The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Framework Laptop vs Lenovo ThinkPad X1

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Framework LaptopLenovo ThinkPad X1
Owners with an opinion751376
Positive verdicts71% of 66171% of 335
Positive/negative since 2024309/13998/57
Happy after 3+ years2428
Longest happy owner5 yrs11 yrs
Praised forrepairability and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbattery and build qualitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Framework Laptop: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
I went for a similar upgrade from X1 Carbon. I don't undestand why OP would compare the weight of a 16 to carbon which is closer to framework 13 (which I bought). For me on Arch it's working great and has none of the issues he mentions, its the best laptop I ever owned. I bought one because the Carbon started decomposing fairly quickly (headphone jack, usb c port, keys) and think the modularity is a really great feature.
Framework Laptop: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
I have two Framework 13 DIY, top of the line (Ryzen AI 9 HX 370, 96 GB of RAM, 2TB WD BLACK SN850X). Well, TBH just one, the other one was stolen with less than one month, but that's a different story. Can't be happier with this choice. First of all, now I feel confident I can easily tinker with my laptop, open it and replace any components. No, I'm not repeating their Marketing, I'm truly confident now. Some months ago my previous Lenovo X1 Carbon stopped charging and I was scared as hell. Sure, I have everything in version control and cloud drives blah blah blah but if it doesn't charge, it's dead. Sure, I can extract the NVMe (is it easy at all?) and rsync the data (for a faster recovery) but is that easy, feasible, can I do it on the go (X1 stopped charging while I was on a trip). The Framework 13 DIY I built it in less than 10 minutes. I can easily disassemble again in a heartbeat. This is priceless. Other than this, build quality is higher than expected, and several other people said exactly the same when I showed my unit. Powerful? Most than any desktop out there. Perfectly portable. Works well OOB with Linux. What else do I need? Nothing, it's my laptop and will be the next one. (Actually the next one may be cheaper, as I may only need to replace the motherboard, we will see)
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
For a good laptop it wouldn't be too bad, i.e. my X1 Carbon cost me about the same back in 2019 if I remember correctly. But it's ultimately about the price/quality trade-off, and this is where I feel Framework has some work to do, at least with the 16 inch model.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
My Thinkpad X1 Carbon (gen 5) running linux can suspend for weeks without dying. There was definitely a window where battery life under suspending wasn't a huge problem in Linux, not sure what happened. I also have a Framework 13 (11th gen intel) which has terrible suspend battery life (also loses 2-3%/hour like the newer AMD version)– I was hoping that the AMD chips would fare better, but it seems not.
Framework Laptop: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Neutral
I love my Framework AMD 13. Coming from an old Thinkpad X1 Carbon gen 3 I got used after a few years. Excellent form factor and oh so repairable. I’ve been very satisfied with the purchase. I’m really rooting for Framework over the next decade to really establish themselves and hopefully affect some change in laptop repairability. And hell, even if they don’t, hopefully they’ll be around so I can continue to be a customer.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
Deepest apologies; I meant to say grille. Regardless of the flow direction, I am constantly blocking the aperture with my legs or blanket. The touchpad frequently misidentifies movement as taps, something that hasn't been a problem for me on the Macbook Pro, the X1 Carbon, or the Microsoft Surface. The keyboard keys aren't too bad, but could have a sharper inflection point in the force vs travel and also be little bit less wobbly. Neither of these are fatal flaws, but are enough, I think, to call them mediocre. Do you also find that the computer forgets its DDR5 training pretty regularly and takes a long time to boot? For me I think it's ~1-in-10 boots.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
Tbh, if I could put the framework's AMD motherboard in my T470, that'd be amazing. I love the thinkpad keyboard, I enjoy the X1E glass touchpad, the T14 Gen2 screen is amazing, my battery life is 13h of work in IDEA, and I got all of it combined for less than 600$. But I really dislike the hardware of the framework :/
Framework Laptop: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1: Recommends it
I own both a Framework and a Thinkpad X1 Carbon Gen 10. I bought them both a few months ago, and I've been using the Thinkpad X1 Carbon line for years. Between the two of these, it's the Thinkpad hands down that I'd rather use. It's designed for Linux and has thousands of hours more R&D put into it. I really love what the Framework folks are doing, but their laptop feels like a Raspberry Pi when stacked against a Thinkpad. Hobbyist, toyish. It's going to need a lot more work to feel comparable. A higher budget, more premium option would be great too.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I'm writing this with buyer's remorse on my Framework. It's a huge step down from my previous Thinkpads. The battery life is atrocious - a night in modern standby drains the battery from 80% to 35%. Outside the office battery life is a constant worry, I mostly use it docked these days. The display hinge is wobbly - when I lift my Framework from my lap on a table it often folds back 180 degrees. Very annoying. In general it feels less durable than my old Thinkpad X1. Linux support is better than on most laptops and worse than on Thinkpads, e.g. no BIOS upgrades out of the box (only beta firmwares for months). Additionally, I experience rare kernel loops, sometimes the laptop doesn't shut off properly etc. Overall Thinkpads seem to be more stable.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 to the Framework LaptopFramework Laptop: Likes it
Disagree. I switched to Framework from a Thinkpad X1, I've actually been very impressed by the quality - feels super sturdy, keyboard is a significant improvement, it's great.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 to the Framework LaptopFramework Laptop: Recommends it
I replaced my previous Thinkpad X1 carbon with a Framework 12th gen recently - vast improvement, runs Linux better than any other laptop I've ever used, I love using it, and I _love_ how repairable & upgradeable it is. Highly recommended.
Framework Laptop: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I've had a Framework 13 for nearly a year, been very happy with it, I've taken it on international work trips but it mostly sits on my desk with external displays attached. I ran Windows on it until I switched jobs, now its Ubuntu. I also have an X1 Nano, which I love too, its the around-the-house laptop and a great little machine but whenever it dies, if I replace it at all, it will likely be with another Framework (perhaps the 12") The real test will be in 2-3 years when I'm itching for an upgrade, assuming Framework is still around, I'll be able to swap out the MoBo and leave everything else as-is. We'll see.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
Link to the one that's so great, especially a Macbook contender? He has a $2000+ Thinkpad X1 and it was basically his least favorite one in his lineup from last week except for the Framework's bad display: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M96O0Sn1LXA The snark doesn't seem warranted. Edit: The laptop you're talking about is also 14" 1920x1200 or am I lost in Lenovo's awful website? A 14" Macbook is 3024x1964. The more I look, the worse it gets, especially after you hyped it like that.