The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Fairphone vs Pine64 PinePhone

Hacker News owners lean toward the Fairphone.

FairphonePine64 PinePhone
Owners with an opinion194137
Positive verdicts65% of 16325% of 112
Positive/negative since 202468/3711/49
Happy after 3+ years141
Longest happy owner10 yrs4 yrs
Praised forrepairability and reliabilityease of use and repairability
Criticized forperformance and supportperformance and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Fairphone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
I mean there has been a new entrant in the past few years, the fairphone, which arrived with a vision and an ethics, and is slowly getting market share, and better products, that are repairable, or new entrant like frame.work, which arrived with a vision, ethics too, and is slowly improving and getting market share. I am not sure why as a society we need to accomodate small vendors who arrive without a plan or anything selling shit shipped from China that is going to last 30 days and just become e-waste, like PinePhone or Librem comes to mind, I am not sure why society needs to accomodate any cowboy who wants to become a manufacturer to sell low effort china phones
Fairphone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
I got mine a month ago; ordered oktober 2019. Since than tried the Pinephone and PPP as a daily driver. The Librem5...it's slower and clunkier than the Pinephone pro. Both last less than 24 hours on a charge(suspend and calls seem to be a difficult problem tot fix). In the end, these may be nice tinkering devices, but nowhere near anything that you can reliably use as a phone. I now use a Fairphone 4 + Calyxos, and am quite happy with it. Spotify instead of Ncspot, Bluetooth that works, calls that work, no more buggy mobile Firefox config, reliable maps, messaging clients that work in the background. Most importantly; a battery that last at least 2 days, with reliable fast-charging. Purism, Pine and the Opensource community around it are just too small; either they run out of cash and/or people burn out trying to make it happen. A whole different case, but Valve's steamdeck is IMO a good example that Linux-based products with a good value proposition are possible, under the right circumstances.
Fairphone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
I don't. Maybe it would be worth writing one some day? But quickly here: I used CyanogenMod on a Galaxy S2 10 years ago, then Lineage on an S4. I liked them, but clearly that was "experimenting with alternative ROMs". I had bugs, crashes, sometimes the camera would not work, etc. I have tried a PinePhone for fun in 2020, which was mostly a good opportunity to learn about PostmarketOS. That's a nice Linux project, but it didn't work as a phone for me. Two years ago, I got a FairPhone 3+ Murena (i.e. with /e/ OS pre-installed). The experience has been extremely close to a vendor ROM: I essentially have not touched/tuned/reinstalled anything, I use it like any vendor Android I've had in my life. That's a big change from my previous experiences where I was expecting things to go wrong. The big difference with Google-Android is that I don't have the Play Store and the Play Services (so GMail and Google Maps won't work). /e/ OS has their own store ("App Lounge") which works really well and can connect to the Play Store. I am not a very heavy user of my phone (I'm a dev, so my main is the computer): messaging apps, web browser, public transport app, stuff like this. Most work, I have only had to give up on my banking app a month ago (presumably an update makes it crash because I don't have the Play Services?). I had to adapt a few things though. I use CalDAV to fetch my Google Calendar (for work), the /e/ OS Mail app (which is a fork of K-9 Mail) to fetch my Google Emails (works gre…
Fairphone: NeutralPine64 PinePhone: Likes it
Seems a SFOS or Murena or Fairphone smartphone might suffice (not sure about eSIM). I am sure the Planet Cosmo Communicator and Planet Astro Slide have eSIM. With Waydroid you can even run Android applications on a Pinephone. What I like about Pinephone and Librem 5 is hardware killswitches. There's also the Steam Deck, it runs Arch. All of these have different pros and cons. For example, some of these don't have a keyboard (which you may or may not care). But all have BT or USB and therefore could use a keyboard. I ran LOS + microG on FP2 for a while, but back then without Gotify and Gotify-UP. With these I believe you can have notifications with top control, without using the Google framework.
Fairphone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
There are repairable and upgradeable phones (Google search for fairphone). If people really cared about this stuff companies like fairphone would be dominating the market now. But people don't buy those phones because they don't agree that "smartphones are shit". They would rather have cheaper less upgradeable less repairable phones. Not sure that's a problem which Pinephone are solving?
