The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell XPS 15 vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Dell XPS 15Lenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion1102732
Positive verdicts42% of 9675% of 2366
Positive/negative since 20246/10686/273
Happy after 3+ years3281
Longest happy owner5 yrs25 yrs
Praised forreliability and displayreliability and performance
Criticized forbattery and noisebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I got my first Dell laptop, the XPS15, 5 years ago. Prior to that I had a good 25 years as a Thinkpad die-hard. The XPS has been ... ok. I've had some issues with it resetting for no apparent reason over its life. Frequency varies, but sometimes it'll just blank the screens and then the BIOS comes up on the display, a few times a week, then it'll be good for a month or more. I had one issue where I needed to ship it back: it would reset and then it was running off the battery, and no matter what port I plugged a charger/docking station into it wouldn't charge until I powered it off and back on again. I got them to do a replacement under warranty a couple years ago. Around a month ago it was doing the reset fairly frequently and then wouldn't power on sometimes, and I noticed the wrist rest was a little bowed. I replaced the battery pack (kind of a pain, but not the worst I've done), and it was good for around a month, but now it has that "won't charge the battery" issue again. I believe when they did the previous repair they replaced the motherboard, but now I'm out of warranty. For my next laptop I kind of want a Framework, so I can replace the mobo if I need to. My work likes us to replace hardware no more frequently than every 5-6 years, but we get a warranty for way less than that (my laptop I pushed to get a 4 year). Meanwhile my previous Thinkpad T470s is still going strong, though the screen just developed a line through it. That's ~10 year old now. My person
Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
> Realistically you might get the same mileage with a Dell, but to fans, it feels different. Not quite, and I tried. Dell laptops with bother you if your power supply is not a genuine dell one. Dell refused to repair a second-hand dell laptop (xps 15) under warranty because I did not have the receipt of original purchased. Lenovo repaired my second-hand ThinkPad no question asked, because it was still under warranty. And the laptop i bought had the pick&return warranty package, so they sent a courier to pick the laptop from my home and they delivered it back within the same week. Dell has been just unreliable in my experience. I fixed that laptop myself and sold it as soon as I could (and bought another used ThinkPad).
Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I still have a gen1 x1 extreme and its going strong. Runs fedora flawlessly. If I don't buy Apple then I aint buying anything other than Lenovo. Work gave me a DELL XPS 15, one of the worst laptops ever. 2 jobs, 2 XPS's, both 2 generations apart and both terrible plagued with issues.
Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Build quality on non-Apple machines have been rough for me. I burned through both an XPS 15 (caseflex causes restarts with keyboard use) and a Framework (random restarts, never could pin down the hardware issue even with mainboard replacement). The I've settled on a good ThinkPad and, honestly, I set the power settings simple and just keep it in a docked state. Never even think about it!
Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
It’s amazing that my ThinkPad x1 extreme with a 7th gen Intel compiles my project faster than my dell XPS 15 with 12th gen cpu. I’m convinced the heat and throttling kills the 12th gen laptops. Apple did the right thing dropping Intel.
Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Back when Dell had its Latitude series they were known for being as indestructible as the Thinkpads. Little did I know how shitty Dell laptops were afterwards. My excourse had gone through the 300/310 Touch Ultrabook series, the XPS13 and XPS15 series, and the Dell Precision series. Bought 5 laptops from Dell, all broken within under a year of lifetime. It was so bad that in the Ultrabook the GPU literally melted, and they claimed this laptop is working totally fine by just using the internal display with more artifacts than actual pixels. And now, here I am in 2022, using my Thinkpad from 2012...because it keeps working. I don't even know what to buy after the Thinkpad dies, so I have one other as a spare parts donator.
Dell XPS 15: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Funny that, when my beefed up XPS 15 finally died, I went on eBay on got one of those Thinkpads dumped by corporations for like £120. I put in the NVMe drive from the XPS and... it was working out of the box. What is surprising that it feels much faster, fans don't make as much noise that despite weaker CPU and 4x less RAM. I really like it. I got an M1 Pro as well, but Thinkpad will be a nice backup machine.
Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I've noticed they have gotten worse. After three bad MacBook Pros in a row, I bought a used 2015 MacBook Air, which has never given me a problem. The pros all had battery/power issues, shutting down randomly several times a day. The keyboards were also horrible. I've been a Thinkpad fan for years, and I use a Carbon X1 with Linux outside of work. No complaints about that, though I do wonder if it's as physically durable as the older, bulkier models. I've noticed Lenovo is putting out more consumer grade laptops now. I don't know about their quality, but it doesn't seem as high as their professional line. My son has a Dell XPS 15, and had to replace a loud, failing fan after a year. I suppose manufacturers face a lot of pressure selling to consumers who don't know what to look for in terms of quality and don't understand why two visually similar machines with similar specs would be priced so differently. The low-end machines in Walmart look just like the high-end machines at Best Buy. The business grade machines from Lenovo, Dell, and HP have incentive to be higher quality because businesses often buy them with high level service plans. Lenovo, Dell and HP really don't want to send techs into the field to service laptops if they can avoid it, and the best way to avoid that is to build a good product.
Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I have older XPS 13. I bought a M1 PRO recently, because I was tired of issues with my XPS 15 (which eventually died - won't power on). I wish I didn't have the mindset that XPS was enough for me. For instance when I am running tests on M1, they finish in about a minute, whereas on XPS I could go on a quick coffee break. Having ADHD it was a productivity killer. On M1 I can fire off tests, read something quickly on interwebs and then go back to developing in no time. Best of all, no distracting fans (it has fans, and sometimes they do activate, but I wouldn't know if I hadn't installed a fan monitor - they are that silent). > and setting up the dual-boot myself. Only good thing about XPS is that you can replace the NVMe drive. So when I bought mine, I also bought a separate NVMe drive and simply removed the one laptop came with and just installed Linux on a new drive. When my XPS died, I could buy a cheap used laptop (got a ThinkPad!) and put my XPS's drive in it and recover any data I needed. With M1 you don't have that option sadly.
Dell XPS 15: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
> Then don't buy an Apple laptop, simple. Buy a Thinkpad that is almost indestructible and you don't have these kind of problems, or as I did a Dell XPS 15 (though I can't talk about how solid it is, since I have it only since 2 months). Sure but now I have to use Windows if I do that, unless there are Thinkpads that come with support for Linux from the OEM.
Dell XPS 15: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
Then don't buy an Apple laptop, simple. Buy a Thinkpad that is almost indestructible and you don't have these kind of problems, or as I did a Dell XPS 15 (though I can't talk about how solid it is, since I have it only since 2 months). Surely I would prefer Dell for the support, I have 1 year of premium assistance (if there is a fault a technician will come where I am to make the repair, I don't have to bring it to a store that takes days to do the repair on a computer that I need for my job) and with like 20$ more I got the coverage even for accidental damage. Apple doesn't have correct policy, first it doesn't recognize in warranty faults that should, and secondly repairs outside the warranty period cost more than buying a new computer, and it doesn't sell spare parts to others that are not Apple authorized repair center (that needs to apply the policy of Apple otherwise they will not send the spare parts): something called mafia.
Dell XPS 15: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I've also been a ThinkPad user since the IBM days, but my most recent work laptop was a Dell XPS15. It has been working fine for me. For my home laptop, I had been using, for around the last 4 years, an HP Chrome 13 g1 Chromebook (6Y75), which I really loved. Got one for my son for last Christmas for $120 landed. 16GB RAM, 32GB SSD, 2560x1440 display. The original one I got for $550, it was refurbed on woot. List price was more over a grand, but I wasn't prepared to spend that on the experiment. For the longest time it didn't support the Linux containers, but that got remedied last year. I was mostly using it for the browser and using a Chrome extension to SSH into my work machines. With the Linux containers, it's a full Linux environment, though with some restrictions. However, over it's life it lived very well up to the "just works" idea that I got it initially to try out. OS updates are super fast (they just show up and when you reboot next they are there, <30 seconds). If you need a full laptop running Linux, you're going to just need to get a laptop. I'd probably consider another Dell, it has worked fine. My last Thinkpad had some weird battery issues, and because of it's slim config it had two small batteries and I wasn't quite ready to have work buy $300+ of batteries for a problem I couldn't reliably reproduce. But, I'd definitely consider a Chromebook with Linux containers for lighter duty work.
Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I think it depends on your needs, really. When I bought a laptop in December of last year, I narrowed my options down to a Dell XPS 15 and a Thinkpad T15 (both with the Intel CPUs, although AMD seemed to perform better on benchmarks, Dell doesn't even ship with them and the Thinkpad with AMD wasn't available in my region). I didn't consider System76 much because I need Windows support, and sadly couldn't go for a framework because they didn't ship to where I needed. I ended up going for the Thinkpad even though it has a worse screen, because I read many negative things about defects in XPS laptops, the CPU was of a lower tier but apparently more energy efficient (also I learned that laptop CPUs are a mess), the Thinkpad has more varied ports, and it has the trackpoint. I was pleasantly surprised to learn that many top of the line laptops (not counting Apple of course) now have user upgreadable components -- both of my options had upgradeable hard drives and ram. Back to my original point, for my workload I didn't need more than 16gb of ram, or a dedicated GPU, or good Linux support (although I heard it's pretty good for Thinkpads at least), so my option made sense to me -- and still it set me back almost 2 grand, so not an easy choice. I expect this device to last at least 5 years, which puts the cost into perspective to me.
Dell XPS 15: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
My gf bought a dell xps 15" with OLED and an i9 processor. I think it was reasonably priced compared to competitors but it just so happened that her screen broke, or it got loose. She called Dell and they sent a new one so she could transfer her work over to the new machine and picked up the other one a few days after. All and all it was a good customer experience. In my view, it seems like it has good build quality (in general, stuff can happen) and good customer support. Although she will never run linux on it. This website reads like a frustrated developer who decided to take matters into his own hands. I am very doubtful that this is the common experience, at least if you order directly from them. Sure it may have driver issues but at least they have an option to ship it with linux and without paying the windows tax, most companies don't even do that. I personally use a Thinkpad t460p from 2013 that runs Ubuntu and still works great honestly, even the battery life. I will soon upgrade to a desktop instead of a laptop so that I can run more heavy duty stuff like training models.
Dell XPS 15: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Yep. Even the 14 & 16" MBP with M1 Pros stay much cooler & quieter than your typical AMD/Intel Windows laptop. Silence is golden, and even on the odd occasion where the fan on the 14" M1 Pro starts spinning (e.g. running Cinebench to purposefully max all cores), it's extremely difficult to notice without your ear right up against the laptop. By comparison, my Windows work laptops (previously an XPS 15, now a ThinkPad T14 Gen2) become plainly audible from 10ft+ away just attending a Teams meeting.
Dell XPS 15: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
The whole S3 sleep fiasco is the stuff of nightmares. I have a gen 6 X1 Carbon too and I've gotten it sleeping very well. I also have a Dell XPS 15 that I love but... it's been 2 years since it was brand new and it's still stuck on S2 "idle". As I understand it, Microsoft wants it this way so they can maintain network connectivity. My major gripe with the Lenovo is the 16 gigs of RAM soldered on the board. It's so nice to be able to pop open my Dell and put up to 64 gigs in there, while replacing the SSD in one of the two M2 slots. Then again, I'm typing this on a 2019 Macbook Pro (Intel) that has nary a single replaceable part.
Dell XPS 15: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I used ThinkPads for a decade, and then XPS13 for the last 8 years (plus a year on XPS15 for my personal machine before switching back to XPS13). The XPS13s ran Linux for most of that time. My current work XPS13 is Windows 11 plus WSL2 running Ubuntu 22.04. I like the XPS13 for its small physical size, good Linux compatibility (if buying a brand new model, wait for the first BIOS point release to come out before purchasing) and in recent models, the 16x10 rather than 16x9 screen. Quality is ok. Needed one motherboard replacement (under warranty) in 8 years, and that's running/cycling every day with the laptop in my backpack. The other thing is I use it with an external monitor above the laptop. Don't use an external keyboard because I don't mind the XPS13 keyboard [1] and don't want to be changing keyboards between work/home/while travelling. [1] Apart from the new touch-sensitive function key row... Just give me normal keys that depress. I won't buy the 2022 XPS13 if I can't buy one with a proper keyboard.