The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell XPS 13 vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Dell XPS 13Lenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion2562732
Positive verdicts64% of 22275% of 2366
Positive/negative since 202423/22686/273
Happy after 3+ years22281
Longest happy owner12 yrs25 yrs
Praised forreliability and displayreliability and performance
Criticized forbattery and performancebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
This weekend I installed Haiku on my old Thinkpad X40. It’s fast and surprisingly stable. Emacs, VLC works like a charm. Computer to slow for web browsing. The BeProductive office suite is a masterpiece of application at a 9MB download; although not open source. Then I installed Haiku on my XPS13 under KVM/Qemu. Everything runs blazingly fast. I’m thinking of maybe using that install for organizing my photos. The metadata functionality built into the BeFS is great for that. I must say that I am really impressed.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Yet after 14 years you still have it and use it? Quality also went down while with later models - back in 2014 I was laptop shopping, based on the X2xx series reputation I tested an X240 and it was crap, even the keyboard was super bad, I ended up getting a Dell xps13 whose keyboard was miles better and it still works today.
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
The last reliable laptops I had were IBM T40 (my first one) and IBM/Lenovo W500. I ran a bootstrapped software company and they didn't fail me. After that I briefly had a Samsung ultrabook (that was semi-reliable) and then a Dell XPS 13 that one day had a screen crack when I opened it. Then I switched to MacBooks when M1 came out: first keys got stuck in my M1, then the screen bezel spontaneously cracked on an M2 just when the warranty ended and I was in Europe. Apparently now Apple laptops are luxury items, you have to wipe the keyboard from dust before closing the lid. I do not care about cost, I just need something that won't suddenly break when I am abroad and need to do something important. I miss those American IBM ThinkPads.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Spent like $2000 NZD on a new XPS 13 to replace my old XPS 13 from ~2017 - a device I loved. The new one was a piece of hot garbage. Overheat and throttled playing League of Legends - a game that has ran adequately on every other piece of hardware I've owned since 2011? I couldn't understand how a 2022 device would run so much worse than 2017 device and assumed it was faulty. Returned, given a replacement, same issue. It is quite literally not built to hand the heat from the Intel chip doing very minimal stuff. I refuse to use a laptop that sounds like a jet engine when Microsoft is doing basic background stuff. Returned and ended up buying a used 15 inch T-type Thinkpad with an AMD chip recommended by Reddit for $500 NZD. Runs great, cool, and quiet. It's much bigger and bulkier that the Dell but I don't mind. Note: Not a Thinkpad fanboy, work has given me an X1 Carbon that I dislike for the same reasons I didn't like the new XPS 13 - it's useable, but it's still much hotter and louder than I would like.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
In my experience, it's entirely manufacturer-dependent. Comparing Apple, Dell and Lenovo, the Dell and the Apple machines (MacBook Pros and XPS 13) have had no problems. Both feel as good as the day they were purchased. The Lenovo (ThinkPad P14s/x280) had connectors falling out after around six months - which is particularly annoying given that they charge over USB C. Overall, I've been massively disappointed by the build quality of the more recent ThinkPads, especially since they get a lot of individuals espousing their benefits here, especially over the MacBooks.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
> I've been running OpenBSD on my T480s for a bit now. I think it's an absolutely amazing machine. Same. I've been buying them off-lease for many years. You can usually get them for a couple hundred bucks. Best non-Apple computers I've ever used. Keyboards are awesome. The last laptop I bought was a Dell XPS13 because research indicated it's a pretty popular Linux-compatible laptop. It's nice, but I'm going back to a Thinkpad next...
