The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell XPS vs Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon.

Dell XPSLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon
Owners with an opinion659154
Positive verdicts48% of 58368% of 137
Positive/negative since 202472/9711/10
Happy after 3+ years4911
Longest happy owner20 yrs10 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forbatterybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell XPS: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I was issued an equivalent Latitude 7490 at a gig in 2019 and enjoyed using it (under Linux). It's robust and easily upgraded, but a little heavier than I would like. I replaced the battery a year or two ago. I generally haven't had much trouble with second hand Dell and Thinkpad machines; perhaps buying second hand means that the real lemons are already ewaste? Though the XPS machines bought new were fine aside from the annoyingly brief battery life. Currently using a Thinkpad X1 Carbon Gen 13 under Linux for work stuff and I like that (much lighter) so if I can get one second hand with enough memory I might choose that when/if the Dell eventually feels too slow.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
As a VERY long-time Linux user, I agree. Multi-monitor setups, where you can unplug the monitor and have your windows gather back onto your laptop screen requires WAY too much configuration. Having your audio switch back to internal laptop speakers requires homebrewing a script. On my 2020 Dell XPS, I still haven't figured out how to enable the subwoofers - so I'm stuck with ThinkPad quality audio. I have 3 ThinkPads (one with straight ArchLinux, 2 with CachyOS) and there's always some little piece I'm annoyed with. The X1C has good battery life, the T480 and P14s are meh. I JUST bought my first HiDPI Lenovo laptop this weekend. Getting that to be a decent tradeoff between readable text and mongo-duplo-massive UI has been "fun". (Yoga 15.3" Aura edition - I really like it) But running apps in Wine is darn near impossible - the text is for ants! All of these issues go away with Mac and Windows. I'm not giving up on Linux, I'm just a realist.
Dell XPS: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I did compare it to the XPS 13 - the XPS looked like a solid machine, but it felt a little cramped to me. I preferred the still-svelte-but-bigger 14" X1. Another consideration was having a company that cares about Linux running flawlessly, and Red Hat gives their employees Thinkpads. That dogfooding means that if I'm having a problem, it's likely some Red Hat employee is having the same problem, so it ought to be fixed soon :)
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I got a 1200€ XPS 13 Developer Edition (with Linux) a few years ago. Sleep did not work well from the start and it would randomly drain battery while sleeping. About 9 months in, the battery swelled up and outright died, and was replaced under warranty with a week+ wait. 9 months after that, so just after the 1.5yrs warranty expired, the motherboard died. 500€ to replace. Got a ThinkPad X1 Carbon for about the same price instead and never looked back - will not buy Dell again.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I've noticed they have gotten worse. After three bad MacBook Pros in a row, I bought a used 2015 MacBook Air, which has never given me a problem. The pros all had battery/power issues, shutting down randomly several times a day. The keyboards were also horrible. I've been a Thinkpad fan for years, and I use a Carbon X1 with Linux outside of work. No complaints about that, though I do wonder if it's as physically durable as the older, bulkier models. I've noticed Lenovo is putting out more consumer grade laptops now. I don't know about their quality, but it doesn't seem as high as their professional line. My son has a Dell XPS 15, and had to replace a loud, failing fan after a year. I suppose manufacturers face a lot of pressure selling to consumers who don't know what to look for in terms of quality and don't understand why two visually similar machines with similar specs would be priced so differently. The low-end machines in Walmart look just like the high-end machines at Best Buy. The business grade machines from Lenovo, Dell, and HP have incentive to be higher quality because businesses often buy them with high level service plans. Lenovo, Dell and HP really don't want to send techs into the field to service laptops if they can avoid it, and the best way to avoid that is to build a good product.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Neutral
