The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell XPS vs System76

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Dell XPSSystem76
Owners with an opinion659312
Positive verdicts48% of 58369% of 280
Positive/negative since 202472/9749/23
Happy after 3+ years4933
Longest happy owner20 yrs20 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forbatterybuild quality and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell XPS: Likes itSystem76: Neutral
I just upgraded from a 7-year old XPS 15 - technically it was a Precision 5520 from when Dell still had a Developer Edition that would ship with Ubuntu but it was hands down the best Linux laptop I had. The things I loved about that one was: - 45W TDP processor - none of the U series 15W slowness - 4K screen that scaled to 1080P perfectly at 200% scaling - so X11 and XWayland apps still looked good. Also the screen quality was amazing - Integrated Graphics - no messing around with NVIDIA drivers I searched high and low for something similar but could not find anything on the market. So made some compromises and went with System76 Pangolin (pang15). Here are my notes on the machine Pros: - 45W TDP processor is fast - They let you load it up with memory and disk for reasonable prices unlike most mainstream manufacturers - 2nd M2 slot is nice for copying over old SSD - They provide Windows Drivers in a GitHub repo Cons: - Battery life is pretty bad but I stay plugged in most of the time so not a huge issue for me - Fans spin up pretty often - USB-C charging only. There is an A/C Adapter barrel jack but they don't ship a charger and I can't find a suitable aftermarket charger. I worry about wear and tear on the USB-C port damaging it one day and that will be the end of the laptop effectively if I can't plug in. - The screen needs around 133% fractional scaling which is not even an option. So I have to use a combination of 125% scaling and t
Dell XPS: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
3 days ago my system76 oryx pro 4k 2023 just died dead. i had 2022 dell xps with 17 4k touch screen. i thought, okey, will plug encrypted nvme system disk. i was doubt it will boot at all, not speaking about sound, wifi and touch. but magically, after reboot, some firmwares installed. it all worked perfectly. sound, voice, touch, sleep, keyboard.
Dell XPS: Recommends itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
In the last month I bought and returned a Darter Pro from them. Almost immediately I realized what some have mentioned already-- these machines are overpriced and lack build quality you'd get with mainstream laptops. The bezel was messed up, causing light bleed on the display. I'd be better off loading Ubuntu onto a Dell XPS for half the price.
Dell XPS: NeutralSystem76: Likes it
I used to use ThinkPads exclusively, but Lenovo's priorities for ThinkPads no longer match mine. I've since moved on to HP Dev One. It's well-rounded for me, was easily upgraded to 64GB of ram, and came with Pop! OS out of the box. I've also used System76 machines in the past with success, but I'm rather attached to having a pointing stick. My dayjob provides a Dell XPS 13 (factory-loaded with Ubuntu) which is an acceptable machine, but I don't travel with it much. I always use GNU/Linux. Of late I've been sticking to LTS Ubuntu or Pop! OS releases. I'm a strange case though, because my desktop is LXDE, and all I ever really do is run a browser or two with a pile of terminals, so I'm not running heavy desktop apps like Slack, Discord, or LibreOffice.
Dell XPS: Likes itSystem76: Neutral
I had one of their systems, a gazelle professional 4 if I recall right, it must've been around, oh say, 2013? And it was quite a nice machine, great linux compat, the 4-core i7 in it performed quite well and it let me load it up with RAM. It wasn't too heavy or anything and I liked the display. But the battery life. Good lord. 45 minutes, 55 if I messed and fussed with power settings and such. Basically gaming-laptop-tier "more like a UPS than a battery" battery performance. My next laptop was a thinkpad T440s and it had similarly good linux compat and it performed much better for battery life - I got an i5 in that one and saw 8ish hours of battery life, and it had a hot-swap feature where I could swap in a big-ass battery once I depleted the slim one and get an additional 20(!!) something hours of battery life on a single boot. Great for car trips and heavy all-day use like at conferences. But then superfish and I swore Lenovo had lost me for-ever. So my current laptop is an XPS13 and I get 8-10ish hours off one charge with it, and it is super thin and the only Linux issue I've had is needing a very new kernel when I bought it new a year and a half or so ago, new enough that Linux Mint didn't ship it OOTB and the live ISO couldn't get WiFi, so I installed Arch instead, where their latest install image did indeed have a sufficiently new kernel. So I'm a happy XPS user right now and I've found I like the 13" form factor. Would I be disappointed on battery performance if I went…
Dell XPS: Likes itSystem76: Neutral
In much of Europe Dell will end up cheaper because it will be sold within the single market, meaning no customs tax and import levies, and warrantee doesn't cost you hundreds of Euros in shipping costs. System76 is really only an affordable option if you live in North America. That's if this comes out in whichever European country one lives in of course, because Dell is exasperatingly vague about their specific offerings, and in my case (the XPS 13 with Ubuntu 20.04 with Dell Netherlands) I could only offer it via telephone. That part sucks. The laptop is fine though. For the record: for my work laptop over the past ten years I've had two System76's and now a Dell XPS 13.
