The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell XPS 13 vs Framework Laptop

Hacker News owners lean toward the Framework Laptop.

Dell XPS 13Framework Laptop
Owners with an opinion256751
Positive verdicts64% of 22271% of 661
Positive/negative since 202423/22309/139
Happy after 3+ years2224
Longest happy owner12 yrs5 yrs
Praised forreliability and displayrepairability and reliability
Criticized forbattery and performancebattery and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell XPS 13: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
Dell just announced an XPS 13 that is $699 (with a $599 education pricing) and fairly nice CNC machined body (1 kg) and nice screen (2560x1600 30-120 Hz 500 nit 100% DCI-P3). That could be a tempting alternative to the Macbook Neo for people who don't want to use macOS. Unfortunately for the Framework, it is no longer competitive even with other PC laptops. https://videocardz.com/newz/dell-unveils-xps-13-its-lightest...
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Neutral
Touchscreen is one of those things that sound nice, but in my experience are not so useful. At least not for my typical use (programming, writing, even CAD design). Before having a framework 13 I had a dell xps 13 with touchscreen for about ten years. I never really had a use for it. But hey, the rest of the specs of the screen alone make it still a nice upgrade possibility for the future :)
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Framework 13 [0]. It also has balanced USB ports on each side with being able to charge on the left and right. No Microsoft tax. I have been using it and at the moment will not go back to other OEMs. This is after having laptops from; Acer, Asus, HP, Dell, Lenovo, Apple (PPC). Apple (PPC) was the laptop that died the fast after the warranty expired, Dell XPS 13 was the second fastest to die. [0] https://frame.work/laptop13?tab=specs
Dell XPS 13: Likes itFramework Laptop: Neutral
Dell will sell you an XPS 13 with linux preloaded, but you'll pay extra. It's ludicrous that you can't just choose it for any laptop. https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/laptops/intel-core-ultra-ser... I had one of the early Project Sputnik laptops (XPS 13 with Ubuntu preloaded) and loved it. Now I use a Framework which is fine, but not anything amazing.
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
I've been running my 12th Gen Intel Framework for just over a year (since I got it) with Linux (KDE Neon). Bluetooth, expansion cards, thunderbolt, wifi - literally no issues. I haven't even had to fiddle with it. I use it all day for work (software engineering - lots of VM's and browser tabs) and all evening for Minecraft and movies. When I'm at my desk at home it's plugged in to a Thunderbolt 4 dock driving two monitors and getting Gigabit network speed. Before that I had a brand new Dell XPS 13, which again I had for a little over a year, running KDE Neon. It wasn't used for work as much, but again it worked perfectly fine, including the touch screen I didn't even want on it (okay- a major issue was the battery life, which was atrocious). Neither of these even came with Linux installed.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itFramework Laptop: Recommends it
I'm using a Framework laptop since November 2021, as my everyday laptop. I don't treat my laptop with too much care. It has been working really well. I also have an M1 MBP, and an xps 13. They both feel more solid, but I don't care. I hate the UX in macos, and I don't like how I'm basically stuck with my choices of ram, hdd, and ports. My only major problem with the framework laptop was the stupid Intel thermal throttling. If only Intel had decided to apply the throttling gradually as the cpu gets closer to the limits (instead of working full speed and then suddenly drop to 400Mhz or even 200 if it reaches a certain temperature, they could lower the max speed over a range of 2-3 degrees, that would work perfectly well: the cpu would settle on a slightly lower frequency than max, and no one would notice, except benchmarks, which were probably the only thing that Intel cared about). My desktop is based on AMD. I'm much happier. Even with an Nvidia GPU and Linux, I'm doing amazingly well. Whenever I really need to get a new laptop, Framework with an AMD cpu is my #1 choice. It does not hurt if they manage to add the external GPU support to the 13" version by that time :D. That would be the ultimate laptop. I'll probably even sell my $6000 desktop. For now, I prefer not to carry a larger laptop.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itFramework Laptop: Neutral
I bought a 12th-gen Intel Framework last summer when they first came out. Aside from some thermal throttling issues (that are actually kinda bad and common, and Framework support has been so far unable to address), and so-so battery life, I'm otherwise happy with it, after I got used to the screen's odd aspect ratio and made my peace with it being a physically larger machine because of that. (I'm assuming the driver for this was the need for a larger mainboard due to the expansion slots and connectors for RAM, WiFi, and storage.) A bit bummed that they're offering a matte display option only now; I don't see it offered in the marketplace, but I assume it'll get there eventually, and the glossy screen is $179, which isn't too expensive an 'upgrade', assuming the matte screen ends up being priced similarly. The higher-capacity battery will come in handy, though I'll probably wait until the existing battery gets a bit older. I'm not interested in a 16" laptop, but I really like the black keyboard area, though the two-tone black keyboard area with silver touchpad/wrist rest is kinda ugly. I wonder if Framework will eventually offer replacement input covers (for the 13") with different aesthetics. One thing I miss from my old Dell XPS13 is the soft-touch material on the input cover. One cool small detail on the 16" is they've dropped the built-in 3.5mm jack and added two more expansion card ports, with one of the options being a card with a 3.5mm jack. Really smart move the…