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I went from a T440s to an XPS 13 (9310). It's my favorite "ultrabook"-type laptop I've owned so far (where the point is moderate specs in a small form factor with great battery life). It beat out my T440s for me because my t440s needed its mobo replaced TWICE because whatever about it that connected it to the trackpad and keyboard kept failing. Whereas my 9310 has been perfect. The only real hiccup I've ever had with it was: - when I bought it, the (intel) wlan card was too new and only arch had the driver in the kernel. - there was some flickering/jittering display problem that started showing up when we bumped kernel major versions somewhere in 2021ish. Was it 5 to 6? Anyway it ended up being reduced by a subsequent kernel update and then fixed when I disabled panel self-refresh (PSR) in the kernel args. But I stayed on the last 5.x kernel for a while until I figured that out. It's also generally impressed me at how well all its USB3/C stuff works. I use it with a dock while at work to drive an external display for personal stuff, and it has also driven a 49" 1440p super ultrawide which impressed me. And it's worked well even when I have literally every port on the dock populated with something or other: display, nic, mouse, kb, webcam, etc etc. with some docks or some laptops I've found that you usually find limitations as you try to use every single port simultaneously. I tend to hold on to laptops that I know work well with all my stuff for well past their technical re…
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Had a 220. Looooved it. It probably even had the substandard screen. But my X1 Carbon Gen4 (I don't upgrade too often) was terrible. I never thought I would be one to say this: it was probably the keyboard I disliked the most. Now rocking a Dell XPS 13 (7390) and it's great. The light keyboard is fine. I've tried colleagues Apples of varying styles and never like the keyboard or trackpad. (Included because I consider the Dell design to be superficially similar, or at least both are in contrast to the IBM/Lenovo nice keyboard philosophy of yesteryear). I hear more negative reports about more recent XPS 13s than mine but I'm still not going back to Lenovo.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I t420s fell out of my opened backpack a couple of days ago. Not the first time it fell, once I even stepped on it - but after the last drop the display has some problems and i have to push on a certain point to get it working, which made me put it to it's well deserved retirement.[*] In need of an quick alternative I bought a Dell XPS 13 9343. I like this a lot - it has a way nicer display, the form factor is just great for my needs, build quality is good and even the keyboard feels right (missing a trackpoint tho). Unfortunately it supports Microsoft's "Modern Standy", which is a fancy name for s2idle - which just doesn't work using Linux, at least I couldn't get it to work . When in s2idle it looses power and does not reliably wake up, in s3 it goes to sleep but needs a hard reset to wake up. Waiting for my t470s now, as far as I know the latest Thinkpad generation stat supports classic s3 sleep. *: Actually it lives on as a small NAS/Homeserver. It even packs three disks (M2 SSD, HDD in the HDD slot and an Ultrabay-HDD adpter).
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I have a Thinkpad P1, which I bought for Linux compatibility. I installed Ubuntu 20.04 on it and have had no issues. However I use the machine semi-strictly for development, and I have a Macbook where I keep my 100-tab browsing, video calls, and document authoring. I previously had an XPS-13 and I ran into a lot of (minor) stuff where the computer would lock up and CPU would max out when having too many tabs open, or e.g. being on a zoom call and trying to alt-tab into g-suite in the browser.
Dell XPS 13: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
Hi! Been running Linux on laptops for years (over a decade). Everything from XPS to Thinkpad and System76. My first recommendation is to check the Linux distro wiki and see what hardware is officially supported. Ubuntu, RHEL / Fedora, and the major distros have lists and tell you what is officially supported; even sometimes down the the piece of hardware (i.e. Thinkpad fingerprint reader) and precise serial numbers. If you're not going to look at the distros wiki or you're not sure what distro you're going to run, the general rule of thumb is the older the hardware the better chance it is of being supported. Now, my personal opinions: I've owned two Thinkpads (x270 & x220), had a dell XPS 13 from work ~4 years ago, and my wife currently owns a System76 Lemur Pro (I have a Thelio Desktop). I've run Ubuntu and RHEL flavored distros on all these. Personally, the Thinkpads blow the Dells and System76 in terms of quality out of the water, and I'd argue they do with hardware support as well (if you're running RHEL / Fedora). The System76 works great with Ubuntu since the drivers and firmware are open (and POP!OS), but I'm not impressed with the quality of the product. Keyboard is low quality, as well as finish (footpads ungluing, finish on keys / track pad coming off, etc.). Dell makes a nice computer, but when I had my XPS 13 there were some major issues with HiDPI (I'm sure it's fixed now). I also didn't like the keyboard and the charging port was finicky. Gonna be honest, you're
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
I don't know if it was clinically RSI, but I had severe cramps in my forearms, shooting pains and tingling sensations from shoulders to hands for about 6 years. Switching from using MacOS laptops back to Gnome 3 (first an XPS 13, currently a Lenovo L14) fixed it in three weeks. I realised in retrospect I had been using Apple laptops for about 6 years. Never going back without a fundamental redesign.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
Yeah I don't use the touchpad most of the time either. With a huge SSD and plenty of RAM, the i7-3520M T430S gets the job done. I'm not entirely pleased with the screen quality, but perhaps I've been spoiled by the IPS display on my personal laptop (Dell XPS 13) and my desktop monitor (Samsung S24C750PS). My one complaint is that the keyboard isn't as robust as previous models. After only a few months I already have some keys which don't work without a firm push. I could sent it away for repair (or replace the keyboard myself) but I can't afford the downtime and tend to use an external mechanical keyboard when I'm not travelling anyway.
