The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Watches and wearables

Casio G-Shock vs Garmin

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Casio G-Shock.

Casio G-ShockGarmin
Owners with an opinion93834
Positive verdicts93% of 8777% of 713
Positive/negative since 202443/3346/122
Happy after 3+ years1131
Longest happy owner20 yrs15 yrs
Praised forreliability and durabilitybattery and ease of use
Criticized fordisplaysoftware and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Casio G-Shock: Likes itGarmin: Neutral
Yeah, it's something I think about a lot. I have a smartwatch, I like it just fine, but I kind of think that smartwatches are actually pretty bad at being a watch. I had a Casio G-Shock for about a decade that I wore nearly every day [1], and I never had to change the battery. My Garmin Instinct Crossover, which is considered to have very good battery life, has to be charged every two weeks, which despite that seeming like a long time, I manage to forget about it every time until the battery is dead. [1] I have a few fancy wind-up watches I wear to formal occasions.
Casio G-Shock: Likes itGarmin: Neutral
I replaced my mechanical watch with a G-Shock that lasts ten years without charging of any kind. Even my current Garmin will last a week when charged - it will last even longer if I turn off every single feature. I use the Garmin to track my exercise - I don't care if the mechanical watch will last all my life if it doesn't do what I want it to do, and it's not even that great at the one thing that it does do. There aren't a lot of normally-priced mechanical watches that get 1 second/day accuracy. That precision can be admired in mechanical watches, but as I said, it becomes a fun expensive hobby.
Casio G-Shock: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Likes it
This looks pretty cool, but can't seem to find it for sale anywhere in Sweden. Also, I would prefer a slightly sleeker form factor, similar to the G-shock in the OP, something that the Instinct is closer to. Some of the G-shock designs are pretty ridiculous in my eyes. Way too much excess form without apparent function or benefit.
Casio G-Shock: Doesn’t like itGarmin: Likes it
35 hour battery life? Compare this to Garmin's most modern watch (the Venu 2) with OLED screen and it's just not even worth considering. I get 6-8 days with mine, but I don't use GPS at all. This G-Shock only gives basic data too. I like the look of it, but $300 is just way too much. Part of the appeal of the G-Shock is 10 year battery, so you'd think they would go for something a little better.
Switched from the Casio G-Shock to the GarminGarmin: Likes it
I have a Garmin Instinct 2 solar. I had g-shock watches before, because I liked how tough they were, and the instinct2 is pretty close. I wear it swimming, running, sleeping, showering, etc. I take it off about once a month when I charge it up. This summer, I went 6 weeks between charges. The basic tracking of cardio, hiking, snowshoeing, etc, is exactly what I want from a smartwarch (lets me gamify my physical activity, and sleep). I does have some great ways to map hikes, find out how to get back (direct path, or retrace steps, etc). Its pretty amazing for a low level garmin.
Casio G-Shock: Likes itGarmin: Likes it
> all high end watches are mechanical. No, most high end male jewelry are mechanical watches (and much of women-oriented jewelry as well). High end watches are such a solved problem we don't even talk about them anymore. Either the G-shock, the Garmin watches, or the Apple Watch run circles around mechanical watches in terms of functionality with each satisfying a different niche (100% self-contained, long lived smart functionality, glance-oriented integration with full-stack personal tech ecosystem).
Casio G-Shock: Likes itGarmin: Likes it
So, not really trying to take sides on this as I have both GPS smartwatches and G-shock watches, and think they both have their pros and cons. However, in looking at reviews and discussions in various types of forums, it always seems like Garmin longevity is discussed in terms of years, and G-shock can be decades -- sometimes without ever charging them or replacing the battery. I think the essence of a watch is still timekeeping, as most of the other functions can be provided by other things (online mapping, paper maps, dedicated GPS, etc.). So if you just want a timekeeping device and want it to be really indestructible, G-shock has that appeal. It's like the omega dive watches but digital and more practical financially speaking (a bit of 80s tech nostalgia doesn't hurt). I admit Garmin Instinct is where they start to compete with G-shock, and on a feature-by-feature basis, the Instinct should come ahead. I don't really understand sometimes why Casio isn't trying to introduce slimmer GPS watches, as that should be their niche. At the same time, the Garmin Instinct just hasn't had as much time as the G-shock watches to establish a reputation. So even if 30 years from now people are talking about how their Garmin Instinct 2s are still ticking, and they acquire the same reputation as a G-shock, that's still 30 years from now. Casio also seems to really favor - or at least appeal to someone looking for - rock-solid implementation of established features in firmware/hardware. The…