The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Pixel 5 vs Google Pixel 6

Hacker News owners lean toward the Google Pixel 5.

Google Pixel 5Google Pixel 6
Owners with an opinion145175
Positive verdicts65% of 12540% of 144
Positive/negative since 202430/1625/16
Happy after 3+ years51
Longest happy owner6 yrs3 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forsupport and softwaresoftware and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Pixel 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel 6: Doesn’t like it
I was going to complain about the screen size but my Pixel 5 has a 6.0 screen and I might actually finally upgrade to the Pixel 8. The pixel 8 is still half a cm wider than the pixel 5 but they appear to be the same height and nearly the same thickness. I had a Pixel 6 briefly, at launch, but returned it almost immediately in exchange for a 6.0" screen Pixel 5 because the 6 was ludicrously too large for daily use on the go and uncomfortable in my pants pocket. Hopefully they keep shrinking the non-pro models and we settle on 6" as an ok size.
Google Pixel 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel 6: Doesn’t like it
Yeah, I got the Pixel 6 when it was on sale a couple months ago. Amazing camera and buttery OS, but damn that thing was just huge to me. Also the on-screen fingerprint reader was only about 90% accurate which was just frustrating enough to make me hate it. Ended up sending it back and getting a refurbished Pixel 5. Not state of the art, but the size/weight is perfect and the physical fingerprint reader never misses a beat. Really, really hoping they bring back a sensible model to the Pixel line for people that just want a nice, clean, lightweight phone.
Google Pixel 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel 6: Doesn’t like it
> pixel 6 My condolences! I hate this phone so much that I am taking evey chance to shit on it and warn people. I never realized how perfect the pixle 5 and A11 were until I "upgraded".
Google Pixel 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel 6: Doesn’t like it
I’m a long-time small phone Android user. But after the Pixel 5, I have not been able to find a suitable small Android replacement. The Pixel 6 is gigantic, and the Pixel 7 looks like it is also destined to be huge. It’s gotten so bad that I’ve resorted to using an iPhone Mini, biding my time and hoping desperately that some Android OEM would step up. But it’s increasingly clear that a small premium phone is not on the roadmap. So I’ve decided to take matters into my own hands. My goal with https://smallandroidphone.com is to rally other fans of small phones together and put pressure on Google/Samsung/Anyone to consider making a small phone. I have a very specific set of skills and industry connections that I have acquired over a long career in the hardware business (my first startup was Pebble). I will put them to use in our shared quest to get the perfect small Android phone. If no one else builds one, and enough people sign up...maybe I will be forced to make it myself. If you want a small premium Android phone, this may be your last chance (ever?) to help bring back the phone category that we love.
Google Pixel 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel 6: Doesn’t like it
The Pixel 5 is perfect. It's the only phone that tore me away from the iPhone 7/8 SE form. The fingerprint sensor is arguable in a better position (on the back). Plus you get better battery, an OLED screen, 90hz. It sucks the Pixel 6 series went huge and bulky instead of continuing the successive wins of Pixel 3,4,5.
Google Pixel 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 6: Doesn’t like it
I'm really picky. Creaks, screen issues (got the line down the middle of the screen on a 2XL, 3, and 6), speaker went out on 5, cell radio would randomly stop working on the 8, having to reboot multiple times per day. Most recently a 9 Pro XL, flexed more than my wife's, and the screen creaked when pressed (which my wife's didn't). The camera bump falling off didn't happen to me, but I've seen it on others. If I'm going to pay Apple prices, I expect the same level of quality. I really want to like the pixel, but I can't trust Google's quality until they prove otherwise. Every generation of Pixel has had some sort of QC problem.