> * No Suspend/Resume? Linux has solved this for years, I have not come across a laptop in the last 10 years that had trouble with s2r or s2d (but I guess that there might be a few that don't fully support it, I mainly tested Dell laptops) I wouldn't be so sure. My Dell XPS 13 and ThinkPad X1 Carbon both had issues with suspend/resume. Close the lid @ get surprised with a completely dead battery. Ironically, when I used FreeBSD on X1 - S3 state worked perfectly fine. The issue in post is how bhyve handles wake up from S3 state, with devices being pass-through to the VM. Not once had a laptop that isn't a MacBook with macOS with properly working hibernation. > * Bluetooth not supported??? Yeah, BT stack is completely broken for years. No one has desire to fix it. > Ethernet over USB-C both highly unstable? - I had no issues with my no-name dongle. > I wonder if there is any laptop from the last 5 years where FreeBSD fully works. Define fully works? Graphics - you're limited to Nvidia and whatever Linux 5.4 supported. Wi-Fi - 802.11g is as fast as you can go without wifibox. > but these days I kinda expect most things to just work out of the box ... Even on Linux, you either have to deal with hardware that been out for some time or know how to install the latest kernel and maybe apply some patches. When I got my XPS, it was the first one with Intel Xe - had to use "unstable" kernel in NixOS with every other distro not having graphics output. This is still an issue in 2022: htt…
Dell XPS: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Recommends it
I agree with this answer – the Dell XPS machines are beasts and you might eventually even find yourself caring for the "fancy things", e.g. a touch screen. To add to this list, I still think that Lenovo makes great and very customizable Thinkpads. As far as I know, the P15 is one of the popular ones. It's a chungus though, so if you need something lighter, the X1 Carbon is a great choice as well as it's very compact and portable.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Doesn’t like it
This is personally frustrating me right now because I'm trying to help somebody select a new laptop, and I'm finding that I don't have the confidence to recommend _anything_ anymore. This is the situation: - Switching away from an M1 MacBook because they can't stand macOS. - Happy with Windows or Linux from past experience. - Close lid, put in bag is an important workflow. - Something reasonably modern and capable would be nice, but doesn't need to be a powerhouse (don't need current gen CPU necessarily, don't need discrete graphics). Does anything on the market actually have reliable power management? I've been looking at the Dell XPS range, Lenovo Yoga, X1 Carbon, and Framework laptops today. But I can find power management horror stories for all of them, so I don't know what to think.
Dell XPS: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
The whole S3 sleep fiasco is the stuff of nightmares. I have a gen 6 X1 Carbon too and I've gotten it sleeping very well. I also have a Dell XPS 15 that I love but... it's been 2 years since it was brand new and it's still stuck on S2 "idle". As I understand it, Microsoft wants it this way so they can maintain network connectivity. My major gripe with the Lenovo is the 16 gigs of RAM soldered on the board. It's so nice to be able to pop open my Dell and put up to 64 gigs in there, while replacing the SSD in one of the two M2 slots. Then again, I'm typing this on a 2019 Macbook Pro (Intel) that has nary a single replaceable part.
Dell XPS: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Recommends it
I've been a dev for almost 20 years. Though a bulky laptop with finest specs would be great, I need mobility so I had luck with these three. Super portable, yet powerful. 1. Dell XPS 13 2. Lenovo X1 Carbon 3. HP Dragonfly Elite (current) Regardless of the brand I always stuc with i7/16Gb and at least 512Gb NVMe storage. One downside with my current machine (HP Dragonfly) is it comes with 8th Gen intel processor not really a big problem for me, but fan it a bit louder to my liking. Coming to Linux compatibility I've used Dell XPS 13 and Lenovo X1 with no issues. Haven't tried Linux on the current machine yet.
Dell XPS: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I've had great success with Lenovo X1 Carbon laptops running Linux (Debian with XFCE). I've also had good luck with the older Dell XPS laptops. Getting either of these for $2k would require a sale and if you want to run a lot of Docker containers you'll need to pick a beefier model. My only annoyance, which seems to cross brands, is that none of the newer laptops support the deeper sleep modes.
Dell XPS: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
This is true with ultra books as well. 3 or 4 year old Thinkpad X1 Carbons or XPS 13s are an easy cost savings and quality improvement compared to low or even midrange contemporary competitors.