The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Headphones

Bose QuietComfort vs Sony WH-1000XM

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Bose QuietComfort.

Bose QuietComfortSony WH-1000XM
Owners with an opinion265214
Positive verdicts76% of 22965% of 180
Positive/negative since 202440/2145/27
Happy after 3+ years194
Longest happy owner15 yrs6 yrs
Praised fornoise and comfortnoise and sound
Criticized forreliabilityease of use and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Bose QuietComfort: Recommends itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I had the Sony WH1000XM3s and found similar - I still loved them but it was cutting out low droning noises etc that they shone at and voices definitely cut though quite a bit. Recently though I got the Bose Quietcomfort Earbuds 2 (in ears), and the noise cancelling on them is next-level. So much better at cutting out higher pitches and I love them. I often use them in a room with a loud television and people speaking and they cut out a lot of speech and general noise It still doesn't create silence in those conditions admittedly, but it's very impressive
Bose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I have the newer XM5s. The main reason for me to go with them instead of the cheaper XM4s was the call quality. I use my headphones very often in conference calls and the XM5s have excellent microphones compared to their predecessors. Side note: before, I have tested the Bose QC45 but those microphones are absolutely garbage. Sad, because the QC35 microphones were good. I don’t mind that the XM5s don’t fold anymore. In a way I like the new design better compared to my wife’s XM3s.
Bose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
Owning Sony XM4s, Galaxy Buds Pros, Bose QC, and Airpods Pros: that's an extreme take. All of these devices "just work" and "don't just work" in nearly the same ways. The microphone quality is a tin can on all of them. Among my friends in Discord, anytime someone logs on with a shit mic the meme is "dude are you using airpods?!" They usually are. Or any earbeans. Because they're all bad. The AV desync is an equal issue on both of them. BT headphones are basically useless for any realtime application (think: playing a digital piano). This may just be me, but: I have no idea what the "automatic device switching" airpods feature is. I have a Mac. I have an iPhone. If I want to switch my Airpods from iPhone to the Mac, I have to go to the bluetooth menu in the toolbar, and click the Airpods on the Mac... just like the XM4s. To go back, I go into the bluetooth quick settings menu and click Airpods Pros. Its exactly the same. Like, ever since they announced this feature, I feel like either the world entered a collective psychosis on what this feature does, or I'm getting old and I'm missing something, but its exactly the same (and, not that bad; exactly how many steps I'd expect to switch an audio output device). The Airpods are certainly very nice during the initial pair process, but that's a one-time thing on both devices. The scary part to me is: the APPs do have slightly better UX on Apple devices. And it isn't just the value-add features like "automatic" switching and spat…
Bose QuietComfort: NeutralSony WH-1000XM: Recommends it
I think the new benchmark seems to be the Sony WH-1000XM3. I was lucky enough to be able to try these and the Bose QC35II and for me the Sony just edged it. They are over ear, have extraordinary battery life and are very comfortable. They can even hold their own on the London Underground which is saying something. Highly recommended!
Bose QuietComfort: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
I have the QC35 and the WH-1000XM3. The Sony have punchy sound. If you're a bass head, you are going to love them. The application that goes with them also gives you a lot of control. However, after playing with all the settings for a few days, I found myself not touching them ever again. For noise cancellation on airline flights, the Bose do a better job. Even after adjusting the Sony to the aircraft pressure level. Maybe the Sony are better at canceling other people's voice, but they are not as good as the Bose to cancel the noise of the aircraft engine. The Airpods Pro also do a surprisingly good job at canceling the noise of the engine. During my last flight, I used the Airpods Pro and the Sony on top of them. Not very comfortable, but noise cancellation was amazing :) When it comes to comfort, the Sony tend to hurt the top of my head after a while. The Bose are more comfortable.
Bose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Recommends it
Commuting/Daily: Apple AirPod Gen 1 (~220AUD at the time) Office / Airflights: Sony WH-1000XM3 ($350AUD) Others: MH40 for home listening / PC, Grado SR215E for Open back listening at home with Jazz etc. AirPods for general day to day travelling when I'm not using a backpack. The Sony 'cans' for noise cancelling and concentrating and added Bass. Previous Earphones/Headphones: In the last 5 years * Bose QC35 - Rubbish sound quality for a pair of 300+ headphones. Active Noise cancelling is very pressured, hurts my ears. Microphone picks up EVERYTHING! Do not recommend * Shure SE215 - Great sub $200 in ear canals with great sound quality. I broke mine cause I stepped on them, decided to go wireless. * RHA T20i - Great sound quality but the rubber on the earlets broke. I replaced them twice, was to expensive to send to London each 12 months so I gave up on them. Too expensive for this design flaw. * Master and Dynamic MH40 - Look cool but heavy and expensive. Sound quality doesn't justify the price Recommendation: The Sony WH-1000XM3 is the bee knees!
Bose QuietComfort: Recommends itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
I bought Bose QC35 2 weeks ago and I am absolutely thrilled about them. The noise cancelling is almost perfect and when I have them on and somebody speaks to me I really don’t hear anything. Unlike many other headphones I have tried they are also very comfortable. I tried Sony MDR-1000x and to be frank their noise canceling is maybe even better than the Boses, however they are so tight on my head I know I wouldn’t be able to wear them for more than an hour.
Bose QuietComfort: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
