The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Nexus vs Motorola Moto X

Hacker News owners lean toward the Motorola Moto X.

Google NexusMotorola Moto X
Owners with an opinion32625
Positive verdicts52% of 28174% of 23
Positive/negative since 202428/326/1
Happy after 3+ years181
Longest happy owner13 yrs5 yrs
Praised forreliability and designdesign and performance
Criticized forperformance and batteryreliability and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Nexus: Likes itMotorola Moto X: Neutral
Yep, on older phones it was certainly possible without an Internet connection. On the Nexus 5, you could just `fastboot oem unlock` right out of the box, install TWRP (custom "recovery") and install CyanogenMod/LienageOS, without ever booting the stock ROM. On my Moto G4 Play and Moto X4, you had to get an unlock code from the Motorola website (based on the phone serial number I think) and waive some warranty terms, but once retrieved at least the phone didn't need to be online to unlock the bootloader. The process on the newer Pixels is disappointingly intrusive, like basically everything Google has done for the last decade.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itMotorola Moto X: Likes it
The Nexus 4 was a nice phone but I thought the battery life was bad and it also ran hot. My Moto-X was truly next level. It was oled and could do always on display that didn't need to power the blacks pixels on the screen. It was the first phone to do this. It has voice recognition for unlocking (getting info that you couldn't when the phone was locked). First to do this too since I believe it uses dedicated hardware at the time. It also knew when I was driving to unlock the phone for voice commands also. It was small.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itMotorola Moto X: Likes it
I hated the Nexus 4... it was slippery and broke waaaay to easily. I think the Moto X with the wood back was one of the coolest looking phones ever though.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itMotorola Moto X: Likes it
It takes only one slip up to screw your security. One targeted attack that you don't notice because you're in a rush. I love my MotoX 2013, but it never got updates (Sprint model, Sprint blamed Motorola, Motorola blamed Sprint); it's succeptible to Stagefright so I can't use it anymore. And it will never receive an update for it. As much as we use our phones and as much personal information is on them, security updates should be first and foremost. Yes, AOSP exists for some devices, but 9 times out of 10, something breaks when using it. When Android moves to a new way of doing audio or video, drivers stop working, and some people try to come up with shims, but as others point out. The developer of it gets a new phone and the project dies. My Nexus 5 (November 2013) hasn't gotten a security update since October 2016. My iPhone 5 (September 2012) just got an update to 10.3.3 in July. Android devices are notorious for being slow to get updates, if you ever get them at all. Yeah it can be cheaper to get an Android device, and I have quite a few, but they simply aren't up to the same standards that iPhones are.
Google Nexus: NeutralMotorola Moto X: Recommends it
Indeed. The Moto X is the most overlooked, but not under-rated, phone in recent history. The reviewers loved it. It is a truly awesome phone. They just failed to drum up sales to match. I recently used a Nexus 5 for a week. While a nice piece of hardware, I found myself consistently wanting the little extras that the Moto X comes with.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itMotorola Moto X: Doesn’t like it
I agree, but here is my rough memory: - the Nexus One died when the power button broke - the Nexus S died when half the touch screen stopped working - the Galaxy Nexus died for some hardware reason that I cannot remember - one of my Nexus 4 died when the battery ballooned and shattered the glass - another Nexus 4 died in an infinite boot loop - the spare BLU brand phone died in an infinite boot loop - the Moto X died when the radio antenna (both WiFi and cell) stopped working - the Nexus 5X died in an infinite boot loop