Dell XPS 13: NeutralFramework Laptop: Likes it
> battery efficiency My understanding is that some of this is because the Intel 12th gen 15-watt U-series chips only had 2 performance cores so Framework went the 28W P-series instead to get 4 performance cores. Using socketed ram is also going to use more power than lpddr. > sleep efficiency under Linux What are you comparing it to? Macbooks can sleep a week and lose 5% of battery but I don't know any non-apple machines that can do that. The Framework sleep perf seems comparable to my XPS 13. IME all non-apple laptops suck at suspend. Sleep works out of the box with Fedora 36/37. > By the time they fixed this to be on par with the best of the best in linux notebooks it's already old hardware. It seems to work as well as it will already? It's easy to swap out the mainboard if more efficient chips come out.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itFramework Laptop: Neutral
Primary computer is a desktop (since going full remote): ubuntu on repurposed gaming rig. I'm really happy with how well this computer works. As such, it's taken some of the pressure off having a perfect laptop. Laptops: Dell XPS 13 with ubuntu (preconfigured with ubuntu from Dell) -- has been an incredibly steady machine for years. I bought the framework laptop, installed ubuntu, but never got around to tweaking it to work as well as the Dell. So even though the framework is new, hardware better in every way it just sits on a shelf. I also use newer thinkpad for work with windows -- it's fine I guess.
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Neutral
I had an xps 13 9300 and struggled with battery life on any Linux distro ( tried fedora, Ubuntu, pop, elementary, solus, Arch, void ) and I'm not a beginner or anything. Even with combinations of tlp, powertop, gnome power profiles, kernel shit to make it run lower speed. Framework is really nice from a hardware perspective, but the display res is wonky with scaling, 100% is small and 200% is big, which puts you in the no no zone on most display servers which employ fractional scaling. MacOS is the only I've ever used that doesn't completely butcher oddball scales. Battery life I've observed to be around 4 hours of light usage on stock fedora. (11th gen main board) I personally run a new MacBook Pro M1 running any Linux I want in Lima or parallels, depending on GUI needs. Damn thing is god tier on battery, outlasts any other laptop I've ever owned by a factor of 3 at least.
Switched from the Dell XPS 13 to the Framework LaptopFramework Laptop: Recommends it
For anyone thinking about a Framework I would echo the same final thought. They have there issues but are really worth giving a shot. I have a 16 that had a motherboard that got bricked by a bios update. After trying everything to fix it that their tech support advised I did get a new motherboard shipped to me. Not a trivial thing to replace but doable and I've had no issues since. I realize that to many just hearing about that failure would turn you off of getting one but if it were any other company, I would have to send it back and more than likely the whole laptop would be scrapped. I probably also would have gotten the run around to get the approval to fix it first. I wish it just worked perfectly out of the box but their response was about as good as one could hope for. I can also say that on the 16, the hinge issue is fixed. I have a type A port but haven't used it heavily yet so can't comment on that one. As far as the sleep situation, I've been running linux for close to 10 years as my daily driver and I've had sleep issues off and on the entire time (with two previous Dell XPS 13's running mostly Ubuntu or Fedora). So far I haven't had them with the Framework 16 but I'm sure some update will trigger it at some point. I don't use my laptop for work, just for personal use, so maybe that lets me lean towards things that are a bit more finicky but if you care about open hardware this is a product that deserves your support. Having basically taken one apart as much as on…
Switched from the Dell XPS 13 to the Framework LaptopFramework Laptop: Likes it
If most people here use laptops (which is my -- perhaps flawed -- perception), then maybe not. I just put together a new Framework laptop with 64GiB, and that was a huge jump from my Dell XPS 13 with 16GiB. All of the other 13" laptops I looked at max out at either 16GiB or 32GiB. Even 15"/16" laptops probably usually only have 16GiB or 32GiB, on average, though I'm sure there are some with 64GiB. And then phones, even the high end ones max out at around 8GiB, right? I think mine has 6GiB, though it's a few years old now. Even someone with a desktop machine (for gaming, perhaps) probably "only" has 64GiB. So the total (64GiB desktop + 16GiB laptop + 8GiB phone = 88GiB) is still under 100GiB. I guess if we include the dedicated VRAM on a the discrete GPU that might be in the desktop? Not sure I'd count that, though. I do have a few Raspberry Pis (of various vintage) and an old Mac Mini that are doing various things around the house, so I guess that's another 4+4+1+0.5+16 = 25.5GiB. So my grand total (including my phone and laptop; I don't have a desktop) comes to 97.5GiB -- so close! I wouldn't count these, but my router has 2GiB, and I have two APs with 128MiB each, so that'd bring me to 99.75GiB. Can't believe I'm only 256MiB short!
