The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Framework Laptop vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Framework LaptopLenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion7512732
Positive verdicts71% of 66175% of 2366
Positive/negative since 2024309/139686/273
Happy after 3+ years24281
Longest happy owner5 yrs25 yrs
Praised forrepairability and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbattery and build qualitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Framework Laptop: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I would rather have a Framework 13 Pro where I could choose 4 ports of my choosing and swap them out at will. (That’s my current machine, sold my M2 MacBook Pro for it). I would rather have a ThinkPad X9 15p Aura Edition, which has 3x thunderbolt, SD Card, HDMI, and USB-A, all at the same time with no dongle.
Framework Laptop: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I've had Dell XPSs and Lenovo Thinkpads exclusively prior to Framework, and they all died by component failure. Sure, Dell will send a technician to your house and Lenovo has off-shore call centers, but the end result is the same: either buy an eye-wateringly expensive warranty that won't cover most failures or buy a new laptop. While I'm all for stronger consumer regulation when it comes to this stuff, on balance I prefer the Framework approach here relative to the other options available to me.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
the conclusion section is a pretty damning and disappointing read. i'm realizing that framework's marketing swayed my opinion a lot more than i thought. i was seriously considering a framework laptop when my current one dies, but i'll probably just end up going with a thinkpad again, as the level of serviceability seems a lot closer to equal than i was lead to believe, and apparently there is no "feel good" advantage of buying framework.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Well, if Apple killed it, Lenovo killed it even more. I recently was looking for a laptop for a student. The Lenovo E14 Gen7 is 800 Euros here in Germany (where prices are always higher, the MacBook Neo is 700 Euros), it has 16GB of RAM, 1TB SSD, a 2.8k IPS display, a Intel Ultra5 12core CPU, and it has a repairability score of 9/10 from ifixit. Framework doesn't even come close to that package.
Framework Laptop: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
It's so ironic. I've had several Thinkpads over the years and I've repaired or upgraded every one of them, from RAM, SSDs, an upgraded screen, and a new fan/heatsink assembly. I have a first generation Framework 13 and I've yet to upgrade it. And by now this new Pro model has an upgrade for every component. If it weren't for crazy prices, I'd just buy a whole new laptop. At least I have the option of that CoolerMaster case. But maybe it'd be best to just sell the whole thing.
Framework Laptop: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I switch from ThinkPad to Framework because they couldn't send me a replacement keyboard. They want me to send the keyboard back to get a refund but I never receive it so... I never did get a refund. Later, Framework send me a laptop in 1 week and later a replacement screen in less then a week. It's been 3 years ago now.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
I used my ThinkPad T430s for 12 years. I got it second hand from a developer I looked up to when I was in college and it carried me through a large part of my career. Loved that machine to death. When I finally replaced it with a Framework a few years back I've regretted every second of it. The ThinkPad still lives. I refurbished the batteries and slapped ChromeOS Flex on it and donated it to a Ukrainian refugee who needed a Chromebook for school. It'll probably live another 10 years. I loved that thing to death. And I'm just happy it is still being used.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I also find the lack of ports in a Framework frustrating. My Thinkpad has USB-A USB-A USB-A USB-C HDMI Ethernet SD Charging and a Framework has only half of that. Most of these are used at least once per day. I'm hoping for third party chassis offerings to solve this.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I won a max spec Framework 13 at a hacking tournament a few months ago and use it as my daily driver now. I'm very happy with it. The 13 is much more clean than the 16. Framework 16 still feels like a bit of a beta product. That being said, I probably would have gone with a Thinkpad if it had been my own money. The peicing is just really steep.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I have the similar ThinkPad like the author, except Gen 3, I7, 16Gb. Have Omarchy on it, works like a charm, even camera is not bad. Battery works but I can plug it in the same dock my macbook is (two usb-c dock). While you can change keyboard or battery on your Thinkpad, they are cheap enough, around $500 that you can just get a new one. I get why he wanted Framework, they say 13" are much better and more useful deal then 16". I wish Framework 12" is better, but it is not. Maybe Apple can dazzle us at this form factor.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
You've got a 16 inch Laptop, why are the arrow keys so tiny! And where's the PgUp PgDn Home End Insert Delete cluster? I wish a design-based shop like Framework would have some leadership in the keyboard area. This is why I have been exclusively Thinkpads for my last 3 laptops. Something more niche is that I also enjoy the mouse buttons above the trackpad, I can move with the thumb and click with a finger.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
