the same level of quality. I really want to like the pixel, but I can't trust Google's quality until they prove otherwise. Every generation of Pixel has had some sort of QC problem.
Google Pixel 6: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
My Pixel 6 and Pixel 8 have worked remarkably badly as cellular devices. I may well not re-up. The last straw is the aggressive Doze mode. Notifications regularly come in very late, 30+ minutes or more.
Google Pixel 6: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
I'm still salty about my Pixel 8 dying out because of the "green screen" bug (basically, screen just progressively turns greener until it stops working). Very common according to reddit, and the ubreakitifixit guy acknowledged it's a common problem as well. My Pixel 5a also had some shenanigans and my dad's pixel 6 as well No idea why they don't do proper Q&A. Looks like a good phone but yet fails in ways my work iphone never has.
Google Pixel 6: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
Yeah, the reception issue is a serious problem, I went from years of the galaxy line to a pixel 6 and then to a pixel 8, and both pixels have terrible reception, though I suspect it's a software issue because for about 8 months into the pixel 6 I had never had a single reception issue, now I have them constantly, even with full bars I'll lose connectivity about a dozen times a day. I'll be going back to a Galaxy for my next phone.