Switched from the Dell XPS 13 to the Lenovo ThinkPadLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I've used Lenovo laptops almost exclusively for the past 5 years (coming from a Dell XPS 13). I've had a X1 Carbon, an X1 Yoga, a couple of T4xx, and now a P1 Gen3. All of my lenovos were awesome. None of them had real issue. I love how they're built and their small design decisions. You do have to keep in mind that small devices with great battery lives usually don't have as powerful of a CPU or can't sustain it for long without sounding like a small jet engine, but that's more a question of adjusting ones expectations to what's realistic within a category. This was largely the reason I switched from an ultrabook-y lenovo (X1 Carbon and the Yoga) to a slightly heavier device (P1) when my laptop became my main dev machine during COVID (before that, my laptop was used for hardcore dev work occasionally, but my desktop at the office was my main machine for heavy lifting...)
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad to the Dell XPS 13Dell XPS 13: Recommends it
Happy Dell XPS 13 user here. I have been using it for the past 3 years without any issue. In the same timespan many of my coworkers had to replace/return macbooks (kb glitches, screen issues, battery problems etc). I was a thinkpad only person before that, but the quality went downhill. I am tempted to buy a pixelbook and use linux on it next, the specs/price/quality seem just right.
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
That’s just not true. Every coworker I know who use Linux[1] have occasional issues with webcams, mics, Slack notifications, whatever. It’s all fixable and this kind of inconvenience can be worth it when balanced with the perceived advantages, but saying driver issues are a thing of the past is just a lie. [1]: I’ve seen these issues on Dell (XPS 13), Thinkpads, and HP laptops
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I have a Dell XPS 13 Developer Edition from work that came with Ubuntu 20.04 preinstalled. Basically a flawless experience. I've posted about it on here before, I guess the Windows SKUs are slightly different? People reported different results when installing Linux themselves on top of machines that shipped with Windows. I have a ThinkPad 25 for personal use with Debian and that's great too. For machines that I use routinely I don't have time for any issues.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
At that time I enjoyed my X220. To be sincere, the form-factor and practicality moving from home to work and having the dock. Then the XPS 13 was more perfect for me because I could attach three external monitors and have power just via a single Thunderbolt cable (no more custom docks). The crux for all of these was the battery daily duration and replacement after a few years. In that context the MacBook Airs excel at a point that more expensive and powerful Apple notebooks such as the MacBook Pro cannot sustain a "marathon" without a charger. The issue with the Airs is that you cannot currently connect three external monitors (without doing very hacky things), but this is just a question of time. Also, this obsession from Apple about not having touch screens in notebooks because they also sell iPads is disturbing. Finally, an XPS 13 with good battery support (assuming ARM) and good Linux power handling will, probably, be the best notebook available. (would love if they remove the XPS 13 fan and there are more non-moving part notebooks)
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
> Aside from the processor, there really isn't anything particularly compelling to me about the hardware The trackpad. I've tried a dozen laptops. Thinkpads work great for linux support, as do Dell XPS 13's and the X1 Carbons. But the trackpads on all those pale in comparison to the accuracy of an Apple Trackpad. It's accurate, precise, I can select text anywhere easily, double click works reliably and consistently, and the mouse feels like it is directed exactly where I want. Here's a recent example of a linux distro using libinput: https://old.reddit.com/r/archlinux/comments/sp3yfe/libinput_... There are some good suggestions for improvement in the comments, but the fact remains it is always more frustrating to use a trackpad on a non-apple device. Have the state of trackpads changed in the last 6 months for other laptop vendors? If so I'll seriously consider switching but in my experience, even on Windows, those other laptops don't even come close to what Apple offers. Other sources about the linux trackpad problems, I've not tried these changes but allegedly they're supposed to come close to what Apple offers: https://www.gitclear.com/blog/linux_touchpad_update_december...