The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Pixel 4a vs Google Pixel 8

Hacker News owners lean toward the Google Pixel 4a.

Google Pixel 4aGoogle Pixel 8
Owners with an opinion194122
Positive verdicts61% of 15646% of 101
Positive/negative since 202447/3344/50
Happy after 3+ years60
Longest happy owner5 yrs–
Praised forreliability and portabilityperformance and ease of use
Criticized forbattery and supportreliability and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Pixel 4a: Likes itGoogle Pixel 8: Neutral
I've considered this before, but the short software support timeframe given by device manufacturers makes this a costly endeavour. I still have a perfectly functional Galaxy Tab S2 9.7, but even the third party ROMs have dropped it. I have a pixel 4a, and although it works beautifully running a supported version of lineage it's very likely that the modem baseband has a significant vulnerability that Google isn't patching. I don't think running banking or crypto wallet software on those devices is any smarter than running it on my daily driver pixel 8.
Google Pixel 4a: Likes itGoogle Pixel 8: Neutral
I've been using it for more than 2 years, and I can't think of ever going back to a stock OS. I had to send my phone for a screen repair, in the meantime I picked up my old Samsung, and the sheer amount of apps I didn't want, notifications and dark patterns to tricking me into handing over my data made me anxious. I couldn't finish setting the phone up and drove to my parent's home to pick up their old, remotely nerfed by Google, Pixel 4a so I could install GrapheneOS into it and use it while I waited for my repaired Pixel 8.
Google Pixel 4a: Likes itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
I had a two phone lifestyle as well for different reasons: I needed car play but don't like iOS, and also needed to know Android and iOS quite well for my job. One iPhone that was wifi only, had my entire music library local, used for car play and a few exclusive apps. One android with a sim that had my communication apps, social media, and some custom tinkering stuff that doesn't exist on iOS. I did this for about two years. The main takeaways: -I 100% could have just had the iPhone with a sim for communication apps and been fine. The social media was just annoying enough to swap to that I never felt that draw and barely used it on 2phones. -even though I despise how little customization iOS lets you do, without social media or game apps, the only actual pain point with it was the nightmare of managing notifications/alert/vibration/screen wake settings* -god it made me miss small phones so much. The android was a pixel 4a, the last real phone with real hardware that released at the actual ideal size for my hands(that has an unlocked bootloader, I really can't do the Samsung hellOS experience again). Now Im on a pixel 8 only, with Glider for this site and no other social media or games. It's fine. Phones too big, car doesn't have AAuto, and Google is trying to rot the foundation of android, but for now it's fine and better than the two phone experience because it's less juggling.
Google Pixel 4a: Likes itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
Yup. I had a Pixel 4a, which is 5.8". I thought it was a great phone and still perfectly usable, but it stopped getting security updates. I'm now using a Pixel 8. It's fine, but too large and no headphone jack. I'd buy a new Pixel tomorrow if they released a smaller one.
Google Pixel 4a: NeutralGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
The primary reason I replaced my Pixel 4a was it going EoL for security updates. The battery did get replaced once, and it brought it back to life. I don't want a halo device, I want something that is secure, functional, repairable and cheap enough that if this portable slab of glass explodes I am not that sad. The primary reason I replaced my device with a Pixel 8 is for the 7 years of security updates. Going from the 4a to the 8? Barely noticed a change in functionality.
Google Pixel 4a: NeutralGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
I had the same problem on my 4a. I've since upgraded to a Pixel 8, and I still have the blank screen problem. Notably with a PWA, has to be killed and restarted. This is on Fennec (so FF dev basically). Annoys so much, chromium-based browsers don't have any issue.
Google Pixel 4a: Likes itGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
> Approximately nobody is throwing away phones because the OEM stopped providing security patches. They're doing it for more practical reasons, like the phone getting slow, the battery wearing out, or wanting a better camera. I did this just last year because my Pixel 4a stopped getting security updates and some app I needed to use for work (I think Duo?) refused to install or run because of it. The phone was otherwise running perfectly fine and I had no reason to change it. I'm on a Pixel 8 now which is supposed to have 7 years of security updates, and I don't see myself replacing it until then.
Google Pixel 4a: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
Same here. I kept my 4a for ages for the same reason until it died on me (power button stopped working). I'm now on a Pixel 8 and am hauling around a USB-C to 3.5mm adapter as I don't want to put up with the logistics of keeping wireless headphones charged. It works OK(ish), but often comes loose when putting my phone in my pocket while listening to music and little annoyances like not being to turn the volume as far down as I used to be able to on the headphone jack. Definitely a downgrade in user experience. In German there's a nice word for this: Verschlimmbesserung.