The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell XPS vs Lenovo ThinkPad X1

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad X1.

Dell XPSLenovo ThinkPad X1
Owners with an opinion659376
Positive verdicts48% of 58371% of 335
Positive/negative since 202472/9798/57
Happy after 3+ years4928
Longest happy owner20 yrs11 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forbatterybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I have the Lenovo X1 and I'm very happy with it, though obviously that's in a very different price category than the Yoga, Surface, or Macbook Neo. On the other hand, more money doesn't always mean better computer. I had a Dell XPS 9570 at a previous gig that had a lot of issues: coil whine, bad camera placement, terrible thermals, etc.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
What about Lenovo? They have desktops, although only one laptop with it pre installed at the moment. https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/p/laptops/thinkpad/thinkpadx1/t... They do however support Linux, and have the best upstreaming support that I've seen getting fingerprint readers, webcams, etc all with working kernel drivers. https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/faqs/operating-systems/how-to-i... The XPS's I've tried in the past have always ended up with unsupported hardware after a while, so I've written them off.
Dell XPS: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
Funnily enough based off Lenovo's reputation for their higher end laptops, in April I bought a Lenovo X1 Carbon Gen10, pretty much as they came out. The machine is a nightmare, and has been through about 10 firmware updates over the last 6 months, but has barely improved. From day one and still now... on Win11 that it shipped with it won't hibernate, just a black screen on resume, then pot luck over the next boots whether it starts or not. Sometimes from shutdown it does the same thing. Under little load, it gets hot as hell, you literally can't type on it, I use a bluetooth keyboard. If I'm doing light dev work, 3h battery life, tops. Audio drivers are broken, the internal 3.5mm just emits noise above around 10% volume and is distorted below that. Shipped with an underpowered 45W adapter... same SKU now ships with a 65W (an i7-1260p w/32GB). I don't think it's faulty, there are plenty of people with the same story about Gen10s. Mine is in for repair now, so we'll see, if it comes back with the same issues, it's getting warranty returned. I know the X1 Carbon Gen9 is a really good machine, maybe Lenovo got screwed by Intel's 12th Gen platform and Microsoft's support for the processor, but the machine should not be going out the door like that. Come to think of it... my XPS15 9560 from 2017 is STILL a better machine, which is what I switched back to while it's in for service (and cost half as much!)
Dell XPS: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
Out of curiosity, what laptop? My samples in the last 6 years are: - Thinkpad Carbon X1 14" (i7-5600u). Everything worked out of the box with Arch Linux at the time. Best experience I've ever had. - HP Envy 13z (R5 2500u) everything works today but the out of the box experience was very poor. Windows update installed an APU microcode update that broke the Linux AMDGPU driver and had to run an -rc kernel for awhile. Took a year to get a touchscreen driver and years to get the driver for the tablet sensors (rotation, etc.). Total wait of 3 years for all features, but I never had the desire to use it as a tablet so I was okay with it. Sleep works but this laptop had awful battery drain issues in sleep (30% per day). - Dell XPS 15 7590 (i9-9980hk) - Sleep is broke in both Linux and Windows. Everything else works well, including, notably, NVIDIA Optimus / DRI PRIME. - Asus ZenBook 14 (R7 5800U) - second best out of box experience. Touchpad is connected via i2c and my Gentoo install didn't have it enabled. I'd never bumped into i2c hid devices other than touchscreens.
Dell XPS: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I've loved my Thinkpad X1 Xtreme for years now. I was given the choice of what I wanted to be issued for my job and it has served me well. Would I buy it for my personal use? No. I am not a fan of Lenovo being a Chinese company now, and it's very boring. I still haven't had any problems with it. Before this machine I was issued a Dell XPS and the battery life was amazing for a Wintel laptop, great speakers and a unique power button + fingerprint reader button in one, but it had a ton of BIOS based issues and quirks. It always seems to me it takes years for them to work all the bugs out vs other companies. Dell is like a lot of companies where I prefer their designs over everyone elses, but I just can never bring myself to love them. For personal use for fun or as a consultant, I'd reach for a Samsung laptop. They lag behind on CPUs and such but they're my pick. For a fleet, I'd probably have to go Lenovo out of necessity for the support.
Dell XPS: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
While I am personally a heavy apple user - I'd say for a developer it actually comes down to are there any good non Mac Operating Systems for developers? The XPS 15, Lenovo X1 Extreme, Rog Zephyrus, and Razer Blade Advanced are all laptops I've personally used for development, and would mostly recommend, however I find windows hard to use for development and linux support varies of course. Personally, I'd give apple another chance, but if that's not an option, The XPS 15 is probably the best bet.
