The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Pixel 3 vs Google Pixel 5

Hacker News owners lean toward the Google Pixel 5.

Google Pixel 3Google Pixel 5
Owners with an opinion135145
Positive verdicts58% of 11765% of 125
Positive/negative since 202431/1230/16
Happy after 3+ years75
Longest happy owner8 yrs6 yrs
Praised forreliability and batteryreliability and performance
Criticized forsoftwaresupport and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Pixel 3: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
Not sure about iPads, but going from a pixel 3 to a pixel 5 made me feel like my pixel 3 was broken. Xr to 16 pro was similar, but that is because Xr was legit broken.
Google Pixel 3: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
I have a projector that can project 4k at 60hz or 1080p at 240, and I can really notice it by just moving the cursor around. I don’t need to render my games anywhere near 240 to notice that too. Same with phones - moving from pixel 3 to pixel 5, scrolling through settings or the home screen was a palpable difference. Pixel 3 now feels broken. It is not.m, it just renders at 60 instead of 90 fps.
Google Pixel 3: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
i guess flip phones are the new small. once they become more affordable. my pixel 3 died after 4 years so i upgraded to a used pixel 5 which was the last small-ish pixel. very surprised with the battery. rarely end the day less than 75% - and it's smaller than the not small (imo) zenfone 10.
Google Pixel 3: NeutralGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
I'm not clumsy at all, but pixel 7 is so slippery, that if you put it on a table/laptop with little aderence and maybe a bit of inclination, it can fell off. Meanwhile my older pixel 5 is the total opposite - it feels good in the hand and the grip is not slippery at all My even older pixel 3 is betweenn p5 and p7, it has a glass back but it's not that bad compared to p7. There are other advantages to plastic backs too: cheap, easy to replace, (usually) lighter compared to glass
Google Pixel 3: Likes itGoogle Pixel 5: Doesn’t like it
I'd still be happy with just my (GrapheneOS) Pixel 3, if only it were still getting closed blob security updates. Instead, I've had to replace it repeatedly: Pixel 3, Pixel 4a, Pixel 5, and now Pixel 6a. Each model upgrade was a regression in size and weight. The only improvement I liked was in the cameras, but photography-wise they're still only cameraphone snapshot grade, so not a worthwhile upgrade to me. I would've rather been able to keep using the Pixel 3. I'm looking forward to keeping the Pixel 6a awhile (once the carrier flakiness that coincided with the move the other day settles down). (Edit: Unless there comes out some local ML model that I want that needs more processing hardware.)
Google Pixel 3: Likes itGoogle Pixel 5: Neutral
I was happy with GrapheneOS on Pixel 3, and would still use it except it's EOL for some firmware security updates. The Pixel 4a hardware I then got (didn't want a 4) is fine with GrapheneOS, though an "a", and I prefer the 3. The Pixel 5 seems OK so far, though the display colors on this particular unit (don't know about the model) are noticeably less vibrant than the 3. I hope GrapheneOS keeps going on a good path, and that there's an appealing option for hardware after the Pixel 5. (I can't yet justify the cost of a non-backordered Librem 5, for how little I use a smartphone, and I have mixed feelings about the PinePhones.)
Google Pixel 3: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 5: Doesn’t like it
I'm really picky. Creaks, screen issues (got the line down the middle of the screen on a 2XL, 3, and 6), speaker went out on 5, cell radio would randomly stop working on the 8, having to reboot multiple times per day. Most recently a 9 Pro XL, flexed more than my wife's, and the screen creaked when pressed (which my wife's didn't). The camera bump falling off didn't happen to me, but I've seen it on others. If I'm going to pay Apple prices, I expect the same level of quality. I really want to like the pixel, but I can't trust Google's quality until they prove otherwise. Every generation of Pixel has had some sort of QC problem.