The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Nexus vs Samsung Galaxy S

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Samsung Galaxy S.

Google NexusSamsung Galaxy S
Owners with an opinion326449
Positive verdicts52% of 28163% of 368
Positive/negative since 202428/32107/71
Happy after 3+ years1842
Longest happy owner13 yrs12 yrs
Praised forreliability and designperformance and reliability
Criticized forperformance and batterysoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Nexus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Neutral
I have recently taken to gathering old phones and putting Nerves on them (Nerves packages up the Erlang VM into a mainline kernel to run on a variety of devices). I got inspired by a talk by Marc Lainez at Goatmire who had put it on a variety of exotic devices (e.g., a Wii). I am by no means an expert at this, but starting of with a device on the Postmarket OS list and Claude, you can get a lot of these old devices working with mainline Linux and nearly all drivers. The newer devices are a bit harder, but if you go back nearly a decade, they're very easy to get working. So far I have repurposed a Fairphone 3, Nexus 5, Galaxy S20, and Galaxy Tab 3.0 7". All of them (except the s20) with all drivers working compared to stock. Others have done a lot too: https://github.com/mlainez/awesome-nerves-systems For DIY projects you can use host USB, or get one of the Adafruit FT232H type boards for GPIO pins.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
Loved my Nexus 5x until the high power CPU cores started failing causing instabilities. Loved my pixel 2 until the battery stopped holding a charge. Liked my 4a (it is literally a faster 2 that you can't squeeze to bring up google assistant (the squeeze was my fave feature)) until the April 2023 update that ruined the battery life. They never fixed it. Pixel 7 was suffering the same issues at the time. I made the decision to switch to a Samsung S23+ and not looking back. Build quality of the Google flagships never have been the best, but they always have issues. I am getting too old to have time to fiddle with this stuff and just want something that works.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
If you want to get into Android, a safer bet for high-end devices would be Samsung. It helps if you have other Samsung devices, like TVs or Galaxy Watch. I have an S21 Ultra (2021). It's big and somewhat heavy, but it has 16 GB of RAM, 512 GB of storage, a good camera, it will get 4-5 years of updates in total, and it's easily the best Android I had thus far. My last Google device was Nexus 6 and it was shit. The first device I got had screen issues. Changed it in warranty, and the replacement died just after the warranty was over. Pixels are not as appalling as Nexuses were back then, but from reviews on the web, it's not far either. Also, the default Google experience is shit too.
Google Nexus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
I have to admit, I'm on the opposite end of the spectrum there, having had both devices I loved my 2012 Nexus 7, and was a Day 1 upgrader to the 2013 model (my Mom enjoyed the 2012 for many years for eBooks and Facebook) My Nexus 5 I was also a day 1 purchase, upgrading from a slowly deteriorating Galaxy S2. Unfortunately I had to replace it much earlier after I slipped and fell on uneven concrete and shattered the screen If Google could just take the SoC of the Pixel 6/7/8/whatever and stuff it in the housing of the Nexus 7 2013, give it a modern battery and a nice OLED screen it would truly be the best tablet on the market. But instead they want "bigger" and are chasing after the iPad with the new pixel tablet
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
I owned the original Nexus 5 phone and Nexus 7 tablet. I love both of these devices for their design but both had serious issues. The Nexus 7's storage degraded, which rendered the device unusably slow. I thought it was the upgrade to the next version of Android that did it, but downgrading it did not fix the issue. There's been some workarounds that made it slightly more usable but ultimately it was a serious hardware defect that made it unbearably slow to use even with these workarounds. The Nexus 5 had a bootlooping issue — I had the issue occur on my first Nexus 5, 2 weeks out of warranty. Fortunately Google was kind enough to send me a refurbished one... that shortly after had the same bootloop issue. My opinion of Google has gradually deteriorated over time to the point now where I actively avoid using anything made by Google because 1) they can't do hardware right and 2) they sunset way too many products for me to feel comfortable using them. So the promise of 7 years of OS updates on a hardware device by Google just seems empty and maybe pointless because I don't trust the device itself will continue functioning, even if the updates keep coming... which I have doubts they will. While I was still using Android, my Samsung Galaxy S6 was probably the most headache-free experience I had, even with the complete lack of feature/OS updates but as it stands, my iPhones have all been rock solid devices, so that is probably what I will continue using unless something drastic ch…
Google Nexus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Recommends it
A Nexus 4 handed down to my son recently stopped working when he dropped it, smashing the screen. Gave him my cast off Nexus 5 that was still storming great. My wife's Nexus 5 was working perfectly, though we replaced it with an iPhone 7 (to her great dismay, it turns out). My own Nexus 6P has worked perfectly, but for dev reasons I replaced it with a GS8 (which is simply a stunning device in every way, including the fact that I immediately dropped a UHS-1 64GB SD card it in and now do my data churning development on that). The point, I guess, is that anecdotes vary. Heck, my son has been toying around with the G1 and G2, and Nexus One, I had sitting in drawers.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
I had a Samsung Galaxy S2 and a Nexus 10 which both suffered from flash related problems making them incredibly slow. Samsung never fixed that nor was there ever a recall. I also owned a HTC One M7 which worked well for a very long time but it also got slow even though there were no hardware problems. The M7 worked just as good from day one if I factory reset it, it only becomes slow again once all the apps are updated. What I think is happening here is that apps move to the newer Android API but keep compatibility with older Android versions through compatibility layers, and they compound so once the entire compatibility layers become "too thick" the CPU gets bogged down and the whole thing becomes slow...
Google Nexus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
I think the Nexus 5 and S2 were unbeatable if you look at "bang for the buck" over time ( ~200 €). Unfortunately, it seems that, since then, almost all phones have raised their "lowerbound-prices" thanks to the iPhone. ( probably not a popular opinion, considering popularity of the iPhone in the US :p)