The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Nexus 5 vs Google Pixel

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Google Pixel.

Google Nexus 5Google Pixel
Owners with an opinion691968
Positive verdicts57% of 6056% of 1602
Positive/negative since 202410/9503/387
Happy after 3+ years154
Longest happy owner5 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forreliability and batterysoftware and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Nexus 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Neutral
There's a line to toe - each kid is different, but with my daughter she went from a flip phone in middle school, to a smart phone in high school. We didn't turn on mobile data for her smart phone (hand me down pixel) until about a year ago. She is very responsible with it and it hasn't been much of an issue. She had no problems making friends, and if her phone was filtering shallow people out her friend pool a bit that probably wasn't a bad thing. Now, my oldest son is dying to have a smartphone but really he just wants to use it as a tablet. I installed lineageOS on an old D821/Nexus5 and it can run some mobile games, and we have a chromebook. We'll try the same flip phone in middle-school route. It fulfills the basic needs of emergency contact, and is a good test of responsibility with lower stakes.
Google Nexus 5: NeutralGoogle Pixel: Likes it
I'm about to retire one Nexus 5 from phone duty (the other I'm using as a dashcam) only because I'll need to have VOLTE when visiting the US from Canada. Carriers offer "deals" on new phones, like the Pixel 6a. For $10 a month over 2 years, BUT you have to sign up for a more expensive plan for more gigabytes than most people need - an extra $22.50 a month making the real price of the phone $780. Having had to replace screens from time to time, replacement screens for the newest Pixels are in the $200 range. Pixel 4a's can be found in the $200-300 range and the replacement screens are reasonably priced. The mid range OnePlus phones have a number of disgruntled reviews - a shame because OP offers reasonably priced parts directly. Too bad Fairphone is unavailable in North America.
Google Nexus 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
Very similar to me, I went nexus 5 > 5x > pixel > pixel 2 after the 5/5x/p1 broke in different ways, but the Pixel 2 I used until it ran out of support and I was annoyed at having to replace a phone so quickly because it was fine for me, so I switched to a second hand iphone XS and it still works fine even though it's only 1 year older. I doubt I'll ever buy an iPhone brand new (I go out of my way not to support the CCP) but until Pinephone and linux becomes a usable mobile OS I'll stick with the XS until it either dies or Apple stop supporting it in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_iOS_and_iPadOS_devices 4 years or so? The iphone 6s was released in 2015 and it's still getting support, that's incredible.
Google Nexus 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Watch a jogger jogging, and try to take a photo each time their foot hits the ground (so about 1.5 Hz). Within 10 seconds you'll find the camera crashes and/or starts throwing away photos you already took. Try it on battery saver mode or while playing music for even more bugginess. Tested this on: Nexus 4, Nexus 5, Nexus 6P, Pixel 1, Pixel 5, Pixel 7.
Google Nexus 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Galaxy nexus, while plastic, was still very nice phone. Nexus 5 had already quality issues. Pixels went downhill completely, while simultaneously bumping up the price.
Google Nexus 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
My thought when I read it as well. I've owned Nexus 4, 5, 6, Pixel 1, 2, 3, 4 and finally gave up. Half of these phones were purchased because the previous model crapped out. I am not a heavy phone user either. I think I stuck with them because there was always some integration with Google and iPhone that didn't make me happy, but whatever it is must have been solved by the time I got an iPhone because I'm on three years with mine. Probably won't replace it for another three years.
Google Nexus 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
They also don't give enough polish to their products. For example, the Nexus 5 (2013!) had a bug - if you took 7 photos in quick succession, it wouldn't save photo 3 and 4. For example, you're photographing someone doing a dance, and you want a photo on each beat, so you tap the shutter to the beat of the music. On a 2022 Pixel 7, 10 years on...... The exact same bug.
Google Nexus 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
That's funny since the Pixel 6 has had so many people complaining about various bugs. Google has no quality consistency both with SW and HW, it's all hit and miss with their Pixel range. Some turned out great, some were abasically e-waste. IMHO they peaked with the Nexus 5 and then went downhill after that. Then current Pixel 7 seems to be an exception.
Google Nexus 5: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
My wife and I loved ours, but both bootloop suicided at the 13 and 15 month mark. _Both_. Out of warranty by 1 and 2 months. That was my official departure from Android (which I otherwise loved). I've never had a problem with the 6 iPhones I have owned (3 before, 3 after) -- but ironically my Wife's second iPhone after _also_ suicided. She somehow negotiated a free replacement 6 months out of warranty, so iPhone still came out ahead. I had a pretty good experience with the Nexus 5 (my favorite for its time) and the Pixel 2 (not my favorite form factor, otherwise great). Both make great phones but having a popular phone has a really killer feature where it works out a lot of bugs. Not perfect, but I think if iPhones had the same level of issue as the Nexus 6 there'd be an extended warranty or something comparable.
Google Nexus 5: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Google mobile hardware has a long history of shoddiness. It absolutely shines in the components useful to marketing and completely falls down in the ones which aren't. The Nexus 4 had screen tint issues and a defective speaker that emitted a high pitched buzzing noise. The Nexus 5 overheated often and sometimes the camera just stopped connecting. The Nexus 5X had boot loop issues so bad there was a class action lawsuit. The Nexus 6P had the same boot loop issues as well as faulty battery sensors and poorly-designed frame that bent and snapped in the middle. Pixel 1 had faulty microphones that Google knew about and still sold, resulting in another class action lawsuit. The Pixel 2 emitted weird clicking and scratching noises from its speaker at all times. The Pixel 2 XL had a godawful POLED display with colors so uneven it looked like someone stomped on the panels before installing them. Oh and both their USB-C ports would spontaneously break and prevent charging the phone. Pixel 3XL included two wildly disparate speakers with no way to balance them, so the audio always feels like it's coming from one side. Trust me, some wild-ass Pixel 6 hardware fault will emerge in the next twelve months.