The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell XPS 13 vs Lenovo ThinkPad X1

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Lenovo ThinkPad X1.

Dell XPS 13Lenovo ThinkPad X1
Owners with an opinion256376
Positive verdicts64% of 22271% of 335
Positive/negative since 202423/2298/57
Happy after 3+ years2228
Longest happy owner12 yrs11 yrs
Praised forreliability and displayreliability and performance
Criticized forbattery and performancebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
The 2017 Dell developer edition XPS 13 with Ubuntu is actually one of the systems that gave me the most trouble, quite ironically. Bluetooth loved to disappear for no reason and would only return with a reboot. No amount of unloading/reloading modules could bring it back. Didn't have any issues with Windows on that laptop. Current laptop is a Lenovo X1 Nano and it's behaving reasonably.
Dell XPS 13: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
Really? When? I rolled a lenovo x1 as my daily driver about 5 years ago. I don’t recall a single thing not working. The Dell xps13 was similarly fine (except for coil whine which I am told is not os specific). The only thing that didn’t work was trackpad smooth scrolling and pointer precision.
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I use a X1 Carbon Gen 9 for my daily driver after switching from Gen 6. I still love both. I have been using Arch primarily which has a great wiki for installing in case you were leaning that way. Ubuntu is also spot on for all drivers. I only had an issue with the battery in the Gen 6 early on, which was fixed within two days by replacing it (under warranty). I have not had any issues with my Gen 9 (though it is only 5 months old). Firmware is incredibly easy to update on it under linux. I also from time to time swap out the M.2 SSD with windows when I need it. The screws are super simple and you won't lose them. I have used a XPS 13 in the past, though it is an okay alternative, I will say, the keyboard is super compact and inconvenient. The battery is iffy (one friend's exploded on him), mine just did not last long. The form factor was nice, but it did not feel nearly as nice as the X1 Carbon.
Dell XPS 13: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
I've had a Lenovo x1 carbon (latest gen) earlier this year for work - hardware compatibility for linux is good, didn't really like the typing experience and the touchpad is imo awful. For my personal laptop, I have Arch (Manjaro) on a 13" xps 9130, and wouldn't trade it for anything. Screen is beautiful, keyboard is the best I've ever used (including new m1 macbooks), touchpad is fantastic - It's the perfect little laptop, imo.
Dell XPS 13: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
TLDR: If you don't care about USB-C charging I'd suggest a Librem. Otherwise, I'd go with the new X1 Carbon. I initially switched from an MBP to an XPS13. Pretty good, but I wasn't super super happy with it, nothing wrong in particular, but it felt a bit plastic-y. Then bought a Lenovo X1C6 as soon as it was announced last year and I'm very happy with it: super solid and no issues with any component. I also bought a Librem 13 because I wanted a free laptop and because why I love the X1C6 as a machine, I'm not willing to trust Lenovo 100% as far as ethics go. The Librem is a beautiful machine and works really well, however I'm not willing to use it as my main driver because it doesn't have USB-C charging. As soon as they'll release a model with USB-C charging, I'll get it and switch to it.
Dell XPS 13: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
I used Linux for 10 years (mainly on Lenovos and some early Dell XPS back in the days), then I switched to MacOS about 3-4 years ago and over the last couple weeks I have been trying to go back to Linux because I am sick having to use MacOS everyday. It is a great OS for an everyday user, but not for a developer. Here is what I tried so far: 1) Dell XPS 9370 Developer edition: This comes preloaded with Ubuntu and it is actually amazing that everything works out of the box. It was too small for me though, and the fan made a rattling noise so I decided to return it. The 4K screen is probably overkill on such a small display. Based on the review people recommend taking the normal screen, it saves a lot of battery and there is not that much difference. 2) Lenovo X1: I didn't like the feel of the Keyboard, and the screen was not that good. Installing Linux (Arch) was easy, but decided to return it. 3) Dell XPS 9570: I have this one for the last two weeks and so far I love it on the hardware level. I would even put it as somehow superior to my MacBook Pro. The downside is that Linux is not well supported at all. I have installed Arch so far and spent all my evenings trying to fix all the drivers. So far: The Nvidia drivers are barely working, ACPI needs a lot of tweaks (but it seems I got it working and got my 7 hours of battery). I still need to work on the Touchpad, and couple other things. So far, the Dell XPS 9570 is a good challenger to the MBP, but installing Linux is still
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 to the Dell XPS 13Dell XPS 13: Likes it
Had a 220. Looooved it. It probably even had the substandard screen. But my X1 Carbon Gen4 (I don't upgrade too often) was terrible. I never thought I would be one to say this: it was probably the keyboard I disliked the most. Now rocking a Dell XPS 13 (7390) and it's great. The light keyboard is fine. I've tried colleagues Apples of varying styles and never like the keyboard or trackpad. (Included because I consider the Dell design to be superficially similar, or at least both are in contrast to the IBM/Lenovo nice keyboard philosophy of yesteryear). I hear more negative reports about more recent XPS 13s than mine but I'm still not going back to Lenovo.
Dell XPS 13: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Recommends it
I'm surprised/pleased that this time around we have more 16x10 displays than not. System76 Oryx Pro - Best Linux laptop for performance and customer service Dell XPS 13 Plus Developer Edition - Best Linux laptop for overall design Star Labs StarFighter - Best Linux laptop for configurability HP Dev One - Best Linux laptop for developers Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 10 - Best Linux laptop keyboard Only the "System76 Oryx Pro" and "HP Dev One" are 16x9 displays.