Dell XPS: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
I used Linux for 10 years (mainly on Lenovos and some early Dell XPS back in the days), then I switched to MacOS about 3-4 years ago and over the last couple weeks I have been trying to go back to Linux because I am sick having to use MacOS everyday. It is a great OS for an everyday user, but not for a developer. Here is what I tried so far: 1) Dell XPS 9370 Developer edition: This comes preloaded with Ubuntu and it is actually amazing that everything works out of the box. It was too small for me though, and the fan made a rattling noise so I decided to return it. The 4K screen is probably overkill on such a small display. Based on the review people recommend taking the normal screen, it saves a lot of battery and there is not that much difference. 2) Lenovo X1: I didn't like the feel of the Keyboard, and the screen was not that good. Installing Linux (Arch) was easy, but decided to return it. 3) Dell XPS 9570: I have this one for the last two weeks and so far I love it on the hardware level. I would even put it as somehow superior to my MacBook Pro. The downside is that Linux is not well supported at all. I have installed Arch so far and spent all my evenings trying to fix all the drivers. So far: The Nvidia drivers are barely working, ACPI needs a lot of tweaks (but it seems I got it working and got my 7 hours of battery). I still need to work on the Touchpad, and couple other things. So far, the Dell XPS 9570 is a good challenger to the MBP, but installing Linux is still
Switched from the Dell XPS to the Lenovo ThinkPad X1Lenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I have a ~2018 Dell XPS that runs Ubuntu and Debian fine. I still prefer the ~2017 ThinkPad X1 Carbon, despite the much slower CPU, half the memory, worse screen, and the coating peeling off. Not sure why I prefer it, perhaps some combination of it being lighter, quieter, and the screen opening 180°
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 to the Dell XPSDell XPS: Likes it
I loved my P1 Gen1. 64GB RAM already back then, lots of power. Got a Carbon from a new employer, which was really lacking for dev purposes (Gen8 or 9, only 16 GB ram, choked on remote meetings). Wanted to upgrade to the X1 Extreme which looked nice, but was impossible to get hold of at the time so got to switch to a Dell XPS 15 9510 which works quite well.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 to the Dell XPSDell XPS: Neutral
It seems to be pretty solid. Compared to the thinkpad extreme, - The xps 17 "feels" more solid and less creaky. It's probably less survivable, but it feels like a higher-quality machine - The wifi seems great, but lately I've been having problems with the microphone. It just stopped working in Windows a week ago, presumably after an update? - The keyboard isn't quite as good as the thinkpad, but the thinkpad extreme's keyboard isn't nearly as good as the keyboard in my old thinkpad t520. Lenovo are hell-bent on gimping their keyboards until they're no better than anyone else's, and reviews suggest that they've finally succeeded with the x1 extreme gen 4. The xps 17 keyboard is nice, but I notice a squeaking noise from the enter and right shift keys when I type. - The xps 17's battery life is a lot better. My thinkpad's battery life was puzzlingly bad, even under windows.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
I've owned a few XPS/X1 high end laptops in my time. Every single one of them had serious design flaws, as in "I'm not buying that again" type design flaw. That's true of every vendor. I was sucked in by the advertising I guess. They looked very good on paper - good battery life for the time, thin, light, powerful, sleek, latest everything. I've built computer systems for most of my professional career. Looking back on it, how I could have possibly thought some fresh shiny new design first off the production line was going to be rock solid work horse is beyond me. Lack of critical thinking skills I guess. Now, I buy something like a Dell Latitude. It's an enterprise machine. Translation: a plain, boring design with parts that have been trialed by the XPS/X1 suckers, so most of the bugs are ironed out. Enterprise tends to mean expensive. But they lose 75% of their value in 2 years, so second hand prices are very reasonable, and since Dell offers 5 years warranty on them they can effectively come with the same guarantees as a new one. Enterprise also means well supported. It's almost night and day. Ring Dell about a Inspiron or even an XPS issue, and you are met with a wall of excuses. Contact them about an Latitude issue, you get a fast response. The one time I wasn't happy with the outcome, I said so in their "how did we go" questionnaire, and they rang me back begging me to let them have another go.
Dell XPS: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Recommends it
1. Dell XPS 13: Known for its sleek design, powerful performance, and vibrant display, the Dell XPS 13 is a top choice for many. It offers a great balance of portability and performance, making it suitable for various tasks. 2. HP Spectre x360: This 2-in-1 convertible laptop combines versatility with style. It has a flexible hinge that allows you to use it as a laptop or tablet. The Spectre x360 offers a premium build quality, impressive battery life, and high-performance specifications. 3. Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: If you prioritize durability, reliability, and a great keyboard, the ThinkPad X1 Carbon is worth considering. It is known for its excellent build quality, long battery life, and robust performance. 4. Microsoft Surface Laptop 4: The Surface Laptop 4 from Microsoft offers a sleek design, excellent display, and solid performance. It is available in both 13.5-inch and 15-inch models, and it delivers a premium Windows experience. 5. Asus ZenBook 14: The ZenBook 14 is a lightweight and portable laptop with a stylish design. It features a bright display, powerful specifications, and a compact form factor, making it suitable for those on the go.
Dell XPS: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I just replaced a thinkpad x1 extreme gen 2 with a dell xps 17 (I wanted a 16:10 screen and shipping estimates for the x1 extreme gen 4 were ridiculous. Also, Lenovo of Canada are a bunch of dirty crooks). The thinkpad was pretty good, and wayland on fedora worked beautifully (I only used integrated graphics in linux, didn't even try to get the discrete gpu working). The one thing that really didn't work in linux was the fingerprint scanner - it would fail about 7/8 times I used it, which is really too bad because fedora has really nice fingerprint integration with sudo. Also, something seemed to be a bit funny about it's displayport implementation - when it was connected to my DP monitor and went to sleep, the monitor would wake it back up again almost instantly and it would get into this weird back-and-forth between sleep mode and waking. That happened in both linux and windows. This doesn't happen with my new xps. Otherwise it was pretty smooth sailing. It was a well-built computer with a nice keyboard. I might get another thinkpad at some point, but I'm loving this super-compact 17" 16:10 display on the xps.