The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Pixel 5 vs Google Pixel 7

Hacker News owners lean toward the Google Pixel 5.

Google Pixel 5Google Pixel 7
Owners with an opinion145125
Positive verdicts65% of 12543% of 100
Positive/negative since 202430/1622/27
Happy after 3+ years50
Longest happy owner6 yrs1 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forsupport and softwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Pixel 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel 7: Doesn’t like it
I ordered and sent back a Pixel 7 because it was so large/heavy compared to what I was used to. Ended up buying a refurbed Pixel 5 (the model before Google introduced the new camera bar design) that's still kicking, been very happy. Looks like they've gotten the Pixel 9 a bit smaller than the 7 but still the same weight. It's still larger than the Pixel 5 too. https://www.phonearena.com/phones/size/Google-Pixel-9,Google... The iPhone, to be fair, is closer to the Pixel 9 in size/weight than the Pixel 5 too.
Google Pixel 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel 7: Doesn’t like it
I'm not clumsy at all, but pixel 7 is so slippery, that if you put it on a table/laptop with little aderence and maybe a bit of inclination, it can fell off. Meanwhile my older pixel 5 is the total opposite - it feels good in the hand and the grip is not slippery at all My even older pixel 3 is betweenn p5 and p7, it has a glass back but it's not that bad compared to p7. There are other advantages to plastic backs too: cheap, easy to replace, (usually) lighter compared to glass
Google Pixel 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 7: Doesn’t like it
> If you can find me credible evidence that Unihertz will support the device for 5+ years, delivering major version upgrades and timely security patches... You don't even get that with most Pixel phones. Through to the Pixel 5 family, you only get three years of updates, period. Through to the Pixel 7 family, you get an additional two of security updates. It's not until the Pixel 8 family that you're getting what you demand. That's a lot of "e-waste" that Google only recently stopped generating. ;) But, honestly? I'm not sure why you consider the current five-years-of-updates policy to not be creating an unacceptable amount of e-waste. I have (and still use) nearly-twenty-year-old laptops with the latest Linux kernel and desktop environment software (& etc) versions available. They work just fine. The only maintenance required has been battery replacement and occasional thermal paste replacement. [0] Only five years of updates? That's an absolutely absurd policy. [0] Though, it's not clear that the thermal paste actually needed to be replaced... it was just fun to break out the screwdrivers and service manual.
Google Pixel 5: NeutralGoogle Pixel 7: Neutral
I get Pixel phones and keep them until the battery goes. I've owned the original, the 5, and now the 7. None of the in-betweens because I didn't need to upgrade (the battery in the 5 went a bit earlier than expected, but I still got 3 or so years out of it, which is okay). Technically my original Pixel still works, but the screen is cracked pretty good so it's my backup phone. Why do you feel you need to change phones every 2 years? The hardware is probably fine unless your carrier of choice completely changes their network. The software will still work, although security fixes might be less frequent (it seems those are done for about 4 years, though 3rd-party distributors like Motorola might not honour that). Are you sure your perception that you need a new phone every couple years isn't being driven by marketing and contracts?
Google Pixel 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 7: Doesn’t like it
Watch a jogger jogging, and try to take a photo each time their foot hits the ground (so about 1.5 Hz). Within 10 seconds you'll find the camera crashes and/or starts throwing away photos you already took. Try it on battery saver mode or while playing music for even more bugginess. Tested this on: Nexus 4, Nexus 5, Nexus 6P, Pixel 1, Pixel 5, Pixel 7.
Google Pixel 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel 7: Likes it
On twitter I got sorta-popular mostly sharing photos of my life, documentary style, and a few are with a Leica Q2 ($5000). Most are with a Pixel 5 (or recently Pixel 7). People very often ask me what camera I used to take a photo. When they do, it's usually the Pixel! Maybe 80% of the time it's a phone camera shot. Of course highly specific gear matters for sports shooting (as he mentions) or wildlife shooting (telephoto), but otherwise limitations don't matter too much. Blurry or lower dpi photos are OK. Quick editing on your phone is OK. Finding the right photo in the world is still what matters most. One of the reasons I love the Leica Q2, with its fixed 28mm lens (no zooming, no changing lenses), is that it forces you to find these photos. You're not thinking about gear, about what to bring or how to start. Instead you spend your energy just seeing and moving (zoom with your feet only) and I think this makes you a better photographer than one with a bigger gear loadout. It's also why I think I can seamlessly switch between my 'real' camera and my phone when thinking about what to point at, since I'm married to just a single focal length. Since I always have my phone, I get more shots on my phone, and maybe to the audience those are the most impressive shots, so they ask, and they find out I'm using a phone camera. The gear definitely doesn't matter that much.
Google Pixel 5: NeutralGoogle Pixel 7: Neutral
I think this is a very big systemic problem. And it's all in the way things are presented. Think of smartphones and the rate at which "new" phones come out. The industry is based on a year by year renewal rate which is completely environmentally unsustainable and in order to sustain this speed they need big, bold advertisement. It's not at all about telling people how to differentiate between products and which products are better than the competition which in many cases it's their own smartphone from the previous year. I mean, how long has it been since we've really required our phones to be "2 times as fast as the year before", I had a pixel 5 and a pixel 7 and there's honestly very little difference whatsoever between them. But of course, there were a lot of bells and whistles for the new AI and so on that I really barely get any use out of. Not only that, but a lot of modern improvements are software improvements that come packaged in "new" hardware. That's a ridiculous thing, I'm not saying software is not important but we don't need new hardware to benefit from it in most cases. But hey, it's much more lucrative to sell a brand new 1000 dollar phone with a 30% margin than try to get people to pay 300 dollars for new software. We value hardware but hardware is not progressing as substantially as software is, at least in areas that truly have an impact on our lives. So they need to make things a bit prettier and that's where advertisement comes in. But is this a healthy…
Google Pixel 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 7: Doesn’t like it
At the very least they can add an environmental tax on anything that is not coming with a removable battery. Then we can stop tossing entire phones in the garbage. I have a Pixel 5. The Pixel 7 isn't even an improvement to me. The fact that my battery is at 15% after the day is done means I am on my last year with the device. I have a Nexus 6 with basically no battery to speak of but it works great still outside of that. So for my second suggestion, if a company claims to be focused on climate change reduction, using a non-removable battery will double the tax. All proceeds go to renewables for whatever state has the best(lowest) carbon footprint not yet at 0. Let's see how long the "thinness" of the phone matters.