The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Keyboards

Das Keyboard vs IBM / Unicomp Model M

Hacker News owners lean toward the Das Keyboard.

Das KeyboardIBM / Unicomp Model M
Owners with an opinion97201
Positive verdicts89% of 7977% of 176
Positive/negative since 202410/260/26
Happy after 3+ years1426
Longest happy owner15 yrs38 yrs
Praised forreliability and durabilitycomfort and reliability
Criticized forease of use and comfortnoise and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Das Keyboard: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Neutral
Love my Unicomp keyboards... but have had some minor issues... I've been mostly using brown-switch daskeyboard backlit models lately. My current desktop can't get into the bios via my unicomp 104-key, which is pretty annoying to say the least. I miss the bigger space bar and ctrl/win/alt positioning on the left side. There's really something to years of muscle memory that even years later a different keyboard can throw you off. I also liked the buckling spring feel a bit more than MX browns. And definitely prefer Cherry MX Brown to any other brown-like knockoff switch I've tried. I can hardly handle typing on an actual laptop keyboard... half the time, depending on my needs I'll stuff a full size keyboard in my bag. I'll also opt for either a BT mouse, or a magic pad.
Das Keyboard: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Doesn’t like it
I have used several inexpensive Apple-keyed mechanical keyboards. My random observations: Buckley Springs (e.g. IBM Model M -type, Unicomp) are absolutely the best keyfeel , but they just won't last longer than the keyboard's warranty (probably nowhere near as long, YMMV). They are obnoxiously loud (similar to my electric Smith Corona Coronet typewriter). Simple keystrikes above 100wpm often result in blown-out springs — I have thrown away my last Unicomp keyboard (after spring/warranty failures). das keyboard (brown>blue>red) is heavenly, my daily-drivers (I own three, identical). Just a little bit louder than an OEM Apple keyboard, and always responds as depressed. The worst tactile keyboard I've ever used (non-mechanical, but physical buttons): mid 2010's Apple Laptop "butterfly" keys, which fail spectacularly (to crickets from Apple).
Das Keyboard: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Doesn’t like it
I had to throw away my first Unicomp because several springs "deformed" — this led to constant phantom typing and volume changes. Interestingly, the keyboard arrived new with a "soft" F5 key — never using this key, I didn't think to return it (but should have, immediately... it was predictor of what would happen to other keys over the next year). As phantom keystrikes became more common, I slowly had to rip out keys/springs until the alphabet became inaccessible. The 2018 Unicomp (for Mac) is the ONLY keyboard I've ever thrown away before a decade of daily use =( I have now settled on cherry-brown DasKeyboards, which don't have the ideal "feel" of Unicomp buckling springs... but also don't fail as quickly.
Das Keyboard: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Recommends it
Depends which keyboard I use, but sometimes, same here. My main work PC has a 1991 Model M on it. Best PC keyboard ever made, and I have about 5 of them, carefully kept since people were throwing them away in the 1990s. I remap Caps Lock to Super, and I'm good to go. I really don't need media-control keys or anything, or a right Super key. I am trialling an early model of Das Keyboard on my Mac. The volume-control dial is quite nice, because I listen to music and watch films on that. I never use the media keys, and happily, it's old enough that it doesn't have nonsense like light-up keys, multicoloured lighting or any of that ugly frippery. Most computer lighting and decorations are visible designed to appeal to teenaged boys, with all the taste and discrimination that implies.
Das Keyboard: Recommends itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Neutral
I own a DasKeyboard with MX Browns and it's my daily driver at work. I prefer MX Blue switches (or even MX Greens) because I grew up in the old buckling spring era of IBM keyboard dominance (my home keyboard is an old Model M from the late 90s). I would use a clicky keyboard at work, but my coworkers don't like it, so I stick with the browns. I HIGHLY recommend the DasKeyboard. It's hefty, and I installed a custom key set with my preferred key profile and I LOVE it. This is the one I own and I can't recommend it highly enough: https://www.daskeyboard.com/model-s-professional/
Das Keyboard: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Neutral
For new options, I think the Unicomp options are pretty nice, though I did have 1 in 4 fail over the past 12 years. Not as strong/durable as original IBM Model M options, plastic casing is lower grade and backplate is thinner. Another down side compared to other options is no backlighting. I've also been pretty fond of Cherry MX Brown switch keyboards, probably the most similar feel imo. Have a few das keyboards, which have been pretty good, started using this at work since my unicomps are more noisy. Since WFH using the unicomp again. While I've been willing to go up to the $100-150 price range, I don't think I'd notice the difference going beyond that where I would find it worth it. Laptop and sub-$75 keyboards all feel like mush... and the knockoff "brown" switches aren't nearly as good imo.
