The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Watches and wearables

Fitbit vs Garmin

Hacker News owners lean toward the Garmin.

FitbitGarmin
Owners with an opinion199834
Positive verdicts52% of 16077% of 713
Positive/negative since 202433/38346/122
Happy after 3+ years531
Longest happy owner10 yrs15 yrs
Praised forease of use and batterybattery and ease of use
Criticized forreliability and softwaresoftware and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Fitbit: NeutralGarmin: Doesn’t like it
I've looked at Garmin, because I have the fitbit sense 2 and was looking for something with a reasonable battery life. However, I think Garmin has made the flaw of overcomplicating their product offerings. I ended up pre-ordering a pebble because I implicitly don't like a company that tries to segment their market that hard on smart watches.
Fitbit: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Recommends it
I have a Garmin Forerunner 255 (which does everything you requested and much much more). I used to be a Fitbit guy, and the sleep tracking and data is 10x better than Fitbit, with no subscription. The battery life is about 20 days. The Forerunner 255 can be found on Amazon right now for $250. Mind you, I also used to own an Apple Watch. Garmin is the best, and second place isn't close.
Fitbit: NeutralGarmin: Likes it
There's really only 2 features my garmin forerunner lacks that would make it pretty awesome. 1. LTE connectivity. Being able to take calls, get texts, send out live track notifications from my watch would be really fantastic. I take my phone out on runs not because I want to use my phone, but because that's the only way I can do all that stuff. 2. Paired with LTE connectivity, music/podcast streaming. My watch supports downloading playlists before a run which is nice but (frankly) a bit clunky. I really want to just be able to kick off yt music or spotify and instead. But honestly, if I had to give up my other features like long battery life to get either of those two then I'm good just not having them. I had fitbit watches before my garmin and I love the garmin ecosystem. My wife has a pixel watch and really the two features above are the only things it does that I'd want from it.
Fitbit: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Likes it
I just got my first Garmin Watch (Venu 3) in December for Xmas. So far I'm enjoying it. I'm happy to see the company knows how to survive because my last few smart watches didn't fare so well, not exactly from market changes, but from acquisitions. I had the original Pebble and Pebble 2. Loved them. Then one day Pebble was just shut down because of an acquisition by Fibit[1]. There was a group of people that started Rebble[2] to restore web services and support the watch but I was not interested so I switched over to Fitbit. I had the Fitbit Versa 2 and Versa 3 watches and for a while they were great. Then Google bought Fitbit[3]. The impending "Killed by Google" was always in the back of mind, especially since they already sold smart watches. But I have been on Pixel phones for a while now and I thought maybe Google buying them would lead to good things. At first not much changed, but eventually I started having issues with the watch (more info about that below) and I got fed up with it and now I have a Garmin Watch. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pebble_(watch)#Closing_of_Pebb... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pebble_(watch)#Rebble [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fitbit#Google's_acquisition The issues I was having with my Versa 3: Daily I would notice I had missed a sms notification and realize that my watch was disconnected from my phone. I had to go in and manually reconnect it. I also had issues using the voice command feature. I used to be able to use my G…
Fitbit: Recommends itGarmin: Doesn’t like it
I have been trying to get in better shape and lose some weight over the past six months, and what helped me a lot was getting a Fitbit and having a minimum number of “zone minutes” per weekday. I started off at just 22, but I increased it a few minutes every month. Most days I end up doing more than that, but that’s the absolute minimum, but I’ve hit it every weekday for six months excepting a week where I was sick. I do different things different days, so it’s nice to have a consistent metric across all activities that I’m shooting for. I recently switched to a Garmin watch for a number of reasons, and you can make it track these in this way if you do some customization, but unfortunately the defaults out of the box don’t really support what I got from the Fitbit. I’d really recommend a Fitbit, focusing on zone minutes for anyone getting started on getting in shape.
