The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Nexus 5X vs Google Pixel

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Google Pixel.

Google Nexus 5XGoogle Pixel
Owners with an opinion231968
Positive verdicts30% of 2356% of 1602
Positive/negative since 20242/3503/387
Happy after 3+ years054
Longest happy owner–10 yrs
Praised fordisplay and valuereliability and performance
Criticized forreliability and performancesoftware and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Nexus 5X: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
As an aside, I really liked my Google Nexus 5x, but it felt like basic quality control fell off a cliff for the Pixel line. Between Pixel 2/4/8 (yeah yeah what can I say I'm a masochist), I had problems with out-of-focus pictures, widely inaccurate GPS, and my absolute favorite making a call which would dial the number and then about a second later immediately hang up. I had a brief fling with using an iPhone but the speech-to-text dictation was absolute GARBAGE DAY and I make pretty heavy use of that feature while walking my dog.
Google Nexus 5X: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Also Google stuff always lacks SD card slots and have tiny storage. The $250 Motorola can add a $50 1 TB SD Card, which is enough to fit your entire music collection, all of wikipedia, and an offline ad-free routable map of the world from OSM, and still have probably like 700 GB left over for photos/videos. Google meanwhile charges $100 for a 128 GB storage upgrade. Probably because they want to funnel you into their cloud storage, want you to use their online maps/music services, etc. Phone cameras are also absolute trash anyway, and pulling up some comparisons in Google Photos right now, I'm fairly certain that my Pixel 6a takes obviously worse photos than my Nexus 5x did 10 years ago, even comparing high light for the 6a to low light for the 5x. I'll probably buy a Motorola when my current phone dies because the only ostensible reason to buy a Pixel is the camera. Or I suspect the real big-brained solution lives in the handheld gaming PC space.
Google Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
My own experience in the Android land, after making that jump from Nokia N900 to Nexus 4, is that you can get a new $CURRENT_GEN-1 (or -2) device for much much less while still having most of the performance/features . As such, I have never bought a then-current flagship. I have always kept my mobile plans (yes, multiple) separate from devices - I prefer the flexibility. With my story being: (N900 [USB port fell off!] ->) Nexus 4 [battery died] -> Nexus 5X [dropped it] -> Pixel [battery died on warranty, sent in] -> Pixel 2 [got as warranty replacement!] _and_ Pixel 3A [bought it]... I'm still very fine with the 3A thank you very much. In fact the only reasonable argument I've read for replacing a perfectly functional Android device is "when Google stops doing sec patches". Anyone here has any other good arguments for "replace before it's not functional"? (P.S. For "fun" I later replaced the battery and antenna in Nexus 4 - it still works today! And I keep Pixel 2 in the drawer as a hot backup. And yes, for both phones I do periodically turn them on, update and charge the battery.)
Google Nexus 5X: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Neutral
The Nexus 5X was the perfect size phone in my opinion. I'm content with the Pixel 4a at the moment, but it is clearly too tall to use with one hand for me. I have to shimmy it up and down to reach the top and bottom. Which I suspect is the problem with almost every phone these days.
Google Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Neutral
I hated that my Pixel 3 had no headphone jack, I swore I'd never buy a phone without one, but when my Nexus 5X broke and I needed a phone, I got the Pixel 3. I didn't even realize it didn't have a headphone jack until I got it. It came with a USB-C->headphone dongle and then I discovered that USB->headphone dongles were cheap, so I bought one for each of the headphones I used regularly, and it was really not a big deal. But now I've switched almost fully to bluetooth headphones, except for my old expensive Etymotics that I use on airplanes since they are small and easy to pack, and the in-ear style is great at blocking noise.
Google Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
Very similar to me, I went nexus 5 > 5x > pixel > pixel 2 after the 5/5x/p1 broke in different ways, but the Pixel 2 I used until it ran out of support and I was annoyed at having to replace a phone so quickly because it was fine for me, so I switched to a second hand iphone XS and it still works fine even though it's only 1 year older. I doubt I'll ever buy an iPhone brand new (I go out of my way not to support the CCP) but until Pinephone and linux becomes a usable mobile OS I'll stick with the XS until it either dies or Apple stop supporting it in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_iOS_and_iPadOS_devices 4 years or so? The iphone 6s was released in 2015 and it's still getting support, that's incredible.
Google Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
I was a Nexus/Pixel user for 10+ years. Majority of the phones I owned during that time had some quirks or issues. The worst examples were Nexus 5X and Pixel 5 – both just suddenly froze one day, shut down, and never turned back on again. After that Pixel 5 surprise I grudgingly switched to iPhone 12 mini. I still think Google’s Android UI is the best one out there for me, and I despise a lot in the iPhone UX (such as the keyboard) but I just need a phone that works and I can get repaired or replaced easily if I need to. At least in Finland, Google’s customer service has been abysmal over the years.