Dell XPS: Likes itSystem76: Neutral
My current laptop is an XPS 13 (9310), and I got it specifically because it comes with Ubuntu supported and installed. My work laptops before that were System76 (which is OK, but way too much of a hassle in Europe when something goes wrong). I guess the next one will be something else again. Damn, I hate it when there isn't just a go-to model I can pick, and I hate comparing laptops and not just having an easy filter for 'works perfectly with Linux'. Ah well, this one won't need replacing for quite a while. Honestly, I wouldn't mind getting something a little bigger either (15" that is) if it just comes with RJ45 Ethernet, DisplayPort and HDMI, a bunch of USB-A ports, USB-C, and a headphone jack. You know, stuff we actually use. Now I have docking stations at work and at home (hybrid office/work-from-home), which works well enough, but it feels inefficient and cumbersome.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
Sad to see the XPS 13 starting out ~10 years ago as a "super"-portable (it was the one that introduced the tiny bezels, if anyone remembers), but still proper laptop, then turning into this fashion monster today. No headphone jack? C'mon, you must be joking. I don't even dare to ask if there is going to be a "developer" version of this running Linux, because the target market is so different now I cannot imagine it makes any sense. But OK, in the meantime other players like System76 and Tuxedo are getting better and better - it is not such a void anymore in the Linux laptop space that used to be.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
Did you try to run Windows on a Macbook? Do you expect that it should work flawlessly? Will you blame Microsoft or Apple for its problems? Same with Linux. Linux tries to support "all" hardware, but you should not expect that it's possible to actually do it perfectly. > commercial "designed for Linux" laptops like the Dell XPS Developer Edition have critical features missing like suspend/sleep So you should stop trusting Dell with their hardware. Why do you blame the Linux community for not supporting proprietary hardware without documentation flawlessly? > pretend like all hardware works "fine" on Linux I never said that all hardware worked fine on Linux. There is no OS with which all hardware works fine, and can't be. I'm just suggesting to rely on actually supported hardware, which is rare but pretty much possible to find. See also: System76.
Switched from the System76 to the Dell XPSDell XPS: Recommends it
I think it has some kind of firmware that manages the backlight, so if you switch between really bright and dark windows a lot (like a browser and terminal) then it changes brightness a lot which is annoying, and there's no way to turn it off. Personally the only thing I've had issues with (on Linux) is the soundcard producing low-level noise because of the CPU going into powersaving mode. It's fixable but I can't remember exactly what I had to do to get it to stop. On the bright side, it does help a lot for the battery life (I get around 8 hours usually). I also have an older system76 laptop and I would definitely recommend the XPS (13 or 15) over it if you want something lightweight with good battery life.
Dell XPS: Likes itSystem76: Likes it
I've had a System 76 laptop for a few months now and I'm pretty happy with it. They've done a good job with Pop!Os, it's the only distro I've found that has made Gnome usable for me out of the box. The only downside over my previous laptop (Dell XPS) is that I can no longer run 2 external monitors, the System 76 hardware just doesn't seem to be able to handle it.
Dell XPS: Recommends itSystem76: Recommends it
Older Asus fold had many issues with Linux. In most cases, you can get headless mode working but forget about GUI. A better solution would be trying out System76, HPDevOne or Dell XPS dev edition for Linux desktop.
Dell XPS: Recommends itSystem76: Recommends it
You need to see the laptop page and scroll down to get a Keyboard section. Now you can select en-US https://slimbook.es/en/store/slimbook-kde/kde-slimbook-16-co... I think folks outside the EU zone need to pay customs duty on imports. So, if you are in the US, go for System 76 (AMD/Intel), HP Dev One (AMD), or Dell Dev Edition XPS (Intel).
Dell XPS: Recommends itSystem76: Recommends it
>But frankly, I don't want to care about all this "oh, but you just have to do [insanely_technical_thing]" >It should just work. Then you should buy a laptop that ships with Linux and has official support from the vendor. Like the Dell XPS Developer edition, or anything from System76.
Dell XPS: Likes itSystem76: Likes it
I like System76, and my two previous work laptops came from them (both served me for over four years each; I only had to replace the last one due to a hard to diagnose RAM issue), but I can't recommend them to anyone outside of the US. By now they really should have gotten into bed with an EU distributor to handle warrantee, customs, and shipping, because it's just too costly and too much of a hassle to deal with System76 with an ocean in between. I'm using a Dell XPS 13 pre-loaded with Ubuntu now. I had to order it by telephone because the option to configure it with 32GB of RAM and Ubuntu wasn't available on their website (in this respect Dell really sucks with their localized web shop, but at least you can contact them within the EU), but no hassle with customs and shipping, and warrantee isn't limited to the US standard of one year by default, but the EU mandated standard of two years. If it breaks down, I can get a replacement within a week; that's just impossible with overseas commerce.