Fitbit: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Likes it
Having gone through 5 different fitbit watches and them all breaking within a year or two, as well as two different fitbit scales and them breaking too, i have moved on and will NEVER look back. Fitbit is CRAP. let me reiterate. crap. C-R-A-P. crap. Lets use that in a sentence. Mark grumbled, "My Fitbit is such crap—it breaks down faster than I can count my steps!" And for those wondering, I moved onto Garmin watches. I mean if you're going to pay it might as well be a nice one and most importantly one that is reliable.
Fitbit: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Likes it
> Fitbit Ace LTE has been tested with hundreds of families and is designed to get 16+ hours of use from a full battery. Fail. Adults struggle to recharge their devices every day and my kids certainly won't remember to. Garmin Kids watches, while drastically different in functionality and connectivity, last 12 months before a battery replacement is needed and are wildly more suitable for young kids.
Fitbit: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Likes it
> Can anyone who uses or has tried to use recent "watch" style products from Google/Fitbit provide anecdotes on this claim? I was a Fitbit user from the day the initial fitbit went on sale for preorder. I used pretty much every 'flagship' fitbit since then until Google bought them. Ever since Google took over the Fitbit product got worse and worse. I decided a year ago I needed out when they got rid of the communities favorite feature, challenges. I'm pretty sure when I finally packed my fitbit away I had logged more days of usage then anyone else. I started exploring what the other options were but was not able to even consider the apple watch because I do prefer android to ios. If it had supported android I'd have potentially gotten one though. Anyway as apple placed themselves out of the running I explored other options and decided Garmin had the best offerings. The biggest issue there though was they had way too many models and way too many versions of each model and little help to figure out which one is the best for you beyond super high level titles like "runner". That said I ended up settling on the Fenix series and after a year of use I can say I'm quite happy with it! When I upgraded my phone this past fall to the latest Pixel Google actually was giving away free Pixel watch 2's with every purchase so I did wear a pixel watch for a couple of weeks to test it out. It was.. not great... especially the battery which was supposedly improved from the pixel watch 1. Any…
Fitbit: NeutralGarmin: Doesn’t like it
These plots definitely align with my personal anecdotal experience. I own both a Fitbit Vivo Active 4S and a Garmin VivoSmart 4. In the daytime, as a watch, I much prefer the Garmin, but at night, as a sleep tracker, which is the main thing I want from these watches, I only trust the data from the Fitbit. If I'm concerned about actual total sleep times, I do generally need to edit the Fitbit data in the morning. Over the years, my Fitbit watches have fairly consistently confused idle time sitting on a couch watching videos or lying in bed reading on my phone before or after sleeping as sleep. The data edit tools in the app fortunately make it easy to correct this (I'm not someone who falls asleep with the video playing, so I generally know when I turned off the activity at night and when I woke for the morning). The data during the night, which is what I care about, I've come to trust on Fitbit watches over the years. I can't know if it's precisely accurate, but it's definitely directionally correct (if there's an overall scale factor error or similar from true sleep quality and time numbers I don't really care as the measurements are consistent enough that I can use them and benefit from them). My Garmin I view as a random number generator as far as sleep tracking. My perception is it's probably a bit better about not misclassifying idle time before and after sleep, but not accurate enough to be actually correct, and I have not been able to find any simple data editing featu…
Fitbit: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Neutral
They're doing people a favor. Fitbit is trash: the second Fitbit Charge we've owned in the last 3yrs has died, this time a Charge 5 that refused to turn on overnight 13 months after purchase -- 1 month after the warranty expired. We got a refund on it through our credit card's Extended Warranty protection benefit & bought a Garmin Venu Sq 2 to replace it.
Fitbit: NeutralGarmin: Likes it
I am so satisfied with my Garmin Fenix. It's comically expensive, but it has been a dream compared to the Fitbits I used for years. Garmin has lots of lower-end watches, too, which would have resolved most of my headaches and many still have great battery life compared to the competition. I haven't touched the "smart watch" features, though. Garmin conducts themselves really well, too. They make good stuff and do little to lock it down: you don't have to use their cloud shit if you don't want (I do use it and like it), they created a peripheral standard in ANT+ that became widely adopted, without actually privileging their own stuff, etc.
