The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Nexus vs Google Pixel

Hacker News owners lean toward the Google Pixel.

Google NexusGoogle Pixel
Owners with an opinion3261968
Positive verdicts52% of 28156% of 1602
Positive/negative since 202428/32503/387
Happy after 3+ years1854
Longest happy owner13 yrs10 yrs
Praised forreliability and designreliability and performance
Criticized forperformance and batterysoftware and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Neutral
There's a line to toe - each kid is different, but with my daughter she went from a flip phone in middle school, to a smart phone in high school. We didn't turn on mobile data for her smart phone (hand me down pixel) until about a year ago. She is very responsible with it and it hasn't been much of an issue. She had no problems making friends, and if her phone was filtering shallow people out her friend pool a bit that probably wasn't a bad thing. Now, my oldest son is dying to have a smartphone but really he just wants to use it as a tablet. I installed lineageOS on an old D821/Nexus5 and it can run some mobile games, and we have a chromebook. We'll try the same flip phone in middle-school route. It fulfills the basic needs of emergency contact, and is a good test of responsibility with lower stakes.
Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
As an aside, I really liked my Google Nexus 5x, but it felt like basic quality control fell off a cliff for the Pixel line. Between Pixel 2/4/8 (yeah yeah what can I say I'm a masochist), I had problems with out-of-focus pictures, widely inaccurate GPS, and my absolute favorite making a call which would dial the number and then about a second later immediately hang up. I had a brief fling with using an iPhone but the speech-to-text dictation was absolute GARBAGE DAY and I make pretty heavy use of that feature while walking my dog.
Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Also Google stuff always lacks SD card slots and have tiny storage. The $250 Motorola can add a $50 1 TB SD Card, which is enough to fit your entire music collection, all of wikipedia, and an offline ad-free routable map of the world from OSM, and still have probably like 700 GB left over for photos/videos. Google meanwhile charges $100 for a 128 GB storage upgrade. Probably because they want to funnel you into their cloud storage, want you to use their online maps/music services, etc. Phone cameras are also absolute trash anyway, and pulling up some comparisons in Google Photos right now, I'm fairly certain that my Pixel 6a takes obviously worse photos than my Nexus 5x did 10 years ago, even comparing high light for the 6a to low light for the 5x. I'll probably buy a Motorola when my current phone dies because the only ostensible reason to buy a Pixel is the camera. Or I suspect the real big-brained solution lives in the handheld gaming PC space.
Google Nexus: NeutralGoogle Pixel: Likes it
I owned several Nexus phones as well as Pixel phones. I'd say that the Pixels were pretty decent; my main annoyance was with the fact that Google deliberately disabled some of the hardware features in that line-up to push their own proprietary solutions - most notably, there's no video output over USB-C nor Miracast, so that your only option is Chromecast.
Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
I have a nexus 6p with a battery charging to 60% and the battery is on year 4 right now, runs android 11, and seems to have no end in sight for the battery. The phone itself is 2015 I got from a relative who bought a Pixel 3. So battery if handled properly will last a very long time. The bigger issue is storage errors and being locked out. The Google Pixel 3 phone he bought died after 2 years due to the operating system not properly handling errors in the non-volatile storage, which is a very common error in Pixel 3/3XL/4 and maybe future ones as well. Google doesn't offer the firehose so owners are out of luck not able to reformat or recover the phones at all and completely locked out by the qualcomm bootloader with phones stuck in EDL mode. Google Pixel 3 EDL to see how prevalent the problem is, and google just doesn't care to help people fix the issue.
Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Neutral
Too little, too late for me... I hate to be the guy having those "hot takes" or whatever, but hear me out for a sec: I didn't get a cell phone until 2013. (Yes I used land lines until then.) It was a Nexus 4 (still love the grippy sides and sleek glass back). Every 2-3 years I traded up, all the way until Pixel 6. Tomorrow my first iPhone will be delivered. Why? A lot of reasons, but some are: - I can't just plug my Google phone into an external display to mirror it. Uh, hello?? DisplayPort out is explicitly disabled in the source code with no reason given: https://twitter.com/MishaalRahman/status/1189998588023234560 -- yet this works great in other phones. - I can't access my text messages from my Android phone (without a separate app like SMS Backup & Restore) -- go ahead, try it. Yeah, do an adb backup. Maybe rooting your phone would give you access, but it's impossible otherwise AFAIK. And I think rooting your phone deletes everything in the process. Did you know you can just plug in an iPhone into Windows or Macs and dump a backup to your computers? It's all right there, text messages, system settings, contacts, photos, databases, EVERYTHING (except maybe hardware-protected keys). It's amazing. - I can't access my phone backup. It's ONLY stored on Google's servers. The only way to even get close is to restore it to a phone. This is a physical device I bought and literally am holding in my hand but can't access all the stuff on it! - Do I even need to mention all the Go…
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
My own experience in the Android land, after making that jump from Nokia N900 to Nexus 4, is that you can get a new $CURRENT_GEN-1 (or -2) device for much much less while still having most of the performance/features . As such, I have never bought a then-current flagship. I have always kept my mobile plans (yes, multiple) separate from devices - I prefer the flexibility. With my story being: (N900 [USB port fell off!] ->) Nexus 4 [battery died] -> Nexus 5X [dropped it] -> Pixel [battery died on warranty, sent in] -> Pixel 2 [got as warranty replacement!] _and_ Pixel 3A [bought it]... I'm still very fine with the 3A thank you very much. In fact the only reasonable argument I've read for replacing a perfectly functional Android device is "when Google stops doing sec patches". Anyone here has any other good arguments for "replace before it's not functional"? (P.S. For "fun" I later replaced the battery and antenna in Nexus 4 - it still works today! And I keep Pixel 2 in the drawer as a hot backup. And yes, for both phones I do periodically turn them on, update and charge the battery.)
Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
At the very least they can add an environmental tax on anything that is not coming with a removable battery. Then we can stop tossing entire phones in the garbage. I have a Pixel 5. The Pixel 7 isn't even an improvement to me. The fact that my battery is at 15% after the day is done means I am on my last year with the device. I have a Nexus 6 with basically no battery to speak of but it works great still outside of that. So for my second suggestion, if a company claims to be focused on climate change reduction, using a non-removable battery will double the tax. All proceeds go to renewables for whatever state has the best(lowest) carbon footprint not yet at 0. Let's see how long the "thinness" of the phone matters.
Google Nexus: NeutralGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Had the same experience with 2 Nexus phones. My Nexus tablets were fine outside of... Every Google Nexus and Pixel device I've owned, going back longer than I can remember, had had sharp battery decline around 16-18 months with not-heavy but daily usage. I'm also looking at an iPhone as my next smartphone, and I've been on Android since the original G1. I've also had issues with Project Fi "support" in the last year or two despite the fact that I vastly prefer their pay as you go and international service.
Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Neutral
Danger Sidekick II Palm Treo 700 Motorola Droid Samsung Galaxy Nexus LG G2 Google Nexus 6P Google Pixel XL OnePlus 7Pro None of them had glaring problems I had to live with or work around. The battery life up until the LG G2 was a problem -- I usually needed to recharge mid-day if I was doing anything active. The G2 had the best form factor ever -- honestly, they should have kept the external dimensions the same and just improved the internals each year. 5.2" screen, 460 ppi. 138.5 x 70.9 x 8.9 mm. 143g. Eventually it developed a touchscreen fault that slowly spread. The Nexus 6P was a great phone, but big. It developed battery problems after about a year. Up until then, fine. The Pixel XL was a little disappointing because it didn't really feel like much of an advance, but it didn't have the battery problem. I'm still using the 7 Pro, which, for a bigphone, is not bad. It has the excellent motorized pop-up selfie cam, which I like because I hardly ever use it. When I do use it, it deploys quickly. Battery life is starting to degrade (2.5 years in) and I'm thinking about either a Pixel 7 or an Asus Zenphone 9 this fall. So, no. Not every phone has glaring problems.
Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Mine doesn't crash (anymore, it did when v12 came out), but my cell/data goes offline randomly and I get worse service than my peers in many places. It also overheats when exposed to almost any sunlight at all no matter the ambient temperature (it's overheated in my car with the ac on and no case) or when charging and doing a video call at the same time. My Nexus 4 and Note 5 were solid phones, but every android phone I've had after that has been awful in one way or another. The final straw for me has been android auto on this phone. Completely unusable and unsafe. So many crashes and lockups and touching any cable causes it to disconnect (but my wifes iphone doesn't do this so it's not just the cables). At this point I'm looking at an iPhone for my next phone. Something like android would be nice, but I also want a premium phone that works. My Note 5 is actually still going strong and is smooth and responsive (except for lack of updates). The battery hasn't swelled or anything.
