The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Framework Laptop vs System76

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Framework Laptop.

Framework LaptopSystem76
Owners with an opinion751312
Positive verdicts71% of 66169% of 280
Positive/negative since 2024309/13949/23
Happy after 3+ years2433
Longest happy owner5 yrs20 yrs
Praised forrepairability and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbattery and build qualitybuild quality and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Framework Laptop: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
(Lenovo) Thinkpads, specifically many of the X, T and P products, are best in class. All the Linux things just work at this point, and have for the last 5-10 years. Some products ship with Fedora or Ubuntu. Those lines have the highest end individual products with the best build quality, and user-serviceable/replaceable components. Other Lenovo laptops are either less good or much less good/absolute crap. I have several Framework laptops, to be supportive of alternative supply chains. They are great with Linux compatibility, all the things work, but in terms of build, they are much less mature from a long term maturity and tolerances perspective. The new 13 Pro is probably a pretty solid machine, though. I occasionally have to work on Dells or HPs for clients, and just don't like the keyboards or the fit/finish. I had a couple of earlier system 76 machines, they did not last and the keyboards also were not comparable to a Thinkpad.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Neutral
Adding to the review thread: I bought a Framework 13 in 2021. I'm sold on the ideal, I really like the chassis and the keyboard, and I _love_ the screen ratio. I replaced several parts and own every type of connector. I really liked my 13! I just had my mainboard die, and I was advised there currently isn't another mainboard in stock that works with my old DDR4 RAM. They don't have any newer DDR5 RAM in stock apparently either, so I was out of luck and ended up buying a Lemur Pro last week. In my experience, the Framework hardware is great but very flakey and frequently needs replacing. Support is awful; they'll repeatedly ask you to do things you've already done (and shown proof of), they can take days to get back to you, and are generally unhelpful. They also didn't think to mention to me when I said I needed to buy a new laptop and their parts were all out of stock that they had a new machine coming out in the next week, which is insane to me. I would've been an easy convert. Sometimes I think it's bots doing the support, but if that was the case, they'd reply back faster. Time will tell whether I'll return back to the ecosystem, but the support experience (and the hardware being poor enough that I frequently need support) is putting me off for now.
Framework Laptop: Likes itSystem76: Recommends it
>i'm caving for a world where hw manufacturers exist who fully embrace opensource development, Those do very much exist! My go-to is System76. There are others, e.g. arguably Framework. > and are rewarded for that... Oh well, one can dream anyway. The freedom Linux gives you also gives you the freedom to slap Linux on some random bit of Windows kit and then blame Linux for failing to work around the broken firmware. Apparently this is preferable to buying hardware that works with Linux.
Framework Laptop: Recommends itSystem76: Likes it
In my experience, Linux works quite well on laptops that are intended to run it. I’ve only tried the System 76 Lemur Pro and the Framework 13, both of which worked smoothly. The Framework has better build quality, and I can wholeheartedly recommend it to anyone who wants to try a Linux laptop.
Framework Laptop: Recommends itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
Maybe take another look at frameworks, they are by far some of the best laptops out there for computer people imo. Other than that, steer clear of system76. I've only bought one laptop from them a few years ago, but the build quality was astoundingly bad and after a year of use the battery couldn't last more than a couple hours.
Framework Laptop: NeutralSystem76: Likes it
That is a worry I have, but on the other hand, more pro RTR brands out there is more opportunities to win over customers. I had a galago ultrapro 10 years ago. Loved it, loved system 76's support for it (they shipped everyone a replacement keyboard at no cost simply because they weren't happy with the one it launched with). The only part I didn't like was the plastic body which saw a lot of wear and tear. But the laptop is still working fine. Now I have a framework. The first touchpad on mine had issues. Wasn't registering clicks unless I pressed really hard. They shipped me a replacement, I swapped it out myself and shipped them back the defective one at no cost to me. I wish both companies the best, but yeah I do hope there is enough business out there for them both.