Fitbit: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Recommends it
I am a big fan of Garmin watches, there is usually a good deal on something at https://g.factoryoutletstore.com/ These sync reliably because they use a cable instead of the janky bluetooth sync of fitbit devices. It's true that they send your data to a cloud service but at least they aren't comingling your data with everything you watch on YouTube.
Fitbit: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Likes it
I used to use a FitBit Ionic (GPS enabled watch) and now use a Garmin watch and fortunately it shows a more accurate and better exercise results. In terms of running I saw a difference of ~10-20% in the distance measured in some terrains. I have not precisely compared everything. BTW the Fitbit Ionic GPS stopped working and now (if it didn't expire) I will go for the health (battery) recall: https://help.fitbit.com/en_US/ionic.htm and give them to another person. This will be the second replacement since this model stopped working after 1 yr of use and Fitbit sent me a new one.
Fitbit: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Likes it
Garmin smart watches are very accurate for tracking total sleep time. But as for details on sleep phases, who knows? No wrist device including Fitbit can be totally accurate for sleep phases. Regardless of how good the sensors and algorithms are, there just isn't enough clinical information available at that body site. The smart watches with blood oxygen saturation sensors can be useful for detecting sleep apnea. But that only applies to people with the condition. Why do you think you need sleep tracking? Is the data actionable? If we want to improve sleep quality then it's no big mystery what to do. Consume less alcohol and caffeine. Exercise more. Don't be obese. Don't eat a large, protein-rich meal late in the day. Go to sleep earlier. Keep the bedroom cool, dark, and quiet. We all know what we ought to do, we just don't reliably do those things. Better sleep tracking won't fix a lack of discipline or give us more hours in the day.
Fitbit: NeutralGarmin: Likes it
personal experience X a bit of personal research on the matter: - deep sleep is restorative (AIUI the brain needs deep sleep otherwise it poisons itself, whereas e.g muscles don't, they need rest) - light sleep is important too but I feel that was not the question - I noticed I had a hard time falling asleep early/at "normal" hours - even if I did, waking up before 9am made me feel terrible through the day until 4pm, even though I had 8-12h of sleep - I got a fitness device (back then fitbit charge HR, now garmin forerunner 735xt) for unrelated reasons but figured out any data could be helpful as long as I'm aware of the limitations and error margins. Either device I had/have cannot record REM sleep, only deep+light+movement (via HR monitor+accelerometers) - over five years, data shows that either I sleep no earlier than 1am, or when I sleep before, it's only light sleep and a lot of movement, deep sleep starting between 1-3am - also, attempts at imposing myself an earlier sleep schedule (in order to get 8h of sleep given I started work at 9am) resulted in worse sleep/later deep sleep - sometimes on a given night, cumulative deep sleep as reported may look to be enough (e.g 3-4h) but looking at that night timeline graph showed that it was extremely segmented instead of a couple or three chunks - even if I'm extremely tired I cannot sleep before 1am. it's that or I sleep at 7-9pm and wake up within an hour after 23pm, theb can't get back to sleep until 3-4am - exercise helps (…
Switched from the Fitbit to the GarminGarmin: Likes it
Nice! When I wanted a “dumb” smart watch many years ago, I went with a FitBit. I think it matched the features to what this Casio offers minus the HR monitor. Fast forward to now, I use a Garmin Instinct that hits the spot for me. I’ve grown accustomed to the more detailed analytics (HRV and “daily battery” are awesome). Still I’d consider a Casio with more sensors and a solid phone app to give them justice. Anyhow, I own the previous version of this watch and a few other Casios and I still like them for what they are. Gonna hold on to them until I die :)
Switched from the Fitbit to the GarminGarmin: Likes it
The battery life of Garmin watches is astonishing. When I get a low battery alert, I still have several days to plug it in. If my phone dies, my watch stores my run until I get home, at which point it logs into my Wi-Fi network and uploads it automatically. I had a bunch of Fitbits over the course of a decade and wish I'd made the change earlier.