The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Dell Precision vs Dell XPS

Hacker News owners lean toward the Dell Precision.

Dell PrecisionDell XPS
Owners with an opinion182659
Positive verdicts62% of 15748% of 583
Positive/negative since 202434/1472/97
Happy after 3+ years1549
Longest happy owner17 yrs20 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbattery and portabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell Precision: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
At work, our Windows devs use expensive XPSs that are complete crap failing constantly, both hardware and software. As someone who used Latitudes and Precisions when these were the reliable workhorses you seem to describe, the new stuff is just outrageous. (My personal laptop is still an e6440). My work machine is an M2 Pro MBP and except the shitty input HW (compared to the golden era of Thinkpads/Latitudes without chiclet keyboards) and MacOS being quite bad compared to Linux, it completely trounces the neighbouring Dells that constantly need repairs (mostly the USB-C ports and wireless cards failing).
Dell Precision: Recommends itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
Dell only support the XPS 13 for Linux. I like mine, it's not perfect but seems pretty acceptable. Everything works out of the box including bluetooth, battery life isn't great though. If you want a larger screened Dell for Linux you should definitely go with the Precision line that you mentioned as you can order them with Linux out of the box. You might be OK with an XPS 15 or 17 but I've heard of issues with the GPU on the XPS 15 so might be a bit of a crap shoot. So personally I would avoid them. My advice for buying any Linux laptop would be always get one that comes with Linux out of the box even if you're going to replace it.
Dell Precision: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
Yes the XPS series is a bit of a cooling nightmare but for example the Precision 3000/7000 series are quite a different story. (We have around 10 assorted Dell laptops from all the different models and we don’t like the XPS much by comparison, and wouldn’t ever buy another. Aside from thermal issues, for whatever reason the XPS drivers are very beta and always crashing compared with the Precision series which is just rock solid)
Dell Precision: Doesn’t like itDell XPS: Neutral
Nope. Hitting Enter or F1 brings you into Windows diagnostics rather than BIOS, at least on the Thinkpad X13 Gen 2 Ryzen Pro subnotebook w/ useless Windows installed a customer sent me for a project, and that is now contributing to a growing number of 3 bricked (brand-new!) latitude/precision and thinkpad notebook trash I'm accumulating at home. With the current state of non-existant quality in PC notebook hardware, I'm not going to buy anything except Apple hardware. Right now I'm back to using a 2016 XPS, with my 2019 Thinkpad collecting dust (and blocking its crap trackpad due to it); it's not that there are news regarding x64 performance since over ten years anyway.
Dell Precision: Likes itDell XPS: Likes it
If your company demands/keeps buying the shittiest, cheapest plastic Dell laptops instead of XPSes or higher end Latitudes/Precisions, that's not Dell's fault. My company uses XPSes and Precisions. They work great.
Dell Precision: NeutralDell XPS: Neutral
I also have a first gen Framework. I've used the following recently: - Framework 1st gen - Dell XPS 13 - Macbook Pro 14" (m1) - Dell Precision 5570 I wouldn't say that the framework is perfect, there are a number of minor complaints I have with it. However, it holds its own, and I really do love it, especially while running linux. I hope that Framework the company continues to support the early models with new mainboards and parts. If so, I'll be a very loyal customer. Oh, and the fact that I know I'll be able to replace the battery when the time comes is a beautiful feeling!
Dell Precision: Likes itDell XPS: Likes it
I’ve had a lot of Dell laptops through work. 2 XPS-13’s in the past few years. 1 with camera’s positioned at the bottom of the screen, which was the absolute worst design ever, unless you enjoyed showing off your nose hairs. 1 with the screen flicker and an issue with an internal fan that failed to start consistently which resulted an a blaring alarm. It would go off in the middle of the night. The last one was replaced by a Dell XPS-15 (by my employer) which has worked fine. I also own a personal XPS-15 that was my first Dell purchase ~3-4 years ago. It’s never had an issue and I do some heavy compute and web scraping. I have a refurbished Dell Precision T-5600 with 128GB of RAM and 16 core processor 4TB SSD + 2TB SSD. It’s a beast, I’ve had it for 3 years. Run it daily for large scrape jobs, store and process a lot of data. It has never let me down.
Dell Precision: Likes itDell XPS: Likes it
I have a XPS 13 9310 2-in-1, bought directly after release & put Linux on it. For a brand new released Laptop, this was the best Linux experience I had. Dell's preinstalled Ubuntu wasn't available as an option, but on other devices I used it always sucked, not suprising if the Ubuntu Kernel is much older than the device release. I don't understand why they do this half-baked thing. Build quality is very good, except for the standoffs, the silicon is getting loose 2 years later. This was much better on Precision devices I had before. I think this website is a rant by a disappointed customer, but does have lots of valid criticism listed.
Dell Precision: Doesn’t like itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
Back when Dell had its Latitude series they were known for being as indestructible as the Thinkpads. Little did I know how shitty Dell laptops were afterwards. My excourse had gone through the 300/310 Touch Ultrabook series, the XPS13 and XPS15 series, and the Dell Precision series. Bought 5 laptops from Dell, all broken within under a year of lifetime. It was so bad that in the Ultrabook the GPU literally melted, and they claimed this laptop is working totally fine by just using the internal display with more artifacts than actual pixels. And now, here I am in 2022, using my Thinkpad from 2012...because it keeps working. I don't even know what to buy after the Thinkpad dies, so I have one other as a spare parts donator.
Dell Precision: Likes itDell XPS: Likes it
I think it’s a software company (apple) making changes to the ui to sell more hardware (apple). In a predictable coordinated fashion. The issue here is apple will always be the bad guy since they are seen doing all of this in a coordinated attempt to sell more stuff. Dell on the other hand only sells more stuff either when the software landscape, that they don’t control, has moved too far for the legacy hardware to keep up. Or they innovated on the hardware and show enough value for you to change hardware independent from software. Dell will almost never be the bad guy here unless they make subpar machines. The XPS and precision laptops are far from subpar. So you get guys like the parent that prefer dell since it seems more natural and not like they are being played.
Dell Precision: Likes itDell XPS: Likes it
My maximum spec Lenovo P1 Gen 1 that I have been using for the last 3 years has been really underwhelming. It feels just very average. No premium feel whatsoever. XPS13 by comparison feels a bit more premium. Most damning, out of the two M2 SSD drives in Lenovo P1, the main one was some no name Chinese make that failed without a warning after a year. For a premium model that is just unacceptable. Secondary drive is a WD that is still alive. By comparision 10 year old Dell Precision M6700 and M4700 are built like tanks have ports and upgradability to the max. Same goes for Lenovo T440p that I bought for 200 Euros for my kid's schoolwork. Same goes for older HP ProBooks. Another kid has a Macbook Air M1 and that is just alright. The laptops from early 2010s just feel sturdier and better built. The question is which will be the well built professional Alder Lake laptop to get? Will it be Lenovo, Dell, HP, Asus maybe MSI or maybe even Framework? Intel 12th gen offers some impressive gains over AMD and 11th gen Intel so it makes sense to wait.
Dell Precision: Likes itDell XPS: Likes it
To add as a counter point, I've only had positive experiences with Dell. And that's over 10+ years at work and personally. It's never been more complicated than the normal: 1) "make sure your BIOS is upto date" hogwash, which I troubleshoot prior. 2) Acknowledge it's a hardware issue 3) Get a field tech to call me 4) Wait a day or two at most for parts, if not the same day 5) Tech comes out and replaces any parts at my place of work or home 6) Fixed And this has been over years and years with Precision and XPS laptops.