The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell XPS vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Dell XPSLenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion6592732
Positive verdicts48% of 58375% of 2366
Positive/negative since 202472/97686/273
Happy after 3+ years49281
Longest happy owner20 yrs25 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forbatterybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I had a Dell latitude E6400 for many years, and it was rock solid for me with zero complaints. After that I had an XPS 9550, and it had a lot of issues over just ~3-4 years: issues with power connector, audio stopping working, touchpad issues, etc. Since then I decided to go back to Thinkpad.
Dell XPS: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I was issued an equivalent Latitude 7490 at a gig in 2019 and enjoyed using it (under Linux). It's robust and easily upgraded, but a little heavier than I would like. I replaced the battery a year or two ago. I generally haven't had much trouble with second hand Dell and Thinkpad machines; perhaps buying second hand means that the real lemons are already ewaste? Though the XPS machines bought new were fine aside from the annoyingly brief battery life. Currently using a Thinkpad X1 Carbon Gen 13 under Linux for work stuff and I like that (much lighter) so if I can get one second hand with enough memory I might choose that when/if the Dell eventually feels too slow.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
>Because realistically in the laptop computer space Apple is obliterating everything else right now. Probably right, seeing how bad the laptop world is nowadays. Even with its shitty chiclet keyboard and button-less trackpad, the M2 Pro I have to use at work trounces the XPSes my Windows colleagues have. Still far from the Latitude e64x0 and old 6x series Thinkpads I had but well, they only win on the haptics and repairability level. Thankfully I kept an e6440 that still works "okay" with its Haswell i5 and 1080p IPS screen; the thermals and crappy Intel iGPU are the only thing I really lament.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
As a VERY long-time Linux user, I agree. Multi-monitor setups, where you can unplug the monitor and have your windows gather back onto your laptop screen requires WAY too much configuration. Having your audio switch back to internal laptop speakers requires homebrewing a script. On my 2020 Dell XPS, I still haven't figured out how to enable the subwoofers - so I'm stuck with ThinkPad quality audio. I have 3 ThinkPads (one with straight ArchLinux, 2 with CachyOS) and there's always some little piece I'm annoyed with. The X1C has good battery life, the T480 and P14s are meh. I JUST bought my first HiDPI Lenovo laptop this weekend. Getting that to be a decent tradeoff between readable text and mongo-duplo-massive UI has been "fun". (Yoga 15.3" Aura edition - I really like it) But running apps in Wine is darn near impossible - the text is for ants! All of these issues go away with Mac and Windows. I'm not giving up on Linux, I'm just a realist.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
My last decent PC laptop was a Lenovo Thinkpad T530. That thing was a chunky black brick and felt like it was made from recycled Soviet-era tanks. Super modular, easy to upgrade RAM, drives, etc. I got practically 10 years out of it. My next machine was a Dell XPS (Infinity Edge) laptop. I ordered it direct from Dell, unboxed it, turned it on and let it run the standard set of Windows updates. Came back an hour later and it was hung in a BSOD state. Rebooted and everything seemed to be working smoothly again but it was... concerning so I left it running overnight. Came back to YET ANOTHER BSOD the next morning and was like F### this. Immediately RMA and sent it back. If your QC is a hot circle of garbage for a nearly $3000 machine then I have zero faith in your company.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I got my first Dell laptop, the XPS15, 5 years ago. Prior to that I had a good 25 years as a Thinkpad die-hard. The XPS has been ... ok. I've had some issues with it resetting for no apparent reason over its life. Frequency varies, but sometimes it'll just blank the screens and then the BIOS comes up on the display, a few times a week, then it'll be good for a month or more. I had one issue where I needed to ship it back: it would reset and then it was running off the battery, and no matter what port I plugged a charger/docking station into it wouldn't charge until I powered it off and back on again. I got them to do a replacement under warranty a couple years ago. Around a month ago it was doing the reset fairly frequently and then wouldn't power on sometimes, and I noticed the wrist rest was a little bowed. I replaced the battery pack (kind of a pain, but not the worst I've done), and it was good for around a month, but now it has that "won't charge the battery" issue again. I believe when they did the previous repair they replaced the motherboard, but now I'm out of warranty. For my next laptop I kind of want a Framework, so I can replace the mobo if I need to. My work likes us to replace hardware no more frequently than every 5-6 years, but we get a warranty for way less than that (my laptop I pushed to get a 4 year). Meanwhile my previous Thinkpad T470s is still going strong, though the screen just developed a line through it. That's ~10 year old now. My person