Das Keyboard: NeutralIBM / Unicomp Model M: Recommends it
It depends on your taste, and where will this be located. As an ancedote, I got the Das Keyboard brought it to work. I literally felt daggers in my back. Until I was kindly asked to remove the keyboard as it was disturbing the work environment. So keep in mind the sound it outputs. When I worked tech support, everyone had mechanical keyboards so sound wasn't an issue. I remedied this by getting http://matias.ca/quietpro/pc/ At home I used the Unicomp which is buckling spring instead of switch. This is by far my favorite keyboard I've used. https://www.pckeyboard.com/ My friend has a Kinesis, and constantly tells me it's helped his hands significantly. https://www.kinesis-ergo.com/shop/advantage2/ So how much resistance do you want, a solid click feel, and audible sound? Something older fashioned. Do you need backlight, ports, etc.
Das Keyboard: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes it
Nice to see what people put together... I'm hoping to do some custom desk builds etc in the next year or so myself. My biggest change for my home setup has been moving away from a KVM with work and personal computers on a single desk to multiple desks where I'm physically moved. I prefer to have my feet on the ground, so don't like the drafting chair or barstool foot rests. I've also moved to 45" (U)WQHD displays (3440x1440) for my work spots. I have two Xeneon Flex and another display of the same size that's by LG. It's kind of like 2x large 3:4 aspect displays glued together mostly pinning apps to half the screen on one side or the other. My vision is pretty bad, so having the larger pixels helps a lot for my visibility and being able to function. It's also worth noting that I didn't pay full retail for any of the screens. The Xeneon goes on sale for about half price every couple months on Corsair's site, and I picked up the LG as a return from BestBuy for about $550, which was a pretty good deal for what it is. I also tend to prefer physical switch keyboards, currently backlit Das keyboards with Cherry-MX Brown switches. My mouse is a Logitech with a weighted scroll wheel. I do like the Unicomp keyboards more, but they're a bit more noisy so I settle with the browns.
Das Keyboard: NeutralIBM / Unicomp Model M: Neutral
I own seven, at the moment. One is an IBM Model M buckling spring keyboard (1983, needs a PS2-to-USB adaptor). Two others I use daily, including the Das Keyboard (Cherry MX Blues) I'm typing this on. My latest is the Launch Heavy with Kaith Brown keys that arrived yesterday (with a new system). It's replacing a gaming keyboard I've had for more than a decade. I'm not even "in to keyboards," I've simply been using computer equipment at home for so long that I have them around.
Das Keyboard: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes it
This is the first time I've gotten a real headache by looking at a website, and I'm assuming the culprit was too much movement mixed with only a couple hours of sleep. Make sure the spin on the 360 view is user-controllable, and get rid of the marquees. A hover animation on the sections would only be expected if they're interactive. Text is needlessly large. Everyone else has covered my qualms about the keyboard itself, but I'm legitimately not a fan of anything besides it being USB-C and made of aluminium, so I'm clearly not in the target market (I'm happy with my Model M and Das Ultimate) =b Best of luck!
Das Keyboard: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes it
At work: Das Keyboard, with CherryMX Brown switches. At home: Corsair K70, with CherryMX Brown switches. I like CherryMX brown switches. They're a good balance of actuation force, slight click, but still rather quiet and with a decently long travel (so I'm less likely to bottom out the keys). I like the K70 more because the open frame makes cleaning between the keys easier. I like that the Das has a 2-port hub built in without using a second USB A slot like the K70 does. I utterly hate keyboards without numpads, both have numpads. I've used Unicomp model Ms (they bought the license from IBM), they're quite nice too but a bit louder and harder to actuate than I want. Likewise with CherryMX blue switches. I've also used a Corsair keyboard with CherryMX red switches, those don't really have any detent and extremely low actuation force, so they're too easy to accidentally actuate when resting my hand on the keyboard. I've never used a laptop keyboard I liked. Short travel distance is frustrating.
Das Keyboard: Likes itIBM / Unicomp Model M: Likes it
1) Their "regular" keyboards work just fine with Macs (see the link in 2) for more; 2) The Das Keyboard is nice but still not as good as Model M / Unicomp SpaceSaver: http://jseliger.com/2009/11/01/product-review-das-keyboard/ . I used the review copy with an iMac. 3) Virtually any mechanical keyboard is a HUGE improvement on the default keyboards that most manufacturers ship.