Fairphone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
Well if you're ready to spend a month's salary on a phone, you'll probably get better hardware/software from Fairphone or Librem. Pinephone is also an option (at a more accessible price point) but it's still in some kind of beta where random users who just want to take photos and have a long-lasting battery are not the target audience. I know many people who use Fairphones and they've never been disappointed. You can still find the spare parts, remove the battery, and setup the OS you want. Be careful though the "setup your own OS" part may not be supported for a few months after a new model comes out so be sure to check the compatibility list on lineageos.org. Unfortunately to my knowledge all other vendors are just scammers who will sell you half-functioning phone due to spyware bundled as part of the system (just try to remove Google Play Services :)) where you can't unlock the bootloader to setup your own system.
Fairphone: Recommends itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
Pinephone give a month warranty, that's it. Its a dealbreaker for any consumer. Pinephone Pro can get you through the day, but it goes for 400 plus duties, and it also only has a month warranty. Kickstarter, Indiegogo can get away scamming or false advertising. Instead, look at Framework and Fairphone how a company can release a modular device, for a realistic price.
Fairphone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Neutral
> If the PinePhone isn't a good choice is there another good more FOSSy phone I can turn to? I am sick of Google, and I have neither the inclination nor funds to join the apple ecosystem, anything else I could do? Maybe have a look at the Fairphone, the last iteration seems neat, and it's compatible with several FOSS OSes (at least Android based ones, but I think other too). Best is to use a second hand/refurbished phone: better for the planet, the price, and you can choose carefully a model compatible with the FOSS OS you would like to have. PinePhone (Pro) is not (yet?) good as a daily driver, but it's a great platform if you want to develop for various OSes (booting on a new OS is as easy as switching SD card). With the new keyboard accessory, it's a great super small and portable computer, and the community is very active.
Fairphone: Doesn’t like itPine64 PinePhone: Likes it
> Fairphone is more free than almost every smartphone out there Except it relies on proprietary drivers, which will not be updated by the vendor, resulting in a brick after some years. Librem 5 and Pinephone will receive software updates forever. > But you're bound to old, refurbished ones (X230/T430 apparently) [1]. Not necessarily: https://forum.qubes-os.org/t/community-recommended-computers... . > Librem 5 delivers awful performance What do you mean? It can run 3D games and provides full desktop mode. What else do you need?
Fairphone: Doesn’t like itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
Pinephone is close to useless. Fairphone 5 I think is as good as it gets if you want to avoid android. It is annoying though that fairphone 6 is not working with linux.
Fairphone: Doesn’t like itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
All the open/pro-privacy/pro-consumer cell phones I've seen (pinephone, Fairphone, Librem) never go far enough (non-open cellular modems/wireless chipsets) while also being either insanely priced, unobtainable, barely functional, scammy, broken, or some combination of those things. I really want a product like that to succeed, but I'm just not seeing anything reasonable being produced.
Fairphone: Doesn’t like itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
Compared to a pixel, they're budget phone specs missing some fundamental quality of life stuff that other phones have offered, usually for years. The fairphone 5 seems a bit closer to flagship specs, but it still clearly misses the mark and also seems priced at flagship levels. Pinephone is just a junk budget phone, although at least it's priced much lower.
Fairphone: Doesn’t like itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
> If you buy a phone or general purpose computing device Point of clarity, the devices we are discussing are neither telephones, nor are they general purpose. They are smartphones, a sort of miniature computer with a bunch of general-purpose sensors, and actuators viz. a screen and a speaker and some haptic feedback. They don't really do much computing per se; we outsourced most of that to The Cloud some 15-odd years ago. These things are just highly capable I/O devices, or clever terminals if you prefer. And while Android has the PlayStore or whatever they call it this week, one can usually choose to load rogue APKs and one can usually succeed; and things like the Pinephone or Fairphone have been attempted that leave more power (and responsibility) in the hands of the user, but in practice it seems that they simply don't _work_ that well. I agree with you wholeheartedly; I just think the "if" part is a bit out of sync with reality.