The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell XPS vs Framework Laptop

Hacker News owners lean toward the Framework Laptop.

Dell XPSFramework Laptop
Owners with an opinion659751
Positive verdicts48% of 58371% of 661
Positive/negative since 202472/97309/139
Happy after 3+ years4924
Longest happy owner20 yrs5 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancerepairability and reliability
Criticized forbatterybattery and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
I've had Dell XPSs and Lenovo Thinkpads exclusively prior to Framework, and they all died by component failure. Sure, Dell will send a technician to your house and Lenovo has off-shore call centers, but the end result is the same: either buy an eye-wateringly expensive warranty that won't cover most failures or buy a new laptop. While I'm all for stronger consumer regulation when it comes to this stuff, on balance I prefer the Framework approach here relative to the other options available to me.
Dell XPS: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
having 2 fw 13s this is my experience as well (and also friends who bought into FW); i was willing to give the 13 pro a try until they downgraded my order. I inevitably cancelled and went with a dell xps14 and its a fantastic laptop. I am unsure bout any future fw purchases. also my m1 macbook pro is made so well I've abused this to the cows come home and i feel like it still has another 3+ years to it.. everytime someone brings up the e-waste aspects of fw, i don't know if its that simple...because i've definitely already generated much more e-waste with my frameworks than any other laptop i've bought in the last decade that being said, i do like the fw vision, but they might be trying to do TOO much that their quality is suffering for it
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
I've had this sort of thing happen with a Dell XPS, and their response was "purchase a new laptop". While it would be great if we had stronger consumer protection, for both economic and environmental reasons I prefer the Framework approach.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Yeah, really impressive to see that you can take a 13 and turn it into a 13 pro with just a few new parts. I've just ordered my own 13 pro. I've been waiting for a laptop and this ticks all the boxes. I'd previously ordered a new dell xps laptop and ultimately returned it because the keyboard was busted. I would have kept it if I could have swapped the keyboard for a new one. The use of LPCAMM is also really nice. I've hoped to see this standard start taking flight and I'm happy to grab a product with it included.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
The recent-ish Dell XPS I had for work was the worst hardware I've ever had in my entire life, full stop. The touchpad was an abomination. Like, nobody bothered to use it before it shipped. Just completely broken. I also experienced everything else you experienced with regard to power management. That fact that a team of human beings could create something so awful actually made me depressed. Very happy with my framework when I switched jobs. And my asus zenbook was also great.
Dell XPS: Likes itFramework Laptop: Recommends it
We're blood brothers my friend. Never again on Asus (though I do have a traitorous exception for mother boards, though I'm trying to change). I also refuse HP stuff for the same reason. Could be so good, but brittle easily broken parts end up wiping out all the quality stuff. Definitely take a look at Framework laptops ( https://frame.work ). Unless they lose their way, I don't plan to buy anything else. I've also had great luck with Lenovo T* line (my T580 was one of my favorites of all time). Dell makes some gorgeous stuff as well (though I go with the business line of XPS, I forget what they're called at the moment, maybe Precision?). If you're going with Dell, Ubuntu or a derivative works a little better. I've had friction in the past with Fedora and Arch on Dell because it takes 6 to 9 months for all the drivers to make it upstream to the kernel, so if the model is new within 6 to 9 months you're stuck relying on Dell's build.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
That makes sense. My assumption prior to purchasing these devices was that AMD support would be the main reason for me returning them. I was quite surprised to see just how well everything worked, and, in fact, these devices have given me much less trouble than my i7-1165G7 Dell XPS 13". In fact, these devices has worked so well that it's really made me more excited about consumer technology and new laptops and portables than I have been in a long time! I am worried that I may be mistakenly generalising this to all AMD devices. I have even been considering ditching Intel for my next laptop upgrade…
Dell XPS: NeutralFramework Laptop: Likes it
I also have a first gen Framework. I've used the following recently: - Framework 1st gen - Dell XPS 13 - Macbook Pro 14" (m1) - Dell Precision 5570 I wouldn't say that the framework is perfect, there are a number of minor complaints I have with it. However, it holds its own, and I really do love it, especially while running linux. I hope that Framework the company continues to support the early models with new mainboards and parts. If so, I'll be a very loyal customer. Oh, and the fact that I know I'll be able to replace the battery when the time comes is a beautiful feeling!
Dell XPS: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
> battery benefits of Linux In my experience, battery life under windows is far superior due to more mature drivers. I'm lucky to get 4hrs out of my Framework laptop (with the i5-1240p) whereas Windows nets 6+. And that's with a 6.x kernel that has 12th gen support (I'm running Fedora as per Framework's recommendation). My old XPS 15 had much better battery life but a similar drop (percentage wise) running Ubuntu.
Dell XPS: NeutralFramework Laptop: Likes it
But you're in a thread about how the GP's Mac didn't last two years. I'm fairly sure I will be using my Framework laptop as my daily driver in 2026, maybe with one motherboard replacement. I just switched from my 2017 XPS, and I do development work. I gave it to my dad, who loves it and will probably hold on to it for another few years. It's a bit odd to be saying this about pre-M1 Macs, as they were "just" Intel machines, same as everything else.