Google Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Dogfooding there was historically kind of a joke. I had severe issues with my Nexus hardware as a Googler and none of them ever got fixed. When they offered to give us all free Nexus phones as a Christmas gift one year I refused because I wasn't about to subject myself to another one. I'd wager money that dogfooders caught this issue and reported it, and nothing was done because it either fell through the cracks or wasn't reported enough to pass the "care about it" bar. Don't interpret this as a slam on the individual developers from the Android team, though. They're determined to fix stuff and some of them worked with me to troubleshoot issues. At the end of the day though it was organizational priorities preventing fixes, or high level decisions resulting in trainwrecks down the road. My favorite example is that the Nexus 5x phone I owned (bought out-of-pocket) had horrible thermal characteristics. The second-hand explanation I got was that late in the design process, they decided to put a fingerprint reader on the housing such that it sat directly on top of the main CPU package, and it turns out fingerprint readers don't work terribly well as heat sinks. The people who knew enough to protest about this decision were, it seems, overruled. I can attest that the stupid thing overheated constantly, causing the CPUs to throttle. I had to stop using the official (also purchased from Google) case because the case further impaired heat dissipation. That was my second Google hand…
Google Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
iPhone 6s (released September 2015) - ~ 8 years and going Nexus 5X & Nexus 6P (released September 2015) - last update January 2019 [1] ~ 2.25 years Pixel & Pixel XL (released October 2016) - 2019 (can't find a good reference) ~ 3 years Pixel 2 (released October 2017) - December 2020 [2] ~ 3.3 years [1]: https://9to5google.com/2018/11/07/nexus-6p-and-5x-final-guar... [2]: https://www.androidpolice.com/2020/10/05/pixel-2-and-2-xl-re... My conclusion: an iPhone outlives (at least) 2+/3+ android phones
Google Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
> I've owned many of the nexus and pixel phones, never had a problem. I've had 2 Nexus 5x and a Pixel 3a before switching to an iPhone. I can't believe the amount of bullshit I coped up with because I didn't know better. Both Nexus died because of a well known boot loop issue that was never truly acknowledged by Google (support ghosted me twice). The Pixel died because the socket kinda broke and I couldn't charge it anymore. All 3 phones became awfully slow after roughly one year of use. In comparison I switched to an iPhone 2 years ago and it really is good as new: it doesn't feel slower, every single hardware or software feature works great, it's still a first class citizen when it comes to OS updates. As it goes I easily plan to keep it at least 2 to 3 more years. I've never kept an Android phone more than 2 years. To be fair though the Nexus and Pixel were low end devices. Maybe my experience would have been better with higher end Androids.
Google Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
I wouldn't be surprised if the people doing product reviews managed to not hit this scenario often enough for it to show up in a review. The average reviewer may not be running special software to figure out what their signal level and mode are when outdoors. Could also be specific to the type of modem being used or specific frequency band for the article author (who is in France, I think?) vs reviewers who might be in the US or UK or etc. Personally I've had very bad experiences with quality control on Google phone handsets. Every single one I've owned had various problems that wouldn't make it past QC at other manufacturers - like a broken proximity sensor on the Pixel 4 I got for work, improper cooling on the nexus 5X I bought while working at google (constantly thermal throttled), and a nexus 4 I bought that had a bad internal flash drive that failed a week after I set it up (RIP my 2fa codes).
Google Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Google mobile hardware has a long history of shoddiness. It absolutely shines in the components useful to marketing and completely falls down in the ones which aren't. The Nexus 4 had screen tint issues and a defective speaker that emitted a high pitched buzzing noise. The Nexus 5 overheated often and sometimes the camera just stopped connecting. The Nexus 5X had boot loop issues so bad there was a class action lawsuit. The Nexus 6P had the same boot loop issues as well as faulty battery sensors and poorly-designed frame that bent and snapped in the middle. Pixel 1 had faulty microphones that Google knew about and still sold, resulting in another class action lawsuit. The Pixel 2 emitted weird clicking and scratching noises from its speaker at all times. The Pixel 2 XL had a godawful POLED display with colors so uneven it looked like someone stomped on the panels before installing them. Oh and both their USB-C ports would spontaneously break and prevent charging the phone. Pixel 3XL included two wildly disparate speakers with no way to balance them, so the audio always feels like it's coming from one side. Trust me, some wild-ass Pixel 6 hardware fault will emerge in the next twelve months.