All true. My previous laptop was a 2014 MBP, and the two basically feel the same. I’d say the MBP’s layout is marginally worse because of the stupid power key and the half-size left and right arrows, and of course the MBP’s construction makes your life hell if you spill liquid on the keyboard and need to replace it. (Framework’s prohibition on freight forwarding makes my life difficult in the same situation, but that’s a me problem—I should have taken the hint that I wasn’t wanted when I was jumping through hoops to buy it in the first place.) It’s not a bad keyboard. As far as laptops of the last decade go, it’s even a good one. But the up/down arrows sucked on the MBP and they (though not left/right) suck on the FW13, I expect(?) because a rectangular keyboard ends up cheaper than one with protruding arrows. Furthermore, my (grandparent) comment was about how vertical shrinkage made the keyboard smaller but the FW13’s taller screen didn’t restore the missing keys, and if half-size up/down arrows just suck to use, Home/End/PgUp/PgDn hidden behind Fn suck to a Pavlovian extent: I didn’t realize how much the MBP trained me out of using them before I had to use an older ThinkPad for a bit that had them on separate keys. I won’t even mention Ctrl-Break except to look in its direction wistfully. Finally, the Copilot key is of course a distraction. I don’t know what it actually sends on those keyboards, but if I can map that to Compose I couldn’t care less about what’s drawn on it…
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Yeah, the price is the only thing that holds me back from trying a Framework 13. I have a few Thinkpad X260s which can be got on eBay for $100US. Drop in a fresh SSD and stick of 16gb memory for another $100US and you have a very capable little machine for common, daily use that suits all my needs more than adequately. If one gets damaged, I am not out too much money. I've been using two for about 4 years now, one as my daily driver at home and one that goes on the road with me. I have not needed to further upgrade either one beyond what I did initially when buying* them. So, with that in mind, I think use-case has a lot to do with whether or not someone can get away with running the more disposable cheap-but-good Thinkpad like I do. But >$800US for a Framework 13 that bends like a reed in the wind is not a smart choice for me. I really like their ethos of modularity, too, but there's just no way I'm hitting that cost anytime soon. *Note on buying Thinkpad from eBay: yes, collectors have ruined the price of some models, but not all. Lots of the X Series models are still very cheap, but please do not support sellers who are offering cheap laptops without a battery and power cable. Be patient and dig, you'll find the ones who are selling you a complete, useable machine for cheap. Unfortunately, eBay is flooded with a lot of vulture tech resellers that part perfectly good batteries from devices so they can make more money selling you both separately.
Framework Laptop: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I used to do this, I have "retro modded" Thinkpads. I keep one still running (X61p) to use as a car computer. I've since switched everything I do that isn't on my Macbook to a Framework 13 AMD. The Framework 13, other than the case design being flimsier plastic vs magnesium alloy, is better at everything a new Thinkpad does than a new Thinkpad, and is roughly equivalent to an old with modern specs. As much as I wish that Lenovo would make a modern equivalent to the X60/X61, that's never happening, so Framework 13 is the best choice right now.
Framework Laptop: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Framework laptops aren't really repairable in the same way that old Thinkpads are. Maybe that's good, maybe not, but replacing an entire motherboard every 3 years isn't all that different from replacing an entire computer really.
Framework Laptop: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
> docked operation (TB4 dock) maybe Linux but could also be specific to the Dock, many docks are not tested against standards but just Windows and/or Macs and sometimes just one of them, too. > I have a long history with ThinkPads and never ran into problems with them. I have a long history with them too, but I did ran into problems in more recent (T440, T480s) models. E.g. their USB-C charging ports are _very_ prone to breaking when there are frequent slight amounts of up/down force and there are only two and you need one working for charging to work. I have "bricked" one laptop this way and the only way to repair it is to go to a repair shop which can solder replacement ports on it... Not an issue I ran into with the framework the USB-C ports didn't break due to wear (yet) and even if they did they are trivial to replace (as you just replace the expansion card they are on).
Framework Laptop: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I have experimented with a Thinkpad T14s and Framework 13 AMD during the past year. Running Linux. I think the Framework is a much more solid machine. The quality of the hardware feels higher to me and I like the screen ratio more. The keyboard feels even better than my Macbook Air M2's. I would recommend it for Linux use at least. I don't know about Windows. If something closer to the hardware quality of Macbooks came along, I'd switch immediately, but there doesn't seem to be such a thing. Of course, I don't have the resources to try everything out there.
Framework Laptop: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Could you recommend a thinkpad model you feel is built like a tank? I bought a used t540p 5 years ago and it's been the crappiest laptop I've ever used. Terrible display with about 15deg of visibility. Flimsy plastic parts that broke in multiple places during replacements. Display randomly got damaged while in my bag, keys constantly falling off, even after fully replacing the kb when keys just stopped functioning, worst trackpad ever, RAM just started failing. Honestly the framework is practically macbook-quality in comparison to a used thinkpad IME but maybe I'm looking at the wrong series or era?