Wireless: - Top tier general: sennheiser Hbd 630 - good enough: sennheiser momentum 4 (affordable) - good ANC and “bassy”: Sony xm5/xm6 (‘muddy’ for some) - I like the Bose ANC profile: Bose QC2 All of them have bad microphones (worse than wired ear pods) All of them have good to great ANC All of them are wireless If you need a good mic then get dedicated headset for calls. Otherwise settle for “ok” I didn’t include bathys/marklevin cause the new senn 630 outplay them on all fronts.
Bose QuietComfort: NeutralSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
Out of curiosity, what issues have you had with them? (I'm not at all involved with their development, just a fellow user of them). I had the Bose and Sony ones. They were OK, just uncomfortable. Been using the in-ear Airpods Pro for a few years now, for everything from work to flights to trains to exercising, and I love them soooo much... they're probably my favorite tech purchase ever (and I don't even have an iPhone). Pairing is always a pain in the ass (I just manually pair again with every device I want to switch to) but other than that, they've been so nice. Personally, I'm not an audiophile, but I find the audio quality incredible (vs my Sonos speakers, wired Koss PortaPros, generic soundbars, Sony XM3 and Bose QC35s, etc.) and the comfort unbeatable. But some people hate the in-ear kind. Anyway, not trying to convince you of anything, just wondering what made your experiences so different and bad?
Bose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
AirPods Pro Max I've had two Sonys (XM4 and XM5) and a bunch of Boses (QC 1x something, 25, 35II). These are by far the best ones for me. The fabric on the ear cups doesn't get sweaty, I have tactile buttons for every function (unlike the Sonys), ANC works even when the mic is on (Bose can't do this). And the best feature: I can charge them while I'm using them. Neither the Sony or Bose can do that, they just go offline.
Bose QuietComfort: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I hope these are better for calls. We've debated banning AirPods at my workplace because the mics are so awful. I tried AirPods but eventually landed on the new Pixel Buds, which are incredible. Sony's WF-1000MX4s are good too, and I'm still using my Bose QC 35 II as daily drivers (pun intended, I guess).
Bose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
I think that somehow each Bluetooth device has its own kinks. With my QuietComfort 35 sometimes the A2DP profile is not negotiated and it falls back to HSP/HFP which sounds like a landline in the 90s. Then you have to disconnect/reconnect it and hope it works this time. Another pair of cheap sports headphones I own just like to pair with everything that is in range if no other device is connected. And lastly my Sony WF-1000XM3 just never automatically connects to my phone. I always have to manually go into the Bluetooth menu to connect them. I think there should be some type of conformity certification, not for the implementation of the Bluetooth protocol itself but for how a device has to act in certain scenarios.
Bose QuietComfort: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
> OP should try using another brand of Bluetooth headphones for a week Extensive user of various BT headphones on Android for few years now - went through everything from cheap Corwin E7 to Galaxy Buds to Bose QC to latest one Sony WH-1000XM4 - had minor issues with the Galaxy Buds - had to wiggle them in the case to get the charging going but other than that all of the other ones work really well - Sony being the king of the hill - even two devices work as expected and the sound quality is good.
Bose QuietComfort: Recommends itSony WH-1000XM: Recommends it
As far as noise cancelling goes, there's really only 3 phones that are worth considering: WH-1000XM3 QC35 Bose 700 As a side note, I use a pair of beyerdynamics DT770 80 ohm headphones, and they have positively excellent isolation. With music on, I can't hear anything outside, and nobody can hear anything I'm hearing at all. Have you tried to see if closed, isolated headphones fit your use case? There's way more options in that space, so you're more likely to find something comfortable and with a sound signature you really like.
Bose QuietComfort: Likes itSony WH-1000XM: Likes it
I have both the Bose QC-35 ii and the Airpod pros. The Bose have better noise reduction. Plus, if you really want total quiet, you can wear earplugs underneath the Bose. The Airpod Pros are good but the physical noise isolation isn't that great. The rubber tips in Etymotics are far superior. Even my Jabras had better physical noise isolation than the Airpod Pros. My friend has the Sony WH1000XM3, so I got to play around with those. They have slightly better noise cancelation than the Bose. However, the Bose are more comfortable to me because they rest around your ear instead of on your ear like the Sony's.
Bose QuietComfort: NeutralSony WH-1000XM: Neutral
Slightly ot. For sound quality, go for B&O Beoplay h9i. Worse ANC than Sony XM3s or Bose, but the sound is so nice. I tried Bose QC35, bought and returned Sony XM3. For flights, as others have said, bose or sonys (maybe airpods pro?). But for music listening in the office, can't recommend h9i enough.
Bose QuietComfort: Doesn’t like itSony WH-1000XM: Doesn’t like it
I have tried quite a few different as I value th sound quality as high as the noise cancelling. I originally had Sennheiser Momentum Wireless 2. They had amazing sound, connected quickly and quite good battery life. They were however not that comfortable for long durations as the headband lacks padding. I then bought B&O H9 which was almost as good sound quality wise but a lot more comfortable. They however ended up having problems with bluetooth and I had to switch them. Both Sony MX3 and Bose QC35 have a way too synthetic sound to them for my taste. I then tried the third gen H9 but they did not sound as good as my old ones for some reason. I then tried the new Sennheiser Momentum 3 which sounded quite good, with really good deep bass, but it lacked some control at places and was just a very large headset. Then finally B&W came out with the PX7 recently and once I tried those I just had to have them. Their sound is almost bar none - at least to my taste, and their noise cancelling is exceptional on par with MX3 to my ears and finally they have extremely long battery life. So 4 weeks in or something like that, I am really loving my PX7's and would recommend giving them a listen.