Framework Laptop: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I think it's the laptop a lot of people have been looking for for a while. I've got one, think it's a great laptop, and prefer both the layout and philosophy of openness to my work Macbook. Macs are walled gardens, ThinkPads are attached to Lenovo, "developer" HPs and Dells have problems, System76s are rebranded generics (not that that's a bad thing, but it's not as carefully designed); Framework comes in as a new company who hasn't made bad decisions yet, has made an acceptable laptop (some things like full size arrow keys can wait a bit), and keeps showing through their actions their commitment to openness and owning your own computer. The expansion cards are a great solution too. The only real problem I have with it is the battery life, which I think even the most enthusiastic proponent will point out
Framework Laptop: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
If this helps ... Framework have refurb models which are extremely reasonably priced. Personally I tried the System76 but I found the keyboard layout obnoxious. I'm not sure it was all models, but the one I picked up was unusable for me, coming from a mac. They tried to shove everything on the keyboard, like num pad, which wasn't necessary IMHO. Not sure if it was just a bad pick, or every model.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
Aren't all laptops that aren't macs easily repairable? RAM, SSD, battery, keyboard(but in many laptops the whole top panel has to be replaced), track pad, wifi card, display(framework has the better way only over here). I mean buying a tongfang OR a system 76 is a way better option than going for framework due to its QR codes I don't understand why. I'm not shitting on framework this is just what I've been wanting to ask for so long
Framework Laptop: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
First, "no linux support" is disingenuous. Second, with a Framework you can replace a USB-c port with a 1TB expansion card, or with an Ethernet port, or whatever is in stock. Those who bought the first model can now upgrade to a next-gen processor and/or reinforced lid, without throwing the whole laptop away. While System76 has surprisingly lower prices than I expected, it does not appear to have similar features--you still have to replace the entire system whenever your Pangolin becomes obsolete in 3 years. Framework was always more about sustainability. They didn't anticipate the demand for Linux/FOSS stuff, but they're adjusting for that. Hopefully some future motherboard will have Coreboot, and I can buy that motherboard and pop it in my laptop.
Framework Laptop: Likes itSystem76: Neutral
I also used to always run ThinkPads (and Precision workstations with pointing sticks). I these days run a System76 Lemur Pro with a USB thinkpad keyboard I stick on top. The built-in keyboard is good, but trackpads and I have never gotten along. They've come a long way. Another option that friend got was the Frame Work. I helped him assemble it, and it also is a great GNU/Linux machine. Everything just works.
Switched from the System76 to the Framework LaptopFramework Laptop: Likes it
It looks like the author has hit some pretty serious snags along the way and is a lot more understanding than I might be under similar circumstances. My experience, having just bought a framework 13 with AMD internals a couple of months ago (and letting them build it for me), has been a purely flawless one with ubuntu 24.04. Everything just works and I love being able to swap the ports and the ethernet adapter as needed. The fan rarely makes a sound at all and it's blazing fast compared to the similarly spec'd system 76 darter pro it replaced (though it was a few years old). Battery life is "fine" but not amazing but charging is pretty quick, so it's still a bit of an improvement over the darter.
Framework Laptop: Likes itSystem76: Likes it
I had a fujitsu lifebook that was 10 years old when I bought it and it lasted another 8 or so after that. I'd maxxed out the ram to 8GB, replaced the missing stylus and bought a new battery. It had a fantastic display that was brighter and had a wider viewing angle than the system76 gazelle I replaced it with. And the swivel hinge connector was soo solid. I now have a framework 13 that I'd rate slightly higher than that fujitsu (it's lighter and the changeable ports thing is a truly wonderful idea), but it's a bit of a toss-up.
Framework Laptop: Recommends itSystem76: Recommends it
Your best bet is to get a brand that is well known to run Linux if you want it bad enough to get a new laptop. Dell business line, lenovo thinkpad, framework, system76 are all good platforms. If it's not working on your old laptop it's probably only one or two drivers, and you should probably try running with debian, endeavour, ubuntu and a few flavors that might have the driver you need working.
Framework Laptop: NeutralSystem76: Neutral
I am a satisfied Apple user, and have been for over 30 years. I have never contacted Apple support. Not once. Yes, really. Unfounded claims are unfounded. Sometimes devices break, sometimes they last for 20 years and keep on humming. Also for the record, I'm also a Linux, Windows, and FreeBSD user running on HP, Dell, Lenovo, SuperMicro, Framework, System76 and DIY machines. My experience indicates premium components usually (but not always) last longer than more economical alternatives. That said, if I never had to use a Microsoft product again, I'd be fine with that.
Framework Laptop: Recommends itSystem76: Recommends it
Who said I'm shilling for System76? If I'm buying a new laptop today, its gonna be a Framework. If I need to recommend something more inexpensive and casual, System76 exists, but I'd only recommend that to people have yet to fix their flawed thinking and think they don't want a Framework.