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I recently got a new Thinkpad for work, can't recall which model. I think L series? The build quality is nicer than my T530. The bottom cover doesn't have access panels anymore, but it's got just a few captive(!!) screws and the whole bottom comes off. Everything is neatly exposed and you don't need to access the top of the board at all. The bottom cover has plastic clips along with the screws, but they're spring loaded! They aren't simply molded in and cannot snap off. It's some incredible attention to detail. I've noticed that most recent laptops have the vent behind the screen hinge where it's completely blocked if the screen is closed. Thinkpad has the vent fully exposed. In fact, it exposes more vent when the screen is closed. Too bad the CPU is a lemon. One of the new AMD chips with a built in NPU. The NPU is slower than the integrated graphics for inference. Not a discrete card, just the GPU baked into the chip. In contrast, I got a hand-me-down Dell XPS-something from 2020 when I first started this job. It idles IDLES! at 100°C. I tried to re-paste the CPU, but the heat pipes were so small and thin that I crushed one between my fingers. Even with massive airflow through the case from external fans, it never drops below 100C. Absolutely inexcusable. Looks to me like Lenovo still has it. At least if you're paying real money for a professional level machine. This new Thinkpad is now my #1 most repairable and maintainable machine. T530 is a close second. Absolutely ever
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I was given a 2023 Dell XPS 13 for work. I was pretty stoked to go back to an XPS after using one in 2019 for work. For some reason, the MOBO was dying slowly after a year. My other coworkers also reported similar problems. Lenovo-wise: My personal Thinkpad X1 Extreme was a champ for 7+ years, and a few P series I've used over the years since 2021 were also great. At the end, I just built a desktop and use a Macbook Air. So far so good.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I have a 2017 Dell XPS13 that's been hammered as a developer laptop and is still going great guns. It's on its third battery, and I've just replaced the screen. I bought a newer one in 2022 and sold it again a couple of months later because, although it had a faster processor and more RAM, it felt flimsier. I'm also currently upgrading a refurbed Lenovo X270 for my granddaughter who's starting high school, and I am thoroughly impressed. Newer Lenovos are slimmer and slicker, but this thing will still be trucking after the cockroach apocalypse.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
> Realistically you might get the same mileage with a Dell, but to fans, it feels different. Not quite, and I tried. Dell laptops with bother you if your power supply is not a genuine dell one. Dell refused to repair a second-hand dell laptop (xps 15) under warranty because I did not have the receipt of original purchased. Lenovo repaired my second-hand ThinkPad no question asked, because it was still under warranty. And the laptop i bought had the pick&return warranty package, so they sent a courier to pick the laptop from my home and they delivered it back within the same week. Dell has been just unreliable in my experience. I fixed that laptop myself and sold it as soon as I could (and bought another used ThinkPad).
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
This is precisely the reason I switched over. The QA control for 99% of Windows laptops is completely hit or miss. My last decent Windows machine was a Lenovo T530. That thing was a workstation and didn't pretend to be anything else. Modular, easy to replace components, that thing got out of my way and just worked. That was over a decade ago. After that I had nothing but irritating issues. Everything from poor wifi (looking at you Killer), poor battery life (2 hours max), ventilation issues and overheating, etc. Example: My Dell XPS with InfinityEdge screen looked amazing. What was less amazing was the constant BSODs on a brand new machine within a few months of light usage. I switched to a MBP Max M1 and haven't looked back.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I bought a Dell XPS about 4 years ago, and having used them for work I was excited to get one for myself. A few years later (I think 2 years), the battery failed to hold any charge whatsoever. When I called support to _buy_ (with money!) a new battery pack, they told me that it was impossible, that they no longer held them in stock. I will never buy another Dell Laptop again. Have been more than pleased with my Thinkpad T495, and will be buying a Framework laptop after this one dies.