Switched from the Dell XPS 13 to the Framework LaptopFramework Laptop: Likes it
That’s not my personal experience at all. Yes, my $4000 14” MaxBook Pro has objectively better build quality, but I think the Framework is at least on-par with the $2000 XPS 13 I bought first (and later returned for the Framework). Can’t comment on the trackpoint, which is something I’ve never personally liked, but if that’s a deal breaker, you’ll probably have to have a Thinkpad. But I’ve been very pleased with the build quality of my Framework.
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I've been using Kubuntu for years with good results. I prefer KDE to Gnome, which Kubuntu takes care of, and I normally add in the flatpak repositories so I don't need snap. That has generally worked well for me in the last 5 years. For certain timeperiods I have needed to switch to Fedora, or the Fedora KDE spin, to get access to more recent software if I'm using newer hardware. That has generally also been pretty stable but the constant stream of updates and short OS life are not really what I'm looking for in a desktop experience. There are three issues that linux still has, which are across the board: - Lack of commercial mechanical engineering software support (CAD & CAE software) - Inability to reliably suspend or sleep for laptops - Worse battery life on laptops If you are using a desktop and don't care about CAD or CAE software I think it's probably a better experience overall than windows. Laptops are still more for advanced users imho but if you go with something that has good linux support from the factory (Dell XPS 13, Framework, etc.) it will be mostly frictionless. It just sucks on that one day where you install an update, close the laptop lid, put it in your backpack, and find it absolutely cooking and near 0% when you take it out. I also have never found something that gave me the battery life I wanted with linux. I used two XPS 13's and they were the closest but still were only like 75% of what I would like. My current Framework 16 is like 50% of what I would…
Dell XPS 13: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
For anyone considering the 16, mine has had some teething issues (1. motherboard failed and I was sent a replacement 2. keyboard/touchpad started having a issue losing connection which I still need to submit a ticket for). The USB A port also feels like it's gonna break at some point (the rest seem fine). The linux experience has been about the same as on a Dell XPS 13 with the consistent issues being poor battery life and an inability to sleep properly. If I were to do it again I would get the 13 not the 16 but would still give it a shot.
Dell XPS 13: Likes itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Was the laptop advertised as supporting Linux, or, if not, did you at least do your research ahead of time to ensure that everything worked properly? Because clearly it didn't, so I expect Linux support was already known to not be in a great place before you bought it. And yes, that sucks. We should have first-class support. It's no wonder macOS gained popularity among developers. But I've been running Linux on laptops for 15+ years now (even on Macs), and I've seen how it's changed from barely-working and having to futz with things at every kernel upgrade, to pretty much seamless (and these days I really have little patience for futzing around with things; I want something that works so I can do useful things on it). But, again: you need to choose your hardware carefully. For reference, I had a 2016-model Razer Blade Stealth, which had no issues with Linux. Then in early 2019 I bought a 2018-model Dell XPS 13 that worked flawlessly (except for the fingerprint reader, which I knew ahead of time and accepted as ok). For the past yearish I've been using a Framework Laptop, which has had some problems (unrelated to Linux; Windows users have the same problems), but the hardware support on Linux has been solid. Meanwhile, I'd constantly hear problems from my friends with Macs about how it could never stay connected to a wireless network after a couple hours (requiring a reboot to fix), or would frequently "beachball" under not that much load, or how the yearly major OS upda…
Dell XPS 13: Likes itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Got one under Ubuntu 22.04. My only issue is that some transitions are frustratingly slow, much moreso than on my 2014 XPS13: * Getting out of sleep (deep RAM sleep, not hibernate) * Handling password/fingerprint authentication once out of sleep * Wifi rescan frequency * Occasionally, plugging/unplugging external screens And I've got no idea why. Once woken up and plugged to whatever I need to use, it's a really good laptop.