Google Nexus: NeutralGoogle Pixel: Likes it
I'm about to retire one Nexus 5 from phone duty (the other I'm using as a dashcam) only because I'll need to have VOLTE when visiting the US from Canada. Carriers offer "deals" on new phones, like the Pixel 6a. For $10 a month over 2 years, BUT you have to sign up for a more expensive plan for more gigabytes than most people need - an extra $22.50 a month making the real price of the phone $780. Having had to replace screens from time to time, replacement screens for the newest Pixels are in the $200 range. Pixel 4a's can be found in the $200-300 range and the replacement screens are reasonably priced. The mid range OnePlus phones have a number of disgruntled reviews - a shame because OP offers reasonably priced parts directly. Too bad Fairphone is unavailable in North America.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
Like many others have said this is not true. I've had a nexus 4 (2012-2017) which I had to change due to battery starting to swell, also had a custom rom which might have helped. I upgraded to a Pixel2 in 2017 which I still have. I'm even considering replacing the battery instead of the whole phone since it's still doing just fine otherwise. I really don't need a better camera so why bother with a new phone that doesn't offer much more than what I already have. Both of those phone are/were caseless too, just be careful with your stuff and you'll do just fine for a couple of years. In my opinion people choose to change their phone more than they have to change their phone.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
I agree with your comment. The camera was really impressive and it was first nexus phone where the camera outperformed an iPhone. But I think the video quality wasn’t that great when compared to iPhone. Mine started shutting down prematurely in Canadian winter after more than a year of use. But Google replaced mine for free even after the 1yr warranty expired. Ended up with Pixel 2 which had even better camera than Nexus 6P. The first iPhone to outperform Pixel 2 for low light was the iPhone 11. But during those times the video quality really sucked on both Nexus and Pixel, which it still does to the day.
Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
So, a speech-to-text and vice versa with a limited set of options, a website to buy domains from and "inovations", that you cannot buy yet, and might be cancelled before they ever come to consumer-ready completion? That doesn't sound like a lot. Google had an XMPP compatible chat client, that they killed of and revived with a new product every few years, so from gtalk, to wave, duo, alo, meet, chat, or whatever else it was called. Youtube stopped promoting independent producers, and is basically just a frontend to legacy media. Google apps was a great free tool for your own domain, but nope, not free anymore. Google maps started featuring ads everywhere and is a pain to try to find thing X with lidl logos everywhere. Google reader, great product, dead. Google cardboard... great, cheap VR "for the masses"... dead. Google fusion tables.. dead. Google search results are 50% pinterest, 50% unrelated. Google inbox, dead. The audio only chromecast.. dead. Google mytracks, great tool, killed by google (luckily an opensource replacement exists). Picasa. Google+ was a great idea... create bubbles, share stuff to only specific groups... too much forced integration everywhere, people hated it, dead. Google nexus/pixel phones were great in the nexus 4/5/5x era.. now they're expesive and "meh". Android privacy features are broken... no way to change unique ids, and most of the permissions are not granular enough, and people have been complaining for years about that. The only thing google…
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
Yep, I'm using a Pixel 2 with both DroidCamX and DroidCam OBS (with OBS' virtual camera), I can second that claim. I occasionally use a Nexus 6 on another setup, but it's a bit bulkier to mount and is a bit finicky with DroidCamX. It has froze up on me a couple times. The OBS version works fine, though. I'll chalk it up to not cleaning up the phone prior to repurposing it.
Google Nexus: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Neutral
The Nexus 5X was the perfect size phone in my opinion. I'm content with the Pixel 4a at the moment, but it is clearly too tall to use with one hand for me. I have to shimmy it up and down to reach the top and bottom. Which I suspect is the problem with almost every phone these days.
Google Nexus: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Neutral
I hated that my Pixel 3 had no headphone jack, I swore I'd never buy a phone without one, but when my Nexus 5X broke and I needed a phone, I got the Pixel 3. I didn't even realize it didn't have a headphone jack until I got it. It came with a USB-C->headphone dongle and then I discovered that USB->headphone dongles were cheap, so I bought one for each of the headphones I used regularly, and it was really not a big deal. But now I've switched almost fully to bluetooth headphones, except for my old expensive Etymotics that I use on airplanes since they are small and easy to pack, and the in-ear style is great at blocking noise.