Dell XPS: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I have the same Z13 laptop with the fancy OLED but (until recently) with the Fedora preload instead of Ubuntu. It had a lot of bugs---to the point where I think it could have had a defect (especially after half of the keyboard stopped accepting keypresses even in BIOS and even after full power down and restart; the solution was to plug in the USB charger. Epic WTF). More likely, Lenovo/Mark Pearson were put in a bad place of, "we're releasing for Windows whether you're ready or not!" I suspect the latter because the support forum would often have "we're waiting on the BIOS team", "Intel doesn't have a driver for that webcam", "the haptic thing will get a utility soon", "the temperature issue is known", "the higher resolution timer is unstable", and so on. The XPS 9370, for me, had ZERO problems. To the point where I wondered often why there aren't more Linux users. It felt like all of my previous Linux pain (especially a life chapter of running Linux on a Chromebook) had gone away. I looked into a recent XPS but for a variety of reasons (keyboard layout availability in Europe, Michael Dell's political beliefs, wanting to switch away from Ubuntu's snaps and UX, reports of hardware issues on Reddit) I decided to try out "the other" major laptop brand with Linux offerings. Maybe I just got lucky with the last laptop? Forcing a BIOS reset and installing Windows made enough problems go away that I now just run Fedora Remix as a WSL distribution. Annoyingly, the thing gets hotter t…
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I remember the boot roulette with my XPS. The laptop randomly just wouldn't turn on. I learned that biggest chance for it to turn on was to disconnect power, plug it back in and quickly press the power button and hold. Sometimes it took half an hour of this dance. Eventually it stopped turning on. The "good" thing was that when this happened I bought a cheap post lease Thinkpad and just put my XPS's nvme in. I could resume work straight away it just worked. I paid £100 for that Thinkpad and it was miles better than then flagship XPS. That being said, I decided to take a plunge and bought M1 Max. This think is next level and smokes any laptops I had before. But Dell in comparison is just complete junk and that company should be banned from making laptops.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I'm on the latest kernel (Arch btw) and I still have to manually "sleep" my Dell XPS 9500. To add insult to injury, it's not even "real" S3 sleep. It's Microsoft, "we want access to your machine 24/7" S1 sleep. To be fair, I haven't spent much time in the last year messing with any of that. I do miss the days when I could shut the lid on my old Thinkpad, it'd sleep, and I'd open it a day later to an i3lock screen, and it would have only drained a percentage point.
Dell XPS: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
Anecdata, but before going all-in on ThinkPads I though I share my experience. For the ThinkPad x13 2nd gen Ryzen I received for a customer project (with the customer not interested in getting it back after the project was completed) it's too early to say anything about reliability, but somehow the touchpad isn't centered properly and I always hit left click when I want right click - it's unbearable and surprisingly bad for a ThinkPad. Before, I had an ThinkPad E495 Ryzen that worked ok but after two years the touchpad got stuck - the pointless (for me!) construction with touch point and extra mechanical buttons (only acting as barrier) certainly didn't help. Before, I had my beloved Dell XPS 2016 which however had a swollen battery. Still, I consider it one of the best notebooks I had; gnome 2 and Unity also just got it right. In the last four years I got five (!) ThinkPad and Dell Precision notebooks for customer projects having battery or memory problems OOTB (the x13 I mentioned above was a notebook that finally worked). The notebook I used for the longest time (7 years) was a PowerBook G4 2003. I hope my current MacBook M1 will last me about as long, but at least 5 years. In terms of power management, display, and usability, a Mac notebook is in another league compared to Dells and ThinkPads with Linux, it's not even funny. Linux desktops have regressed to the point they have ceased to be usable for me. With the newer MacBooks, I think Apple listened to customers and na