The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Desktops and mini PCs

Dell OptiPlex vs Lenovo ThinkCentre

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Dell OptiPlexLenovo ThinkCentre
Owners with an opinion7154
Positive verdicts96% of 5494% of 47
Positive/negative since 202426/128/2
Happy after 3+ years31
Longest happy owner11 yrs3 yrs
Praised forvalue and performancevalue and performance
Criticized forportability and reliabilitydesign
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Dell OptiPlex: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkCentre: Doesn’t like it
This encourages me to buy a node for my homelab but holy shit the prices now are very skyrocketed. Even I kinda struggle to find a new node for my homelab because most of the mini PCs or refurbished such as Optiplex and ThinkCentre are going expensive too and most of it are out of stock.
Dell OptiPlex: Recommends itLenovo ThinkCentre: Recommends it
> I wish someone would just tell me exactly what to buy. I’ll bite. You can save a lot of money by buying used hardware. I recommend looking for old Dell OptiPlex towers on Facebook Marketplace or from local used computer stores. Lenovo ThinkCentres (e.g., m700 tiny) are also a great option if you prefer something with a smaller form factor. I’d recommend disregarding advice from non-technical folks recommending brand new, expensive hardware, because it’s usually overkill.
Dell OptiPlex: Recommends itLenovo ThinkCentre: Recommends it
I think if its a one off purchase for use as a general pc or learning tool that doesn't require GPIO something like a second hand thinkcentre or optiplex is probably the best option. They'll be cheaper than a Pi 5 or Pi 500, plus often come with a keyboard and mouse in addition to the power supply. Sure, they arent going to be quite as power efficient but you're getting significantly more for your money, as well as repurposing second hand kit that might have otherwise ended up in landfill. GPIO aside I struggle to think of a good reason to buy a Pi 5 for this sort of application, especially when the cheaper second hand alternatives have one thing the pi doesn't - upgradability. On the N100's, they seem to occasionally get a fair bit cheaper. The GMKtec G3 Mini for example (8GB ram, 256GB SSD) was down to £67.55 on Aliexpress[1] recently for example. I do like a good Pi but for a lot of applications they just do not make much financial sense anymore. [1] https://www.hotukdeals.com/deals/gmktec-g3-mini-pc-intel-ald...
Dell OptiPlex: NeutralLenovo ThinkCentre: Neutral
mini PCs are < 10W also. I have a full on Dell Optiplex 3070 (i5-9500, 1x16GB memory, 512GB NVMe) running windows 10 that idles at 8W. I have a lenovo m92p tiny (i5-3570s, released 2012) that idles at 6W.
Dell OptiPlex: Likes itLenovo ThinkCentre: Likes it
But the trouble is they are too expensive. Not sure I would buy a NUC but tons of gently used/new overstock thin-client machines from Lenovo (ThinkCenter) and Dell Optiplex that cost $75-200 depending on spec and give you as good or better bang for buck, more reliable, etc. (I would however separate out unique applications with the RPI Zero given the form factor)
Dell OptiPlex: Likes itLenovo ThinkCentre: Likes it
>For this article’s purpose, I won’t recommend any specific servers because this will vary a ton depending on what you will be hosting. NAS storage, VMs, web servers, backup servers, mail servers, ad blockers, and all the rest. For my requirements, I purchased a ThinkCentre M73 and ThinkCentre M715q; both used off eBay. This is the way. HP, Lenovo, and Dell are all making identical small form factor PCs that are more than enough for most people at home. They are also very silent and power efficient. I have a Lenovo M720 Tiny and a Dell Optiplex 3080 Micro (they are virtually almost the same). You can change parts, there are ample ports available and you can pretty much run any OS you want.
Dell OptiPlex: Likes itLenovo ThinkCentre: Likes it
Honestly, I'm a big supporter of refurbishing old computers. Admittedly I have 2 usff(1 liter) pc's which I got for less than 100 bucks with some minor upgrades thrown in there(a bit more ram and hard drive) - a Dell Optiplex and a Lenovo thinkcenter. With a quad core, 6-th gen i5, those two are stupid powerful for self-hosting and homelab purposes. At this point, I'd take one of those over an SBC any day of the week. Take the one that uses most resources: it's on 24/7 and has been doing an insane amount of work without batting an eye. It's been processing gigabytes of data daily and running 3 ML models for over 8 months and has been helping with what would otherwise be a very time consuming and difficult task. Refurbishing old PC's is really a goldmine in the homelab/automation/hacking spaces.
Dell OptiPlex: Recommends itLenovo ThinkCentre: Recommends it
For homelab or self hosting, Power per watt is my favourite measure now. Depending on your need (many apps just idle most of the time) a usff pc can make an excellent proxmox server. Check out a Lenovo m920q, Dell Optiplex 7060, HP EliteDesk or ProDesk 800 series. They are easy enough to bump to 64G of ram and stack up as you need. The 8700T cpu is a desktop grade in a small shell and watt footprint and also has vpro and hyperthreading. It’s not a rack server but it’s easy enough to add a Mac Studio/Mini soon enough for crunching. I have spent too much time with full rack server gear and using it a can seem like a matter of preference before need. It’s heavy, hungry, noisy, and my better half didn’t like when I brought the leftover data centre stuff home. The USFF boxes are near silent and sip electricity.