Dell XPS: Likes itFramework Laptop: Neutral
The best Laptops I ever had were all from dell. Started with the Dell XPS 12 and the rotatable screen. I thought this won't last a year. THIS FREAKING THING still works to this day. It is now over 8 years old. Moved to XPS 15 when I started coding at a new company. They were provided by my employee, but we were allowed to install our favorite OS. In my case, this is Arch Linux. For almost all XPS / Latitude and Precision Laptops there is a guide, what needs to be changed to get everything working. They work freakishly well. I am now on a framework laptop (11 gen for linux support), which is also a great Laptop. However, build quality isn't as good when you compare it to a Dell XPS or Precision. Every other Laptop brand I tried sucked in comparison (Lenovo, Acer, Apple all > 2000$).
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Eh - I threw Arch on it right away and it's been ROCK solid. No freezes, no wifi disconnects, running gnome/wayland without any hitches. All ports work fine, settings keys all work fine, basically - no issues at all. Suspend even works relatively well, although I tend to turn on hibernate on lid close since modern laptops boot so quickly, and it entirely eliminates battery drain. I'm also on the 12th gen intel version - None of these issues, so either OP isn't quite as good as he thinks he is, and borked a bunch of things... or the issues op hit are just "Ubuntu" related. Frankly - I like their server products but their consumer desktop releases have been dogshite since they dropped unity. I'd go with basically any other distro at this point for a laptop device (popOS, Arch, Fedora, etc). It's sort of a shame, since Ubuntu was the distro that really focused on consumer support for a while - but they aren't that anymore, at least in my opinion (although again... they do good stuff server side, if only they would cut it out with forcing everything to snaps. I don't even mind snaps, I just want the option to do a real install) --- Long rant aside - it replaced a more expensive Dell XPS that was designed to work with Ubuntu (although I also ran Arch there). The Dell had some of the same issues OP complains about while running Ubuntu - so I would suggest he try something else. I like mine a lot. I didn't have to think about it much. It just runs Arch well.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
I use a mac and a thinkpad for two clients. Great machines. I had an XPS for 1.5 years, with terrible chassis issues that got worse and worse until typing would cause it to freeze. I use a Framework for my daily driver and I couldn't be happier! I do have the occasional issue with a WD-SN850 that causes freezing, but that isn't due to Framework specifically.
Dell XPS: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
As a framework owner, there's maybe two orders of magnitude difference in build quality between a mac and a framework. The track pad and display suck for a laptop in 2022. The display has issues with calibration and resolution (understandable from where they're at right now, but still it's trash compared to an XPS or MB). The trackpad has mechanical issues that cause it to wiggle, its been reported on the forum (and personally to staff a few times) but they don't seem to have a decent way to fix it. Its been a nightmare calibrating the touchpad to my liking, on my XPS and Macbook it has always "just worked" (even on Linux!)
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
A few weeks ago I spilled an entire cup of sugary espresso on my framework laptop which completely ruined my keyboard by making it a sticky mess. You know what I did? I ordered a replacement keyboard kit for $99, installed it in ~5 minutes, and I haven't thought about it since. Some other part will fail in the future, or I'll spill another cup of coffee, and when that happens all I need to worry about is swapping out the affected parts. And that's great compared to my previous alternatives with an XPS, which was basically to buy a brand new laptop.
Dell XPS: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
Framework laptop is certainly cool if you like to change out ports and want to repair your own laptop, but you are currently giving up quite a bit if you choose to get one: * No AMD offerings, at all. The AMD 5900 processors have been available since EOY 2019 and dominate this 11 series processor on performance/battery life * No dedicated GPU options, period. * Even if you stay with intel, the processors are basically 2 revisions behind now. * Form factor is quite a bit more bulky than its competitors, even considering the fact parts are removable. * No guarantee of companies longevity for future bios updates / repair parts * Price is quite a bit more expensive for what you get, compared to its competitors. For instance, This dell will be more powerful, slimmer and cost less ( https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/dell-laptops/xps-13-plus-lap... ) I love the reparability of the framework, but I just cant get around the drawbacks if you choose to go with them. Its not even a issue of money. You cant pay more to match features of other 'non repairable' laptops. You just have to accept a inferior product compared to other options.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
+1 for Framework as well. With recently launching a company, I have been evaluating laptop builds for my soon-to-hire employees. Thinkpads were at the top followed by XPS builds (which have been terribly variable in quality in recent year, unfortunately). I am now using a Framework as a daily driver w/ Fedora and it is wonderful! Deep sleep needs work still, but everything else is working great. Plus Framework works well with Windows as well.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Likewise, 2021 Dell XPS 15. Had to retire it very early -- trackpad issues, then frame deformation caused by moving the laptop would cause the RAM or the CPU to crash. Framework working great now.
Dell XPS: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Both my XPS 13 and XPS 15 rock on the table due to being flexed somehow. Last week I was sitting in a meeting and tilted my screen up a little on the XPS 15 so I could see past some glare from lights and the hinge snapped. It has the smallest little piece of metal at the point it snapped, about 3-4mm wide and 1-2mm thick, it was no wonder it snapped, so work had to give me a new XPS 15. The hinge itself is plastic-welded to the chassis so it can't just he replaced without the whole chassis being replaced. I was planning for my next laptop to be a Framework anyway but my (£1600) XPS 13 is only ~2 years old so I am a little way from wanting to buy a new laptop just yet. This sort of behaviour from DELL is confirming that going Framework is probably the right choice. EDIT: Also don't get me started on the i9 / 4K XPS 15 a friend of mine bought that seems to want to kill itself any time it's switched on, and has never worked correctly since day dot.